Putin Has meltdown: Russian Military Communications Exposed, Russian Spies at Risk!

Business Basics
28 Aug 202420:26

Summary

TLDRThe video delves into the recent arrest of Telegram CEO Pavel Durov in France, sparking a crisis for the Russian government and military who relied on the app for secure communications. It explores the implications of Durov's arrest on Russian intelligence, the potential exposure of Russian spies, and the political and privacy debates surrounding the incident. The video also touches on the crackdown on social media in Russia and the role of Telegram in the information war.

Takeaways

  • 😨 The Russian government, military, and intelligence community widely used Telegram for secure communications, which has now been compromised due to the arrest of its CEO, Pavel Durov.
  • 🛑 Putin has ordered military personnel to delete sensitive messages and the Telegram app from their devices in response to the arrest, indicating a significant security concern.
  • 📰 Russian media is blaming various international entities for Durov's arrest, highlighting a sense of panic and uncertainty within the country.
  • 🤔 The relationship between Durov and Putin is complex, with Durov previously showing defiance towards the Russian government and its demands for data access.
  • 🔑 There are speculations about the possibility of a backdoor in Telegram that could allow the Russian government to monitor encrypted messages, raising questions about the app's security.
  • 🚫 Russia has been cracking down on social media platforms, with Telegram being a notable exception until recent events, suggesting a strategic interest in controlling information flow.
  • 🌐 Telegram's use of domain fronting to evade Russian blocks and its subsequent unblocking in 2020 have led to theories about cooperation between Durov and the Kremlin.
  • 🏛 The French government's arrest of Durov on charges related to content moderation and legal non-compliance has sparked controversy and concerns about free speech.
  • 🔒 The potential implications of Durov's arrest for end-to-end encryption and privacy rights have been criticized by free speech advocates, including Elon Musk and Edward Snowden.
  • 🌍 The arrest has international repercussions, with implications for global intelligence agencies and the ongoing information war, especially in the context of the Ukraine conflict.
  • 🕊️ Despite the tensions, there is a debate about whether the arrest is truly about political motivations or legitimate legal concerns, with some suggesting it could be a PR move by Russia.

Q & A

  • Why is the Russian government concerned about Telegram?

    -The Russian government is concerned about Telegram because it has been widely used by the military and intelligence community for secure communications. The arrest of Telegram's CEO, Pavel Durov, has raised fears that Western intelligence could gain access to the encryption keys or that Durov might provide information that could compromise Russian communications.

  • What was the reason behind Pavel Durov's arrest in France?

    -Pavel Durov was arrested in France due to 12 charges related to the lack of content moderation on his platform, Telegram, which was allegedly used for drug trafficking, fraud, and child sexual abuse. Additionally, he was accused of rejecting legal requests from authorities to monitor and intercept communications of certain users on the platform.

  • How has the Russian government reacted to Durov's arrest?

    -The Russian government has reacted with alarm, ordering military personnel to delete sensitive messages on Telegram and delete the app from their phones. Russian media has been in a state of panic, blaming various international entities for the arrest, and the Russian Embassy has sought access to Durov.

  • What is the significance of Telegram's end-to-end encryption in this context?

    -Telegram's end-to-end encryption is significant because it ensures that messages sent through the app are secure and can only be read by the intended recipients. This encryption has raised concerns for the Russian government, as it could potentially protect sensitive military and intelligence communications from being intercepted.

  • Why did Pavel Durov willingly go to Paris, where he knew he would be arrested?

    -The exact reason for Pavel Durov's decision to fly to Paris, knowing he would be arrested, is not explicitly clear from the script. However, it suggests that it could be due to a complex relationship with the French government or possibly an attempt to share critical information with Western intelligence agencies.

  • What is the potential impact of Durov's arrest on Telegram's users, especially in Russia?

    -The potential impact of Durov's arrest could lead to increased censorship or surveillance of Telegram by Western governments, potentially compromising user privacy. In Russia, it could result in the exposure of military and intelligence communications if Durov were to provide information to Western intelligence agencies.

  • How has the situation with Telegram affected Russia's relationship with France?

    -The situation with Telegram has strained Russia's relationship with France, with the Russian government accusing France of double standards on free speech and using the arrest for political purposes. This has led to a PR battle and further deterioration of already tense relations between Moscow and Paris.

  • What are some of the theories surrounding Durov's arrest and his relationship with the French government?

