Is Fiber Ruining Your Gut Health? The Truth About Fiber Intake & Digestion
Summary
TLDRIn this episode, the host discusses the potential downsides of increasing fiber intake for gut health, contrary to common recommendations. They differentiate between soluble and insoluble fiber, emphasizing the importance of a balanced intake and variety in sources. The conversation touches on high-fiber foods' impact, especially processed ones, and how they might exacerbate gut issues. The host also addresses FODMAPs' role in gut health and suggests that, in some cases, reducing fiber intake could alleviate constipation. The episode concludes with a call to action for health professionals to understand fiber's complex role in digestion and offers resources for further learning.
Takeaways
- 📚 Fiber intake recommendations should be tailored to individual needs, as a one-size-fits-all approach may not be beneficial for everyone.
- 🍽 It's important to consider the type of fiber and its source, with a mix of soluble and insoluble fiber being generally recommended.
- 🔍 The amount of fiber intake should be scaled relative to caloric intake, with a general guideline of about 14g of fiber per 1000 calories.
- 🚫 Be cautious of getting all fiber from one source, as this can lead to an imbalance and potential digestive issues.
- 🚫 Consuming large doses of single-source, isolated fiber from processed foods can exacerbate gut issues for some individuals.
- 🍏 A varied diet with different fruit sources, leafy vegetables, and single-ingredient starches can provide a more balanced fiber intake.
- 🌾 FODMAPs, a class of fermentable fibers found in certain foods, can feed gut overgrowths and worsen symptoms in people with gut issues like IBS.
- 🔬 If traditional fiber supplementation doesn't alleviate constipation, a temporary low or zero-fiber diet might be considered to address the root cause.
- 🏋️♀️ Regular exercise and movement can improve gut motility and may be beneficial for those with constipation.
- 📈 For a comprehensive understanding of gut health and fiber intake, further education and resources are available for health professionals and individuals.
Q & A
What is the common recommendation given by health professionals regarding fiber intake?
-Health professionals commonly recommend increasing fiber intake to improve gut health, but it's important to understand the context behind these recommendations as it may not be suitable for everyone.
Why might increasing fiber intake potentially harm some individuals?
-In some cases, increasing fiber intake can cause more harm than good, especially if it's not tailored to an individual's specific gut health situation, such as those struggling with constipation or diarrhea.
What are the two general types of fiber discussed in the fitness and nutrition industry?
-The two general types of fiber discussed are soluble and insoluble fiber, which are often found in fiber supplements and on food labels.
What is the general rule of thumb for scaling fiber intake with caloric intake?
-For every 1000 calories consumed, it is generally recommended to have about 14 grams of fiber, although this can vary depending on individual needs and activity levels.
Why is it advised not to get all fiber from a single source?
-It's advised not to get all fiber from one source to avoid overloading on a single type of fiber and to ensure a balanced diet that includes a variety of fruits, vegetables, grains, and other fiber-rich foods.
What is the issue with consuming large doses of single-source, isolated fiber from processed foods?
-Consuming large doses of single-source, isolated fiber from processed foods can lead to an overload of total daily fiber, potentially causing digestive issues like bloating, distension, and constipation.
What are FODMAPs and how can they affect gut health?
-FODMAPs are fermentable oligo-, di-, and monosaccharides and polyols, which are types of carbohydrates that can feed overgrowths in the gut. For individuals with gut issues like diarrhea-dominant IBS, consuming FODMAPs can exacerbate symptoms.
What is the potential benefit of a low or zero-fiber diet for individuals with constipation?
-A low or zero-fiber diet might help individuals with constipation by addressing the root cause of their gut health issues, such as low gut motility, which may not be improved by adding bulk to the stool.
What are some factors other than fiber intake that can impact gut motility?
-Factors impacting gut motility include stress and anxiety levels, nutritional status, physical activity levels, and the presence of certain irritants in the diet, such as nightshades, gluten, dairy, or eggs.
How can a coach or health professional better understand the nuances of fiber intake and gut health?
-Coaches and health professionals can better understand fiber intake and gut health by studying resources like the Nutrition and Metabolism Specialization program, which covers topics like fiber types, gut irritants, and the impact of lifestyle on gut health.
