The Multiverse Hypothesis Explained by Neil deGrasse Tyson

Summary

The video explores the concept of the multiverse, discussing theories from ancient Greek philosophy to modern physics. It covers how quantum fluctuations could lead to multiple universes with different laws of physics. The idea has evolved over time, with significant contributions from physicists like Erwin Schrödinger and Max Tegmark. The video also touches on the debate within the scientific community about the legitimacy of multiverse theories and their implications for understanding our universe. It concludes by explaining various classifications of multiverses proposed by physicists.

Takeaways

• 🌀 The multiverse theory suggests that there are multiple universes, each potentially with different physical laws due to quantum fluctuations.
• 🧑‍🔬 Quantum fluctuations in the early universe could lead to variations in physical laws, creating different universes.
• ⚛️ The concept of infinite worlds dates back to ancient Greek atomism, which proposed infinite parallel worlds arising from atom collisions.
• 🗣️ Erwin Schrödinger in 1952 described the idea of multiple histories occurring simultaneously, known as superposition.
• 🚢 The multiverse can be imagined as different, non-interacting pockets of the universe, like ships with their own horizons.
• 🌌 The multiverse hypothesis posits a group of multiple universes, encompassing all space, time, matter, energy, information, and physical laws.
• 🔬 Some physicists argue that the multiverse is a philosophical rather than scientific hypothesis due to its lack of empirical falsifiability.
• 📊 Data from the Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe and the Planck satellite found no statistical evidence of universe collisions.
• ⚛️ Quantum mechanics suggests that at very small scales, predictions become statistical rather than precise, influencing multiverse theories.
• 🧩 Max Tegmark and Brian Greene have proposed classification schemes for different types of multiverses, expanding the theoretical understanding of these concepts.

Q & A

What is the multiverse theory?

The multiverse theory suggests that there are multiple universes, each potentially having different laws of physics and constants. These universes together comprise everything that exists, including all space, time, matter, energy, and the physical laws that describe them.

How do quantum fluctuations relate to the multiverse?

Quantum fluctuations in the early universe could cause different regions to develop slightly different laws of physics. This variation can lead to the formation of multiple universes, each with its own set of physical laws.

What historical ideas have influenced the concept of the multiverse?

The concept of the multiverse has roots in ancient Greek atomism, where philosophers like Chrysippus suggested the existence of multiple worlds. This idea has evolved and matured through modern physics.

What did Erwin Schrödinger propose about multiple histories?

In 1952, Erwin Schrödinger suggested that his equations describing several different histories implied that all these histories happen simultaneously. This concept is related to quantum superposition.

What are the different classifications of multiverses proposed by Max Tegmark?

Max Tegmark classified multiverses into four levels: Level 1 involves different Hubble volumes within our infinite universe; Level 2 includes universes with different physical constants formed through eternal inflation; Level 3 is based on the many-worlds interpretation of quantum mechanics; and Level 4 encompasses all universes described by different mathematical structures.

Why do some scientists argue against the multiverse theory?

Some scientists argue that the multiverse theory cannot be empirically tested or falsified, making it more of a philosophical notion than a scientific hypothesis. Concerns include the potential erosion of public confidence in science if the multiverse is accepted without empirical verification.

What did data from the Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe and the Planck satellite reveal about the multiverse?

Initial data from the Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe suggested evidence of universe collisions, but more thorough analyses, including data from the higher-resolution Planck satellite, found no significant evidence supporting the existence of other universes or their gravitational influence on ours.

How do quantum mechanics and general relativity intersect in the context of the multiverse?

Quantum mechanics and general relativity intersect at the very small scales of the early universe. When applied together, they suggest a 'quantum foam' where regions of space-time could hatch entire universes with different laws of physics.

What analogy is used to describe the separation of different universes in the multiverse?

An analogy used is that of ships at sea: each ship represents a universe with its own horizon, and they do not see each other unless their horizons overlap. This represents the idea that different universes in the multiverse are essentially independent and non-causal.

What potential dangers could arise from traveling between universes in the multiverse?

Traveling between universes could be dangerous because different laws of physics might cause significant changes in matter. For example, if the charge on the electron is different, it could disrupt biochemistry, leading to a scenario where a traveler could dissolve into a pile of goo.