    -Some theories suggest that Durov's arrest might be related to a deal with the French government, possibly to share information about Russian communications in exchange for leniency. Others propose that it could be an attempt by the French government to force Telegram to abandon end-to-end encryption, allowing for easier monitoring of communications.

  • How has the arrest of Pavel Durov been viewed by the international community, particularly in terms of free speech?

    -The arrest of Pavel Durov has been met with criticism from free speech activists who see it as an attack on privacy and an infringement on basic human rights. Elon Musk and Edward Snowden have publicly criticized the French government's actions, highlighting concerns about the potential for increased government surveillance and censorship.

  • What role has Telegram played in recent geopolitical events, such as the Ukraine war and the Israel-Gaza conflict?

    -Telegram has served as a primary communication platform for various groups involved in geopolitical conflicts. It has been used by the Russian military and intelligence community, as well as by Hamas during the Israel-Gaza conflict, to disseminate information and organize activities. This has made Telegram a target for government agencies seeking to control the flow of information and suppress opposition.

Outlines

00:00

😨 Telegram CEO Arrest Sparks Russian Government Panic

The Russian government and military, once trusting users of the secure messaging app Telegram, are now in turmoil following the arrest of its CEO, Pavel Durov, in France. This arrest, seemingly a voluntary act by Durov, has led to a series of reactions from the Russian side, including orders to delete sensitive messages and the app itself. Russian media is blaming various international entities for the incident, while the relationship between Durov and Putin is highlighted as complex, with a history of conflict over data access and free speech. The potential exposure of Russian spies and the impact on communication security are major concerns, as is the possibility of a built-in backdoor in Telegram that could be exploited by Russian cyber agencies.

05:00

🏛 The Complicated Saga of Durov's Citizenships and Telegram's Legal Troubles

Pavel Durov's journey from Russia to global entrepreneur is marked by a series of citizenships and legal challenges. After a falling out with Russian authorities over content moderation on his social media platform, VK, Durov left Russia and continued developing Telegram, which became a massive success. His decision to base Telegram's HQ in the UAE and acquire French citizenship raises questions about his relationship with governments. The arrest of Durov in France on charges related to content moderation on Telegram has sparked controversy, with critics arguing that holding a platform owner responsible for user actions is akin to blaming car manufacturers for road accidents. The case has implications for free speech and the power of governments to monitor communications.

10:01

📰 Russian Officials and Media Respond to Telegram CEO's Arrest

The arrest of Telegram CEO Pavel Durov in France has sent shockwaves through Russia, prompting officials and media to react. The Kremlin has instructed law enforcement and officials to delete Telegram chats, fearing that Durov's arrest could expose Russian military and intelligence communications. Theories range from Durov having dirt on Putin to the possibility of a setup by intelligence agencies. The situation has also highlighted the use of Telegram by various groups, including political opposition, and its role in recent conflicts and unrest, raising questions about content moderation and government surveillance.

15:02

🕊️ Free Speech Activists and Governments Alike React to Durov's Arrest

Durov's arrest has sparked a debate on free speech and government surveillance. Free speech activists, including high-profile figures like Elon Musk and Edward Snowden, have criticized the French government's actions, fearing an attack on privacy and the potential for government overreach. The case has also drawn parallels with Russia's own content moderation and censorship practices, with concerns that Western governments may be moving in a similar direction. The Israeli government has also shown interest in controlling the app, adding another layer to the international implications of the arrest.

20:03

📹 Overcoming Camera Shyness: Growing a YouTube Channel Without Showing Your Face

The script concludes with a pivot to advice for aspiring YouTubers who may be camera shy. It offers examples of successful channels that have grown their audience without ever showing the creator's face, highlighting the channel's own milestone of reaching one million subscribers as proof of the viability of this approach. A free 7-Day YouTube crash course is promoted as a valuable resource for those looking to start their channel, with a testimonial from a previous student attesting to its quality, even superior to a paid course.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Telegram

Telegram is a cloud-based instant messaging and voice over IP service that offers end-to-end encrypted messaging. In the video's context, it's the primary communication tool for the Russian government and military, which has led to significant concern following the arrest of its CEO, Pavel Durov. The script mentions the app's widespread use in Russia and the implications of its potential vulnerability.

💡Pavel Durov

Pavel Durov is the founder and CEO of Telegram, who is central to the video's narrative. His arrest in France is portrayed as an unusual event, potentially akin to a surrender, and it raises questions about the security of the Telegram app and the privacy of its Russian users. The script discusses Durov's contentious relationship with the Russian government and his actions that led to his current predicament.

