What is Brutalist Architecture? | ARCHITECTURE 101

All Things Architecture
22 Feb 202417:00

Summary

TLDRこのビデオスクリプトは、戦後ヨーロッパで勃興したブルータル建築の歴史と特徴について掘り下げています。1950年代から1970年代にかけて人気を博したこのスタイルは、その生粡コンクリートの使用と社会主義理想的追求で特徴づけられています。しかし、その壮大さと機能性に反して、多くの人々に嫌悪感を呼び起こし、後にはその人気は衰退しました。最近では、その独創性と彫刻的な美しさに注目し、再評価が進んでいます。ブルータル建築は、建築物の美しさと倫理性の間で揺れるアーキテクチャのジャンルを象徴しています。

Takeaways

  • 🏢 ブリュータリスト建築は、主にコンクリートでできた大きな建物で、世界中で政府施設、住宅複合体、学校キャンパスに見られます。
  • 📈 ブリュータリスト建築は、第二次世界大戦後のヨーロッパで発生し、1960年代と1970年代に人気を博しましたが、その後数十年はほとんど無視されました。
  • 🏗 ブリュータリスト建築の名前は、フランス語の'béton brut'(生コンクリート)から来たと言われていますが、実際にはスウェーデンの建築家ハンス・アドが'ネオブリュータリズム'という言葉を初めて使いました。
  • 🇬🇧 イギリスの建築家たちは、社会主義的ユートピアを築くための手段として建築を使い、ブリュータリスト建築を発展させました。
  • 🏫 ハンスタントン学校は、ブリュータリスト建築の特徴を示しており、生の素材を誇示しています。
  • 📰 建築批評家アルバート・バンハムは、ブリュータリスト建築を定義しようとしましたが、その定義は厳密には明確ではありませんでした。
  • 🌐 ブリュータリスト建築はイギリスを離れて、ヨーロッパやアメリカに広がり、社会住宅や大学キャンパスに影響を与えました。
  • 🏛 ボストン市政庁は、モニュメント性と歴史的な建築の再解釈を求める審査員によって選ばれた、最も重要なブリュータリスト建築の一つです。
  • 📉 しかし、ブリュータリスト建築は維持コストが高く、管理不足のために人々に不快感を与えることがありました。
  • 🔄 1970年代後半には、ポストモダン主义への転向と共にブリュータリスト建築の人気は減少しましたが、近年ではそのスタイルの再評価が進んでいます。
  • 🎨 ブリュータリスト建築は、建築物を単なる箱以上のものとして考え、彫刻的な美しさを追求する現代の建築に影響を与えました。

Q & A

  • ブルータリズム建築はどのような建築スタイルですか?

    -ブルータリズム建築は、コンクリートを主体とした無骨で力強いデザインの建築スタイルです。第二次世界大戦後のヨーロッパで生まれ、1960年代から1970年代にかけて人気を博しました。政府の建物、住宅複合施設、学校のキャンパスなどで見られます。

  • ブルータリズムという名前の由来は何ですか?

    -一般的には、ル・コルビュジエの「ベトン・ブルート」(フランス語で「生コンクリート」)がブルータリズムの由来とされていますが、実際には1940年代のスウェーデンの建築家ハンス・アスプルンドが「ネオブルータリズム」という用語を最初に使いました。

  • ブルータリズムが最初に登場した場所はどこですか?

    -ブルータリズムはヨーロッパで登場しましたが、特に1940年代のスウェーデンと1950年代のイギリスで広がりました。イギリスでは、アリソンとピーター・スミッソンが新ブルータリズム運動のリーダーとして知られています。

  • ブルータリズムが特に強く関連する材料は何ですか?

    -ブルータリズム建築はコンクリートと強く関連しています。コンクリートは、粗くて無加工の状態で使用され、建築の正直さと機能性を表現するために選ばれました。また、コンクリートは安価であったため、多くのブルータリズム建築に採用されました。

  • ブルータリズム建築はどのような社会的理想を反映していましたか?