Outlines
🌟 Fiber Intake: Misunderstandings and Gut Health
The video script begins by challenging the blanket recommendation to increase fiber intake for gut issues. It emphasizes the importance of understanding the context behind such advice. While fiber is generally beneficial, it can exacerbate gut issues like constipation or diarrhea if not properly managed. The speaker introduces the need to differentiate between soluble and insoluble fiber, suggesting a balanced intake and cautioning against excessive fiber from single sources. The script also touches on the general guideline of 14g of fiber per 1000 calories, noting exceptions for high-calorie consumers like professional athletes.
🍽️ The Impact of High-Fiber Foods on Digestion
Paragraph 2 delves into the potential negative effects of consuming large amounts of fiber from single sources, particularly processed foods high in isolated fiber. It uses the example of Quest bars, which contain a significant amount of soluble corn fiber, to illustrate how such products can lead to digestive distress. The script advises a varied diet with fiber from multiple sources like berries, vegetables, and starchy foods to avoid overloading on fiber and causing issues like bloating and constipation. It also distinguishes between supplemental fibers that aid digestion and those added to processed foods for palatability, suggesting the latter may not be as beneficial.
🌱 Understanding FODMAPs and Their Role in Gut Health
Paragraph 3 discusses FODMAPs (Fermentable Oligo-, Di-, Monosaccharides, and Polyols), a class of carbohydrates found in certain foods that can feed gut bacteria and potentially worsen gut issues like diarrhea-dominant IBS. The script explains that while FODMAPs can be beneficial for those without gut issues, they may aggravate symptoms for others. It suggests monitoring symptoms and possibly trying a low-FODMAP diet to identify and manage reactions. The importance of balancing the gut microbiome between commensal and opportunistic bacteria is highlighted, with a recommendation to reintroduce FODMAPs after a period of elimination if symptoms improve.
🌿 Exploring Fiber Intake Adjustments for Constipation Relief
Paragraph 4 addresses the management of constipation through fiber intake adjustments. It references a study that found reducing fiber intake could improve bowel movements in some constipated individuals, suggesting that not all cases of constipation benefit from increased fiber. The script explores various factors affecting gut motility, including stress, exercise, and dietary irritants, and suggests potential interventions like probiotics and serotonin-boosting foods. It also mentions the importance of considering overall lifestyle and nutritional status in managing gut health and provides resources for further learning on the topic.
📢 Conclusion and Call to Action
The final paragraph wraps up the discussion by summarizing key points, including the importance of moderate and varied fiber intake, the role of FODMAPs in gut health, and the potential need to adjust fiber intake for constipation. It encourages health and fitness professionals to deepen their understanding of gut health and offers resources for further learning. The script concludes with a call to action for viewers to engage with the content, share it with others, and support the channel through likes, subscriptions, and reviews.
Mindmap
Keywords
💡Fiber
💡Constipation
💡Diarrhea
💡Soluble Fiber
💡Insoluble Fiber
💡FODMAPs
💡Psyllium Husk
💡Serotonin
💡Gut Motility
💡Low-Carb Foods
Highlights
Fiber intake recommendations can be harmful in some cases without considering individual context.
General advice to increase fiber lacks the context of specific situations and gut health.
Understanding the types of fiber, soluble and insoluble, is crucial for proper digestion.
A general guideline is to consume about 14g of fiber per 1000 calories, but this varies with individual needs.
Avoid getting all fiber from one source to prevent digestive issues.
Large doses of single-source fiber from processed foods can exacerbate gut issues.
Examples of high-fiber processed foods include protein bars, low-carb products, and certain bakery items.
Fiber supplements like psyllium husk and apple pectin are more effective for digestion than synthetic fibers.
FODMAPs, fermentable fibers, can feed gut bacteria and worsen symptoms in people with gut issues.
A low or zero-fiber diet may help alleviate constipation caused by low gut motility.
Serotonin, a gut motility controller, can be affected by stress, diet, and lifestyle.
Magnesium citrate and vitamin C can aid in regular bowel movements for constipated individuals.
A study showed that reducing fiber intake improved bowel movements in constipated patients.
Dietary changes, including fiber intake, should be personalized based on an individual's gut health.
