Ice Spice - Y2K! ALBUM REVIEW
Summary
TLDRIn this music review, the host critiques Ice Spice's debut album 'Y2K', noting its underwhelming nature despite her rapid rise in the industry. The album is criticized for basic hooks, forgettable features, and recycled content, with a lack of lyrical versatility. Despite the album's shortcomings, the host acknowledges Ice Spice's influence on the new era of pop rap stardom, giving it a 2.4 out of 5 rating.
Takeaways
- đ€ Ice Spice's debut album 'Y2K' has been released, marking her rise from a Bronx drill queen to a Taylor Swift collaborator.
- đ The artist has become a commercial phenomenon in a short span, boasting about her success and wealth in her music.
- đ Ice Spice's strategy has been to build her brand and persona rather than releasing a large volume of music, which has proven successful.
- đ The album 'Y2K' feels underwhelming with basic hooks, forgettable features, and typical instrumentals.
- đą The album is short, with only 10 tracks spanning 23 minutes, suggesting a lack of effort to provide substantial content.
- đ The album's content is largely recycled and self-referential, with Ice Spice using the same flows and lyrical themes repeatedly.
- đ” Standout tracks like 'Thank You' have catchy refrains, but even they feel like a joke, designed to provoke a reaction.
- đ€ Collaborations on the album, such as with Central Cee, do not capitalize on the potential due to awkward execution.
- đ€ Some tracks, like 'Papa' and 'I'm Packing', show Ice Spice experimenting with her flow but come off as less engaged.
- đ The album's deep cuts do not offer much beyond the already released singles, and even features like Travis Scott fail to impress.
- đ The album ends weakly with 'TTYL', which, despite its aggression, feels more like an intro than a conclusion.
Q & A
Who is the main subject of the review in the transcript?
-The main subject of the review is Ice Spice, a New York rapper and her debut full-length album titled 'Y2K'.
What does the reviewer describe Ice Spice's approach to releasing music as?
-The reviewer describes Ice Spice's approach as being more about playing to the crowd, trolling them, and releasing each new song with the forethought of a chess move, focusing on building her brand and persona.
How does the reviewer assess the length and content of Ice Spice's album 'Y2K'?
-The reviewer assesses 'Y2K' as being very short with only 10 songs spanning just 23 minutes, and feels that the content lacks fresh, interesting, and distinct ideas, being mostly recycled and self-referential.
What is the reviewer's opinion on the hooks, features, and instrumentals of the album?
-The reviewer finds the hooks basic, the features forgettable, and the instrumentals typical for Ice Spice at this point.
What does the reviewer think about Ice Spice's lyrical versatility?
-The reviewer criticizes Ice Spice's lack of lyrical versatility, comparing her to artists like Lil Pump, and notes that the choruses on the album often do not stand out.
Which track on the album is mentioned as a standout, and why?
-The track 'Thank You' is mentioned as a standout, but even its main refrain is described as feeling like a joke thrown in to troll people.
What issue does the reviewer have with the track 'Give Me a Light'?
-The reviewer finds the chipmunk Shawn Paul sample mismatched with the skittering beat and the shouty flows from Ice Spice, making it hard to engage with the track.
What criticism does the reviewer have for Ice Spice's collaboration with Central Cee on the track 'Did It First'?
-The reviewer criticizes the awkward and unceremonious appearance of Central Cee, stating that the narrative tension between both artists leaves the track with unrealized potential.
How does the reviewer describe Ice Spice's performance on the track 'Papa'?
-The reviewer describes Ice Spice's performance on 'Papa' as exasperated or sleepy and breathy, making her sound less engaged and widening the gaps between each bar.
What is the reviewer's overall rating for Ice Spice's album 'Y2K'?
-The reviewer gives the album a rating of 2.4 out of 5, indicating underwhelming performance.
What does the reviewer suggest about Ice Spice's focus moving forward?
-The reviewer suggests that Ice Spice's focus moving forward is likely to be on singles, performances, viral social media moments, and crossovers, rather than on creating a full-length album with depth.
Outlines
đ€ Ice Spice's Y2K Album Review - High Expectations, Minimal Effort
The video script begins with the introduction of the reviewer, Bony D Tano, who dives into the review of Ice Spice's debut album 'Y2K'. The album has been highly anticipated, given Ice Spice's rapid rise to fame as a New York rapper. The reviewer notes her unique approach to the music industry, opting for a strategic release of singles rather than an overwhelming amount of material. Despite her success and collaborations with major artists like Taylor Swift, the album is critiqued for its lack of fresh ideas, with the reviewer pointing out recycled flows, self-referential lyrics, and a lack of lyrical versatility. The album's length and the predictability of its content are also highlighted as shortcomings. The reviewer expresses disappointment, suggesting that the album feels more like a formality than a creative effort, and criticizes the album's hooks, features, and instrumentals as basic and forgettable.