    -ブルータリズムは、社会主義的なユートピアを実現しようとする建築運動でした。建物の透明性と機能性を強調し、社会全体に平等をもたらすことを目指していました。

  • ブルータリズムが批判された理由は何ですか?

    -ブルータリズムは、その無骨で威圧的なデザインや、住民が快適に感じられないという理由で批判されました。また、コンクリートは時間が経つにつれて劣化するため、メンテナンスコストが高くなることも問題とされました。

  • ブルータリズムがアメリカに導入された際、どのように受け入れられましたか?

    -アメリカでは、ブルータリズムは主に経済的理由から公共住宅プロジェクトに採用されました。多くの建物は、ル・コルビュジエのラディアント・シティの概念に基づいて設計されましたが、時間が経つにつれて住民からの支持は失われました。

  • ポストモダニズムが登場した背景には、どのような要因がありましたか?

    -1970年代にブルータリズムの人気が衰退し、古典的な建築理念への回帰が見られるようになりました。この動きがポストモダニズムの台頭をもたらし、ブルータリズムに代わる新たな建築スタイルが模索されました。

  • ブルータリズムは近年どのように再評価されていますか?

    -ブルータリズムは、特にそのユニークで彫刻的な美学の観点から再評価されています。多くのブルータリズム建築がユネスコの世界遺産に指定され、今では愛される建物として保存されることもあります。

  • ブルータリズム建築の成功と失敗の要因は何ですか?

    -ブルータリズムは、その野心的な設計とユートピアを目指す姿勢で一時的に成功しましたが、人々が快適に感じられない空間を作り出したため、その社会的理想は長続きしませんでした。成功と失敗が交差する中、今日でもその建築スタイルは論争の的となっています。

Outlines

00:00

🏢 ブリュータリスト建築の誕生と特徴

ブリュータリスト建築は、第二次世界大戦後のヨーロッパで生まれ、1960年代から70年代にかけて人気を博したスタイルである。このスタイルの特徴は、主にコンクリートを用いた生粡の建築様式である。このスタイルは世界中で政府施設、住宅complexes、学校キャンパスなどに見られる。ブリュータリスト建築は、人々に強い感情を引き起こし、愛される一方で嫌われる一方もある。この段落では、ブリュータリスト建築の歴史と由来について解説している。特に、フランス建築家ル・コルビュジェが「beton brute」を用いたことと、スウェーデンの建築家ハンス・アスクーが「neo-brutalism」を初称したことが、このスタイルの基礎を形成したとされる。また、英国の建築家であるアリソン夫妇がこのスタイルを英国に持ち込み、社会主義的理想的空間を創出しようと試みた。

05:02

🗿 コンクリートの選定とブリュータリスト建築の社会性

この段落では、ブリュータリスト建築がコンクリートを選んだ理由と、その社会性について説明している。コンクリートは建築家に興味深い形状を作り、生の外観を与えることができた。また、伝統的な材料よりも安価だったことも理由である。ブリュータリスト建築は、建築を通じて社会変革を目指していた。建築物が提供する生活空間や人々が建物を移動する様子が、真の社会主義的ユートピアを示すはずだった。初期のブリュータリスト建築は、その新鮮さから住民に人気だったが、随分後にはその評判が変わっていく。また、アメリカや南アメリカに進出し、異なる文化の中でも同じように受け止められた。

10:02

🏛 アメリカのブリュータリスト建築とその評価

アメリカにおけるブリュータリスト建築の進出と、その評価について説明している。特に、ルーク・ハウが設計したサルインスティトゥートや、マセル・ブレイヤーが設計したウィットニー美術館がそのスタイルを代表している。これらの建築は、その独特なデザインとコンセプトによって評価が分かれる。一方で、ボストンシティホールのようには、当初は批判的だったが、後にはその価値が再評価される例もある。この段落では、ブリュータリスト建築がどのように公共空間や社会構造に影響を与え、またどのように受け止められたかについて詳細に触れている。