💡Encryption

Encryption is the process of encoding messages or information to ensure secure communication, so that only authorized parties can access it. The script discusses the end-to-end encryption feature of Telegram, which is critical for the app's users, especially considering the Russian government's interest in intercepting communications.

💡Arrest

The term 'arrest' in the video refers to the detention of Pavel Durov in France. It is a pivotal event that triggers a series of reactions from the Russian government and raises concerns about the integrity of Telegram's communication security. The script describes the arrest as a complex situation that may involve more than just legal issues.

💡Censorship

Censorship is the suppression or prohibition of any parts of books, films, news, etc. that are considered obscene, politically unacceptable, or a threat to security. The video discusses Russia's crackdown on social media platforms, including Telegram, as part of a broader effort to control the narrative around the Ukrainian conflict and to manage the flow of information within the country.

💡Surrender

Surrender in this context refers to the voluntary act of giving up or submitting to a force or authority. The script uses 'surrender' to describe Durov's decision to fly to Paris, knowing he would be arrested, suggesting a complex and possibly strategic move rather than a simple apprehension.

💡End-to-end encryption

End-to-end encryption is a system of communication where only the communicating users can read the messages. The video highlights this feature of Telegram as a selling point for privacy but also as a point of contention, as it may allow for the secure exchange of sensitive information that is difficult for authorities to monitor.

💡Signal

Signal is a messaging app known for its focus on digital security and privacy. In the script, it is mentioned alongside Telegram as a platform that has been blocked in Russia, indicating the government's efforts to control communication channels and suggesting a preference for platforms that may be more susceptible to surveillance.

💡Durov's citizenship

The video discusses Pavel Durov's acquisition of citizenship in multiple countries, including France and the UAE. This is relevant as it adds layers of complexity to his legal status and potential motivations, especially considering his arrest in France and the implications for Telegram's operations.

💡Content moderation

Content moderation refers to the process of monitoring and controlling the content posted on a platform to prevent the spread of illegal or harmful material. The script mentions that Durov has been accused of failing to adequately moderate content on Telegram, leading to its use for illicit activities and putting him at legal risk.

💡Free speech

Free speech is the right to express one's opinions without censorship or restraint. The video script touches on the debate surrounding free speech and censorship, particularly in the context of government control over online platforms. It raises questions about the balance between security, privacy, and the freedom of expression.

Highlights

Russian government, military, and intelligence community heavily relied on Telegram for secure communications.

Telegram CEO Pavel Durov's arrest in France has caused a crisis of confidence within Russia's security circles.

Putin ordered military personnel to delete sensitive messages and the app itself due to security concerns.

Russian media is in panic, blaming various international entities for Durov's arrest.

Durov's relationship with Putin is complex, marked by public defiance and a history of conflict.

Durov's voluntary travel to Paris, where he knew he would be arrested, has added to the mystery.

The arrest raises questions about the security of Russia's military and intelligence communications.

Russian government's past attempts to block Telegram were unsuccessful due to the app's evasion tactics.

Durov's contentious history with Russian authorities dates back to his refusal to comply with censorship demands.

Telegram's end-to-end encryption is under scrutiny, with speculation about potential backdoors for Russian monitoring.

Durov's arrest in France on charges related to content moderation and legal non-compliance has sparked controversy.

The case has implications for free speech and privacy rights, with critics arguing against government overreach.

The incident has heightened tensions between Russia and France, with accusations of double standards.

Theories suggest Durov may have information that could compromise Russian military communications.

The arrest might be a strategic move by Durov to negotiate better terms or reveal critical information.

The incident could lead to increased censorship or a breach in the security of encrypted messaging platforms.

The potential impact on Telegram's role in global conflicts and information wars is a significant concern.

