Betelgeuse Explained

Cool Worlds
29 Feb 202028:38

Summary

TLDRThe video script delves into the peculiar dimming of Betelgeuse, one of the closest massive stars to the Sun. It explores the star's lifecycle, its transformation into a red supergiant, and the two potential fates it could meet: a supernova explosion or a quiet implosion into a black hole. The script also discusses recent theories for the dimming, including the presence of giant star spots or ejected dust, while emphasizing the star's significance in the cosmic creation of heavy elements essential for life.

Takeaways

  • 🌌 Betelgeuse, located in the Orion constellation, is one of the closest massive stars to the Sun and has recently dimmed to one-third of its usual brightness.
  • 🔍 The dimming of Betelgeuse is noticeable to the naked eye and has raised questions about its future behavior.
  • 💫 Betelgeuse is a very young star in astronomical terms, having been born only about 10 million years ago, compared to the Sun's 4.6 billion years.
  • ☀️ Despite its youth, Betelgeuse is much older in terms of its lifespan, having already entered its giant phase due to its rapid consumption of fuel.
  • 🔥 Betelgeuse has 15 times more mass than the Sun and emits 100,000 times more power, making it a 'monster' among stars.
  • 🌀 Massive stars like Betelgeuse are rare, with only 1 in 200 stars being born with such a large mass.
  • 💥 When massive stars die, they can either undergo a supernova explosion or collapse into a black hole, depending on their mass.
  • 🌑 The recent dimming of Betelgeuse does not necessarily indicate an impending supernova, as stars do not typically dim before such an event.
  • 🌡️ Infrared measurements suggest that the overall power output of Betelgeuse has not changed, indicating that the dimming is limited to the visible light spectrum.
  • 🌐 Two popular theories for the dimming are the presence of a giant star spot or the ejection of dust from the star's surface, both of which could block light without changing the star's overall luminosity.
  • 🌠 Betelgeuse's behavior is a reminder of the cosmic processes that have contributed to the creation of the elements essential for life on Earth.

Q & A

  • What unusual behavior has been observed in Betelgeuse recently?

    -Betelgeuse has recently dimmed down to just one third of its usual brightness, which is noticeable by the naked eye and has demoted it from the 10th to the 24th brightest star.

  • Where is Betelgeuse located in the sky?

    -Betelgeuse is located towards the Orion constellation, specifically at the shoulder of the mythological hunter, also known as alpha Orionis.

  • How does the age of Betelgeuse compare to the Sun?

    -Betelgeuse is much younger than the Sun; it was probably born just 10 million years ago, compared to the Sun's age of about 4.6 billion years.

  • Why is Betelgeuse considered a massive star?

    -Betelgeuse is considered massive because it was born with 15 times more mass than our Sun and has been consuming its fuel supply at a rapid rate.

  • What is the difference between a supernova and a star that implodes into a black hole?

    -A supernova occurs when a star's core collapses and bounces back, releasing tremendous energy and matter. A star that implodes into a black hole does not bounce back; it collapses completely into a singular point of infinite density.

  • What are the two likely fates for a massive star like Betelgeuse when it dies?

    -The two likely fates for a massive star like Betelgeuse are either a supernova explosion or imploding into a black hole.

  • What is the significance of Betelgeuse's dimming in the visible light spectrum?

    -The dimming in the visible light spectrum suggests some change in the star's outer layers, but it does not necessarily indicate an imminent supernova, as the overall luminosity has not changed significantly.

  • What is the role of granulation in the appearance of Betelgeuse?

    -Granulation, caused by the convection of hot plasma beneath the surface, can create large dark features on the surface of Betelgeuse, potentially explaining the lopsided images and visible light dimming.

  • What is the escape velocity from the surface of Betelgeuse?

    -The escape velocity from the surface of Betelgeuse is about 60 kilometers per second, significantly lower than the Sun's due to its weaker surface gravity.

  • How do astronomers determine if a star like Betelgeuse is about to go supernova?

    -Astronomers look for changes in brightness, spectral analysis, and other observational data, but predicting the exact moment of a supernova is challenging due to the complexity of stellar dynamics.

  • What is the connection between massive stars like Betelgeuse and life on Earth?

    -Massive stars like Betelgeuse are responsible for forging many of the heavy elements necessary for life through nuclear fusion. When they explode or die, these elements are dispersed throughout the universe and can become part of new stars and planets, including those that may harbor life.