The importance of considering the gut-brain connection and lifestyle factors in managing gut health.
Resources for health professionals to learn more about gut health and nutrition are available through Metabolism School.
The book 'Metabolism Made Simple' offers insights into optimizing nutrition for metabolic health.
Transcripts
could fiber actually be making your gut
issues worse inside today's episode I'm
going to talk about a common
recommendation from health and medical
professionals which is to increase your
fiber intake in some cases could
actually do more harm than good now this
isn't to say that fiber is bad or to
demonize fiber or that we shouldn't
actually look for fiber on our food
labels but the reality of the situation
is we have to understand the context
Behind These recommendations if you're
struggling with gut issues like
constipation or diarrhea the average
coach or average health and fitness
professional typically may make a just
blanket statement recommendation of oh
increase your fiber and that's pretty
much it right there's not a lot of
advanced knowledge around gut health in
some cases and certainly why in a lot of
my content I'll speak to ways to
optimize your digestion now in most
cases is advocating for fiber a bad
thing not necessarily in many cases this
can actually be good advice but what we
have to understand is when you give a
broad piece of advice to a client or if
you're following this and you're just
interested for your own health blindly
following this type of broad advice
lacks the context of your specific
situation so today you're going to learn
all about these different contexts for
where we may want to increase fiber
where we might want to change the ratios
of our fiber so we're going to talk a
little bit about different fiber types
and I'll also talk a little bit about
when to decrease fiber altogether so
first and foremost um we'll talk a
little bit about types of fiber and
we'll also discuss uh kind of how you
might scale your fiber intake relative
to your caloric intake but generally
you'll see two types of fiber discussed
in the fitness industry nutrition
industry and even when it comes to
medical advice and people suggesting
that you increase your fiber intake this
is usually soluble in insoluable fiber
and you'll often see this on supplement
labels for fiber supplements and even on
food labels some times fiber will be
broken down additionally into the
soluble and insoluble fiber contents in
general the theme Here is to get a mix
of both another general rule of thumb is
typically as we scale our caloric intake
roughly every th calories research does
support the notion of about 14 G of
fiber per thousand calories Now
understand if you're eating Michael
Phelps level calories because you
literally need 5 6 7 8,000 calories per
day this is very rare in a very small
subset of the population the fiber
intake is not going to scale linearly so
for someone who's a professional athlete
or has very demanding physical labor job
and is consuming a lot of calories they
may not necessarily be able to scale
that fiber intake up as they're
consuming those calories because it may
lead to digestive distress or an
inability to get the calories in that
are required in terms of their overall
energy needs another theme to follow is
not getting all your fiber from one
source so don't just only get it from
berries or only get it from green leafy
vegetables or only from starches or only
from Quest Bars some people are largely
getting their fiber from different uh
multi- inrent Foods or only from cereals
typically you know it would be a good
thing to have a variety of fruit sources
maybe some grain leafy vegetables maybe
have some single ingredient starches
that add some Fiber to the equation
maybe something like sweet potato or
regular potato contributing some Fiber
on top of fruits and maybe you know you
even some people do benefit from fiber
supplementation depending on their
personal references and what their
overall diet looks like so the first
point of today's episode and first thing
we're really going to dive in on in
terms of the coverage in today's show is
just understanding that um sometimes
fiber will make gut issues worse when
we're consuming large doses of single
Source isolated fiber from processed
foods this could potentially violate two
of the rules of thumb that I mentioned
as we entered today's episode one is
getting too much fiber from one source
and also overloading the total daily
fiber in general so these days they
considerable number of foods that
contain this stuff that's mostly branded
as low carb right or this could be a
protein bar that's you know trying to
moderate the carbohydrate intake or
maybe be a little bit more filling
there's also different yogurts and other
products that may have fiber in it uh or
other things that are going to
potentially set off digestion for some
folks so let's use quest bars as an
example very popular brand widely
available in grocery stores and gas
stations and there are protein bars that
have 15 gam or more of soluble corn
fiber as the main fiber source other low
carb bars ice creams and sweetened
products will sometimes have some level
of these fibers as well we also have to
consider some people consume low car
bread products or rolls wraps and uh
other things in more of the baked Bakery
section or baked goods section of the
