Lagi-Lagi, Salah Tangkap! | Explained

Summary

This video highlights the recurring issue of mistaken arrests and police violence in Indonesia. It covers historical and recent cases, such as the wrongful conviction of Sengkon and Karta in 1974 and the 2013 Cipulir buskers' case, illustrating the devastating impact on victims. Additionally, it discusses the disturbing trend of torture during police investigations, such as the tragic case of Dulqosim. The video also critiques systemic issues within law enforcement, including procedural violations, pressure on investigators, and the lack of effective supervision mechanisms, urging for reforms to ensure justice and human rights protection.

Takeaways

• 😀 Mistaken arrests by the police have been a recurring issue, with multiple cases documented between 2023 and 2024.
• 😀 A notable case of mistaken arrest occurred in 1974 involving Sengkon and Karta, who were wrongfully convicted of a murder they did not commit.
• 😀 In 2013, six buskers in Jakarta were mistakenly arrested for a murder they did not commit and were detained for over a month before being acquitted.
• 😀 Pegi Setiawan was recently arrested for the murder of Eki and Vina, but after filing a pretrial motion, he was released when his innocence was proven.
• 😀 Torture during police investigations has been widely reported, with at least 40 documented cases between June 2023 and May 2024.
• 😀 The Dulqosim case highlights extreme torture by the police, where the victim was beaten and left dead after being wrongfully detained on suspicion of drug delivery.
• 😀 Excessive use of force and failure to follow police procedure are common issues behind wrongful arrests and torture cases in Indonesia.
• 😀 The police's large workload, rush to make arrests, and non-compliance with proper investigation procedures contribute to frequent wrongful arrests.
• 😀 The lack of oversight mechanisms within the Indonesian police system has led to continued violations, such as wrongful arrests and torture.
• 😀 Civil society groups are calling for public participation in discussions about the National Police Bill to improve police accountability and supervision.

Q & A

What is the main issue discussed in the transcript?

The transcript primarily discusses incidents of mistaken arrests and police torture, focusing on multiple cases where individuals were wrongfully arrested and subjected to abuse by law enforcement. It also highlights systemic issues in the police force related to procedural violations, haste, and lack of proper supervision.

What historical case is mentioned in the transcript as an example of mistaken arrest?

A historical case from 1974 involving Sengkon and Karta is mentioned. They were wrongfully accused of robbing and killing a married couple, leading to their wrongful imprisonment. They were later released after another person admitted to the crime.

What was the outcome of the case involving six buskers in South Jakarta in 2013?

In the 2013 case, six buskers were mistakenly arrested and wrongfully imprisoned for the murder of a fellow busker. After being coerced into admitting guilt, they were later acquitted by the DKI Jakarta High Court and the Supreme Court, with their sentences overturned.

What was the situation with Pegi Setiawan's arrest in 2024?

Pegi Setiawan was wrongfully arrested in May 2024, suspected of being involved in the murder of two individuals. He was detained for a month before filing a pretrial motion, which was granted, and he was released in July 2024 after being found innocent.

What are some of the common issues contributing to wrongful arrests mentioned in the transcript?

The transcript cites non-compliance with procedures, haste in making arrests, and heavy workloads as contributing factors to wrongful arrests. Police officers may rush to make arrests without properly studying the evidence or clues.

How many cases of torture were recorded by Contrast between June 2023 and May 2024?

Contrast recorded 40 cases of torture by police officers between June 2023 and May 2024.

Can you provide an example of a torture case mentioned in the transcript?

An example is the case of Dulqosim, who was tortured during an investigation and later found dead. The police attempted to cover up the death by staging it as an accident. Dulqosim had sustained multiple injuries due to the torture, which was inconsistent with police regulations on the use of force.

What violations of police regulations are highlighted in Dulqosim's case?

Dulqosim's case violated the six principles of the use of force, including proportionality, which emphasizes the balance between the level of threat and police response. The excessive violence caused serious injuries and led to his death, which was not in line with proper police conduct.

What is the stance of civil society groups on the police reforms discussed in the transcript?

Civil society groups argue that the National Police Bill should include public participation and emphasize the role of the Police Code of Ethics Commission and the National Police Commission in supervising police officers. They call for greater accountability and professionalism within the police force.

What are the perceived shortcomings in the Indonesian police law, according to the transcript?

The transcript notes that the Indonesian police law does not explicitly regulate the supervision mechanism for police institutions, nor does it adequately emphasize the role of oversight bodies like the Police Code of Ethics Commission and the National Police Commission. This leads to ineffective supervision and minimal deterrence for police officers committing violations.