Outlines

00:00

🌌 The Multiverse Hypothesis and Quantum Mechanics

The first paragraph delves into the concept of the multiverse, challenging the idea of a singular universe. It discusses how physicists and cosmologists believe that the laws of physics were established during the universe's earliest moments and that quantum fluctuations could lead to the creation of alternate universes with slightly different laws. The script touches on the ancient Greek atomists' idea of infinite worlds and how modern physics, particularly Erwin Schrödinger's concept of superposition, supports the notion of multiple universes existing simultaneously. It also addresses the potential dangers and implications of traveling between these universes, given the possibility of different physical laws, and introduces the multiverse as a collection of universes with varying space, time, matter, energy, and physical laws.

05:03

🔬 Scientific Debates and Theoretical Frameworks of the Multiverse

The second paragraph focuses on the scientific community's divided stance on the multiverse theory. It outlines the concerns about the theory's inability to be empirically falsified, which some argue undermines the scientific method. The paragraph mentions Steve Weinberg's perspective on the implications of a multiverse for understanding fundamental constants and the possibility of universes with vastly different physical conditions, such as those unable to support life. It also references scientific data from the Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe and the Planck satellite, which have not found conclusive evidence for the multiverse. The script then transitions to the theoretical underpinnings of the multiverse, including quantum mechanics and the quantum foam concept, and introduces Max Tegmark's taxonomy of multiverse levels and Brian Greene's classification of multiverse types, suggesting a complex and expansive framework for understanding the potential scope of reality.

Keywords

💡Multiverse

The term 'multiverse' refers to the hypothetical group of multiple universes, each with its own set of physical laws and constants. It is central to the video's theme, as it discusses the possibility of the existence of other universes beyond our own. The script mentions the multiverse as a concept that has been debated within the scientific community, with some physicists considering it a philosophical notion due to its lack of empirical falsifiability.

💡Cosmologists

Cosmologists are scientists who study the universe's origins, structure, and ultimate fate. In the context of the video, cosmologists are interested in the early universe and how the laws of physics were established. The script suggests that cosmologists believe quantum fluctuations in the early universe could have led to the creation of other universes with different laws of physics.

💡Quantum Fluctuations

Quantum fluctuations are temporary changes in energy in a point in space, which can influence the behavior of particles. The video explains that these fluctuations could have caused variations in the laws of physics in different universes within the multiverse. The script uses the concept to illustrate how each universe might have slightly different laws due to these fluctuations.

💡Superposition

Superposition is a fundamental principle of quantum mechanics where a particle can exist in multiple states simultaneously until it is observed. The video script mentions Erwin Schrödinger's lecture, where he introduced the idea that different histories described by quantum equations all happen simultaneously, highlighting the complexity of quantum mechanics and its relation to the multiverse concept.

💡Parallel Universes

Parallel universes, also known as alternate universes, are universes that coexist with our own but are separate and do not interact with each other. The script discusses the idea of these universes as part of the multiverse hypothesis, suggesting that they may have different physical laws and could be the result of quantum fluctuations.

💡Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP)

The WMAP is an uncrewed spacecraft that operated from 2001 to 2010, measuring temperature differences across the sky in the cosmic microwave background. The video script refers to WMAP in the context of scientists who claimed to have found evidence of our universe colliding with other parallel universes in the past, although later analyses did not support this claim.

💡Planck Satellite

The Planck Satellite is a space observatory that operated from 2009 to 2013, mapping the anisotropies of the cosmic microwave background with higher resolution than the WMAP. The script mentions the Planck Satellite as having provided more thorough data analysis that did not find statistical significant evidence of universe collisions, countering the claims made by some proponents of the multiverse hypothesis.

💡Quantum Mechanics

Quantum mechanics is the study of the behavior of particles at the smallest scales, where predictability is replaced by statistical probabilities. The video script explains that quantum mechanics is essential in understanding the behavior of the universe at the atomic scale, especially during the Big Bang, and its principles are foundational to the concept of the multiverse.

💡General Relativity

General relativity is Einstein's theory of gravity, which describes the behavior of large-scale structures in the universe. The script discusses the need to marry the physics of the small (quantum mechanics) with the physics of the large (general relativity) to understand the conditions at the Big Bang, which is crucial for the development of the multiverse hypothesis.

💡Max Tegmark

Max Tegmark is a prominent scientist who has contributed to the multiverse theory by devising a classification scheme for different types of universes within the multiverse. The video script refers to Tegmark's taxonomy of four levels of universes beyond the observable universe, providing a framework for understanding the various theoretical types of multiverses.

💡Brian Greene

Brian Greene is an American theoretical physicist who has discussed various types of multiverses. The video script mentions Greene's work in the context of the multiverse hypothesis, indicating that he has explored different theoretical frameworks for understanding the concept of multiple universes.