Outlines

00:00

🌌 Unusual Dimming of Betelgeuse

The script begins with the observation of Betelgeuse, a massive star in the Orion constellation, which has recently dimmed to a third of its usual brightness. This unusual behavior has raised questions about whether it might be on the verge of a supernova explosion. The star, also known as alpha Orionis, is typically the 10th brightest in the sky but has been demoted to the 24th due to its dimming. The paragraph delves into the star's background, highlighting its relative youth at only 10 million years old compared to the Sun's 4.6 billion, and its status as a red supergiant, which is much rarer than average stars.

05:01

🔥 Betelgeuse's Life Cycle and Potential Supernova

This paragraph explores the life cycle of Betelgeuse, a star with 15 times the mass of the Sun, which has already entered its giant phase due to its rapid consumption of fuel. The script explains the process of helium fusion in the star's core and the subsequent expansion of its outer envelope. It also discusses the two possible outcomes for a star of Betelgeuse's mass when it reaches the end of its life: a core-collapse supernova, leading to either a neutron star or a black hole, depending on the star's ability to resist gravitational collapse.

10:04

🌑 The Mystery of Betelgeuse's Disappearance

The script introduces the possibility that Betelgeuse might not end its life with a bang but rather a whimper, disappearing without a supernova. It references the observation of a similar event in 2010, where a red supergiant star seemingly vanished. The paragraph also discusses the theoretical models predicting whether a star will implode into a black hole or explode as a supernova, based on its mass, and the inherent unpredictability due to factors like rotation speed and metallicity.

15:05

🌗 The Enigma of Betelgeuse's Recent Dimming

This paragraph addresses the recent noticeable dimming of Betelgeuse, which has been constant and steep, dropping to one-third of its usual brightness. The script explains that while Betelgeuse is a variable star and changes in brightness are not unusual, the recent decline is significant and has raised concerns. It also mentions the difficulty in predicting pre-supernova behavior due to the complexity of stellar interiors and the lack of observed data leading up to a supernova event.

20:07

🌟 Debunking the Supernova Hypothesis for Betelgeuse

The script presents evidence that suggests the recent dimming of Betelgeuse may not indicate an impending supernova. It discusses the difference between visible light brightness and overall luminosity, highlighting that infrared measurements show no change in Betelgeuse's power output. The paragraph also introduces two popular theories to explain the dimming: the presence of a giant star spot or an episode of dust ejection from the star.

25:07

🌌 The Significance of Betelgeuse in the Cosmos

The final paragraph reflects on the significance of massive stars like Betelgeuse in the universe. It emphasizes that these stars, despite their rarity and short lifespans, play a crucial role in the creation of heavier elements necessary for life. The script poetically describes the potential supernova or implosion of Betelgeuse as a sacrificial act that contributes to the birth of new stars and planets, and by extension, life itself.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Betelgeuse

Betelgeuse is a massive star located in the Orion constellation, known for its brightness and distinctive red color. It has recently dimmed to one-third of its usual brightness, sparking curiosity and concern about its behavior and potential to go supernova. The video explores its characteristics, life cycle, and the recent dimming event.

💡Supernova

A supernova is a powerful and luminous explosion that occurs during the last stages of a massive star's life. Betelgeuse's dimming has led to speculation that it might go supernova. The video discusses how supernovae are formed and the potential outcomes for Betelgeuse if it reaches this stage.

💡Variable star

A variable star is one whose brightness changes over time. Betelgeuse is a known variable star, but its recent dimming is unusual even for its variable nature. The video highlights the difference between typical variability and the significant recent changes observed in Betelgeuse's brightness.

💡Luminosity

Luminosity refers to the total amount of energy a star emits per unit of time. Despite Betelgeuse's recent visible light dimming, its luminosity, especially in the infrared spectrum, remains unchanged, indicating that the overall energy output has not decreased significantly. This distinction is crucial for understanding the true nature of the star's dimming.

💡Core collapse

Core collapse is a process in massive stars where the core contracts under gravity, leading to a supernova or forming a neutron star or black hole. The video explains how Betelgeuse might undergo core collapse and the different outcomes depending on its mass and internal processes.

💡Hydrogen fusion

Hydrogen fusion is the nuclear reaction that powers stars, converting hydrogen into helium and releasing energy. In Betelgeuse, hydrogen fusion in the core has ceased, leading to the fusion of heavier elements and its expansion into a red supergiant. The video details how this process affects the star's life cycle.

💡Triple-alpha process

The triple-alpha process is a set of nuclear fusion reactions by which three helium nuclei (alpha particles) are transformed into carbon. This process occurs in Betelgeuse's core, significantly increasing its energy output and causing its outer envelope to expand. The video uses this concept to explain Betelgeuse's current state.

