Semua Orang Kaget Shin Tae yong Ambil Keputusan Aneh Tapi Sukses Majukan Sepak Bola Indonesia

Summary

Since taking charge of the Indonesian National Team, Coach Shin Tae-yong has faced relentless criticism despite his significant contributions to improving the team's performance. His unconventional decisions and tactics have sparked debates but also led to notable achievements, including a historic qualification to the AFC Asian Cup's Round of 16. Criticisms have ranged from selection strategies to player management, with some attributing success to luck rather than skill. Despite the mixed opinions, Tae-yong's methods have introduced discipline and encouraged local players to gain international experience. His approach, while controversial, has received support from figures within Indonesian football, highlighting a transformative period under his leadership.

Takeaways

• 😀 Shin Tae-yong has faced intense criticism as Indonesia's national team coach despite helping them qualify for the Asian Cup knockout stage
• 😢 Many felt Shin Tae-yong's decisions were questionable and took away opportunities from local players
• 🤔 Shin Tae-yong made several unusual tactical decisions like playing naturalized players out of position
• 😖 Local clubs and coaches were upset with Shin Tae-yong calling up their key players
• 😠 Thomas Doll and Nabil Husein harshly criticized Shin Tae-yong's decisions
• 😬 Shin Tae-yong encouraged players to play abroad though some felt local players didn't need to go overseas
• 😡 Shin Tae-yong was frustrated with the lack of discipline and punctuality of Indonesian players
• 🙂 Bambang Pamungkas still believes in Shin Tae-yong despite the criticism
• 👍 Greg Nwokolo praised the discipline Shin Tae-yong instilled in the national team
• ❓ It remains to be seen if Shin Tae-yong can continue improving Indonesia with his bold decisions

Q & A

Why has Shin Tae-yong received a lot of criticism as the coach of the Indonesian national team?

He has been criticized for supposedly making fatal mistakes that have brought down the performance of the Garuda squad, even though he has helped improve the national team. Many doubt his unorthodox decisions.

What are some of Shin Tae-yong's controversial decisions as coach?

He has made some anti-mainstream tactical choices like playing a tall striker to expose opponents' weaknesses. He has also sidelined some veteran players in favor of younger talent and motivated local players to play abroad.

What was Shin Tae-yong's tactic against Japan in the Asian Cup?

He played the tall Elkan Baggott as a striker to exploit Japan's weaknesses against high balls and aerial play. This proved effective as Indonesia scored against Japan.

Why does Shin Tae-yong prefer Rachmat Irianto as striker over Ramadan Sobhi?

He believes Rachmat has better movement and ball retention even though Ramadan is a natural striker. Shin sees Rachmat as better suited to lead the attack.

Why has Shin Tae-yong sidelined some veteran national team players?

He felt players like Stefano Lilipaly were past their peak and couldn't play with high intensity for 90 minutes. He is phasing out older generations.

Why does Shin Tae-yong want Indonesian players to play abroad?

He believes playing in leagues like Japan, South Korea, and Europe will help Indonesian players learn the football culture and improve. Some have already moved abroad.

How has Shin Tae-yong improved discipline in the national team?

He has cracked down on lateness and a casual attitude. He was upset to see players late to training and not taking things seriously enough.

What are some of Shin Tae-yong's successes so far as Indonesia coach?

He led Indonesia to the Asian Cup round of 16 for the first time in history. He has also instilled more discipline and helped some local players move abroad.

Why do some still doubt Shin Tae-yong's abilities?

Some feel Indonesia's Asian Cup performance was lucky and not due to Shin's coaching. They question his tactical choices and treatment of veteran players.

Who are some figures who still support Shin Tae-yong?

Legends like Bambang Pamungkas see the improvements he has made. Greg Nwokolo praises the discipline he has instilled in the squad.