SHIN TAE-YONG FIRED?! Indonesia Hires Patrick Kluivert As Head Coach | FIFA World Cup 2026

Summary

In this video, the hosts discuss the controversial firing of South Korean coach Shin Tae-yong, who led Indonesia's national football team to unprecedented success in World Cup qualification. Despite achieving great results with a young squad, the Indonesian Football Federation sacked him in favor of Dutch legend Klyver, aiming for a cultural shift. While Klyver's Dutch background and experience offer hope, the hosts express concerns about the timing of the decision and the potential impact on the team's World Cup aspirations. The hosts highlight the risk of losing momentum and the uncertainty surrounding the team's future under a new coach.

Takeaways

• 😀 Shin Tae-yong, the South Korean coach of Indonesia, was unexpectedly fired earlier this week.
• 😀 Clarence Seedorf, a Dutch football legend with experience at Ajax and Barcelona, replaces Shin Tae-yong as head coach of the Indonesian national football team.
• 😀 The firing of Shin Tae-yong is seen as a controversial decision, given his successes with the team, including their best-ever record and strong World Cup qualification position.
• 😀 The decision to fire Shin Tae-yong is believed to be driven by a desire for a cultural shift within the Indonesian football team.
• 😀 Despite not qualifying automatically for the World Cup, Indonesia was in a strong position to make it to the tournament, thanks to the team's young squad and Shin Tae-yong's tactical guidance.
• 😀 Many believe the timing of Shin Tae-yong's firing—right in the middle of World Cup qualification—is detrimental and could hurt Indonesia's chances of success.
• 😀 The speakers express concern that the change in coaching staff could disrupt the team's momentum and impact player performances.
• 😀 Shin Tae-yong was particularly effective in working with Indonesia's young team, teaching them fundamental international football principles and helping them improve in each game.
• 😀 Despite the coaching change, there is hope that Seedorf can bring positive changes, particularly with his experience in high-level football and potential better communication with the players due to a shared language.
• 😀 The future of Indonesia's World Cup qualification now depends on how the players adapt to Seedorf's leadership and whether they continue their positive trajectory in terms of performance, especially defensively.
• 😀 If Indonesia fails to qualify for the World Cup, many will look back at the decision to fire Shin Tae-yong as a pivotal moment, questioning what might have happened if he had remained in charge.

Q & A

Why was South Korean coach Shinte Young fired from his role as the coach of Indonesia's national football team?

Shinte Young was fired due to what seems to be a desire for a cultural shift by the Indonesia Football Federation. Despite his success with the team, they opted for a change in leadership, which the speaker believes was a mistake.

Who has been appointed as the new head coach of Indonesia's national football team?

The new head coach of Indonesia's national football team is Klyver, a Dutch legend who had a successful playing career at Ajax and Barcelona. He has not had many coaching opportunities but is now leading the Indonesian team.

What is the general opinion about Shinte Young’s performance as Indonesia's coach?

Shinte Young's performance is highly regarded. He is praised for his commitment to the team and his deep understanding of the tactical identity of Indonesian players. His tenure saw some of Indonesia's best results, and he is credited with bringing the team to a strong position in World Cup qualification.

What were the concerns raised regarding the timing of Shinte Young’s dismissal?

The timing of Shinte Young's dismissal raised concerns because it occurred in the middle of World Cup qualification. The speaker worries that this decision could disrupt the team's momentum and negatively impact their chances of qualifying.

How did the speaker describe the progress of the Indonesian team under Shinte Young?

Under Shinte Young, the Indonesian team made significant progress, with improvements in defense and offensive threats. The team showed gradual improvement in each game, which was a key aspect of their evolution during World Cup qualification.

Why is there concern about the potential impact of the new coach, Klyver, on the team?

The concern lies in whether Klyver can replicate Shinte Young's strong relationship with the players, especially since he doesn’t have the same deep connection with them. The speaker fears that this could disrupt the team's progress, particularly in defense, and may affect their chances of qualifying for the World Cup.

What positive aspect is associated with Klyver’s appointment?

A positive aspect of Klyver’s appointment is his Dutch background. With Indonesia recruiting Dutch talent, there’s hope that Klyver's connections and understanding of Dutch football can bring further tactical improvements and benefit the team's development.

How does the speaker feel about the overall decision to replace Shinte Young with Klyver?

The speaker strongly disagrees with the decision, calling it one of the worst in international football. They believe that the team was on the right path under Shinte Young and that this change could have serious negative consequences for Indonesia’s World Cup chances.

What does the speaker hope for the Indonesian players moving forward?

The speaker hopes that the players can adapt to the new coach and continue their improvement. Despite the concerns, they believe the players have a lot of potential, and the opportunity to qualify for the World Cup is still within reach.

What example from 2018 did the speaker reference to express their concerns about firing a successful coach?

The speaker referenced Saudi Arabia’s decision to fire coach Bert van Marwijk in 2018, just before the World Cup. This led to a poor performance in the tournament, and the speaker fears a similar outcome for Indonesia.