SolidWorks VS Creo which one is Better
Summary
TLDRThis video compares two leading CAD software, SolidWorks and Creo, detailing their histories, functionalities, and applications. SolidWorks, known for its user-friendly interface and ease of learning, is ideal for mechanical design and smaller assemblies. Creo, with its advanced capabilities like topology optimization, excels in complex design and large assemblies. The video also covers their rendering capabilities, industry applications, learning curves, and pricing models, helping viewers choose the best software for their needs.
Takeaways
- 🛠️ SolidWorks and Creo are leading CAD software used across various industries for designing and modeling.
- ⏱️ SolidWorks was founded in 1993 and acquired in 1997, evolving from a simple solid modeler to a comprehensive CAD program.
- 🚀 Creo, initially released as Pro Engineer in 1987, is known for its performance and depth of functions, impacting the CAD market significantly.
- 🔄 Both software generate files related to parts, assemblies, and drawings, with changes in one reflected across all associated files.
- 🌐 SolidWorks is used for mechatronic systems development, from planning to project management, while Creo aids in product design for manufacturers.
- 🎨 SolidWorks allows for 3D modeling with both surface and solid modeling, offering a range of tools for realistic model creation.
- 🖌️ Creo focuses on parametric modeling and offers advanced features like freestyle surfacing and interactive surface design.
- 📊 SolidWorks and Creo both support animations and simulations, with SolidWorks using Motion Manager and Creo utilizing its mechanism package.
- 🎭 Rendering in SolidWorks is enhanced by Photo View 360 for photorealistic outputs, while Creo's rendering is more basic and focused on engineering needs.
- 📈 SolidWorks is user-friendly with an easier learning curve, suitable for mechanical design and smaller scale projects.
- 💼 Creo is more complex and scalable, ideal for complex projects and large assemblies, but has a steeper learning curve.
- 💵 SolidWorks offers a free 12-month license for educators and hobbyists, while Creo's pricing varies based on service levels and licensing types.
Q & A
What are the primary industries that rely on CAD software?
-CAD software is primarily used in industries such as architecture, mechanical engineering, and gaming to turn ideas into realistic models.
When was SolidWorks first founded and by whom?
-SolidWorks was founded in 1993 by John Heshtek.
What significant acquisition did SolidWorks experience in its early history?
-SolidWorks was purchased by the company Dassault Systèmes on June 24, 1997.
How has SolidWorks evolved since its inception?
-SolidWorks began as a simple solid modeler and has since developed into a full CAD program with improved assembly performance, 3D mesh modeling, and many other features.
Who founded Creo and when was it initially released?
-Creo was founded by Dr. Samuel Geisberg in 1985 and was initially released as Pro/ENGINEER by the company PTC in 1987.
What are the three basic types of files generated by SolidWorks?
-SolidWorks generates three types of files: the part, the assembly, and the drawing, which are all interrelated.
What additional capabilities does SolidWorks offer besides 3D modeling?
-SolidWorks offers simulation, cost estimation, sustainable design, and data management capabilities.
How does Creo assist in product design?
-Creo aids in product design through 3D direct modeling, finite element analysis, technical illustrations, and visualizations.
What are the differences between SolidWorks and Creo in terms of modeling and designing?
-SolidWorks is mainly a solid modeler and is parametric, while Creo offers parametric and direct modeling, with advanced features like freestyle surfacing and topology optimization.
How do SolidWorks and Creo handle animations?
-SolidWorks uses the Motion Manager and Animation Assistant for animations, while Creo offers two methods: using snapshots and the Mechanism package for smoother animations.
What are the differences in rendering capabilities between SolidWorks and Creo?
-SolidWorks has PhotoView 360 for creating photorealistic renderings, whereas Creo's rendering is more basic and is considered a sub-feature of the CAD package.
Which industries are SolidWorks and Creo commonly used in?
-SolidWorks is used in industries like medical devices, transportation, and building professionals, while Creo is used in automotive, aerospace, heavy machinery, and robotics due to its adaptability.
How do the learning curves of SolidWorks and Creo compare?
-SolidWorks is considered user-friendly with an easy learning curve, making it suitable for beginners and mechanical engineering design jobs. Creo is more complex and has a steeper learning curve, suitable for more complex projects.
What are the differences in availability and pricing between SolidWorks and Creo?
-SolidWorks is available on Windows, Mac, and touch pen or dial input devices, with a standard license price and a free 12-month license for qualified individuals. Creo is only available on Windows, with two types of licenses (locked and floating) and a variety of pricing based on service levels.
What factors should be considered when choosing between SolidWorks and Creo?
-The choice between SolidWorks and Creo depends on the complexity of the project and the user's goals. SolidWorks is better for simpler projects, while Creo is suited for complex designs and top-down design approaches.
