Fighting Disadvantageous Positions, Playing Closer TR (Ext Analysis Jek 17, Marth vs Peach)

Summary

This analysis provides in-depth feedback on a player's performance against Peach, highlighting several areas for improvement. It emphasizes the importance of respecting Peach's threat range, utilizing proper spacing, and understanding projectiles—especially aerial turnips. Key issues noted include overcommitting in disadvantageous situations, poor positioning, and missed opportunities for punishes. The analysis stresses the need for better reaction to DI, more precise tilt executions, and refined counterplay strategies such as crouch power shielding. The player is encouraged to avoid low EV plays, disengage effectively, and improve their understanding of threat ranges to enhance overall gameplay.

Takeaways

• 😀 Understand and respect the threat range of your opponent's moves, especially with Peach's aerial turnips, to avoid low EV (expected value) plays and increase your chances of success.
• 😀 Avoid hard commits, especially when you haven't yet successfully disengaged from your opponent's projectiles. Fighting through disadvantageous situations is generally low EV and should be avoided.
• 😀 Master the timing of shield drops to improve your defensive options. A delayed shield drop, like in the example with the up air, is slower and less effective than an immediate one.
• 😀 Focus on using Crouch Power Shields to deal with aerial projectiles like Peach's turnips, as these require a different approach than ground-based projectiles.
• 😀 Practice respecting your opponent’s spacing and threat ranges, especially with characters like Peach and Link, where misjudging ranges leads to unnecessary punishes.
• 😀 Refrain from engaging in close combat unless absolutely necessary. Characters like Marth are better suited for zoning and spacing rather than entering high-risk scrambles.
• 😀 Learn to react to DI (directional influence) to optimize your punishes. For example, a well-timed fair could replace an auto-assumed dash attack in some situations.
• 😀 Avoid trying to challenge hitboxes or engage in scrappy situations, especially with characters like Marth, who thrive when respecting spacing and avoiding unnecessary risks.
• 😀 Close spacing after successfully disengaging allows you to better control the situation. Take advantage of Peach's slower movement to apply more pressure while staying out of her threat range.
• 😀 Practice tilting with precision, focusing on executing up tilts and down tilts gently to avoid accidental up smashes and optimize your punish game in critical moments.

Q & A

What is the main issue with how the player is handling turnips in the match?

The main issue is that the player is not effectively respecting the threat range of Peach's turnips. They often fail to properly react to aerial turnips and are not positioning themselves optimally to avoid or counter the turnip threats. A better approach would involve crouch power shielding or avoiding the turnips from the ground rather than trying to fight through them directly.

What is the recommended way to deal with Peach's projectiles, specifically her turnips?

The recommended way to deal with Peach's turnips is to avoid being directly above her and instead use crouch power shielding. By being on the ground and reacting to the turnips, players can counter the projectiles more effectively and reset the situation without being forced into disadvantageous scraps.

What does the player need to do in terms of spacing and positioning against Peach?

The player needs to stay within Peach's effective threat range, but not too far away. When they are too far, they lose opportunities to punish Peach's actions. The key is to be close enough to threaten and punish, particularly when Peach is about to pull out a turnip. Maintaining proper spacing will allow for more successful counterplay.

What is the importance of respecting threat ranges during disadvantageous situations?

Respecting threat ranges is crucial during disadvantageous situations. If the player tries to fight through Peach's projectiles or hitboxes without respecting them, they are at a significant disadvantage and are likely to get punished. Instead, they should disengage, reset, and only engage when the threat is manageable or an opening arises.

What is the issue with the player's use of rising fairs?

The player's use of rising fairs is problematic because it is a low EV (expected value) move that doesn't offer enough reward in the given situations. Instead of relying on rising fairs, the player should focus on positioning themselves better and utilizing more effective moves like falling nair or using aerials with higher reward potential.

What could the player have done differently when they had the chance to up-air or up-tilt?

When the player had the opportunity to up-air or up-tilt, they could have been more aware of the situation and executed the moves with better timing. Missing these opportunities often leads to missed chances for a potential kill or advantage. Practicing quicker, more accurate execution would help avoid these mistakes.

Why is it important to be cautious when engaging in a disadvantageous situation?

Engaging in a disadvantageous situation without proper caution can lead to low EV play, where the player gives up control and opens themselves up to more damage or a loss. It's important to understand when to disengage and reset, rather than forcing an engagement that is likely to result in a punishment.

What is a better alternative to the player's habit of running up and grabbing in certain situations?

A better alternative to running up and grabbing is to maintain distance and focus on spacing. Rather than committing to a grab or dash attack, which can be easily punished, the player should use a more reserved approach like full hopping in place to threaten from a safer distance while being ready to react.

How should the player adjust their use of dash attacks against Peach?

The player needs to be more aware of Peach's range and timing when using dash attacks. Dash attacks should not be used recklessly; instead, they should be employed strategically when the opponent is in a position where they can't easily counter it. The player should also practice spacing and respecting the range of Peach's moves.

What general advice is given for improving the player's gameplay against Peach?

The general advice includes improving the player's understanding of threat ranges, learning to disengage when necessary, and practicing more effective movement and spacing. Additionally, the player should work on their tilt game, especially with up-tilts and down-tilts, to improve precision and execution in critical situations.