TUGAS KEWARGANEGARAAN TANGGAPAN WACANA AMANDEMEN UUD 1945

Summary

In this video, Auli Rizki from M01 shares thoughts on the Indonesian People's Consultative Assembly's (MPR) plan to amend the 1945 Constitution. Auli discusses the positive and negative aspects of the amendment, highlighting potential benefits such as more consistent leadership. However, concerns include the risk of political influence, loss of public trust, and confusion over legal interpretations due to frequent amendments. Auli stresses the importance of clear, firm rules to prevent amendments driven by personal or political interests, expressing worries about the rise of political dynasties in Indonesia.

Takeaways

• 📜 The speaker is Auli Rizki from M01 with NIM 245080101111003, discussing the MPR's intention to amend the 1945 Constitution of Indonesia.
• 🔍 The MPR considers the amendments because some articles are seen as not aligning with the preamble of the 1945 Constitution.
• 👍 The speaker believes that the amendment could bring positive outcomes, such as more consistent and goal-oriented leadership in Indonesia.
• ⚖️ A consistent leadership approach could ensure uniformity in leadership styles between different presidents and vice-presidents.
• 👎 However, the speaker also sees potential negative effects, including a loss of public trust in the MPR and the president due to perceived political influence.
• 🤔 The speaker is concerned that frequent amendments might cause confusion among the public regarding the validity of laws and constitutional changes.
• 🚫 According to the speaker, the amendments are not urgently needed at the current time and should be approached with caution.
• 📏 Any changes to the Constitution should include clear and firm regulations to prevent amendments driven by personal or group interests.
• 👨‍👩‍👧‍👦 The speaker mentions a concern about political dynasties, highlighting the succession of Gibran, President Jokowi’s son, as vice president.
• 🙏 The speaker concludes by emphasizing the need for integrity in the amendment process to maintain public trust and national identity.

Q & A

What is the main topic discussed by Auli Rizki in the video?

The main topic discussed is the potential amendment of the 1945 Constitution of the Republic of Indonesia by the People's Consultative Assembly (MPR).

What are the positive aspects of amending the 1945 Constitution, according to Auli Rizki?

Auli Rizki believes that the amendment could lead to more directed leadership and continuity in governance, ensuring that leadership styles do not drastically change with each new president.

What negative consequences does Auli Rizki foresee if the Constitution is amended?

Auli Rizki mentions that the amendment might lead to a loss of public trust in the MPR and the president, and create confusion among citizens regarding which laws and rules are correct due to excessive amendments.

Why does Auli Rizki think excessive amendments could lead to confusion among citizens?

According to Auli Rizki, excessive amendments may cause citizens to be unsure about which laws, rules, and articles are correct, leading to a sense of national identity loss.

Does Auli Rizki believe that the 1945 Constitution needs immediate amendments?

No, Auli Rizki does not believe that the Constitution urgently needs amendments and suggests that such changes should only be made when absolutely necessary.

What concerns does Auli Rizki express about political influence in the amendment process?

Auli Rizki is concerned that amendments may be influenced by political interests, potentially serving the personal, familial, or group agendas of politicians.

What does Auli Rizki fear regarding the creation of a political dynasty?

Auli Rizki fears that amendments might lead to the establishment of a political dynasty, particularly referencing the potential involvement of President Jokowi’s son, Gibran, and other family members in future leadership roles.

What solution does Auli Rizki propose if amendments are to be made?

Auli Rizki suggests that any amendments to the Constitution should be accompanied by firm decisions and regulations to prevent changes based on personal or group interests.

How does Auli Rizki view the role of leadership changes in governance?

Auli Rizki sees the potential benefits of more consistent leadership styles between successive presidents, suggesting that it could lead to more stable and consistent governance.

What is Auli Rizki’s main concern about the future leadership of Indonesia?

Auli Rizki’s main concern is that the amendment could pave the way for political families, such as President Jokowi’s, to establish a political dynasty, leading to a lack of diversity in leadership.