Transcripts

play00:00

Putin is freaking out the Russian

play00:02

government Russian military and even the

play00:04

Russian intelligence Community had full

play00:06

trust in the messaging app Telegram and

play00:08

used it for their day-to-day

play00:09

Communications then just a few days ago

play00:12

the telegram founder and CEO was

play00:14

arrested in France but it wasn't a

play00:16

normal arrest as I first thought that's

play00:18

because he knew he would be arrested and

play00:20

he willingly flew into Paris on his

play00:22

private jet that's more like a surrender

play00:24

than an arrest that's why Putin is

play00:26

having a meltdown first he has ordered

play00:28

all military personnel to delete sens

play00:30

messages on the app and then delete the

play00:31

app from their phone secondly the

play00:34

Russian media is in full-blown panic

play00:36

they are blaming the CIA USA France and

play00:40

everyone in between for this arrest even

play00:43

the Russian Embassy is trying to get

play00:45

access to door off which is wild

play00:47

considering in the past he has publicly

play00:49

posted a picture of himself giving the

play00:51

middle finger to Putin and now it seems

play00:53

like he was in control of the

play00:55

communication app that the whole Russian

play00:57

government relied on so the relationship

play01:00

between Putin and durov is complicated

play01:02

what's even more complicated is that

play01:04

Putin is still trying to figure out if

play01:06

this is an arrest or Surrender you see

play01:09

both Putin and durov were in aayan's

play01:11

capital before the billionaire flew to

play01:13

Paris in fact durov requested a meeting

play01:16

but Putin declined and then from there

play01:18

Duro flew directly to Paris where he

play01:21

knew he would be arrested so I guess

play01:24

Putin's definitely regretting turning

play01:26

down that meeting now anyways in this

play01:29

video let's get into why the Russian

play01:31

government is having a meltdown how the

play01:34

communication failure affects the front

play01:36

lines and why Russian spies in other

play01:38

countries are at risk of being exposed

play01:40

now you guys see the title of this video

play01:42

right I am chuckling but this video is

play01:45

about to be bombarded with dislikes from

play01:47

Bots from Russia so please please help

play01:49

me out and hit the like button on the

play01:51

video so it doesn't die in the algorithm

play01:53

maybe go ahead and share it on social

play01:55

media too if you can now let's start off

play01:57

with the most widely discussed scenario

play02:00

namely something that has to do with

play02:02

Russia this is because of the current

play02:04

situation in the country especially in

play02:06

the social media landscape Putin has

play02:08

just started a massive Crackdown on

play02:10

social media platforms with one obvious

play02:12

reason the continued Ukrainian Invasion

play02:15

into the Russian K region is terrible PR

play02:18

for him it makes Putin look incapable

play02:20

and it places the war he started in a

play02:22

bad light tons of videos and stories

play02:24

from Kur are spreading on the internet

play02:26

showing the civilian and Military damage

play02:28

recently there have also been repeat

play02:30

Ukrainian drone attacks on buildings in

play02:31

Russian cities including the largest

play02:33

ever drone attack on Moscow this is

play02:35

spreading fear across Russian Society

play02:38

right now the Kremlin is doing

play02:40

everything it can to prevent the damage

play02:42

Russians can't access YouTube anymore

play02:45

and recently the messenger app signal

play02:47

has also been blocked Facebook and

play02:49

Instagram have been banned for longer

play02:52

telegram has remained accessible though

play02:54

although there have occasionally been

play02:55

suspicious outages on the app telegram

play02:58

is the largest mobile app in Russia

play03:00

making up 60 to 80% of total internet

play03:03

traffic volume in the country it has

play03:06

been on the rise recently overtaking

play03:08

WhatsApp as the most widely used

play03:10

messenger the app is supposedly secure

play03:12

and private as it offers endtoend

play03:13

encrypted messaging but people are

play03:15

doubtful about this after all why would

play03:17

Russia ban something like signal but

play03:19

allow a similar app like telegram which

play03:22

is much larger some speculate that this

play03:23

has to do with Russia's ability to

play03:25

monitor telegram messages default Chats

play03:27

on the platform are not encrypted so the

play03:29

Russian government can easily intercept

play03:31

them in fact most of the traffic is not

play03:33

encrypted because people forget to turn

play03:35

the feature on but for the messages that

play03:37

are encrypted it becomes much harder for

play03:39

the Russian government in order to

play03:41

access these chats there would have to

play03:42

be a built-in backd door for the Russian

play03:44

cyber agencies the company has of course

play03:46

denied the allegations that such a back

play03:48

door exists to be honest I don't really

play03:50

know the telegram CEO and the Russian

play03:52

government have definitely not always

play03:54