15:04

📚 ブリュータリスト建築の再評価と建築の意義

最後の段落では、ブリュータリスト建築が現在の時代でどのように再評価され、その意義について考察している。ブリュータリスト建築は、ただの美学的なものではなく、倫理的にも重要なスタイルだった。しかし、その理想主義は人々に歓迎される場所を作ることを犠牲にしてしまった。現在では、そのスタイルの独創性や彫刻的な性質が再び評価されており、一度は人々に嫌われた建物も、今では愛される場所となっている。この段落では、建築の理想を追い求めるべきである一方で、人々に快適な場所を作ることの重要性を再確認する。

Mindmap

Keywords

💡ブルータリスト建築

ブルータリスト建築は、主にコンクリートからできており、生のコンクリートの質感を特徴とする建築様式です。このスタイルは、戦後のヨーロッパで生まれ、1960年代から70年代にかけて人気を博しました。ビデオでは、ブルータリスト建築がどのようにして人々の強い反応を引き起こすか、またそれがどのようにして都市のランドマークになったかについて説明しています。

💡コンクリート

コンクリートはブルータリスト建築で最もよく使われる材料の一つであり、その生の感覚と功能性を愛された材料です。ビデオでは、コンクリートが建築物にどのようにして興味深い形状を与え、生の外観を提供するのかについて触れています。

💡ルネ・スポル

ルネ・スポルはブルータリスト建築の重要な人物であり、彼の作品はこの様式の特徴を象徴しています。ビデオでは、彼が設計したUN DEH habit cion(マッドハウス)について触れており、それがブルータリスト建築の原点の一つであるとされています。

💡ハンス・アスプロン

ハンス・アスプロンは、1949年に「ネオ・ブルータリスム」という言葉を初め用了した建築家で、この言葉は後のブルータリスト建築に影響を与えました。ビデオでは、彼がスウェーデンの現代主義を他の現代主義運動と区別するためにこの言葉を使ったと説明しています。

💡アリソンとピーター・スミスン

アリソンとピーター・スミスンは、英国のニューブルータリスト運動の指導者としてビデオに登場します。彼らの設計は、ブルータリスト建築の原則を体現しており、その影響力は英国の他の建築家にも及んでいます。

💡社会主義的ユートピア

ビデオでは、ブルータリスト建築が社会主義的ユートピアを創造するための手段として使われたと説明しています。建築家たちは、平等と共有の価値観を通じて、より良い社会を目指しました。

💡ジャン・アラン・ヴァン・デル・ロビュール

ジャン・アラン・ヴァン・デル・ロビュールは、ブルータリスト建築の理論的支柱の一つであり、彼はブルータリスト建築が社会変革をもたらす力を持つと主張しました。ビデオでは、彼がブルータリスト建築をどのように定義し、その社会的な役割を語ったかについて触れています。

💡エルンスト・グルドフィンガー

エルンスト・グルドフィンガーは、ビデオに登場する建築家で、彼のデザインしたバルロンとトレルタワーはブルータリスト運動のランドマークとなっています。これらの建築物は、社会主義的理想を体現するものであり、当時の人々に支持されました。

💡ポストモダン主義

ブルータリスト建築の人気が1970年代後半に下がり始めた時期、建築の世界ではポストモダン主義への転換が始まりました。ビデオでは、ポストモダン主義がどのようにしてブルータリスト建築の野心的な目標に反対し、建築のより古典的なアイデアに戻ったかについて説明しています。

💡再評価

ビデオでは、近年でブルータリスト建築が再評価を受けていると述べています。人々は、そのユニークな美学や彫刻的な性質を高く評価し、その歴史的意義を再認識しています。

Highlights

Brutalist architecture is characterized by its raw, dominating, and bold use of concrete, often found in government buildings, housing complexes, and schools.

The style emerged in Europe after World War II and became popular in the 1960s and 70s before being largely neglected.

The name 'Brutalism' is often mistakenly thought to derive from the French phrase 'béton brut' (raw concrete), but it actually originated from Swedish architect Hans Asplund's term 'Neo-Brutalism' in 1949.