store so a certain popular low carb
tortilla wrap has about 15 G of fiber
purely from resistant wheat starch which
can be irritating to some people as well
it's not that these are bad for everyone
or that you can't ever have these uh I
would certainly recommend in most cases
you are going to want to get your your
fiber from things like berries some
green leafy vegetables and potential
single ingredient carbohydrate sources
but let's say someone's consuming
something like these wraps or protein
bars and then they're also having fruits
and vegetables that could easily put
someone in the 60 G Plus range when it
comes to fiber which can also just be
simply too much for someone especially
when you have uh more petite individuals
who are potentially let's say 120 130
lbs and they're having half their body
weight in grams in dietary fiber on a 16
or 1,700 calorie diet that's a little
bit uh a little bit high and can lead to
some of the bloating distension and
constipation that people may see uh also
I don't want you to think that
necessarily supplemental fiber uh is bad
so people may consume something like
psyllium husk Apple pectin there's uh
hydroly guarum which is known as
sunfiber it's kind of the trademarked
version of that certain fibers are more
proven in their ability to help with
digestion and in most cases uh they are
efficacious whereas some of the things
that are used as food additives
so in the bars and wraps in different
bread products potential ice creams and
things like that they are almost a
different Beast entirely so even though
they're classified as fiber it's a
different different type of fiber and in
many
cases they're strictly added to the food
to make it a little bit more pable
palatable without adding a lot of
calories so that sort of if you think
about a client or you think about your
own health history or the way that you
shop the grocery store this kind of
describes you if you like incorporating
those types of foods certain popular ice
cream brands that are marketed as low
calorie maybe you consume some of these
different wraps or bars in addition to
your daily intake of fruits and
vegetables or oats there's going to be a
chance that you rack up these fiber
totals pretty quickly and it's not
always from single ingredient Whole
Foods Point number two of today's show
revolves around a class of fibers known
as fodmaps so fod Maps stand for
fermentable
oigo D and monosaccharides and
polyols these are foods that are
basically if you were to think about if
you're in the grocery store you're
shopping for these things a lot of times
it's garlic onions artichoke asparagus
some legumes certain fruits wheat based
products lactose containing dairy
products uh this isn't necessarily a
complete list but it should give you an
idea of where you might encounter
certain uh certain carbohydrates that
have this FODMAP component basically
something that's fermentable it can feed
overgrowths in the gut for many people
these fermentable fibers are great for
the gut if they don't have pre-existing
gut issues and can feed good gut
bacteria in many people who have
existing gut issues particularly
diarrhea dominant IBS these types of
fibers could potentially be making
things worse the leading hypothesis here
is that if someone is reacting poorly to
FODMAP related Foods or FODMAP
containing foods it's likely that they
have small intestinal bacterial
overgrowth or another problematic
overgrowth that the fod maps end up
feeding because remember when these
carbohydrates are fermenting they are
feeding bacteria in the gut and they end
up feeding the overgrowths instead of
your commensal or good bacteria so
anytime you hear a discussion of gut
health there should be a discussion of
commensal or good bacteria and
opportunistic bacteria opportunistic
would be more those overgrowths or
things that we need to bring back into
balance
when discussing the microbiome figuring
this out could be as simple as
correlating something in your food log
or let's say you're a coach and you're
working with a client or maybe you're a
nutrition coach or dietitian looking at
a food log and sort of identifying
symptoms and biof feedback related to
certain meals and you may even trial a
period of FODMAP elimination or a low
FODMAP diet and sometimes people will
notice a difference in 2 to 3 weeks if
it does make a difference then we may
want to keep out those fod maps for a
period of time until people have
resolution in their symptoms and you
know generally you are going to wait a
little bit before reintroduction this
can varry personto person but some
people have success around that 6 to 8
or 12 week Mark maybe making some
reintroductions this is just an average
understand it may be different for you
uh or different for your clients but
this is largely going to be based on the
severity of the symptoms they're
experiencing and the foods that they are
maybe having a negative reaction to in
my third and kind of last point for
today's fiber related content is
understanding that if you or a client is
experiencing constipation and you've
tried mixing and matching fiber types or
you've tried supplemental fibers like
cium husk or apple pectin or others then
it might be worth trying a low or zero
fiber diet for a period of time now
again this is not something we would
want to do super longterm as data does
