Habiskan Rp 1 Triliun, Pembangunan Masjid Al Jabbar Tuai Polemik

Summary

The Al Jabbar Mosque, inaugurated on December 30, 2022, has sparked significant debate due to its extravagant 1 trillion rupiah budget funded by the regional government (APBD). Some view the mosque's construction as an iconic addition to Bandung's Islamic landmarks, while others question its priority, especially given ongoing regional issues like poverty and natural disasters. Critics argue that such a massive expenditure should address more pressing concerns, while supporters highlight the broader development of surrounding facilities, including a retention pond and digital museum. Despite the controversy, local leaders emphasize the project's alignment with regional development plans.

Takeaways

• 😀 The Al Jabbar Mosque, officially inaugurated on December 30, 2022, has sparked discussions among the public, especially regarding its cost and funding.
• 😀 The mosque's construction, initiated during Governor Ahmad Heriawan's tenure, has faced both support and criticism, particularly concerning the budget of 1 trillion rupiah.
• 😀 Some individuals question whether the massive budget allocated to the mosque, sourced from regional budgets (APBD), is justifiable, with some feeling it could be better spent on disaster relief efforts.
• 😀 Governor Ridwan Kamil has defended the use of APBD funds, explaining that it was part of a collaborative agreement and discussed during the Musrenbang forum.
• 😀 Ridwan Kamil clarified that the APBD funds were not solely for the mosque's construction but also for related facilities such as retention ponds and a digital museum dedicated to Prophet Muhammad and Islam in Indonesia.
• 😀 Public policy expert Yogi Suprayogi from Universitas Padjajaran stated that the use of APBD funds for the mosque was not entirely wrong, but the ethics of it depend on the perspective taken.
• 😀 Yogi Suprayogi also emphasized that public infrastructure projects for religious buildings have been a part of previous governance, regardless of the administration in power.
• 😀 A major criticism raised was that such infrastructure projects primarily benefit the Muslim community, and there are concerns about fairness regarding facilities for other religious groups, such as Christians and Hindus.
• 😀 Sugeng Prasetyo, Dean of the Faculty of Social and Political Sciences at Universitas Parahyangan, argued that there are more urgent issues that the government should address, such as poverty and malnutrition in West Java.
• 😀 Despite the controversies, once the mosque was completed, the focus shifted to proper management to ensure that the Al Jabbar Mosque becomes a source of pride for the people of West Java.

Q & A

When was Masjid Al Jabbar officially inaugurated?

Masjid Al Jabbar was officially inaugurated on December 30, 2022.

What are some of the controversial aspects surrounding the construction of Masjid Al Jabbar?

The controversy revolves around the huge budget for its construction, amounting to 1 trillion Rupiah, and the use of regional government funds (APBD) for this project, which some argue could be better spent on other areas like disaster relief.

What is the response of Ridwan Kamil regarding the use of public funds for the mosque?

Ridwan Kamil stated that the use of public funds, including APBD, was based on mutual agreements and discussions in the Musrenbang forum, and that the funds were not just for the mosque's construction but also for various facilities around the mosque, such as retention ponds and a digital museum of Prophet Muhammad and Islam in the archipelago.

What is the opinion of Yogi Suprayogi, a public policy expert from Universitas Padjajaran, on the project?

Yogi Suprayogi believes that the decision to use 1 trillion Rupiah from APBD for the mosque's construction is not entirely wrong, but he highlights that the ethical concerns depend on perspective. He emphasizes that the issue should not just be about the mosque's construction but about the equal distribution of infrastructure for different religious communities.

What is Sugeng Prasetyo's view on the priorities for government funding?

Sugeng Prasetyo, Dean of the Faculty of Social and Political Sciences at Universitas Parahyangan, argues that there are more urgent issues that need addressing, such as poverty and the high rate of stunting in West Java. He believes the government should be more sensitive to these issues when deciding on funding priorities.

What additional facilities were included in the Masjid Al Jabbar complex apart from the mosque itself?

The Masjid Al Jabbar complex includes additional facilities such as a retention pond and a digital museum dedicated to Prophet Muhammad and Islam in the archipelago.

How did the public react to the allocation of the budget for the mosque?

The public reaction has been mixed, with some people questioning the use of a 1 trillion Rupiah budget for the mosque, especially when the funds could potentially be used for other pressing needs like disaster relief or addressing social issues.

Has the West Java Provincial Government provided an official response to the criticism regarding the mosque's construction?

As of the information provided, the West Java Provincial Government has not given an official response to the various criticisms related to the construction of Masjid Al Jabbar.

What concerns were raised by those criticizing the mosque's construction with public funds?

Critics raised concerns about the use of public funds for the construction of a mosque, questioning whether it was appropriate to use the regional budget for a project that benefits only one religious group, while other religious communities may not receive similar support.

What should the government ensure after the completion of the mosque, according to experts?

Experts emphasize that after the mosque's completion, the government must ensure proper management and maintenance of the mosque to ensure that it becomes a symbol of pride for the people of West Java.