Outlines
🔧 Introduction to CAD Software: SolidWorks vs. Creo
The video script introduces the importance of CAD software in various industries, highlighting SolidWorks and Creo as prominent examples. SolidWorks, founded in 1993 by John Heshtek, has evolved from a simple solid modeler to a comprehensive CAD program, enhancing assembly performance and 3D mesh modeling. Creo, initially released as Pro/ENGINEER in 1987 by Dr. Samuel Geisberg, focuses on performance and functionality, impacting the CAD market significantly. The script aims to guide viewers in choosing the best CAD software for their needs, outlining the history and capabilities of both SolidWorks and Creo.
🛠️ Functionalities and Capabilities of SolidWorks and Creo
SolidWorks is described as a 3D modeler that allows users to transform ideas into complex models, parts, and assemblies. It generates three types of files corresponding to parts, assemblies, and drawings, with modifications reflecting across all related files. The software offers simulation, cost estimation, sustainable design, and data management capabilities. Creo, on the other hand, is a family of 3D CAD parametric modeling software used for product design across various manufacturing sectors. It supports 3D direct modeling, finite element analysis, technical illustrations, and visualizations. Creo also offers advanced features like topology optimization and extensions for enhanced surface design control. The script contrasts the modeling and designing processes of SolidWorks, which is primarily a solid modeler with parametric capabilities, and Creo, which provides extensive parametric and freestyle modeling capabilities.
🎨 Animation, Simulation, and Rendering in CAD Software
The script discusses the animation and simulation capabilities of SolidWorks and Creo. SolidWorks allows for animation creation through a timeline and motion manager, with the option to add rotations and bursts. Creo offers two animation methods: snapshot and mechanism package, with the latter producing smoother animations. Both software provide rendering capabilities, with SolidWorks featuring PhotoView 360 for photorealistic renderings and Creo offering a basic rendering feature through Creo Render Studio. The script also touches on the industries where each software is predominantly used, with SolidWorks being favored for mechanical design and building professionals, while Creo is used in automotive, aerospace, and heavy machinery due to its adaptability and simulation capabilities.
📊 Comparing Usability, Pricing, and Licensing of SolidWorks and Creo
The script compares the usability of SolidWorks and Creo, with SolidWorks being more user-friendly and suitable for beginners, while Creo has a steeper learning curve and is more complex. SolidWorks is available on Windows, Mac, and touch pen or dial input devices, whereas Creo is only available on Windows. Pricing and licensing options differ, with SolidWorks offering a standard license at $3995 and an annual subscription service for $1295, including technical support and upgrades. It also provides a free 12-month license for educators, makers, and students. Creo offers two licensing types: locked for single-device use and floating for multiple devices, with subscription pricing varying based on service levels and device usage. The script concludes by emphasizing that the choice between SolidWorks and Creo depends on the complexity of the project and the user's goals, with SolidWorks being more suitable for simpler designs and Creo for complex, top-down designs.
Mindmap
Keywords
💡CAD Software
💡SolidWorks
💡Creo
💡Parametric Modeling
💡Assembly Performance
💡3D Mesh Modeling
💡Simulation
💡Rendering
💡Top-Down Design
💡Ease of Use
Highlights
CAD software is essential across industries for turning ideas into realistic models.
SolidWorks and Creo are prominent CAD software examples known for their functionalities.
SolidWorks, founded in 1993, has evolved from a simple solid modeler to a full CAD program.
Creo, initially released in 1987 as Pro Engineer, was one of the first major solid modelers to impact the CAD market.
SolidWorks generates three types of files: part, assembly, and drawing, with modifications reflecting across all related files.
Creo is a 3D CAD parametric modeling software used for product design by various manufacturers.
SolidWorks is used for developing mechatronic systems from planning to project management.
Creo offers extensions like Creo Interactive Surface Design for advanced control over geometry.
SolidWorks allows creating animations by dragging components along a timeline.
Creo's animation creation is simple, utilizing snapshots or the mechanism package for smoother animations.
SolidWorks' PhotoView 360 technology enables the creation of photorealistic renderings.
Creo's rendering feature, while basic, can produce respectable results for engineering software.
SolidWorks is designed for mechanics designers and building professionals, used in medical devices and transport factories.
Creo is adaptable for industries like automotive, aerospace, and heavy machinery, suitable for complex design projects.
SolidWorks is user-friendly with an easy learning curve, ideal for mechanical engineering design jobs.
Creo has a steeper learning curve but is scalable for projects ranging from simple to complex.
SolidWorks is available on Windows, Mac, and touch pen or dial input devices.
Creo is only available on Windows, with licensing options based on device use.
The choice between SolidWorks and Creo depends on project complexity and goals, with Creo suitable for complex designs and SolidWorks for simpler ones.