đ„ Critique of Ice Spice's Lyrical Content and Flow Experimentation
In the second paragraph, the critique continues with a focus on the lyrical content and flow experimentation present in Ice Spice's 'Y2K' album. The reviewer discusses the repetitive nature of her lyrics, often returning to the same points and references, and the lack of engagement in her delivery. Specific tracks are mentioned, such as 'Papa' and 'I'm packing', where Ice Spice's flow is described as exasperated or sleepy, and 'Plenty sun', which introduces a narrative shift without a clear purpose. The reviewer also comments on the weak ending of the album with the track 'TTYL', which feels more like an intro due to its punchy beat and aggressive flow. The paragraph concludes with the reviewer's overall impression that the album is less about the music and more about Ice Spice's brand and the era of pop rap stardom she is helping to shape. The paragraph ends with a call to action for viewers to share their opinions and thoughts on the album.
Mindmap
Keywords
đĄIce Spice
đĄDebut Album
đĄCommercial Success
đĄMusic Industry
đĄPersona
đĄAlbum Review
đĄChorus
đĄLyrical Versatility
đĄPop Rap Stardom
đĄViral Social Media Moments
đĄMarketing Strategy
Highlights
Ice Spice's debut album 'Y2K' is released, marking her official entry into the music industry.
She has quickly become a commercial phenomenon in the music industry.
Ice Spice refers to herself as a 'rat on the pop chart', indicating her rapid rise to fame.
The album's promotional strategy was to build her brand and persona rather than releasing a large volume of music.
Ice Spice's rise from Bronx drill queen to collaborating with Taylor Swift was rapid.
The album 'Y2K' has a short tracklist of 10 songs spanning only 23 minutes.
The album lacks fresh and distinct ideas, with many recycled and self-referential elements.
Lack of lyrical versatility is noted, with repetitive flows and vocal deliveries.
The choruses on the album often fail to stand out or engage listeners.
The track 'Give Me a Light' features a mismatched sample and aggressive flows.
The song 'Did It First' has an awkward collaboration with UK rapper Central Cee.
The song 'Plenty Sun' includes a character portrait that lacks depth and clarity.
The album ends with 'TTYL', which has an aggressive flow that contrasts with its lyrical content.
The album 'Y2K' may be seen as a formality rather than a significant artistic statement.
Ice Spice's success seems to be more about singles, performances, and social media rather than full-length albums.
The reviewer rates the album a 2.4 out of 5, indicating dissatisfaction with the overall product.
Transcripts
uh hi everyone bony D Tano here the
internet's busiest music nerd and it's
time for a review of this new ice spice
album Y2K finally finally finally
finally here we have the official debut
full length album from New York rapper
Ice Spice in a few short years she has
managed to become one of the biggest
commercial
phenomen across the entire music
industry as she refered herself in one
bar on on this very album calling
herself a rat on the pop chart and
it's absolutely
110% true she has a lot to brag about on
this record in terms of her success
especially considering the show she's
been playing the money she's been making
and the numbers she's been doing off of
so little music because these days and I
feel like this doesn't even need
explaining but when most upand cominging
artists have their hit their moment in
the industry begins they kind of
furiously strike while the iron is hot
and try to maximize their potential by
dropping as much material as possible
and just begin sprinting on the music
industry treadmill until they eventually
have their Fall From Grace but ice
spice's approach has very much more been
about playing to the crowd trolling them
a bit trying to beat their expectations
and release each new song with the
amount of forethought that you would put
into a chess move while Focus using more
on building her up as a brand as a
Persona as a Zoomer rap icon which I
mean isn't much concern for me
personally as a music reviewer but I
can't deny the call that ice spice and
her team made here was the right one
because she really truly did go from
Bronx drill Queen to Taylor Swift
collaborator in the blink of an eye
still even though the process of
building up to this new album has been
pretty long and even a little dragged
out it had to come eventually and now
that we're here it feels like such a
nothing Burger the hooks are basic the
features are forgettable the
instrumentals I would say are pretty
typical for her at this point the
biggest bangers on this thing have been
out for months now and the entire track
list is a very trim 10 songs that span
only just a mere 23 minutes she's
obviously not trying to make a splash
with this thing in terms of uh giving
fans a lot of material to go off of and
comparatively the deluxe version of her
recent like EP is longer though I have
no doubt on some level we are going to
see a deluxe version of this because you
know marketing but yeah for the most
part Y2K just kind of feels like an
album in name and in name only ice spice
meeting that bare minimum 10 track
requirement just to show that she could
because even if we are getting 10 songs
on this thing I don't feel like we're
getting 10 fresh interesting distinct
ideas mostly because the vast majority
of everything on this record is so
recycled and self-referential as Miss
spice hits most of these songs with the