💡Granulation

Granulation refers to the visible pattern on the surface of stars caused by convection cells of hot plasma. In Betelgeuse, these granulation cells are enormous due to its weak surface gravity. The video discusses how granulation could contribute to the observed dimming and lopsided appearance of Betelgeuse.

💡Dust hypothesis

The dust hypothesis suggests that Betelgeuse's dimming is due to dust ejected from the star's surface, blocking some of its light. This explanation is supported by the star's unchanged infrared luminosity and historical instances of dust ejection. The video presents this as one of the plausible explanations for Betelgeuse's dimming.

💡Neutron star

A neutron star is the dense remnant core left after a supernova explosion, composed mostly of neutrons. If Betelgeuse's core collapse results in a supernova, it could leave behind a neutron star. The video explores this possibility as one of the potential fates of Betelgeuse.

Highlights

Betelgeuse, one of the closest massive stars to the Sun, has recently dimmed down to just one third of its usual brightness.

Betelgeuse is located towards the Orion constellation and is the 10th brightest star in the sky, usually.

Betelgeuse is far younger than the Sun, having been born just 10 million years ago.

Betelgeuse has 15 times more mass than the Sun and is running on empty, having transformed into its giant phase.

Betelgeuse is a rare massive star, with only 1 in 200 stars being born with as much mass.

Inside a star, the core where fusion happens and the envelope, which is hot gas, are two key zones.

Betelgeuse is currently accumulating carbon ash inside its core, leading to a rise in temperature and pressure.

The end of Betelgeuse's life could involve a supernova or a more subtle implosion into a black hole.

Astronomers have observed another red supergiant disappear without a supernova, suggesting a possible fate for Betelgeuse.

Betelgeuse's dimming is unusual as it is a constant and steep decline in brightness.

Infrared measurements show that Betelgeuse's overall power output has not changed, indicating the dimming is limited to visible light.

Two popular theories explain Betelgeuse's recent behavior: a giant star spot or a convulsion that flung off outer layers.

Betelgeuse's surface gravity is weak, leading to large convection cells and possibly large dark features on its surface.

Astronomer Emily Levesque's work suggests that the surface temperature of Betelgeuse does not support a dramatic cooling episode.

The dust hypothesis, where dust blocks some of the star's light, is a compelling explanation for the dimming.

Betelgeuse's potential supernova could provide an opportunity to study the final stages of such a star, but it's probabilistically unlikely to occur in our lifetime.

Massive stars like Betelgeuse are crucial for the formation of heavy elements necessary for life.

Transcripts

play00:00

[Music]