support that fiber helps with a lot of
different things whether it's short
chain fatty acid production um managing
inflammation helping with overall
longevity when you look at people who
consume more fiber there are some
confounding variables there in terms of
healthy user bias as the foods people
tend to gravitate towards compared to
your standard American diet and Western
ways of eating but there are situations
where someone may need to titrate that
fiber down if they're experiencing some
pre-existing gut concerns again this
doesn't necessarily mean that they're
doing this long term a study published
in World gastroenterology so this is the
journal sometimes people will comment on
these videos and ask oh what's your
Source like are you making this up is
this your opinion this is not my
personal bias this is specifically from
the world gastroenterology Journal 63
patients with constipation who had tried
supplemental fiber in the past were
divided into three groups zero fiber low
fiber and a control group which
continued the same amount of fiber that
they were eating previously before
starting the intervention all of the
participants were using the bathroom one
to two times per week on average now
remember constipation is typically
someone who's going less than three
times per week ideally we want people
going one to three times per day and no
less than three times per week so
ideally once a day would be fantastic if
you're consuming more food or you have a
little bit more regular bowel movements
or more frequent motility or increased
bow Transit time excuse me decrease bow
Transit time so things are moving along
faster you may see people going to the
bathroom more often but being at one to
two times per week would fall into the
classic sort of definition of
constipation after this intervention of
the zero or low fiber they found that
those in the zero fiber group were going
once per day those in the low fiber
group were going once every 2 days and
those that remained high fiber were
going once per week for some people low
motility is the main cause of their
constipation and adding bulk to the
stool doesn't necessarily increase
motility this could be due to a general
imbalance in the gut some other sort of
overgrowth or uh potentially that over
growth is not allowing the gut to
produce enough serotonin and serotonin
is the main controller of motility in
the gut or at least a major one there
are other factors that play into
motility but serotonin is a big one so
by reducing fiber to zero for the time
being you can potentially try to attack
the root cause of the gut health issues
like helping the client manage their
stress better moving their body more if
they've previously been sedentary
movement does seem to facilitate
motility so regular exercise walking
after meals going for a morning walk you
could attempt some type of more gut
focused dietary intervention to see if
there were certain irritants that were
causing decreased gut serotonin
production so looking at common
irritants for some people this could be
nightshades gluten dairy uh sometimes
for folks eggs can be bothersome nuts
and seeds and things like cruciferous
vegetables so when you kind of go across
the board it's not that these foods are
inherently quote unquote bad foods I'm
using air quotes if you're listening on
audio and not watching on the video just
understanding that sometimes these Foods
need to be temporarily removed and then
reintroduced depending on the issue at
hand potentially you know looking at uh
probiotics motility promoting foods such
as golden kiwi which is high in
serotonin content or motility promoting
supplements alongside of this can you
know kind of go hand inand when
someone's constipated there's evidence
to support the use of things like
magnesium citate or vitamin C in helping
uh these folks obtain regular bowel
movements you might even be able to get
the person to start eating fiber again
if you know they are consistent with
this approach for a period of time
they're having regular bowel movements
they've got the movement and lifestyle
practices in place then perhaps they can
make some dietary changes to incorporate
that over time so as we wrap up today's
show just first and foremost understand
not demonizing all types of fiber here
there's a very big difference between
something that has a laundry list of
ingredients and has these um you could
use the term like more synthetic fibers
added to it just think of it as instead
of something that's naturally exists in
an apple or exists in a blueberry this
would be something that's basically
man-made in a factory to you know create
a treat of some kind right bars ice
creams there's different products uh
there may be things that people don't
view as Treats but grocery items that
may be wraps or breads or different sort
of prepackaged foods that are used that
are a lower carb substitute for the
those options now some people are doing
that for calorie control or appetite
management but understand you can overdo
it so I have seen people where you know
their lunch is one of these wraps or
bars or excuse me one of these wraps or
bread products they're having a bar as a
snack they're eating the low carb ice
cream after dinner and then they're also
still consuming some healthier single
ingredient foods that contain some fiber
or maybe they're also having something