same flows we've heard again and again
and again same vocal deliveries same uh
drill influenced grooves a lot of third
person references to uh herself being a
baddie the fact that she's thick people
she's uh better than or flirting with
also of course a heaping helping of poop
and diaper jokes to get a rise out of
people she truly has a lack of lyrical
versatility that gives guys like little
pump a run for their money which would
be fine if the choruses on this thing
actually popped off but often they don't
I mean thank you the is probably
the biggest standout on the entire LP
but even the main refrain on that one
feels mostly like a joke just thrown in
to troll people and as far as the
singles on this thing are concerned it
kind of goes downhill from there as on
the track give me a light we have this
chipmunk Shawn Paul sample that is kind
of mismatched with a skittering beat and
shouty flows from Ice spice that sound
like she's trying to be heard over like
a club sound system or anything like
that the there's not even really
anything about her flow that makes me
want to nod my head or get further into
the track how spaced out many of her
bars are to leaves a lot to be desired
cuz sometimes what she's doing feels
more like just narrating than spitting
there's also did it first which is a
cute pop Club rap crossover that reminds
me a bit of her recent collaboration
with Pink Panther s that I enjoyed a lot
there are some adorable chopped up vocal
samples peppered throughout the song too
but I think the mood is kind of dampened
by an awkward and unceremonious
appearance from uh UK rapper Central Sea
The Narrative tension between both of
them leaves this track with a lot of
potential that isn't fully capitalized
on especially since the Hook is so
mediocre we also had the laughably basic
fat butt in the leadup to this record
which features ice spice rapping on top
of one of the most uninspired beats I
think she has ever favored she also
performs the track with this stale Nicki
Minaj flow while unironically rapping
about people stealing her flow not to
mention the moment where she brags about
not having a ghost riter and considering
how often she comes back to a lot of the
same lyrical points and references yeah
that that much is clear so yeah those
are kind of the highlights from the
record sadly the Deep Cuts don't offer
much more the Travis Scott appearance is
not really the fireworks that it could
have been meanwhile papa is one of
several moments on the record where
she's kind of experimenting with her
flow a bit hopping on the mic in a way
that feels kind of exasperated or like
she's maybe a bit sleepy and breathy but
all in all it just makes her sound less
engaged and makes the uh gaps in between
each bar that she spits just feel wider
and louder which is kind of the same on
the track I'm packing where she is
really really really leaning into that
vocal fry in and attempt to sound I
guess kind of sexy like she's sort of
moaning while rapping and I'm sure on
some level this is intentional but she
mostly just sounds High out of her mind
and Confused plenty sun is another
switch up on the album for ice spice
narratively as when she's saying stuff
about flirting in her song She's often
not focusing on a single person or
trying to paint a character portrait of
them uh or you know that character
portrait being of a guy who uh pretty
much leads like a more of a gangsta type
lifestyle he has uh plenty guns he has a
trap house and what the purpose of this
interaction is I'm not sure like are
they really all that into each other uh
does anything actually happen really the
most eventful part of this character
portrait is when she says he takes a
fake perk and then he has
diarrhea which I mean you know ice spice
she's always good for a poop joke from
here we have kind of a weak ending on
the record with TTYL which I get that
lyrically it's a sort of a goodbye
moment but considering the punchiness of
the beat the aggression of her flow on
the track it sounds like it could have
almost been an intro I mean maybe the uh
rise in aggression on this one is a
attempting to wake people up before they
completely let the album slip by them
because a lot of it does sound that
background but yeah overall I kind of
feel like this record is proof of how
much for ice spice and her brand an
album really truly does not matter and
that's kind of the thing I don't want to
say that this record is bad or is
underwhelming because I feel like ice
spice lacks the capacity and the ability
to make a good record really to me on
the surface it reads more like a lack of
effort than anything something she had
to ceremoniously go through the motions
of in order to get back to focusing on
what actually brings her success and
attention and that would be singles that
would be performances that would be
viral social media moments and
crossovers traditional media blitzes as
well and that's pretty much it but yeah
I feel like this record kind of marks a
brand new era of Pop rap stardom and Ice
spice For Better or Worse is really
Paving the way I'm feeling a decent two
strong four on this one TR position have
you given this record a listen did you
love it did you hate it what would you
rate it you're the best you're the best
what should I review next hit the like
if you like Please Subscribe and please
don't cry hit the Bell as well over here
next to my head is another video that
you can check out hit that up or a link
to subscribe to the channel Anthony
Fantan ice spice forever
5.0 / 5 (0 votes)