Brutalism was embraced by British architects like Alison and Peter Smithson, who used it to promote socialist ideals, believing that raw materials symbolized honesty and transparency.

Reyner Banham, an architecture critic, attempted to define Brutalism, linking it to Le Corbusier’s béton brut, and emphasizing its social and aesthetic ambitions.

Despite its academic and architectural praise, Brutalism often faced public disdain due to its imposing and authoritarian appearance.

Concrete was favored by Brutalist architects for its versatility, cost-effectiveness, and ability to create dramatic and sculptural forms.

Brutalist buildings often faced maintenance challenges, leading to their deterioration and reinforcing negative public perceptions.

Brutalism had a significant impact on social housing in both Europe and America, though the reception was mixed, with residents often feeling disconnected from these environments.

Notable examples of Brutalist architecture include Boston City Hall, Yale’s Art and Architecture Building, and the Geisel Library at UC San Diego.

Brutalism’s initial appeal was tied to its novelty and promise of a utopian society, but this promise was often unmet, leading to its decline.

Despite its fall from favor, Brutalism is experiencing a resurgence in interest, with many buildings now being appreciated for their unique aesthetics and architectural innovation.

Brutalism’s legacy includes influencing modern architectural designs, particularly in the use of concrete and the creation of abstract, sculptural forms.

The style highlights the tension between architectural ambition and the need to create welcoming, human-centered environments.

Brutalism's complex history demonstrates the challenges of balancing social ideals with practical, livable spaces.

Transcripts

play00:00

[Music]