play00:08

one of the closest massive stars to the

play00:10

Sun is acting weird Betelgeuse recently

play00:17

dimmed down to just one third of his

play00:21

usual brightness

play00:23

what could be causing this irregular

play00:26

behavior could this mean that it's about

play00:29

to explode

play00:33

grab a cup of tea and settle in because

play00:36

today we're going to be taking a deep

play00:38

dive into everything happening with the

play00:41

enigmatic Betelgeuse

play00:55

Beetlejuice lucky' towards the Orion

play00:59

constellation and you'll find this

play01:02

infamous star at the shoulder of the

play01:04

mythological hunter also known as alpha

play01:08

Orionis it's easy to spot being the 10th

play01:12

brightest star in the sky at least

play01:15

usually it's the tenth brightest you see

play01:19

over the last few months

play01:20

astronomers have noticed something

play01:22

strange about this star it's now about

play01:25

1/3 as bright as usual something

play01:28

noticeable by eye in fact it's now been

play01:32

demoted to the 24th brightest star to

play01:36

understand what's happening we first

play01:38

have to talk about some background about

play01:41

this star because you see what makes

play01:43

this dimming particularly interesting is

play01:46

that Betelgeuse is no ordinary star no

play01:49

in fact for example it is far far

play01:53

younger than our own Sun whilst the Sun

play01:56

was born from the gravitational collapse

play01:58

of an ancient giant molecular cloud some

play02:01

four thousand six hundred million years

play02:04

ago Betelgeuse was probably born just 10

play02:08

million years ago for some context this

play02:13

would be about the time that our hominid

play02:15

ancestors started to splinter off from

play02:18

what would become gorillas if we spread

play02:21

the sun's age out over a calendar of 365

play02:26

days Betelgeuse would have been born on

play02:29

December 31st at 5 a.m. it's so damn

play02:34

young that rocky planets like the earth

play02:36

would likely not have had enough time to

play02:40

her formed yet and frankly likely never

play02:43

will

play02:45

so Betelgeuse is a very young star but

play02:50

in another sense it's actually an old

play02:53

star at least when we compare it to how

play02:56

long this star is expected to survive

play02:59

so let's compare it to the Sun the Sun

play03:02

can be thought of as middle-aged enough

play03:05

fuel to last for another five billion

play03:08

years before eventually evolving into a

play03:11

short-lived giant phase and then finally

play03:14

leaving behind a dead white dwarf

play03:19

Betelgeuse on the other hand is running

play03:22

on empty and it has in fact already

play03:25

transformed into its giant phase you see

play03:30

Betelgeuse has been very greedy during

play03:33

its short life time it was born with a

play03:36

whopping 15 times more mass than our own

play03:39

Sun and ever since it got going it's

play03:43

just been feasting through its fuel

play03:45

supply like a bat out of hell the star

play03:49

is a monster it spews out 100,000 times

play03:55

more power than our own Sun does and

play03:58

even before becoming a giant during its

play04:01

main sequence lifetime that the Sun

play04:04

currently enjoys it still even then

play04:07

would have been spewing out tens of

play04:08

thousands of times more power than our

play04:11

own Sun you've probably heard the

play04:13

expression the candle that burns twice

play04:15

as hot lasts half as long well here we'd

play04:19

say that the star that burns 10,000

play04:22

times as bright lasts 1,000 times less

play04:25

long although admittedly we are talking

play04:28

about a star that began its life with at

play04:31

least 10 times as much candle wax in the

play04:35

first place

play04:36

massive stars like Betelgeuse are

play04:39

actually very rare just like animals

play04:42

most develop into a fairly average size

play04:46

for their species but

play04:48

really you get a freakish set of

play04:51

circumstances that somehow result in a

play04:54

giant iced example and these giants

play04:58

really stand out

play05:00

in the same way Betelgeuse is a freak

play05:04

because only 1 in 200 stars will be born

play05:09

with as much mass inside them as

play05:11

Betelgeuse was and not only is

play05:14

Betelgeuse massive the fact that it's

play05:17

enter disjoint phase means it's also

play05:20

humongous to understand this gargantuan

play05:23

term let's look inside a star a star has

play05:28

two key zones the core where fusion

play05:31

happens and the envelope which is

play05:34

basically just hot gas sat on top as

play05:37

stars fuse hydrogen into denser helium

play05:41

inside their cause

play05:43

they accumulate an inert inner core of

play05:47

helium ash inside their centers now

play05:49

because helium is denser than hydrogen

play05:53

the core contracts which in turn causes

play05:56

it to heat up eventually the central

play05:59

temperature and pressure become extreme

play06:02

enough that helium can now fuse into

play06:04

carbon via the triple alpha process

play06:06

which substantially increases the energy

play06:10

output of the core and this in turn

play06:12

causes the outer envelope of non fusing

play06:16

hydrogen to simply puff up a bit like a

play06:19

hot air balloon except that that balloon

play06:22

has now puffed up to the size of

play06:25

Jupiter's orbit around the Sun a

play06:28

gargantuan size so this broadly

play06:32

describes what's happening inside

play06:34

Betelgeuse right now my it is as big as