work together ever since paval durov got

play03:56

successful his relationship with the

play03:58

authorities has been shaky in 2006 he

play04:03

launched Russia's version of Facebook

play04:05

named V contact or VK in short it became

play04:09

a multi-billion company in no time with

play04:12

millions of Russian users in 2011 though

play04:16

the Russian police came knocking at

play04:17

durov's door the government wanted him

play04:20

to remove opposition politicians from VK

play04:22

after the 2011 election this was at a

play04:26

time when there were widespread protests

play04:27

in the country because people believed

play04:29

there was electoral fraud however durov

play04:33

didn't take the police threat seriously

play04:34

at all he didn't open the door and the

play04:37

police left soon after later he would

play04:39

post this picture showing his middle

play04:41

finger presumably to Putin this was

play04:44

after the Russian government demanded

play04:45

access to all private messaging data on

play04:48

the platform it would go wrong again in

play04:50

2014 when the Russian authorities wanted

play04:53

to get personal data from Ukrainian

play04:55

users involved in the eurom maiden

play04:57

protests durov refused because he was

play05:00

committed to free speech and privacy but

play05:02

other investors in VK were more

play05:04

favorable to Putin and dismissed durov

play05:07

as the CEO of the company he and his

play05:10

brother who was also one of the

play05:11

co-founders said it had been effectively

play05:14

taken over by the government the

play05:15

billionaire decided to leave Russia

play05:17

behind with no plans to go back he

play05:22

received citizenship in the island

play05:23

nation of St kits and nevas outside of

play05:25

Russia he and his brother continued with

play05:27

their new telegram project which became

play05:29

widely successful durov decided to

play05:32

create a HQ based in the UAE where he

play05:35

got a citizenship interestingly the

play05:37

businessman also got a citizenship in

play05:39

France in 2021 it's unclear how he got

play05:42

it since France doesn't give them away

play05:44

easily and he hasn't lived in the

play05:46

country the official reason was that

play05:48

durov contributed to France's influence

play05:52

abroad we also don't know why he wanted

play05:54

to get this citizenship there are

play05:56

theories that this was part of some kind

play05:57

of deal which would suggest that the

play05:59

businessman has a more complex

play06:01

relationship with the French government

play06:02

than we know we'll touch on what France

play06:05

has got to do with this story later on

play06:07

but first we have to go back to Russia's

play06:09

policy on telegram the kremlin's

play06:12

internet Watchdog rosom nadzor actually

play06:14

tried to block Telegram in

play06:16

2018 it was unsuccessful as telegram

play06:19

evaded it using a technique called

play06:21

domain fronting presumably the Russian

play06:24

cyber police gave up their attempt in

play06:25

2020 and the ban was lifted even though

play06:29

it didn't go through this just shows

play06:30

that the Kremlin wasn't very pleased

play06:32

with the app the tensions have been

play06:34

there for years but not everyone

play06:38

believes that the ban was lifted because

play06:41

of the technical failure on Russia's

play06:43

side another theory is that telegram

play06:45

provided the back door we talked about

play06:46

earlier in 2020 the official reason the

play06:49

rosom zor gave for lifting the blockade

play06:51

was this it said that paval durov was

play06:53

prepared to cooperate in combating

play06:55

terrorism and extremism on the app what

play06:57

extremism means exactly remains vague

play07:00

as well as how telegram agreed to combat

play07:02

it a potential backo could explain the

play07:04

sudden halt in the Crackdown another

play07:06

reason to believe durov is working

play07:08

together with the Kremlin is that he has

play07:10

visited Russia more than 50 times after

play07:12

he went on his supposed

play07:14

Exile however durov has denied these

play07:17

allegations on all accounts to give him

play07:20

his due it would be a huge breaking

play07:22

character if he suddenly started working

play07:24

with Putin another explanation is that

play07:27

the Russian government just found found

play07:29

out how strong the encryption really was

play07:33

and if you can't beat them you have to

play07:35

join them right anyways back to

play07:39

2024 with the political heat Putin wants

play07:42

to get more censorship on the internet

play07:44

perhaps the Russian authorities wanted

play07:46

to go too far which paval durov refused

play07:49

to do they could have threatened him in

play07:51

some way which then sparked him to go to

play07:53

France in Exile if durov got the

play07:55

impression that the Russian government

play07:57

was out to get him this would make sense

play08:01

after all he'd be safer in a French

play08:03

prison than out in the open still it

play08:06

leaves us with the obvious question as

play08:07

to why he didn't go somewhere else he

play08:09

could have just gone to the UAE where he

play08:12

also has a citizenship what makes it

play08:14

even weirder is that both Putin and

