👀 PURDY CRITICISM?! 👀 Shannon Sharpe & Dan Orlovsky GET HEATED 🔥 | First Take

Summary

Shannon and Stephen A. debate whether 49ers quarterback Brock Purdy has proven himself as a legitimate NFL starter after leading comeback wins over the Packers and Cowboys. Shannon argues Purdy still needs to win the Super Bowl to fully silence his critics, while Stephen A. says Purdy has already exceeded expectations as a last pick rookie and cemented himself as a top 10 QB, though he may lack the elite physical tools of top-tier quarterbacks. They discuss whether Purdy can lead another comeback if the 49ers fall behind the Chiefs in the Super Bowl.

Takeaways

• 😃 The speaker questions if Brock Pry silenced his critics with his recent performance, suggesting that the ultimate test will be his performance in the Super Bowl.
• 👍 Acknowledgment that Brock answered many questions by performing well under pressure, showcasing his ability to make critical plays and use his legs effectively.
• 👀 Skepticism remains around specific plays, questioning whether luck played a part in some of his successful passes, implying that not all impressive plays were purely skill-based.
• 😮 The discussion highlights that while Brock has silenced some critics with his recent performances, skepticism will persist unless he secures a victory in the Super Bowl.
• 💪 Emphasis on Brock's need to defeat top competitors like Patrick Mahomes and the importance of performing well in high-stakes games to truly prove his worth.
• 💎 Credit is given to Brock for his remarkable improvement and significant contributions to his team's success, highlighting his journey from the last pick to leading his team to the NFC championship and potentially the Super Bowl.
• 🙋 The debate touches on whether Brock's success is sufficient to silence his critics or if he needs to win the Super Bowl to fully earn respect and recognition.
• 📱 There's a discussion on Brock's playing style, suggesting that while he may not be among the absolute elite quarterbacks, his performance solidifies him as a top player in his position.
• 📝 The speakers argue over the importance of consistent success and overcoming challenges in critical games, emphasizing that overcoming adversities in such games is a crucial measure of a quarterback's greatness.
• 🔥 The intense debate underscores the high expectations placed on quarterbacks in the NFL, where their legacy and recognition are often contingent on their performance in the most critical moments, particularly the Super Bowl.

Q & A

What does Shannon want to see from Brock Purdy in the Super Bowl?

Shannon wants to see Brock Purdy play well in the Super Bowl like he did against the Ravens. If Purdy plays an average game and the 49ers lose, Shannon feels it would diminish what Purdy has accomplished so far.

What was Brock Purdy able to show in the game against the Ravens?

Against the Ravens, Purdy showed he could make plays and lead the team when needed. He made big throws, used his legs effectively, and led them on a comeback after being down 14-0.

How does Diocare about how Purdy plays in the Super Bowl?

Diocares more about the end result. If Purdy plays poorly but the 49ers win, Diowould still praise him. But if he plays well and they lose, Diowould criticize him.

What has Purdy done to silence some of his critics?

By leading the 49ers to the NFC Championship and Super Bowl in his first two years, Purdy has cemented himself as a top 7-8 quarterback. He has shown he can expand the system and elevate players like Aiyuk.

What concerns does Stephen A. Smith have about Purdy?

Smith is concerned Purdy may need a clean pocket more than other top QBs. He also lacks the experience to lead a comeback against an explosive offense like Kansas City.

What impressive stats did Purdy have against the Ravens?

Against the Ravens, Purdy had 3 carries for 52 yards and 3 or 4 passes for 41 yards on scrambles. Those plays resulted in 6 first downs.

What does Shannon want to see from Purdy in the Super Bowl?

Shannon wants to see if Purdy can finish the job and win the Super Bowl, not just play well and lose. Shannon feels Purdy has more to prove as a quarterback.

How has Purdy elevated the 49ers offense?

Purdy has helped expand the 49ers system and elevated players like Aiyuk, who had the best season of his career. The offense has played well around Purdy.

What experience is Purdy's team lacking?

The 49ers team lacks experience playing in conference championship and Super Bowl games compared to other contenders.

What impressed Shannon about Purdy's play against the Ravens?

Shannon was impressed that Purdy showed he could make plays when it mattered. He led scoring drives and made big throws under pressure to lead a comeback.