play06:37

it is but it will not stay in this state

play06:40

forever because as it's accumulating now

play06:43

carbon ash inside its core that

play06:46

temperature and pressure will continue

play06:49

to rise in the center eventually even

play06:52

the carbon and heavier elements still

play06:55

will be able to start fusing and once

play06:58

this happens well the end is nigh for

play07:01

beetle

play07:01

we'll be looking at a few hundred years

play07:04

perhaps a couple of millennia until its

play07:07

demise

play07:14

what happens to massive stars like

play07:17

Betelgeuse when they die there are two

play07:20

likely possibilities the one you are

play07:23

probably hearing the most about is a

play07:26

supernova remember that the core will

play07:29

eventually start to fuse carbon and even

play07:32

heavier elements in its center but once

play07:36

it starts producing iron ash well the

play07:39

gig is up

play07:40

that's because fusing things heavier

play07:43

than iron is what we would call an

play07:45

endothermic reaction and all that means

play07:47

is that you actually have to put in more

play07:49

energy to conduct the reaction than you

play07:52

get out the other end in other words

play07:54

this reaction saps energy from the core

play07:58

remember that this is a massive star and

play08:01

so it has a huge self gravity trying to

play08:04

collapse it in on itself when the heat

play08:07

source starts to dwindle due to the

play08:09

accumulation of this iron ash well

play08:12

there's nothing to resist that

play08:14

gravitational collapse anymore and so

play08:17

the star literally falls in on itself

play08:20

imploding it's at this point that the

play08:23

two possible futures for Betelgeuse

play08:25

diverge one is going to be a band and

play08:28

the other is a whimper as this wave of

play08:32

infalling material the outer envelope of

play08:36

the star falls in towards the core due

play08:38

to gravity one of two things is going to

play08:40

happen either the core is gonna

play08:43

structurally resist that in falling wave

play08:46

and notice or bounce off the outside or

play08:48

the core will not be up to resist and it

play08:51

will simply crush down stars on the

play08:54

lighter end of the massive star spectrum

play08:56

around ten times the sun's mass will not

play08:59

generate enough pressure to collapse the

play09:02

inner core instead they'll merely

play09:05

compress it into a super dense neutron

play09:08

star state and then bounce off that

play09:11

neutronic interior that bounce back

play09:14

leads to a giant shock wave that

play09:16

propagates out into space

play09:18

releasing tremendous waves of energy and

play09:21

spewing matter

play09:23

across the void and that's what we call

play09:26

a supernova or to be a little bit more

play09:30

technical a core collapse supernova but

play09:33

what if this star is heavier than ten

play09:36

times the sun's mass well now there is a

play09:39

lot more material falling down onto that

play09:42

inner core so much so that it can

play09:45

actually overwhelm even the resistive

play09:48

strength of neutronic matter and so the

play09:52

star will fall in crushing the core in

play09:55

fact it will fall all the way in all the

play09:59

way in to a singular point of infinite

play10:04

density a black hole in some cases the

play10:08

bounce-back still happens it forms a

play10:10

neutron star but some of that wave of

play10:13

bouncing out material ends up falling

play10:16

back onto the neutron star and it just

play10:18

tips the balance enough to turn that

play10:21

neutron star into a black hole all the

play10:23

same but in other cases there is so much

play10:27

in falling material that the star just

play10:30

literally implodes it winks out of

play10:34

existence

play10:35

there's no bounce-back there's no

play10:37

stooping over

play10:38

there's no bang of any kind it just

play10:43

disappears this winking out has in fact

play10:47

been seen before around 2010 astronomers

play10:52

witnessed another red supergiant in the

play10:55

galaxy NGC 6-9 46 simply disappear this

play11:01

actually wasn't even noticed at the time

play11:04

and it was only later that a couple of

play11:06

astronomers at a higher state university

play11:09

checked carefully through the archival

play11:11

data and found this remarkable event now

play11:15

that star was likely born with around 25

play11:19

times more mass than the Sun as shown

play11:22

here but lower mass red supergiant's in

play11:25

the range of sort of ten to fifteen

play11:28

times the mass of the Sun have been seen

play11:31

to do the opposite and explode now if we

play11:34

compare these observations to

play11:36

theoretical more

play11:38

it matches up quite nicely here you can

play11:40

see a prediction for whether the star

play11:42

will implode into a black hole winking

play11:45

out or turn into a supernova in green

play11:49

and this clearly depends on the stars

play11:51

mass the outcome of these models shows

play11:54

some randomness the rotation speed

play11:57

metallicity and intrinsically stochastic

play12:01

nature of the stars interior means that

play12:04

we can't always predict exactly what

play12:07

will happen based on a star's mass alone

play12:10

and so this is why in part it's so

play12:14

difficult to say exactly what will

play12:16

happen to Betelgeuse this situation is

play12:19

exacerbated by the fact we actually

play12:21

don't know the mass of Betelgeuse and

play12:24

certainly not the mass of Betelgeuse it

play12:25