play08:16

durov were in azan's capital before the

play08:19

billionaire flew to Paris both were

play08:22

officially there to talk to azeri

play08:23

government officials but I don't believe

play08:25

that was a

play08:26

coincidence one telegram Channel said d

play08:29

requested a meeting which Putin

play08:31

declined other Russian media have also

play08:34

claimed that there has been no meeting

play08:36

when people started questioning this if

play08:38

it happened or not the intent was

play08:41

probably there this brings us to another

play08:43

theory maybe durov has some dirt on

play08:46

Putin or some plan that hurt his

play08:48

government then he tried to talk to him

play08:50

in neutral territory in order to put

play08:52

pressure on him afterwards durov could

play08:55

have willingly gone to Paris in order to

play08:58

share some Danger dangerous

play09:00

information after all why would he try

play09:03

to meet Putin before heading over to

play09:05

enemy territory the answer could have to

play09:07

do with this the Russian military uses

play09:09

telegram as their main source of

play09:12

communications the Russian intelligence

play09:14

Community including spies also use

play09:17

telegram this is because they themselves

play09:20

haven't been able or willing to make

play09:21

their own endtoend encrypted

play09:24

messenger there's a huge problem with

play09:26

this though if durov hands over some

play09:29

iCal information to France the West

play09:31

might be able to look at Russia's

play09:32

military

play09:34

Communications one Russian newspaper

play09:36

said that this blow to telegram

play09:38

threatens to be a blow to Russia with

play09:40

parval durov's arrest Western

play09:42

intelligence Services could obtain The

play09:44

Messengers encryption Keys a newspaper

play09:47

in Moscow said that telegram might

play09:49

become a tool of NATO if paval durov is

play09:52

forced to obey the French intelligence

play09:54

Services it went on to write that

play09:56

telegram chats contain a huge amount of

play09:58

vitally important strategic information

play10:01

by the way these stories are making

play10:03

headlines right now because people in

play10:05

Russia are freaking out this includes

play10:07

the Kremlin as it has instructed all

play10:09

officials and law enforcement agencies

play10:11

to delete their telegram chats the same

play10:13

could be happening in Russia's military

play10:15

and its intelligence Community the

play10:17

threat to Russia is a little bit nuanced

play10:19

though because even telegram itself

play10:20

doesn't have the encryption keys of

play10:22

chats at least it's not supposed to

play10:24

because that's not how endtoend

play10:27

encryption works the keys are supposed

play10:29

to be stored on the devices themselves

play10:32

but theoretically he could make it a lot

play10:34

easier for Western intelligence agencies

play10:36

to Infiltrate The System the telegram

play10:39

CEO has detailed knowledge about how the

play10:41

app works including its potential weak

play10:43

points giving this information could

play10:45

very well get him out of prison still we

play10:48

should also cover why the French

play10:49

authorities arrested dorov in the first

play10:51

place the country has mysteriously

play10:53

awarded him citizenship 3 years earlier

play10:55

but putting him in prison seems like a

play10:57

very rude way to welcome him back

play10:59

apparently the French government's

play11:00

relationship with him soured the

play11:02

country's center for the fight against

play11:04

cyber crime as well as its antifraud

play11:06

national office launched an

play11:07

investigation against the entrepreneur

play11:10

durov has been accused of a total of 12

play11:12

charges which mostly have to do with the

play11:14

lack of content moderation on his

play11:15

platform France's public prosecutor

play11:18

claimed that telegram was used for

play11:19

things like drug trafficking fraud and

play11:21

child sexual abuse According to some

play11:24

legal views an owner of a platform is

play11:27

responsible for facilitating this

play11:30

on top of this durov has been accused of

play11:32

rejecting legal requests from

play11:34

authorities apparently France wanted to

play11:37

Monitor and intercept Communications of

play11:39

certain users on the platform which

play11:41

telegram didn't cooperate with all of

play11:43

this adds up to potentially 20 years in

play11:45

prison but this case has gotten a lot of

play11:47

heat one of durov's lawyers said that

play11:50

the legal theories behind it make no

play11:51

sense normally you don't prosecute

play11:54

businessmen for what consumers do with

play11:56

their product he compared it to blaming

play11:58

car manufacturers for Road accidents or

play12:00

for people transporting drugs this is

play12:03

also the angle that many Russian

play12:04

commentators are taking an analyst on a

play12:07

popular TV show said that all these

play12:09

accusations against durov sound absurd

play12:13

accusing him of all the crimes that are

play12:15

committed on his platform is like

play12:16

accusing president macron of all the

play12:18

crimes that happen in France it's the

play12:20

same logic it's also very unpopular with

