#katamasdosen EPISODE 5: SHIN TAE YONG OUT, PUBLIK RAGUKAN KLUIVERT

Summary

The video discusses the recent firing of Indonesia's national football team coach, Shin Tae-yong, by the PSSI despite his achievements in improving the team's performance and achieving historic qualifications. The speaker highlights Shin's contributions, such as raising the team's FIFA ranking and developing young talent, but notes PSSI's concerns about strategy and communication. The rumored replacement, Patrick Kluivert, is questioned due to his mixed coaching record and personal controversies. Public skepticism around this decision is expressed, with the speaker urging PSSI to provide a clear justification to avoid damaging the trust built in Indonesian football.

Takeaways

• 😀 PSSI dismissed Coach Shin Tae-yong despite his success in improving Indonesia's national football team.
• 😀 Shin Tae-yong's tenure saw Indonesia’s FIFA ranking rise and historic World Cup and AFC Asian Cup qualifications.
• 😀 Coach Shin Tae-yong gave young players like Rizky Rido, Marcelino Ferdinan, and others significant playing time.
• 😀 Under Shin Tae-yong, the national team developed a more disciplined and professional mindset.
• 😀 PSSI’s reasons for dismissing Shin Tae-yong include poor communication with players and misaligned strategies.
• 😀 The public and football fans are strongly attached to Coach Shin Tae-yong due to his achievements and positive impact.
• 😀 PSSI has been rumored to replace Shin Tae-yong with former Barcelona player Patrick Kluivert.
• 😀 Patrick Kluivert’s coaching record is underwhelming, with more losses than wins in his previous roles.
• 😀 Kluivert has faced personal controversies, including financial issues and a serious car accident, which raise concerns.
• 😀 The public is questioning PSSI’s decision to hire Kluivert, given his less impressive coaching background compared to Shin Tae-yong.
• 😀 The speaker urges PSSI to provide a clear and well-explained rationale behind the decision to appoint Kluivert as coach.

Q & A

Why was coach Shin Tae-yong dismissed by PSSI?

Shin Tae-yong was dismissed due to a combination of factors, including strategic issues, lack of effective communication between him and the players, and a perceived failure to meet certain expectations. Despite improvements in the team, these factors led PSSI to decide to part ways with him.

What achievements did Shin Tae-yong accomplish during his tenure as the Indonesian national football team coach?

Shin Tae-yong successfully improved the national team's FIFA ranking, led Indonesia to the third round of World Cup qualification, helped the team qualify for the Asian Cup, and introduced younger players into the squad. He also achieved victories such as defeating Saudi Arabia 2-0, a significant achievement for Indonesia.

How did Shin Tae-yong's approach to player selection differ from previous coaches?

Shin Tae-yong took risks by selecting younger, less experienced players and giving them key roles in the national team. He notably gave regular starting spots to players like Rizki Rido, who was only 20, and other young talents such as Marcelino Ferdinan and Ernando, which was a departure from previous coaching strategies.

How did Shin Tae-yong impact the mindset of Indonesian players?

Shin Tae-yong significantly changed the mindset of Indonesian players, emphasizing discipline, hard work, and a professional approach. For example, players like Rizki Rido mentioned how Shin influenced their diet and training regimen, and he was not afraid to bench star players for not meeting discipline standards.

What was Erik Tohir's rationale for firing Shin Tae-yong despite his achievements?

Erik Tohir stated that despite the team's achievements, there were strategic shortcomings, ineffective communication between the coach and players, and some tactical aspects that were not working. This led to the decision to part ways with Shin Tae-yong after evaluating the team's performance in various matches.

What are the concerns about Patrick Kluivert potentially becoming the new coach?

The main concerns about Patrick Kluivert taking over as coach include his limited coaching experience, with only two previous managerial roles, one of which was not very successful. Additionally, his controversial past involving a gambling debt, a fatal car accident, and allegations of misconduct raise concerns about his suitability as a leader for the national team.

What is the public's reaction to the possibility of Patrick Kluivert being appointed as coach?

The public has expressed skepticism about Patrick Kluivert's appointment, with many criticizing PSSI's decision. They question his coaching credentials and his past controversies, particularly when compared to Shin Tae-yong's successful tenure. Fans are concerned that Kluivert might not be the right choice to build on the progress made under Shin Tae-yong.

How does Patrick Kluivert's coaching record compare to Shin Tae-yong's?

Patrick Kluivert's coaching record is less impressive than Shin Tae-yong's. Kluivert has only managed to win 4 out of 14 matches as the head coach of Curacao, with 6 losses and 4 draws. In contrast, Shin Tae-yong achieved notable success with Indonesia, improving their FIFA ranking and securing key qualifications.

What controversies have surrounded Patrick Kluivert's personal life?

Patrick Kluivert has been involved in several controversies, including a significant gambling debt of 16 billion rupiah, a car accident that resulted in a fatality, and allegations of sexual misconduct involving a young woman. These issues have raised doubts about his personal character and leadership qualities.

What are the risks for PSSI if they do not explain their decision to appoint Kluivert clearly?

If PSSI fails to provide a clear and logical explanation for their decision to appoint Patrick Kluivert, it could harm their credibility and public trust. Fans may feel that the appointment is not based on merit, and the association could face increased criticism, especially given Shin Tae-yong's popularity and the high expectations surrounding the national team.