was born with and very well and that's

play12:29

because in turn we don't even know a

play12:30

precise distance for Betelgeuse and so

play12:33

in turn this means that we end up with a

play12:35

very large uncertainty on its mass so

play12:38

comparing to the theoretical models one

play12:41

can see how it's certainly possible that

play12:43

Betelgeuse might just disappear one day

play12:45

without a bank

play12:54

okay so with this fascinating background

play12:57

about these massive stars out of the way

play13:00

we can now finally talk about what has

play13:02

been happening with Betelgeuse over the

play13:04

last few months the first thing to say

play13:07

is that Betelgeuse is a variable star I

play13:11

mean it is not surprising for his

play13:13

brightness to change it's not a light

play13:15

bulb it's brightness changes by a few

play13:18

percent even ten percent quite often and

play13:20

has been seen for decades now what's

play13:23

really unusual about what's been

play13:24

happening lately is that this is a

play13:26

fairly constant and steep regular

play13:29

decline in brightness which has gone

play13:31

really quite deep down to one third of

play13:34

its usual brightness and that is frankly

play13:36

kind of weird I want to emphasize that

play13:39

that number represents the minimum in

play13:41

the stars a recent episode of dimming in

play13:44

the last couple of weeks it has actually

play13:46

started to stabilize and even reverse

play13:49

brightening back up again the story gets

play13:52

extra-spicy when we throw in these two

play13:55

images of the star taken about a year

play13:57

apart now normally it's impossible to

play14:00

resolve individual stars like this but

play14:03

some supergiant's are so big that we can

play14:07

at least get a fuzzy image like this one

play14:09

clearly Betelgeuse looks quite different

play14:12

between these two photos and that fact

play14:15

combined with the dimming has a lot of

play14:18

folks quite worried so let's just ask

play14:20

the obvious question that song

play14:23

everybody's lips right now and that is

play14:25

does this dimming of Betelgeuse mean

play14:28

that it's about to go supernova sure

play14:32

answer

play14:33

probably not and there's a few reasons

play14:37

for this first off we really don't have

play14:40

any clear prediction that stars are

play14:42

expected to undergo a period of dimming

play14:44

before going supernova the hydro

play14:48

dynamics of these stellar interiors is

play14:51

very complicated and there's a intricate

play14:53

feedback with gravity waves that

play14:55

actually affects their luminosity output

play14:57

in a fairly unpredictable way here's an

play15:00

example of a prediction for the

play15:02

luminosity of a star essentially how

play15:04

bright is versus its surface temperature

play15:07

in the final years before its death from

play15:10

Professor Jim fuller the star's

play15:13

luminosity is indeed sometimes dimming

play15:16

but it is also often brightening - I

play15:20

mean it's really all over the map we've

play15:23

never really caught a supernova in the

play15:26

act before at least in the days and

play15:29

years preceding the event and so we

play15:32

can't really tell you from data how

play15:35

stars behave just before they go

play15:37

supernova and so these models are really

play15:39

kind of the best we have right now and

play15:41

so frankly we just don't know how stars

play15:46

behave just before going supernova we

play15:49

don't know that it looks like what's

play15:50

happening right now now in that model

play15:52

prediction I showed you for the stars

play15:54

pre supernova behavior what's being

play15:57

shown here is the luminosity now it's

play16:00

tempting to say that this widely

play16:02

reported recent dimming translates

play16:05

directly to a decrease in luminosity but

play16:09

that's actually not true now these

play16:12

reported dimming that we've been hearing

play16:14

about have all been of the star's

play16:16

brightness in the visible light part of

play16:19

the spectrum but Betelgeuse like all

play16:22

stars produces radiation are all

play16:25

different wavelengths across the entire

play16:27

electromagnetic spectrum and so if we

play16:29

want to calculate luminosity we have to

play16:32

actually add up all of that rightness

play16:34

across the entire spectrum and that's

play16:36

not what we observed with these dimming

play16:39

it is not the luminosity

play16:41

of the star fortunately of course there

play16:44

is a way that we can get the luminosity

play16:45

we just simply have to do these

play16:47

observations at other parts of the

play16:49

spectrum

play16:50

apart from visible light and that's

play16:52

exactly what astronomers have very

play16:54

recently done infrared measurements

play16:56

taken at the O'Brien Observatory in

play16:58

Minnesota just last week showed that the

play17:02

star has the same brightness in the

play17:04

infrared as it did 50 years ago in other

play17:07

words this dimming does not represent a

play17:10

change in the star's overall power

play17:13

output it's just limited to the visible

play17:17

light part of the spectrum okay so maybe

play17:19

we can take our fingers off the panic

play17:22

button we don't seem to be in the regime

play17:24

of a wildly varying star like Jim fuller

play17:27

predictor but then how do we explain

play17:29

this pronounced a visible light dimming

play17:32

as well as the strange lopsided image

play17:35

that was recently captured

play17:39

[Music]

