Cara Menang Pileg : Strategi Timses atau Strategi Tandem?

politician academy

15 Sept 202310:54

Summary

TLDRThis video discusses two main strategies for winning the 2024 legislative elections: forming your own campaign team or using a tandem strategy. Forming a team offers greater control but can be expensive and requires careful recruitment. The tandem strategy, which involves working with candidates at different levels, is simpler and more cost-effective but poses challenges with trust and coordination. The recommendation is to combine both strategies, focusing more on the team while still utilizing the tandem approach. Emphasis is placed on strategic control and minimizing risks in execution.

Takeaways

😀 There are two main strategies for winning in the 2024 election: forming your own team (strategy one) and the tandem strategy (strategy two).
🏆 Strategy one involves creating a personalized team tailored to your needs, capabilities, and target votes, which can be divided into different fields like media, creative, and ground attack, as well as by territory.
👥 The team leader, often referred to as the campaign manager, should be someone close, trustworthy, and with strong territorial and leadership skills to orchestrate the victory efforts.
💸 The cost of forming a team can be significant, depending on the number of people and the geographical coverage required, including operational costs and incentives for the team members.
🔎 Challenges with team formation include recruitment of the right people, ensuring loyalty, placing the right person in the right position, and effective monitoring and evaluation.
🤝 The tandem strategy is seen as promising because it appears simpler, less resource-intensive, and aims to share the burden of vote acquisition with other candidates at different levels.
🔄 Tandem partnerships require good collaboration between candidates at various levels, such as between provincial and city/district candidates, to ensure a linear flow of votes.
🚫 The tandem strategy also has its challenges, such as selecting the right partner, ensuring loyalty, and implementing the agreed-upon responsibilities to avoid conflicts and unfulfilled promises.
📈 A recommendation is to combine both strategies, with a focus on team formation (70%) and tandem partnerships (30%), ensuring control and effectiveness in the campaign.
⚖️ Control is a critical factor in the success of the campaign; team formation provides more control, whereas tandem partnerships may lack control and lead to unfulfilled promises if not managed properly.

Q & A

What are the two main strategies discussed for winning in the 2024 election?
-The two main strategies discussed are forming one's own team (timses) and the tandem strategy.
What are the different fields and territories that a candidate's team can be divided into?
-The team can be divided into fields like media, creative, and ground attack, and territories such as Dapil, Kabupaten, Kecamatan, and Desa.
Who typically leads a timses and what are their key responsibilities?
-A timses is usually led by a campaign manager who is close to the candidate, has good territorial and leadership skills, and is responsible for orchestrating the winning efforts and reporting to the candidate.
What are the main challenges associated with forming a timses?
-Challenges include high costs due to personnel and territory, recruitment issues, loyalty concerns, proper placement of individuals, and effective monitoring and evaluation.
What is the basic concept of the tandem strategy in the context of the election?
-The tandem strategy involves working with candidates at lower or higher levels to share the burden of obtaining votes, aiming for a linear increase in votes across different levels.
Why is the tandem strategy considered promising and what are its benefits?
-The tandem strategy is seen as promising because it appears simpler, less energy and cost-consuming, and helps in obtaining votes collectively.
What are the potential issues with the tandem strategy?
-Potential issues include choosing the right tandem partner, loyalty concerns, and the implementation of agreements which might not be honored.
How can a candidate ensure the effectiveness of the tandem strategy?
-A candidate can ensure effectiveness by carefully selecting partners, ensuring emotional closeness and compatibility, and establishing clear agreements and responsibilities.
What recommendation does the speaker give regarding the combination of timses and tandem strategies?
-The speaker recommends combining both strategies but prioritizing timses, suggesting a 70/30 split in focus between timses and tandem.
Why is control within one's own team (timses) considered important according to the speaker?
-Control within one's own team is important because it ensures that the candidate has direct influence over the campaign's direction and can avoid the risks associated with relying on external tandem partners.
What advice does the speaker give to ensure the success of the tandem strategy?
-The speaker advises following certain methods to make the tandem strategy work effectively, which will be detailed in subsequent content.

Outlines

00:00

🎯 Strategies for Winning the 2024 Elections

The speaker introduces two main strategies to win the 2024 legislative elections: forming one's own campaign team (timses) or using a tandem strategy. In the first strategy, candidates build their own teams, which are organized either by specific fields (e.g., media, social media, ground operations) or by territorial hierarchy (from district coordinators to polling station coordinators). A campaign manager leads the team, and trust is essential, as well as ensuring the right person is in the right role. However, this approach requires significant financial resources for operations and incentives. Issues such as poor recruitment, lack of loyalty, and improper task assignments can lead to failure. In fact, 40-60% of candidate losses stem from poorly managed campaign teams.

05:01

🤝 The Tandem Strategy: A Simpler Approach

The tandem strategy appears more straightforward and less resource-intensive. It involves candidates at various levels (local to national) working together to secure votes. By pooling efforts, candidates at lower levels can help those at higher levels. For instance, a provincial candidate needing 15,000 votes could team up with local candidates who each need 1,500 votes, sharing the workload and costs. This strategy can be highly effective, but it also has challenges, such as maintaining loyalty among partners and ensuring clear agreements on cost-sharing for campaigning efforts. Disloyal tandem partners can lead to betrayal and broken agreements, potentially harming the overall campaign.