Highlights

The concept of a multiverse suggests there are multiple universes, each with its own set of physical laws.

Quantum fluctuations in the early universe may be responsible for creating different universes with slightly varying laws of physics.

The idea of infinite worlds dates back to ancient Greek atomism, which proposed that infinite parallel worlds arise from atomic collisions.

Erwin Schrödinger, in 1952, suggested that multiple histories described by quantum mechanics actually happen simultaneously, a concept known as superposition.

The multiverse theory posits that there are pockets of the universe that are expanding independently and are essentially separate from each other.

The multiverse includes everything that exists: space, time, matter, energy, information, and the physical laws and constants.

Some physicists argue the multiverse theory is not scientifically verifiable and should be considered a philosophical notion.

Critics of the multiverse theory suggest it undermines the ability to find rational explanations for the values of constants in our universe.

Evidence from the Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe and Planck satellite did not find statistically significant evidence of universe collisions.

Quantum mechanics and general relativity need to be unified because at the Big Bang, the universe was the size of an atom, requiring both theories to describe it.

The concept of 'quantum foam' arises when applying quantum mechanics to the fabric of space-time at very small scales.

Max Tegmark classified multiverses into four levels, each with different implications for the nature of reality.

Level 1 multiverses are regions of space with the same physical laws as ours but different initial conditions.

Level 3 multiverses stem from the many-worlds interpretation of quantum mechanics, where all possible outcomes of quantum events actually occur.

Level 4 multiverses include all universes described by different mathematical structures, suggesting a comprehensive mathematical foundation for reality.

Brian Greene proposed nine types of multiverses, expanding on the theoretical frameworks for understanding the concept.

Transcripts

you believe this is the only universe there's  not just one universe there's a multiverse we  

think when i say we just the scientific community  physicists who concern themselves with the very  

early universe cosmologists that the laws of  physics as we experience them are set in the  

very earliest stages of the universe and quantum  fluctuations in everything would be responsible  

for another universe having slightly different  laws of physics than ours because the quantum  

fluctuations will taken in a slightly different  law of physics direction than our universe  

and this would just keep going every universe  that's born even if it started out sort of  

the same in the very first instant a later  instant when other laws of physics manifest  

could be slightly different [Music] the  concept of infinite worlds is a very old idea  

discussed in the philosophy of ancient  greek atomism which states that the  

physical world is composed of fundamental  indivisible components known as atoms  

ancient philosophers proposed that infinite  parallel worlds arose from the collision of atoms  

in the 3rd century bc philosopher chrysippus  suggested that the world eternally expired and  

regenerated effectively suggesting the existence  of multiple universes across time however the  

concept of multiple universes has reached  maturity only in the time of modern physics  

in dublin in 1952 erwin schrodinger gave a lecture  in which he warned his audience that what he was  

about to say might seem lunatic he said that  when his equations seemed to describe several  

different histories these were not alternatives  but all really happened simultaneously this  

sort of duality is called superposition  which is a hard concept to grasp in and  

of itself and understandably so our brains are not  evolutionarily equipped to intuitively understand  

quantum mechanics and large-scale cosmic phenomena  but we'll give it a try anyway with the multiverse  

where there could be pockets of the universe  that are expanding with no knowledge of any other  

pockets of the universe these are essentially  independent universes from one another and never  

the twain will meet imagine you're a ship at sea  and you look to the horizon and that's your whole  

universe there to the horizon there's another ship  that has its own horizon and these ships don't  

even see each other you'll only see each other  if somehow your two horizons can overlap and we  

don't know how to do that in our universe because  they're non-causal you'd have to find some way to  

tunnel from one universe to the other in order  to access that but that could be very dangerous  

because if the laws of physics are different  than the ones you evolved on then you could  

just dissolve into a pile of goo because the  charge on the electron is different and all of  

your biochemistry would change the multiverse  is a hypothetical group of multiple universes  

together these universes comprise everything that  exists the entirety of space time matter energy  

information and the physical laws  and constants that describe them  

the different universes within the multiverse are  called parallel universes alternate universes or  

many worlds in pop culture they are known  as parallel dimensions quantum realities  

alternate realities etc the physics community has  debated the various multiverse theories over time  

prominent physicists are divided about whether  other universes exist outside of our own some  

physicists say the multiverse is not a legitimate  topic of scientific inquiry concerns have been  