play00:06

you know them when you see them big bold

play00:09

hulking buildings made mostly of

play00:11

concrete they're raw and dominating some

play00:15

might even call them

play00:16

brutal this style of architecture is

play00:18

found all over the world in government

play00:20

buildings housing complexes and on

play00:23

school

play00:24

campuses it's a style that over the past

play00:26

60 years has been both vilified and

play00:28

beloved there have been equal calls to

play00:31

rid our cities of them as they are to

play00:32

preserve them I'm talking about

play00:35

brutalist architecture a style that

play00:37

emerged in Europe following World War II

play00:40

reaching its height of popularity in the

play00:41

1960s and70s before being largely

play00:44

neglected in the subsequent decades but

play00:47

what is it about brutalism that causes

play00:49

such intense reactions does it deserve

play00:52

all the hate it gets and where does the

play00:54

term brutalism even come from hey

play00:57

everyone my name's Steve I'm an

play00:59

architecture writer and join me as we

play01:01

take a deep dive into brutalist

play01:03

architecture here on architecture 101

play01:07

but before we get started be sure to

play01:09

like And subscribe so you never miss out

play01:11

on all things architecture if you've

play01:13

ever looked up the history of brutalism

play01:15

you'll find many sources saying that the

play01:17

name brutalism was a rough translation

play01:20

from the lar kabier concept beton brute

play01:23

which is French for raw concrete The

play01:25

Story Goes that kaboer was tasked with

play01:27

designing the UN DEH habit cion in

play01:30

France or the mad house as the locals

play01:33

called it which was a massive housing

play01:35

block that would feature space for 1,600

play01:38

residents and offer amenities like a

play01:39

grocery store and rooftop garden

play01:42

originally the tower was supposed to be

play01:43

designed with a smooth concrete exterior

play01:47

a thing that kaboer had experimented

play01:49

with in the past however there was a

play01:51

misunderstanding among the 80

play01:53

contractors working on site and the

play01:55

building's concrete was anything but

play01:57

smooth there were marks left on the

play01:59

concrete from the wooden formwork

play02:01

supposedly kaboer in his frustration

play02:03

called it a massacre of concrete and

play02:06

declared quote leave it brute the

play02:10

building opened in 1952 and

play02:11

revolutionized residential architecture

play02:13

both in design and in

play02:16

materials and he even began to embrace

play02:18

the rough concrete look in his

play02:19

subsequent buildings all over the world

play02:22

he loved the honesty and the

play02:23

functionality of raw concrete and he

play02:26

eventually coined the term bom brute and

play02:29

there you go well brutalism is born

play02:31

right not exactly it's a great story and

play02:35

while kab's beton brute did influence

play02:37

later brutalism it's not a translation

play02:40

of the French phrase for that we've got

play02:43

to travel to 1940s Stockholm Sweden the

play02:47

architect Hans Ood was the first to coin

play02:50

the term Neo brutalism in 1949 the term

play02:53

was coined to distinguish Swedish

play02:55

modernism from the larger modernist

play02:57

movements elsewhere in the world it's

play02:59

soon became a term spoken in Stockholm's

play03:02

architecture circles and according to

play03:04

historian Anthony vidler the term caught

play03:07

the attention of visiting British

play03:09

Architects they took the phrase back

play03:11

with them to England where it was

play03:13

applied by avangard Architects looking

play03:15

to use architecture as a vehicle for

play03:18

creating a socialist Utopia for Britain

play03:21

they were still trying to pick up the

play03:23

pieces from years of devastating War

play03:26

entire cities needed rebuilding and

play03:28

hundreds of thousands of people were

play03:30

displaced to combat this Britain

play03:32

expanded their social housing program

play03:34

offering commissions to large numbers of

play03:36

ambitious politically-minded architects

play03:38

who were ready to take their academic

play03:40

ideas and apply them in the real

play03:43

world the most prominent new voices were

play03:46

Allison and Peter Smithson their designs

play03:48

for the unbuilt golden Lane estate and

play03:51

the hunstanton school in 1952 cemented

play03:54

themselves as the leaders of Britain's

play03:56

New brutalist

play03:57

Movement if you look at the Hunts stand

play03:59

school today it might not look brutalist

play04:02

in fact it might look more like the

play04:04

works of Ludwig M vandero but if we look

play04:07

closer we can see what makes it

play04:09

brutalist remember that the prevailing

play04:11

modernist thought at the time was that

play04:13

architecture should embody the

play04:15

Perfection and precision of the Machine

play04:17

Age materials were to be refined and

play04:21

pure everything needed to be perfect the

play04:24