10:02

💼 Choosing Between Timses and Tandem Strategies

The speaker advises combining both strategies, with a heavier focus on forming a campaign team (70% effort) and using the tandem strategy (30% effort). The control over the campaign is stronger with a timses, while tandem partnerships rely on mutual trust, which can be risky. The speaker suggests that, while tandems reduce costs, they can lead to disappointment if partners fail to meet their vote contribution promises. The speaker concludes with encouragement for viewers to stay focused on their campaign efforts and promises further content on how to make tandems more effective in future discussions.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Strategi Pembentukan Tim Sendiri

This term refers to the strategy of forming one's own campaign team for an election. It is crucial for tailoring the team to the candidate's needs, capabilities, and target votes. In the video, it is mentioned as the first strategy for winning in the 2024 election, emphasizing customization and the division of the team into various fields such as media, creative, and ground attack, as well as territorial divisions.

💡Strategi Tandem

Strategi Tandem refers to the strategy of forming alliances with other candidates at different electoral levels to share the burden of campaigning and to mutually benefit from each other's voter base. This strategy is highlighted as being simpler, less costly, and less time-consuming compared to forming one's own team. It involves collaboration to gain votes collectively, aiming to create a linear flow of support from lower to higher levels of candidacy.

💡Campaign Manager

The Campaign Manager is a key figure in the campaign team who is entrusted with close proximity to the candidate, understanding the candidate well, and being highly trusted. This role is responsible for orchestrating all efforts towards victory and reporting back to the candidate. The Campaign Manager's role is crucial for the success of the campaign, as they oversee the operations and ensure the team's efforts are aligned with the campaign's goals.

💡Biaya Operasional

Biaya Operasional, or operational costs, are the expenses associated with the day-to-day running of the campaign, including field movements and incentives for the team. The video discusses how forming one's own team can be costly due to the need to recruit personnel and cover operational expenses, which are essential for the campaign's activities and team motivation.

💡Insentif

Insentif, or incentives, are the rewards or bonuses given to the campaign team members to motivate them and ensure their commitment to the campaign's success. The video mentions that these incentives are not free and must be provided based on the team's performance, whether it's on a weekly, bi-weekly, or monthly basis.

💡Koordinator

Koordinator, or coordinators, are individuals responsible for overseeing specific areas or territories within the campaign. They are mentioned in the context of dividing the campaign team based on territories, such as Dapil (district), Kabupaten (regency), Kecamatan (subdistrict), and Desa (village), up to TPS (polling station) level. These coordinators play a significant role in organizing and managing campaign efforts at the local level.

💡Trust

Trust is a fundamental aspect of the relationship between the candidate and the Campaign Manager, as well as the entire campaign team. The video emphasizes the importance of trust in ensuring that the team is loyal, committed, and works towards the campaign's objectives without betrayal or disloyalty.

💡Monitoring dan Evaluasi

Monitoring and evaluation are essential processes in managing the campaign team. They involve overseeing the team's performance, ensuring that job descriptions are clear, and making necessary adjustments to improve the team's effectiveness. The video suggests that proper monitoring and evaluation can help address issues within the team and maintain the campaign's momentum.

💡Kekalahan

Kekalahan, or defeat, is mentioned in the context of the consequences of an ineffective campaign team. The video suggests that a significant portion of electoral losses can be attributed to the failure of the campaign team, highlighting the importance of a well-organized and efficient team in achieving electoral success.

💡Perekrutan

Perekrutan, or recruitment, is a critical process in forming the campaign team. The video discusses the challenges of recruiting the right people, ensuring they are loyal, and have the necessary skills to contribute effectively to the campaign. It also touches on the potential issues that can arise from recruiting the wrong individuals, which can lead to disorganization and loss of trust.

Highlights

Discussing two main strategies for winning in the 2024 election: forming one's own team or tandem strategy.

Exploring the first strategy of forming one's own team, tailored to individual needs, capabilities, and vote targets.

Dividing the team into different fields such as media, creative, and ground attack, as well as territorial divisions like Dapil, Kabupaten, Kecamatan, and Desa coordinators.

The importance of having a campaign manager who is close, knowledgeable, and trustworthy to lead and orchestrate the victory efforts.

Challenges of forming a team include high costs, recruitment issues, loyalty concerns, and proper placement of team members.

The tandem strategy appears promising as it seems easier, simpler, and less resource-intensive compared to forming one's own team.

Tandem strategy involves collaboration with candidates at lower or higher levels to collectively gain votes.

Tandem collaborations are usually within the same party and recommended by most political parties for more significant and linear vote acquisition.

The simplicity of the tandem strategy where a candidate for a higher position only needs to work with a few lower-level candidates to achieve the required votes.

Challenges with the tandem strategy include choosing the right partner, ensuring loyalty, and implementing agreements effectively.

The potential for candidates to switch tandem partners mid-way through the campaign, which can disrupt plans and efforts.

The recommendation to combine both team formation and tandem strategies, with a focus on the former for better control.

The suggestion to prioritize team formation with 70% focus and allocate 30% to tandem strategy, ensuring effective collaboration.

Emphasizing the importance of control in team formation versus the lack of control in tandem strategies, which can be risky.

Advice on how to make tandem strategies effective and how to manage the responsibilities and expectations within such partnerships.

The potential for tandem partners from different parties and the need for careful consideration to avoid chaos in vote distribution.

Encouragement for candidates to continue their struggle with a focus on their goals and a salute to the nation.