play12:23

free speech activists who see the arrest

play12:25

as an attack on differing opinions for

play12:28

example on musk has posted multiple

play12:30

tweets criticizing the government in

play12:32

Paris for the arrest and calling for the

play12:34

release of the entrepreneur the American

play12:36

whistleblower Edward Snowden Who

play12:39

currently lives in Russia for safety

play12:41

said that it was an assault on the basic

play12:43

human rights of speech and

play12:45

Association one of the arguments is that

play12:47

France wants to force telegram to give

play12:49

up endtoend

play12:51

encryption if France succeeds other

play12:54

Western countries might follow the flip

play12:56

side of this is that the government

play12:58

could see your messages whenever they

play13:00

wanted to including content that's

play13:02

perfectly legal people on the free

play13:04

speech and libertarian Camp hate this

play13:06

idea as it's an attack on privacy also

play13:09

it could make the government way too

play13:11

powerful there are actually some

play13:13

concerning parallels with Russia itself

play13:15

its internet Watchdog the rosamor was

play13:18

originally created to fight terrorism

play13:21

and extremism now it's used by the

play13:23

Kremlin to hunt down political

play13:25

opposition the line between content

play13:27

moderation and online censorship is

play13:30

pretty vague the fear is that the French

play13:32

and other Western governments are trying

play13:34

to do the same government agencies in

play13:36

the US have already been caught trying

play13:38

to suppress unwanted information on

play13:39

Twitter before it was acquired by musk

play13:42

with telegram people are saying there's

play13:44

a similar motive the app hosts some

play13:47

major communication channels for

play13:49

opposition political groups mostly on

play13:51

the right they form a threat to some

play13:54

governments including the one of French

play13:55

president macron telegram channels also

play13:59

played a role in the recent UK riots

play14:01

where they helped to organize right-wing

play14:03

groups the UK government has been trying

play14:06

to arrest people for their social media

play14:07

posts but it can't do that on telegram

play14:10

because of the encryption at least not

play14:12

yet because that could change after the

play14:14

court case in France telegram is also a

play14:17

place with a lot of pro-russian

play14:19

propaganda regarding the Ukraine war in

play14:21

a conflict both sides usually downplay

play14:24

their own losses and exacerbate those of

play14:27

the other a key part of the information

play14:30

war is shielding your public from the

play14:32

other side just like Russia is blocking

play14:35

Western media Outlets the West is trying

play14:37

to block Russian media Outlets telegram

play14:40

has also served as the main platform for

play14:42

Hamas in the Israel Gaza War it has

play14:45

played a key role in forming the

play14:47

worldwide anti-israel movement because a

play14:50

lot of the graphic footage from Gaza has

play14:52

spread through the app the Israeli

play14:54

government has asked telegram to remove

play14:57

herass Affiliated accounts in exciting

play14:59

violence against Israel but this is not

play15:01

yet waterproof so there's also some

play15:04

pressure from the Israeli government to

play15:06

tighten control over the app this

play15:08

foreign interest in the app is not new

play15:11

at all in an interview with Tucker

play15:13

Carlson pavl durov also claimed that the

play15:15

FBI tried to hire one of the telegram

play15:17

developers to install a back door in the

play15:19

app's encryption the plan didn't succeed

play15:22

but it just shows the interest that

play15:23

intelligence agencies have in the

play15:25

messenger there are several motivations

play15:27

for the FBI to one access

play15:29

as it is important for both domestic and

play15:31

foreign intelligence the app played a

play15:33

key role in the January 6th riots but as

play15:36

we discussed before it also has

play15:38

relevance in the Ukraine war with all of

play15:40

this in mind we can raise some doubts

play15:42

whether the arrest was truly about

play15:44

things like fraud and drug trafficking

play15:46

French president macron has denied

play15:48

everything saying on X that it was not

play15:51

in any way a political decision and that

play15:53

his country is deeply committed to

play15:55

freedom of expression and communication

play16:00

clearly not everyone is convinced by

play16:02

this the Russian government used the

play16:04

event to the fullest for a PR win the

play16:06

Russian Embassy in France has condemned

play16:08

the arrest asking the authorities to

play16:11

clarify the reasons for the detention

play16:13

and to provide for the protection of Mr

play16:15

durov's rights Russian officials wanted

play16:18

to prove a point namely that there are

play16:20

double standards internationally they're

play16:23

saying that when Russia does things like

play16:24

this it gets criticized for not having

play16:26

free speech and democracy but that

play16:29

France can get away with it scot-free a

play16:32

human rights official in Russia claimed

play16:34