play17:43

there are broadly two popular theories

play17:46

to explain what's being going on with

play17:49

beetlejuice recently if we are willing

play17:51

to discount the supernova hypothesis

play17:54

just for the moment the first is a giant

play17:57

star spot if we look at the Sun we see

play18:00

small sunspots quite often these are

play18:03

regions where the sun's magnetic field

play18:05

lines temporarily come together in a way

play18:09

that inhibits convection of heat from

play18:11

the sun's interior up to its surface

play18:14

without that heat coming up to this part

play18:17

of the surface well that patch of the

play18:20

surface cools down it gets to about half

play18:22

of its usual temperature and that in

play18:26

turn means that it appears darker this

play18:29

is very much analogous to how if you

play18:31

pull a piece of iron out of a fire it

play18:34

will glow red initially but then cool

play18:37

down and stop growing now a spot or

play18:40

collection of spots that is big enough

play18:42

to block out about two-thirds of the

play18:45

stars usual brightness would have to

play18:47

therefore block out about two-thirds of

play18:49

the star's surface at least the

play18:51

hemisphere that we can see if the other

play18:54

hemisphere is spot free then this means

play18:57

that in total about 1/3 of the star

play19:00

surface would have to be covered in

play19:02

spots for the Sun spar certainly never

play19:05

get so big or so numerous as to block

play19:08

out anywhere near this much of the

play19:11

surface other giant stars have been

play19:13

recorded to do this in the past for

play19:16

example the orange giant HD one two five

play19:19

four five in a constellation Triangulum

play19:21

has had its surface resolved with a

play19:23

special technique called Doppler imaging

play19:25

that clearly reveals sparse covering

play19:29

about a quarter of the surface not quite

play19:33

a third but close enough to show us that

play19:35

this is at least a plausible explanation

play19:38

now for the sun spots come and go on a

play19:41

roughly 11-year cycle and at the peak of

play19:44

this cycle about 1% of the star surface

play19:47

is covered in spots which corresponds to

play19:50

a fairly marginal change in the

play19:53

luminosity of the star it actually only

play19:55

increases

play19:56

point zero seven percent and so stars

play20:00

luminosities are fairly robust to

play20:03

changes in their spot coverage when we

play20:06

combine all these points together we can

play20:09

kind of see how this spot hypothesis

play20:11

could work then for Betelgeuse we can

play20:13

explain the fact that luminosity doesn't

play20:16

seem to be changing very much we can

play20:18

explain the apparent dimming in the

play20:20

visible part of the spectrum and we can

play20:22

also explain that lopsided image all

play20:25

with a single hypothesis now on the Sun

play20:28

record that spots are caused by magnetic

play20:31

field lines impeding convection these

play20:34

spots are about the size of the earth

play20:35

typically but if we zoom in there's

play20:39

another effect at play here you can see

play20:42

a much finer grain effect each one of

play20:45

these little cells that you're looking

play20:48

at is about the size of Texas what's

play20:50

amazing is that this is real data from

play20:53

Dacus not a simulation of our Sun and

play20:56

here you can cleanly resolve the surface

play21:00

at incredible detail each little bubble

play21:03

that you can see is the top of a

play21:05

convection cell and is usually called a

play21:08

granule the variability you are seeing

play21:11

is usually called granulation caused by

play21:14

the convection of hot plasma beneath the

play21:17

surface a bit like a lava lamp the size

play21:20

of these granulation cells is directly

play21:23

related to the strength of surface

play21:26

gravity on these stars so for the Sun

play21:29

nice out of the size of Texas and the

play21:31

surface gravity is about 270 meters per

play21:35

second square something like 27 28 times

play21:38

earth gravity but for Betelgeuse because

play21:40

it's so puffed up the surface gravity is

play21:44

really pathetic it's just point zero

play21:46

zero three meters per second squared

play21:50

which is about three thousand times less

play21:53

than the gravity I'm currently feeling

play21:55

here on earth it's really quite

play21:58

ridiculous and so because the gravity is

play22:02

so weak on the surface of Betelgeuse

play22:04

then these granulation cell

play22:07

get really really big Beetlejuice

play22:11

doesn't like to do anything small

play22:12

there's some beautiful computer

play22:14

simulations of the convection cell

play22:16

behavior for such stars that I'm showing

play22:18

you here it reveals just how

play22:21

effervescent lively and bubbling the

play22:25

exterior envelope truly is now sadly we

play22:28

can't resolve the surface of Betelgeuse

play22:30

as precisely as this with existing

play22:33

telescopes

play22:34

so let's downgrade the animation to the

play22:37

sort of fuzziness that we'd see

play22:39

realistically in watching this you

play22:42

indeed see that granulation alone can

play22:45

produce very large dark features on the

play22:48

surface as well as creating lopsided

play22:51

images in individual frames so all in