raised about whether attempts to exempt the  multiverse from experimental verification  

could erode public confidence in science and  ultimately damage the study of fundamental physics  

some have argued that the multiverse is a  philosophical notion rather than a scientific  

hypothesis because it cannot be empirically  falsified the ability to disprove a theory  

by means of scientific experiment has always  been part of the accepted scientific method  

nobel laureate steve weinberg suggested  that if the multiverse existed the hope  

of finding a rational explanation for the  precise values of quark masses and other  

constants of the standard model that we observe  in our big bang is doomed for their values  

would be an accident of the particular  part of the multiverse in which we live  

there could be a universe where the laws  of physics there will never allow matter  

to coalesce you'll never get stars that would  be a lifeless universe there could be another  

universe where you can make stars but you don't  make heavy elements that would be a universe with  

stars beautiful night skies as we have now but  nothing that we know and love no planets no life

some scientists analyzed the data from  the wilkinson microwave anisotropy probe  

an uncrewed spacecraft operating from  2001 to 2010 that measured temperature  

differences across the sky in cosmic microwave  background the radiant heat emitted from the  

big bang and claimed they found evidence  suggesting that our universe collided with  

other parallel universes in the distant past  however a more thorough data analysis from the  

wilkinson microwave anisotropy probe and from the  planet satellite a space observatory operated by  

the european space agency from 2009 to 2013  which mapped the anisotropies of the cosmic  

microwave background did not find any statistical  significant evidence of universe collisions  

there was no evidence of any gravitational  pull of other universes on ours either  

and to add insult to injury to the proponents that  the multiverse hypothesis has been backed up by  

statistical evidence the planck satellite has a  resolution three times higher than the wma probe  

in the 1920s quantum mechanics was invented  discovered however you want to think scientific  

advances take place quantum mechanics is the  study of the small how particles behave and we  

learned that if you get to a small enough scale  you lose the ability to predict with precision  

the behavior of the system you can only describe  it statistically and there are ranges of things  

it can do and all you can describe is the range  of properties that it may have well here's this  

big grand universe we have described by einstein's  general theory of relativity but at the big bang  

the entire universe was the size of an atom and so  you have the need to have the physics of the small  

quantum mechanics marry the physics of the large  general relativity because they're occupying the  

same space now when you take quantum mechanics and  apply it to aspects of the fabric of space on that  

scale what you have is a gurgling of the fabric of  space-time in fact it's been called a quantum foam  

and so now when you look at this foam applying the  laws of quantum mechanics to it you realize that  

this fabric is not limited to one zone or another  in fact there's a region of the fabric that could  

hatch out an entire universe with a variations in  the laws of physics simply because the conditions  

that would spawn the laws of physics had  variation in them and so the multiverse  

is not just some invention out of the ether it  flows out of an application of quantum mechanics  

to general relativity prominent scientists such  as max tegmark and brian greene have devised  

classification schemes for the various theoretical  types of multiverses and universes that they might  

compromise max tegmark has provided a taxonomy  of four levels of universe beyond the familiar  

observable universe level one is an extension  of our universe a prediction of cosmic inflation  

is the existence of an infinite ergotic universe  which being infinite must contain hubble volumes  

realizing all initial conditions level 2 are  universes with different physical constants  

in the internal inflation theory the multiverse or  space as a whole is stretching and will continue  

doing so forever but some regions of space stop  stretching and form distinct bubbles that are  

embryonic level 1 multiverses level 3 is the  many worlds interpretation of quantum mechanics  

one aspect of quantum mechanics is that certain  observations cannot be predicted absolutely  

instead there is a range of possible observations  each with a different probability according to the  

mini world's interpretation each of these possible  observations corresponds to a different universe  

level 4 is an ultimate ensemble the ultimate  mathematical universe hypothesis is tegmark's  

own hypothesis this level considers all universes  to be equally real which can be described by  

different mathematical structures tegmark remarks  that abstract mathematics is so general that  

any theory of everything which is definable in  purely formal terms independent of vague human  

terminology is also a mathematical structure he  argues this implies that any conceivable parallel  

universe theory can be described at level four and  subsumes all other ensembles therefore this level  

brings closure to the hierarchy of multiverses  and there cannot be a level 5. the american  

theoretical physicist brian greene discussed  nine types of multiverses but we will discuss  

them in another video enough head scratching for  today thanks for watching did you like this video  

then show your support by liking subscribing and  ringing the bell to never miss videos like this

[Music]  

you