Wacana Sekolah Libur Sebulan Saat Ramadhan, Apa Tanggapan Masyarakat?

Summary

The video discusses the government's proposal to grant a one-month school holiday during Ramadan. This idea is inspired by a similar policy from President Gus Dur's era. The plan has generated mixed reactions from the public. Some parents support it due to reduced costs, while others are concerned that a full month of vacation might cause children to forget lessons. The video also includes insights from various individuals, including parents and community members, who suggest alternatives like combining shorter breaks or encouraging religious activities at home to balance education and spiritual focus.

Takeaways

• 😀 The Indonesian government has proposed a school holiday for one month during the Ramadan period.
• 😀 This idea was previously implemented during President Gus Dur's administration, allowing students a full month off for fasting.
• 😀 The Coordinating Minister for Human Development and Culture, Pratikno, has met with the Minister of Education to discuss this proposal for this year's Ramadan.
• 😀 Some parents are supportive of the idea, as it could reduce their household expenses during Ramadan.
• 😀 However, some parents are concerned that a full month without school could lead to children forgetting their lessons.
• 😀 There is a potential benefit where children could focus more on fasting during Ramadan, allowing for a deeper spiritual connection.
• 😀 One parent expressed concern that a full month off might disrupt the children’s learning schedule, and suggested shortening the break.
• 😀 Another parent proposed splitting the month off, with a break before and after Ramadan, to allow for a two-week learning period during the month.
• 😀 Some parents believe that the break could help children focus on their religious activities and deepen their engagement with Ramadan, such as attending prayers and learning at mosques.
• 😀 Another concern raised was that without school activities, children may end up spending more time on their phones, potentially wasting the free time.

Q & A

What is the main topic of discussion in the video?

The video discusses the government's plan to implement a one-month school holiday during Ramadan, and the public's reactions to this proposal.

Who is the Deputy Minister of Religion mentioned in the video, and what role does he play in the discussion?

The Deputy Minister of Religion mentioned is Romo Muhammad SII, who acknowledges the idea of a one-month school holiday, citing that it was implemented during the presidency of Gus Dur.

What are the concerns of parents regarding the one-month school holiday?

Parents are concerned that a one-month holiday could cause their children to forget what they have learned, as they may not be engaged in academic activities during that period.

What positive aspect of the one-month school holiday is mentioned by parents?

Parents recognize that the holiday may allow children to focus more on Ramadan and engage more deeply in religious practices, such as fasting.

How does one parent feel about the idea of children having a one-month school holiday?

One parent expresses mixed feelings—agreeing that it could reduce household expenses but also concerned that children might forget lessons due to the extended break.

What alternative school holiday schedule does another parent suggest?

One parent suggests that the holiday be divided into two parts: one week before Ramadan and one week before Eid, so that children would only miss two weeks of school rather than a full month.

What does another parent suggest as an alternative to a full month of holiday?

Another parent suggests that children should still be engaged in activities, such as religious activities like attending mosques or participating in study groups, to make productive use of the time at home.

What is the main concern about children potentially forgetting what they have learned during the school holiday?

The main concern is that a one-month break could cause children to lose focus on their lessons, and their retention of academic material may decline as a result.

How do some parents suggest balancing the holiday with academic learning?

Some parents propose that while children are on holiday, they should still engage in light learning activities at home to avoid a complete break from education.

What does the video suggest as a possible solution to prevent children from falling behind in their studies?

The video suggests that if the holiday is implemented, it should be accompanied by supplementary learning activities, perhaps under the guidance of parents or through home-based educational programs.