Transcripts
it is difficult to find an industry
nowadays that is not in any way
dependent on cad software to turn ideas
into a realistic model whether it is in
architecture
mechanical engineering or even gaming
solidworks and creo are two prominent
examples of these different
types of cad software they are both
known for their impressive
functionalities
used by many designers and professionals
in this video
we're going to help you compare between
the two types of cad software
in order to choose the best one
solidworks history spans back to 1993.
it was founded by john heshtek
solidworks was purchased on june 24
1997 by the company dazzle system 2.
this technology was one of the first
significant 3d modelers for windows
while solidworks began as a simple solid
modeler it has since developed into a
full cad
program its early updates have increased
assembly performance
to enable designers to create larger
assemblies
improved 3d mesh modeling and many other
features
creo was founded in 1985
by dr samuel geisberg and initially
released in 1987
as pro engineer by the company
parametric technology corporation
it was one of the first major solid
monitors to winter the cad market
and greatly impact the industry the main
focus was always the performance
and depth of the functions as it was
built from the top down over time
and in countless benchmarks the software
proved that it has a great functionality
and impressive speed
solidworks is a 3d modeler that enables
users to take simple ideas and turn them
into complex models
parts and assemblies it generates three
types of files
relating to three basic concepts the
part the assembly
and the drawing these files are related
any modification
at any level is reflected in all the
files concerned
with it users can also take advantage of
simulation
cost estimation sustainable design and
data management capabilities
it is used to develop mechatronic
systems from beginning to end
at the initial stage the software is
used for planning
visual ideation modeling visibility
assessment
prototyping and project management the
software is then used for the design and
building of mechanical electrical
and software elements creo is a family
of 3d cad parametric modeling software
that aids in product design for all
types of manufacturers used in 3d direct
modeling
finite element analysis technical
illustrations
and visualizations with creo parametric
users can create and develop complex
surface geometry
using a range of features and freestyle
modeling capabilities
for users seeking more extensive
capabilities ptc offers extensions like
creo interactive surface design
extension
isdx to give users better control over
tendency and curvature
so what do you think what are the
modeling and designing differences
between solidworks and creole
solidworks and creo were both used to
make drawings and create models
however there are some differences in
the process that we are going to talk
about in this part
solidworks is mainly a solid modeler it
is a parametric software which means
that you can assign dimensions to your
geometry
consequently it will give you the wanted
result by using this software
you can build your design with surfaces
you can create any shape
and you can imagine of course if you
give it time and practice
you can use solid modelling to create
designs because solids have many
benefits
but there are some limitations those
components are good at capturing
manufacturing data
like mass weight etc but they can also
have
some limits and put banners in your way
while creating designs
your models will often appear somewhat
boxy and dual
the best way to benefit from this
software is to use both surfaces
and solids to achieve truly realistic
models
solidworks comes with a box of tools
that you can use freely
this software is mainly known for its 3d
features but you can also
draw 2d designs and shapes in it however
it should be reserved for annotations
ideally
you should use your 3d models to create
2d drawings
solidworks drawings comprise at least
one view generated from either a part or
assembly
kriya comes with a full screen mod
backed up with context aware mini
toolbars
book selection and geometry regions in
sketching
as opposed to fully trimmed sketch
geometry mini toolbars
are also available across a much wider
spread
of the system's modules and in both 2d
and 3d environments
this software comes with an option
called style features that lets you
create free form curves
and surfaces and also gives you the
possibility to combine
limitless numbers of them furthermore
its technical surfacing option
lets you manipulate patches of specific
types of surfaces
within their designated measurement
constraints working with curved tangents
that you can alter on screen freestyle
surfacing
lets you adjust the boundaries and other
measurements of your surface
the underlying structure changes as the
surface does
so as to keep everything in proportion
creo focuses on
bringing advanced cad tools such as
topology optimization
which makes it possible for users to
create optimized shapes
directly into geometry so can we create
animation and simulations with
solidworks
and creole in solidworks you can create
animation
by dragging the time bar along the
timeline to the specific point you
choose
and then you drag the component you want
to create
animation to the targeted location the
motion manager
moves the component from its essential
position to the position you designated
at the specified time use the animation
assistant to create
animations or to add rotation bursts
and gatherings to exist in motion
studies creating animation in creo is
considered simple
this software comes with two different
methods to create
animations the first one utilizes
snapshots
and the second one uses several matters
in korea's mechanism package
the snapshot method is arguably the
easiest to use
however the latter method creates a
smoother animation
with creo simulate users can cut down
production time by running powerful
simulations in a few mere clicks
from linear statistics structure
analysis to model structure analysis
everything is right at your fingertips
and now
let's talk about rendering well you can
render by using both solidworks and creo
thanks to both software it is possible
to quickly present designs that are
close to reality
offering your customers easily
understandable work
with solidworks and by using photo view