huntstand school does not adhere to this

play04:26

thinking instead rough raw material

play04:30

were the better choice because they were

play04:32

honest both modernists and brutalists

play04:35

saw ornamentation as a crime and for

play04:38

brutalists refined materials were no

play04:40

different than traditional

play04:42

ornamentation so the school features raw

play04:44

brick exposed steel beams concrete

play04:47

floors and the building's utilities on

play04:49

full

play04:50

display the Smithson and other

play04:52

brutalists thought that this Embrace of

play04:55

raw materials would lead to a better

play04:57

Society one that was for Trans

play04:59

transparency and Truth while many of

play05:02

smithson's buildings were built of brick

play05:04

and steel much of the early brutalists

play05:06

saw concrete as the best material to

play05:08

express honesty concrete was chosen not

play05:11

only because it offered Architects the

play05:13

ability to create interesting forms and

play05:15

give that raw appearance it was also

play05:18

incredibly cheaper than traditional

play05:20

materials soon concrete would serve as

play05:23

the go-to material for brutalist

play05:25

Architects intent on redefining

play05:28

architecture a y goal for a style but

play05:31

such ambition soon captured the

play05:33

attention of the architecture critic

play05:35

rner banam in 1955 banam wrote his semal

play05:38

article the new brutalism in it he aimed

play05:41

to Define just what brutalism was he

play05:44

concluded that quote new brutalism

play05:47

eludes precise description while

play05:49

remaining a living force in contemporary

play05:52

British architecture essentially saying

play05:54

that there was no set definition but

play05:57

rather a dedication to creating a Utopia

play05:59

with raw materials this was partly the

play06:02

reason that banam makes the link between

play06:04

British brutalists and Cabo's beton

play06:07

brute he saw the similarities between

play06:09

British Architects and kaboer and tried

play06:12

to bring the two independent Styles

play06:14

together though kabier would reject the

play06:16

label that his buildings were brutalist

play06:18

nevertheless banam saw that by linking

play06:21

kab's ideas with the British movement

play06:23

brutalism gained greater legitimacy it

play06:26

also helped that brute sounded a lot

play06:28

like brutal

play06:30

anyway banam was also obsessed with

play06:32

buildings as objects or images this

play06:35

meant that it was okay if not preferable

play06:37

for a building to not even look like a

play06:39

building that they were independent from

play06:41

their surroundings an idea that would be

play06:43

played with as the style matur Beyond

play06:46

Aesthetics banam stressed that it could

play06:48

not simply be an aesthetic movement but

play06:51

a social one as well brutalist

play06:53

architecture needed to enact social

play06:55

change the way people lived within

play06:58

buildings and moved through them them

play06:59

should demonstrate what a true socialist

play07:01

Utopia looks like everyone would be

play07:04

equal and have access to the same

play07:07

amenities within a brutalist building

play07:09

everything was perfect it's important to

play07:12

note that in the early years of

play07:13

brutalism in Britain the style was liked

play07:15

by residents because of its newness

play07:18

people clamored to live in these new

play07:20

brutalist

play07:21

buildings among these popular buildings

play07:23

were those designed by the architect nno

play07:25

goldfin his balron and trell Towers were

play07:28

landmarks of the movement as they

play07:30

embodied the Socialist ideals that the

play07:32

Smithson and banam advocated for but not

play07:35

everyone was a fan though the writer of

play07:37

the James Bond series famously detested

play07:40

The Works of Goldfinger ultimately

play07:42

naming Bond's arch nemesis after the

play07:45

architect by the end of the 1950s

play07:48

brutalism expanded Beyond Britain and

play07:50

elsewhere in Europe mainly to Eastern

play07:52

Europe where Soviet controlled countries

play07:55

used the ideas of brutalism as a format

play07:57

for their social housing how however

play07:59

unlike the British housing projects

play08:01

these did not attract the same

play08:03

positivity from its residents when

play08:06

brutalism made it to America it also

play08:08

found its way into affordable housing

play08:10

mainly for economic reasons these

play08:12

projects were different from the

play08:13

Smithson and were based on kab's radiant

play08:16

city concept they were often tall

play08:18

identical cruciform towers that were

play08:21

spaced apart with large Lawns and Parks

play08:23

between they were disconnected from the

play08:25

rest of the city and were often placed

play08:27

on the site of historically poor four

play08:29

yet vibrant

play08:31

communities as with the British social

play08:33

housing these were originally met with

play08:35

praise but as we'll discuss later that

play08:37

praise was