play22:54

all I'd say that a fairly extreme

play22:57

episode of this natural convection

play22:59

behavior could be an explanation for

play23:02

what has been happening recently with

play23:03

Betelgeuse but I promised you two

play23:06

possible explanations and the other one

play23:09

is equally compelling now remember that

play23:13

I said that the surface gravity on

play23:16

Betelgeuse is pathetically weak and so

play23:19

that might make you wonder hey if I was

play23:21

stood on the surface of Betelgeuse could

play23:24

I jump off into space could I achieve

play23:26

escape velocity the escape velocity is

play23:29

given by the following equation where G

play23:32

is the surface gravity and R is the

play23:35

radius of the object for the Sun this

play23:37

gives about 600 kilometers per second so

play23:41

you're gonna need a lot of energy to

play23:43

ever leave the Sun surface on Betelgeuse

play23:46

though it's about ten times less just 60

play23:50

kilometers per second and so this raises

play23:52

the possibility that a strong convulsion

play23:55

from within the Stars interior could

play23:57

have propagated out to the surface with

play23:59

enough force to have actually flung off

play24:02

the outer layer into deep space or at

play24:05

least a part of it and once that layer

play24:07

was dispatched from the star it would

play24:09

have cooled down and eventually ended up

play24:11

blocking out some of the star's light

play24:15

essentially it's just dust we even see

play24:18

some ever

play24:19

for previous episodes of dust released

play24:22

as you can see here in this real image

play24:25

now with the giant spot scenario the

play24:28

surface has actually cooled a little bit

play24:30

but here the surface is essentially the

play24:33

same temperature is just that there's

play24:35

some dust getting in the way and so

play24:37

recent work by astronomer Emily Levesque

play24:40

investigated what the temperature of the

play24:42

surface was using a spectral technique

play24:45

they found that the star surface doesn't

play24:47

appear consistent with an episode of

play24:50

dramatic cooling and so on this basis

play24:53

they favor the dust hypothesis and so

play24:56

this leaves us with two quite compelling

play24:58

explanations without the need to invoke

play25:01

a supernova now because there's so much

play25:03

we don't know about how stars behave in

play25:07

those final years before turning into a

play25:09

supernova then it is still absolutely

play25:12

possible that what we are seeing are the

play25:15

signs of an impending supernova but

play25:19

typically stars spend about a hundred

play25:22

thousand years in this phase of their

play25:24

life and so it's just probabilistically

play25:28

unlikely that that will coincide with

play25:31

our short human lifetimes it's also a

play25:35

shame because if Betelgeuse did go

play25:38

supernova

play25:39

it's 650 light years away which means

play25:43

it's far enough away that it won't hurt

play25:45

us but close enough that we would have

play25:47

the opportunity to study in great detail

play25:50

and learn so much about the final stages

play25:53

of this enigmatic type of star of course

play25:57

it would also put up a very nice light

play25:59

show outshining even the full moon of

play26:02

this peak brightness or it might just

play26:06

wink out leaving behind a black hole

play26:09

which would also be an incredible

play26:11

observation to see

play26:13

massive stars like Betelgeuse are

play26:16

amazing yes they are unusual rare beasts

play26:21

which are unlikely to ever form planets

play26:23

let alone life but on the other hand

play26:26

they are also somehow intimately

play26:29

connected to us that's because it's

play26:33

within these massive stellar engines

play26:36

that many of the heavy elements inside

play26:38

your body seems like phosphorus

play26:40

potassium oxygen were forged deep within

play26:44

its interior and when these stars came

play26:47

to their end they violently exploded

play26:50

these enriched guts across the cosmos

play26:53

those newly forged heavy elements were

play26:57

cast out across the galaxy to distant

play27:00

shores because there was so much

play27:03

hydrogen left and fused new smaller

play27:06

stars formed from the debris which in

play27:09

turn eventually formed planets enriched

play27:12

with these heavier elements crucial for

play27:15

life and those same elements are inside

play27:19

of your body right now they were at one

play27:23

point in their history

play27:24

inside the powers of one of the most

play27:27

massive stars in the universe you are in

play27:31

essence made of ash and so watching

play27:35

Betelgeuse is like getting to see one of

play27:38

the earliest steps in the origin of

play27:41

living things like looking into a mirror

play27:44

of our own beginnings these stars

play27:48

violently rip themselves apart in an

play27:51

almost sacrificial act so that complex

play27:54

chemical entities such as ourselves

play27:56

might one day be born rising like a

play28:01

phoenix fire flames

play28:09

[Music]

play28:35

[Music]

Rate This

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

相关标签
BetelgeuseStar DimmingAstronomySupernovaCosmic EventsStellar EvolutionMassive StarsOrion ConstellationScientific MysterySpace Phenomena
您是否需要英文摘要?