360
technology it is possible to create
photorealistic
renderings more easily photo view 360
is a solid works recent adding that
produces photorealistic renderings of
models
the rendered image incorporates the
appearances
lighting scene and decals included with
the model
foreview 360 is available with
solidworks professional
or solidworks premium by these simple
steps you will be able to have a
realistic
final rendering you just have to click
tools
adding photo view 360 start a preview in
the graphics area
edit appearances the scene details
and lights when you feel that your
design is ready to render
perform a final step by choosing photo
view
final render for creo render is simply
not a high enough priority
you can indeed create them with it but
wondering in creo
is a bare bones option that you would
expect in an engineering
software program that can give a
respectable result
but it is limited by the fact that it is
a sub feature
of a cad package the software comes with
a feature called creator render studio
which compiles with elements such as
model appearances
scenes and lighting to create a render
image
in a rendered image you can see how an
environment reflects onto a surface this
can help to reveal design flaws
or confirm design objectives it also
shows
how a modeled object will look in a
real-world setting
with realistic lighting shadowing and
surroundings
solidworks is used by a large class of
industries
technical drawers engineers and
specialists
but it is specifically designed for
mechanics designers and building
professionals
it is used in medical device companies
transport factories
and technical services creo is used in
many
industries and companies because of its
extensive adaptability
including automotive aerospace heavy
machinery
engineering services designing and
building robots companies
for example a robot and others that
require re-bus
testing and simulation of designs before
they are manufactured
i am pretty sure that by now you are
probably wondering
which one is easier to learn and use
well beginners will find some
difficulties using solidworks and creo
because they both require basic
information about using cad tools
solidworks is considered user friendly
and known for its easy learning curve
it is a good tool for mechanical
engineering design jobs
it makes the process of creating a 3d
result of a piece of a machine
or even a building easier this mid-range
cad
package has an easier initial usability
curve although this gets steeper
given that it started life as a simpler
piece of software
with complexity bolted on to compare
with
other cad package solidworks gets messy
when it comes to complicated scenarios
unfortunately the ease-to-use paradigm
falls apart in the face of complex
models when it comes to creo
it is considered a bit complex for
beginners and
also by the difficulty of its deeper
learning curve
it is scalable and can cope with product
from the very simple to very complex
whether working on one small part or
interaction between parts or
sophisticated geometry
long story short as you can tell
solidworks seems to be
easier than creo especially for
beginners however
keep in mind that any software is
considered reachable
and easy to use if you give it enough
time and practice
solidworks is not only available on
windows and mac
but also in touch pen or dial input
devices
to guarantee a better experience when it
comes to creo
it is only available on windows
solidworks and creo
have different options when it comes to
pricing and license as well
one license of solidworks standard is
3995.
the annual subscription service for a
standard license
which covers technical support upgrades
and more for one year
is 1 295 however
this software offers a free 12 month
license
for all qualified educators makers
hobbyists military students and
sponsored organizations
creo is available with two types of
license based on how many devices used
the first one is locked which means that
you can use creo
on a single device such as a work
desktop
and you can not transfer the program to
any other device
the second one is floating with which
you can use creo
on several devices the exact price of
creo can be hard to pin down
without talking to a cell person because
it offers a wide variety of extras
that are meant to be tailored to your
specific situation
however five basic service levels have
subscription pricing
to start off with all prices are pair
year subscription fees
design essentials two thousand three
hundred ninety dollars for locked
two thousand nine hundred thirty one
dollars for floating
design advanced five thousand eight
hundred ninety dollars for locked
seven thousand two hundred ninety nine
dollars for floating
design advanced plus ten thousand three
hundred dollars for locked
ten thousand nine hundred eighty dollars
for floating
design premium fourteen thousand three
hundred seventy five dollars
for locked fifteen thousand six hundred
ten dollars
for floating design premium plus twenty
thousand dollars
for locked and no floating license
available
and now let's answer the most important
question
which one is better there is no right or
wrong answer to which you should use for
your next project
but if your project consists of top-down
design
as an automotive company for example you
will definitely want to use creo
creo is much more stable and far
superior to solidworks
when it comes to top-down design and
surfacing kriya would also be a better
choice for any project consisting of
large assemblies
solidworks is primarily used for smaller
scale
and simpler design projects it will be
able to solve your problem
within limits solid works cannot work
with large assemblies or designed with
high quality surfaces
it is becoming more widely used in the
industry
due to its easy to use nature for
designing simpler projects
there is no need to go through the
hassle of learning
all of these advanced methods and
techniques in creo
this makes solidworks a much more
attractive option to those customers
overall
choosing between creole and solidworks
for your business or studies
comes down to one main factor the
complexity of your project and your goal
if you wish to design something
extremely complex creo is definitely the
choice for you
but if you want to design simpler
objects you might want to look into
using solidworks as the best option
Weitere ähnliche Videos ansehen
5.0 / 5 (0 votes)