play08:39

shortlived beyond social housing

play08:41

brutalism made its way onto college

play08:43

campuses in the wake of the college

play08:44

building boom of the 1950s and 60s among

play08:48

the most notable is here at Yale the art

play08:51

and architecture building designed by

play08:53

Paul Rudolph from

play08:55

1963 given the building's small sight

play08:57

Rudolph accentuated the verticality of

play09:00

the building with these strong Towers

play09:03

between which were windows inside 30

play09:06

different levels were Incorporated

play09:07

across the seven-story building while it

play09:10

was heralded for its unique use of space

play09:13

it was later criticized for its

play09:14

sometimes cramped interior and was

play09:16

eventually expanded in the 2000s

play09:19

nevertheless it brought a sense of drama

play09:21

and presence and helped college campuses

play09:23

Embrace new architecture

play09:25

Styles another important work of

play09:27

brutalism on a college campus

play09:29

is the Geo Library a decade later by

play09:32

William Pereira at UC San Diego this

play09:35

building perfectly captures what banam

play09:37

was saying when he talked about

play09:38

architecture as an image this gravity

play09:41

defying building with its concrete

play09:43

fingers gently holding up the library

play09:46

was placed on a large Plaza that allowed

play09:48

the building to stand triumphantly while

play09:51

the entrance was kept hidden underneath

play09:53

the plaza nearby on a cliff overlooking

play09:55

the Pacific Ocean in La Hoya California

play09:58

stands the Sal

play09:59

Institute for many it is one of the most

play10:02

beautiful brutalist buildings designed

play10:05

by Luke H in 1965 it broke away from

play10:07

early brutalists by incorporating the

play10:10

building's context within the design KH

play10:13

was no stranger to brutalism he designed

play10:16

several important brutalist buildings

play10:17

including the Kimble Art Museum and the

play10:20

national Parliament building in

play10:21

Bangladesh the Suk institutes two

play10:23

identical buildings flanked each other

play10:25

on either side of a large Plaza the

play10:28

building's windows are angled towards

play10:29

the ocean in the distance all the

play10:32

Laboratories and offices were open to

play10:33

the outside linked by a network of

play10:36

exterior walkways and

play10:37

stairs the rough concrete was contrasted

play10:40

by the weathered wood that framed the

play10:42

windows it was a place that felt Grand

play10:45

and still intimate crossing the country

play10:47

we see another figure of American

play10:49

brutalism Marcel Bryer he designed the

play10:52

original Whitney Museum in 1966 the

play10:55

building resembles an inverted zigurat

play10:57

likee structure with floors Cal ing out

play10:59

to maximize the building's small sight

play11:01

the building also has only a few Windows

play11:04

which fails to give the building a sense

play11:05

of scale and makes it feel ominous in

play11:08

the rather quiet neighborhood it resides

play11:10

in it was no wonder that the building

play11:12

was controversial the famed architecture

play11:14

critic ad Luiz huxel famously wrote that

play11:17

it was quote the most disliked building

play11:19

in New York but also argued that it was

play11:21

quote harsh and handsome brism also

play11:25

found a home in South America lenina

play11:28

bardi brought her own flare to the style

play11:30

with her Museum of Art in San Paulo

play11:33

which was completed in

play11:34

1968 it was one of the first buildings

play11:36

in Brazil built of reinforced concrete

play11:39

and appears to defy gravity as its large

play11:41

Gallery space looms above the ground

play11:44

resting effortlessly on four concrete

play11:47

columns of course a conversation of

play11:50

brutalism is not complete without

play11:52

discussing this place the Boston City

play11:56

Hall designed by Colman mckinnel and

play11:58

knows it was the winning submission out

play12:01

of 256 different schemes it was chosen

play12:04

because it was the only design in the

play12:06

competition that featured the

play12:08

monumentality that the jury wanted they

play12:10

wanted a building that would appear to

play12:12

stand the test of time like a modern

play12:14

reinterpretation of past Grand

play12:17

architecture symbolism was used

play12:20

throughout the building the columns are

play12:22

seen as abstractions of traditional

play12:23

columns while the red brick in the plaza

play12:26

and on the bottom floor symbolizes the

play12:28

historical use of brick in the

play12:30

city the offices of the mayor and

play12:32

Council chamber protrude from the

play12:34

inverted zigurat facade as so the

play12:36

building was placing government

play12:38

officials on stage above are

play12:40

administrative offices which are shown

play12:42

symbolically with a standard pattern of

play12:44

Windows to add to the symbolism The

play12:47

Architects wanted to create a varying

play12:49

degree of textures within the building

play12:51