like oatmeal for breakfast this person's
having quite a bit of fiber every single
day so in these contexts and situations
I described you know if you are someone
who's a Health Fitness or nutrition
professional who's looking to better
understand these different types of
situations or you really enjoy the
science behind gut health and you want
to better understand how to navigate
these conversations with clients when to
increase or decrease fiber when to use
particular evidence-based supplements
what to do with training when someone's
experiencing gut health issues whether
it's a bring it up modifying uh
intensity frequency or volume and then
also managing lifestyle you'll
definitely want to check out the
nutrition and Metabolism specialization
program for coaches you can learn more
about that at metabolism school.com we
have a focus on nutrition metabolism gut
health hormones and really all the
aspects of physiology that play into a
successful client transformation all too
often coaches are kind of tweaking and
toggling these surface level
considerations like macros or training
but they're not necessarily looking
deeper at the physiology of the client
case now just to kind of recap and wrap
up today's episode understand that
number one um we don't want to get these
foods that are multi multi- ingredient
with tons and tons of added fiber to
them and if you are consuming them it
needs to be in moderation otherwise it's
very easy to overshoot want to pay
attention to fod map containing foods
that may exacerbate uh your client's gut
issues also did a recent episode on
gluten as well if it hasn't already
aired it will air on the channel very
soon if you're watching on YouTube or if
you're listening to the podcast it'll
probably be within a week or two of this
episode airing and also potentially
reducing fiber to low or zero depending
on the situation right if someone's
constipated they may benefit there's
some evidence from one of the
gastroenterology journals that I
referenced where people went lower in
their fiber intake and actually
experienced improvements in their
constipation uh symptoms that doesn't
necessarily mean that everybody needs to
do that and for some individuals let's
say they're struggling with something
like diarrhea maybe they benefit from
changing that ratio of soluble to in
soluble fiber overall so a lot of times
when you see people adding things like
psyllium husk hydr guarum these are more
soluble fibers that can be used and if
someone's having very loose stool or
loose bowel movements that's where those
potentially come into play um someone
who's experiencing constipation isn't
always just going to magically fix their
constipation by adding a fiber
supplement like psyllium husk it's not
always low fiber that's to blame for
someone's constipation motility has many
different facets to it including the gut
bra brain connection uh someone's Stress
and Anxiety levels other aspects of
nutritional status and their General
lifestyle someone's very sedentary if
they're not moving they're not going for
regular walks or exercising that can
also impact GI function as well if
you're looking for kind of the complete
picture and better understanding
different components of gut health again
I have free content my audio feed on
Spotify and apple podcast that's at
similar science on that platform and
also for coaches looking to learn more
about the gut things like fiber intake
troubleshooting digestion and common
irritants be sure to head over to
metabolism school.com to learn more
about the nutrition and Metabolism
specialization if you're in your own
health and fitness journey a great
starting point is my book metabolism
Made Simple I do talk about maximizing
absorption as one of the keys one of the
five M to managing your metabolism and
just to optimizing your nutrition
overall making sense of nutrition to
transform your metabolic health so
that's kind of the name of the game with
metabolism Made Simple that's been out
since late 2022 and is a great starting
place if if you're someone who's really
passionate about nutrition looking to
learn more and you want some self-study
materials in addition to YouTube or the
podcast if you enjoyed the show and
you're watching on video please give a
thumbs up support the algorithm and make
sure you subscribed so you never miss a
video if you're on audio please leave a
five-star rating and review so on Apple
podcast you can leave that review it
takes 10 seconds goes a really long way
in supporting the work that my team and
I do here to provide this content for
free There's No Interruption inside
today's episode to uh be brought to You
by a given fiber supplement there was no
type of ad for a particular probiotic so
if you're enjoying the free content you
like the fact that we kind of get
straight to the point share this
information with you please uh rate
review and share the show it allows us
to continue to educate folks around the
globe provide this information and I
know there's people who are experiencing
gut issues right now and really could
benefit from this type of content so
share the show either the oldfashioned
way or you can screenshot the episode
tag me I'm at Samer science on just
about every major social media platform
I appreciate you listening today and I
will talk to you in the next
show
e
e
e
e e
Ver Más Videos Relacionados
5.0 / 5 (0 votes)