PERJANJIAN LINGGARJATI - XII MIPA 1 Ikhwan (Short Movie Sejarah Indonesia)

Summary

The transcript depicts a heated discussion between Indonesian and Dutch representatives regarding the sovereignty of Indonesia, specifically focusing on the recognition of Sumatra, Java, and Madura as part of Indonesia. The Indonesian side insists on the inclusion of Sumatra, while the Dutch side refuses to acknowledge Sumatra as part of Indonesian territory, only recognizing Java and Madura. Despite their opposing views, both sides engage in tense dialogue, culminating in the signing of an agreement without resolution on the key territorial disagreement.

Takeaways

• 😀 The session begins with applause and music, setting the tone for the discussion about the peace between Malaysia and the Netherlands.
• 😀 Indonesia’s delegation demands that the Netherlands acknowledge the sovereignty of Sumatra, Java, and Manur islands as part of Indonesia.
• 😀 The Netherlands disagrees with Indonesia's demand, asserting that they only recognize Java and Madura as part of Indonesia, not Sumatra.
• 😀 Tension rises between the Indonesian and Dutch delegations, with Indonesia insisting on the inclusion of Sumatra as part of Indonesia's territory.
• 😀 The Netherlands maintains their stance, emphasizing that only two islands—Java and Madura—are recognized as part of Indonesia’s territory.
• 😀 Despite ongoing debates, Indonesia continues to insist on Sumatra being recognized as part of Indonesia, with the Netherlands rejecting this claim.
• 😀 A brief moment of interruption occurs, where the Dutch side refers to the Indonesian presence as 'just passengers' with no territorial claims.
• 😀 The discussion highlights the refusal by the Netherlands to recognize Sumatra as part of Indonesia, continuing their stance of only recognizing Java and Madura.
• 😀 A proposed solution involves both sides signing an agreement to conclude the meeting, although disagreement on territorial claims remains.
• 😀 The final moments of the meeting end with the signing of a document, but the fundamental disagreement over Indonesia’s territorial claims persists.

Q & A

What is the main topic of the discussion in the script?

The main topic of the discussion revolves around the territorial sovereignty of Indonesia, particularly the inclusion of Sumatera, Java, and Madura as part of Indonesia, and the disagreement with the Netherlands over this matter.

What is Indonesia's stance on the territorial sovereignty issue?

Indonesia firmly requests that the Netherlands recognize its sovereignty over the territories of Sumatera, Java, and Madura, stating that Sumatera should be included as part of Indonesia.

What is the Netherlands' position in the debate regarding Indonesia's territorial sovereignty?

The Netherlands only recognizes Java and Madura as part of Indonesia's territory and rejects the inclusion of Sumatera as part of Indonesia.

Why does the Netherlands refuse to acknowledge Sumatera as part of Indonesia?

The Netherlands maintains that Indonesia consists only of Java and Madura, and they refuse to include Sumatera, despite Indonesia's insistence on its inclusion.

How do the parties react during the discussion when their positions are challenged?

The discussion becomes tense, with both sides firmly holding their respective positions. Indonesia expresses frustration, while the Netherlands remains resolute in its stance.

What happens toward the end of the meeting?

The meeting concludes with a call for both parties to sign a treaty, but the disagreement remains unresolved, with the Netherlands still not recognizing Sumatera as part of Indonesia.

What is Indonesia's hope regarding Sumatera's recognition?

Indonesia hopes that Sumatera will soon be recognized by the Netherlands as part of its territory, highlighting the long-standing issue of territorial recognition.

How does the script reflect the historical context of the Indonesia-Netherlands relations?

The script reflects the ongoing territorial disputes and historical tensions between Indonesia and the Netherlands, particularly regarding Indonesia's sovereignty over its islands following its independence.

What does the repeated mention of 'merdeka' (freedom) symbolize in the script?

The repeated shout of 'merdeka' symbolizes Indonesia's desire for full independence and the recognition of its sovereignty over all of its territories, including Sumatera.

What is the overall tone of the debate in the script?

The tone of the debate is serious and tense, marked by disagreements and firm stances from both sides, with a sense of frustration and determination from the Indonesian side.