it uses a mixture of cast in place

play12:54

pre-cast concrete and brick throughout

play12:57

the cast in place concrete was like

play12:59

other brutalist buildings and contrasted

play13:01

nicely from the smoothness of the

play13:03

pre-cast sections the brick added some

play13:06

much needed color to the spaces when it

play13:08

opened it received mixed reviews the

play13:11

critics loved it ad Lis huxel said that

play13:14

the building was a symbol of quote

play13:16

Excellence another critic said that the

play13:18

building quote carries an authority that

play13:20

results from the clarity articulation

play13:23

and intensity of imagination with which

play13:26

it has been

play13:27

formed the average person was not so

play13:29

thrilled by it they saw it as imposing

play13:33

authoritarian the average person

play13:36

understandably did not get the symbolism

play13:38

and this is the issue surrounding

play13:40

brutalism there was a disconnect between

play13:43

the academics who loved it and saw it as

play13:45

a step toward Utopia and the public that

play13:47

widely hated it seeing it as hostile and

play13:50

dystopic and they often lacked context

play13:53

so they felt disconnected from the rest

play13:54

of the city in the case of large housing

play13:57

projects they lacked a unique identity

play14:00

they just weren't places where people

play14:02

could feel comfortable another issue

play14:04

with brutalism was the cost to maintain

play14:06

it concrete deteriorates after a while

play14:09

and the lack of Maintenance with these

play14:10

buildings causes them to look even more

play14:12

hostile to people like the Jed gaho

play14:14

building in Washington DC which has

play14:17

suffered from years of neglect as the

play14:19

government tries to determine just what

play14:21

to do with it all of this was why the

play14:23

popularity of the style began to fade in

play14:25

the late

play14:26

1970s during this time a turn to

play14:29

classical ideas on architecture would

play14:31

lead to

play14:32

postmodernism and yet all these years

play14:34

later brutalism is seeing a Resurgence

play14:38

there are books articles and Instagram

play14:40

pages that are dedicated to highlighting

play14:42

the inventiveness and sculptural nature

play14:44

of the style even places like Boston

play14:46

City Hall Once under threat of

play14:48

demolition 20 years ago has garnered a

play14:50

loyal group of

play14:52

supporters the buildings designed by

play14:54

Goldfinger have become highly coveted

play14:56

places to live and many of kaboo as bom

play14:59

brute buildings have become UNESCO world

play15:01

heritage sites but this love of

play15:04

brutalism is more about the interesting

play15:06

and unique Aesthetics of the style

play15:08

rather than its impact on our cities if

play15:11

we look at brutalism solely on

play15:12

Aesthetics it's amazing that a material

play15:15

like concrete can defy gravity the way

play15:17

that it does in these buildings however

play15:20

brutalism was about ethics too and in

play15:23

that form it failed people for a short

play15:27

time at least saw brutal is M as the

play15:29

architecture of Utopia but rather

play15:31

quickly it failed in its promise and so

play15:34

brutalism remains in this gray area

play15:36

within the timeline of architecture for

play15:38

every reason why we don't like it there

play15:40

seems to be another reason as to why

play15:42

it's great it could be argue that we

play15:45

might not have the high abstract and

play15:47

sculptural buildings we see today if not

play15:49

for brutalism breaking the mold and

play15:52

allowing Architects to think of

play15:53

architecture as more than simply boxes

play15:56

what can be taken away from brutalism

play15:58

and its history is the knowledge that

play16:00

it's good to have lofty Ambitions for

play16:02

our

play16:03

architecture but the Quest for an ideal

play16:06

should not come at the expense of

play16:07

creating a welcoming place for people

play16:10

architecture is about giving people a

play16:12

place that enlivens them not challenges

play16:14

them that being said even for people who

play16:17

hate brutalism it's hard not to be in

play16:19

awe of these places as there rare

play16:22

moments when the rest of the world seems

play16:25

to slip away and you're completely

play16:27

enveloped in a true architectural

play16:31

[Music]

play16:34

experience thank you for watching what

play16:36

do you think about brutalism let me know

play16:38

in the comments below and if you want to

play16:40

learn more about brutalist architecture

play16:42

visit arbyd design.com and be sure to

play16:45

subscribe so you never miss an episode

play16:48

of all things

play16:49

architecture anyway thanks again for

play16:52

watching my name's Steve and I'll see

play16:54

you next time for another edition of

play16:56

architecture

play16:57

101

play16:59

yeah

Rate This

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

Étiquettes Connexes
建築ブルータリズム歴史社会美学ユートピアヨーロッパコンクリート再評価都市デザイン
Besoin d'un résumé en anglais ?