that the real reason for arresting pvl

play16:36

durov was to shut down telegram a

play16:38

platform where you can discover the

play16:40

truth about what's happening in the

play16:41

world everyone who strives for free

play16:43

speech protests this this is obviously

play16:46

hypocritical because Russia is doing

play16:48

exactly the same with websites like X

play16:52

still rhetoric like this is worsening

play16:54

ties between Moscow and Paris their

play16:57

relations have reached new lows and it

play16:59

was already very bad to begin with

play17:01

France's president maon was the first

play17:03

Western leader that didn't rule out

play17:05

sending troops to Ukraine because of

play17:08

this he was already portrayed as a bad

play17:10

guy in the Russian media anyways there's

play17:13

a chance that this discussion about free

play17:15

speech and politics turns out to be

play17:17

Irrelevant for the story if durov

play17:19

manages to get away by giving some

play17:21

valuable information about Russian

play17:22

Communications the rest of the messenger

play17:24

service could remain untouched and the

play17:27

theories just

play17:29

keep

play17:31

going there are some completely

play17:33

different theories as well that deserve

play17:34

to be mentioned perhaps dorov thought

play17:36

that the arrest warrant didn't amount to

play17:38

anything because he believed that the

play17:40

charges wouldn't hold in court he could

play17:43

have just traveled to Paris like he has

play17:45

done many times before believing it

play17:47

would be no

play17:48

problem this would make sense if we look

play17:50

at the official reaction from telegram

play17:53

the company has said that their CEO has

play17:55

nothing to hide and that it's absurd to

play17:57

blame him for what other people choose

play17:58

to do with the service but risking 20

play18:00

years in jail just to prove a point

play18:02

seems pretty wild to me an even Wilder

play18:04

theory is that his girlfriend convinced

play18:06

him to go to Paris on a holiday and that

play18:08

she might have been a spy she's a bit of

play18:11

a mysterious figure but according to her

play18:13

social media posts she went with him on

play18:15

his recent trips we also know that this

play18:17

mysterious girlfriend has been taken

play18:19

into custody in Paris and that her

play18:21

family hasn't been able to locate her

play18:22

since maybe the French government or

play18:25

some other intelligence agency hired her

play18:26

to trick durov into going to Paris or

play18:29

maybe the Russian government wanted to

play18:31

crazy as it sounds things like this can

play18:33

happen with people as important as the

play18:35

telegram CEO in the end only time will

play18:38

tell what was truly the motivation

play18:40

behind this arrest this is one of those

play18:42

weird stories that only get more

play18:44

complicated as you dive in deeper if the

play18:47

man actually ends up in prison or not

play18:48

will tell us a lot so that's something

play18:50

to pay attention to but we shouldn't

play18:52

expect to get to know the details all at

play18:54

once because there could be some high

play18:56

stake intelligence stuff going on if

play18:58

Western agencies manage to break into

play18:59

Russian Communications or if telegram

play19:02

gets censored it probably won't make

play19:04

headlines now before we get into that I

play19:07

quickly wanted to answer a question I

play19:08

recently got asked a lot of you guys

play19:10

want to start a YouTube channel but you

play19:12

are camera shy or just not comfortable

play19:15

putting your face out there in fact I am

play19:18

one of those people and that's why this

play19:20

channel has no face on

play19:23

it luckily you can still grow on YouTube

play19:26

even without showing your face or giving

play19:29

up your privacy this channel is the

play19:32

living proof of that in fact here are

play19:35

just a few examples of channels that

play19:37

started in the last 12 months and grew

play19:39

an audience without showing their face

play19:41

they have gotten millions of views and

play19:43

made thousands of dollars from them we

play19:45

recently crossed 1 million subscribers

play19:47

and along the way we have learned a few

play19:49

tips and tricks about YouTube that can

play19:51

be helpful to any of you who want to

play19:52

start your channel we have included all

play19:55

this in my completely free 7-Day YouTube

play19:59

crash course so if you are someone who

play20:01

is interested in starting a YouTube

play20:02

channel this is the perfect starting

play20:05

point for you what better way to

play20:07

convince you than to read a comment left

play20:10

by a previous

play20:11

student this free course is better than

play20:15

a paid course I spent $47 on so if you

play20:19

are interested in signing up you can

play20:21

sign up now for free by clicking the

play20:23

link in the description or scanning the

play20:24

QR code on screen

Rate This

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

الوسوم ذات الصلة
Telegram CEOArrest ControversyPrivacy IssuesFree SpeechCensorship DebateGlobal PoliticsEncryption KeysRussian ReactionWestern GovernmentsSocial Media Censorship
هل تحتاج إلى تلخيص باللغة الإنجليزية؟