What is Dollar Cost Averaging? (And why it's GARBAGE!)

Summary

The video script from 'The Dividend Experiment' channel emphasizes the challenges of market timing and introduces dollar cost averaging as a prudent long-term investment strategy. It explains how this method mitigates risks by investing fixed amounts regularly, regardless of market fluctuations, and highlights its benefits like avoiding emotional decisions and reducing the impact of bad timing. However, it also points out the limitations, such as potentially missing out on higher returns during bull markets. The host shares personal insights, suggesting that for individual stocks and index funds, lump sum investing might be more effective, and concludes by offering a free guide on dividend investing principles.

Takeaways

• 📈 Dollar cost averaging is a strategy that helps navigate unpredictable markets by automating regular investments, regardless of market conditions.
• ⚠️ Timing the market is risky and often a losing strategy due to the unpredictability of market movements influenced by economic indicators and global events.
• 🧠 Emotional reactions play a big role in short-term market changes, and trying to predict these reactions is challenging.
• 💸 Dollar cost averaging spreads out investments over time, reducing the impact of market volatility and minimizing emotional decision-making.
• 🛡️ This strategy avoids the pitfalls of investing a large sum at the wrong time and helps investors stay disciplined.
• 📉 A downside of dollar cost averaging is that it may result in lower returns compared to lump sum investing when markets generally rise.
• 🔍 Dollar cost averaging does not eliminate the need for thorough research and choosing sound investments.
• 🏖️ This method can be beneficial for investors who prefer a safer, less risky approach and those who find it emotionally easier to invest gradually.
• 💡 While dollar cost averaging offers emotional benefits, it might not be as financially advantageous as lump sum investing, especially for individual stocks and ETFs.
• 🎁 The video offers a free PDF Guide to the 10 dividend investing commandments, providing criteria for picking dividend-paying stocks, along with other benefits for joining the email list.

Q & A

What is the main purpose of the content discussed in the video?

The content is intended for information and educational purposes only and should not be considered investment advice or investment recommendation.

What is dollar cost averaging (DCA) and how does it help investors?

Dollar cost averaging is a strategy where an investor regularly invests a fixed amount of money, regardless of market conditions. It helps investors stay calm during market fluctuations and encourages consistent investment, leading to a more stable average cost of shares over time.

Why is trying to time the market considered risky?

Timing the market is risky because predicting short-term market movements is difficult due to the influence of numerous factors like economic indicators and global events. Emotional reactions also play a significant role, making it hard to consistently make accurate predictions.

What are the pros of dollar cost averaging?

The pros include avoiding emotional investment decisions, minimizing the impact of bad timing, reducing the effects of market volatility, and providing a structured, less risky approach to investing.

What are the cons of dollar cost averaging?

The cons include the potential for lower returns compared to lump-sum investing in a rising market, the need for sound investment choices, and the possibility of consistently investing in a poorly performing asset.

How does dollar cost averaging reduce investment risk?

Dollar cost averaging reduces risk by spreading out the purchase prices of investments over time, making it less dependent on market timing and providing a safety net against market volatility.

What is the recommended approach when dealing with a sudden windfall?

Investing gradually using dollar cost averaging is recommended when dealing with a windfall to minimize volatility and emotional stress associated with investing a large sum all at once.

Why might some investors prefer lump-sum investing over dollar cost averaging?

Some investors might prefer lump-sum investing because markets generally rise over time, and investing a large sum early on can result in higher returns compared to spreading investments over an extended period.

How does dollar cost averaging align with long-term investment principles?

Dollar cost averaging aligns with long-term investment principles by promoting disciplined, regular investing, which helps investors ride out market ups and downs and avoid emotional decisions.

What are the emotional benefits of dollar cost averaging?

The emotional benefits include reducing stress by not having to time the market, making it easier to stick to a consistent investment plan, and providing a structured approach that can help manage the mental challenges of investing.

Outlines

00:00

📈 Understanding Dollar Cost Averaging

The video opens with a welcome and a disclaimer that the content is for educational purposes and not investment advice. It discusses the challenges of timing the market, explaining that dollar cost averaging (DCA) is a smart strategy that involves regularly investing a fixed amount of money regardless of market conditions. This method helps mitigate risks, reduces the emotional impact of market fluctuations, and avoids the pitfalls of trying to time the market.

05:02

💡 The Pros and Cons of Dollar Cost Averaging

The second paragraph delves into the pros and cons of DCA. It highlights that DCA avoids emotional decision-making and reduces the impact of bad timing by spreading investments over time. However, it notes that since markets generally rise over time, lump sum investing can sometimes yield better returns. Additionally, DCA doesn't eliminate the need for thorough investment research and is not a replacement for finding sound investments.

10:03

🛡️ Reducing Risk and Investing Windfalls with DCA

This section explains how DCA can be used to reduce risk, especially for conservative investors. It spreads out investment purchases, making it easier to manage emotionally and reducing the impact of market volatility. The paragraph also discusses how DCA can help when investing windfalls, allowing for gradual investment and reducing the stress of market timing.

📊 Comparing DCA with Lump Sum Investing

The fourth paragraph compares DCA with lump sum investing, particularly for individual stocks and index funds. It argues that for individual stocks, lump sum investing may be more logical if the investor believes the stock is undervalued. For ETFs and index funds, while DCA makes sense, lump sum investing often outperforms due to the general upward trend of markets. The section concludes by referencing a study showing that lump sum investing is statistically more advantageous than DCA.

🎁 Free Guide to Dividend Investing

The final paragraph offers viewers a free PDF guide to the 10 dividend investing commandments. By submitting their email, viewers can receive the guide and other benefits, such as updates on dividend portfolios, stock ideas, and special deals. The video ends with a thank you to the viewers and an invitation to watch the next video.

Keywords

💡Dollar Cost Averaging

Dollar Cost Averaging (DCA) is an investment strategy where an investor divides up the total amount to be invested across periodic purchases of a target asset in order to reduce the impact of volatility on the overall purchase. It is used as a way to manage risk and avoid the pitfalls of market timing. The video discusses how DCA helps investors stay calm during market fluctuations by automatically purchasing investments at regular intervals, which averages out the cost over time.

💡Market Timing

Market timing involves making buy or sell decisions of financial assets by attempting to predict future market price movements. The video emphasizes the risks associated with market timing, noting that it is often unsuccessful due to the unpredictability of market movements and external influences like economic indicators and global events. The video advocates for the DCA strategy as a safer alternative to avoid the pitfalls of market timing.

💡Emotional Reactions

Emotional reactions refer to the investor's tendency to make investment decisions based on emotions rather than logic or strategy, often leading to poor outcomes. The video explains that DCA can help mitigate the negative impact of emotional reactions by establishing a routine of regular investments, thereby reducing the temptation to make rash decisions based on short-term market movements.

💡Long-term Approach

A long-term approach in investing means focusing on holding investments for an extended period, typically years or decades, rather than trying to capitalize on short-term market movements. The video highlights that a long-term approach has historically been more successful because it allows investors to ride out market volatility and benefit from the overall upward trend of markets over time.

💡Market Volatility

Market volatility refers to the frequency and extent of price fluctuations in the financial markets. The video discusses how market volatility can make it difficult to predict short-term price movements and how DCA helps investors navigate this volatility by spreading out their investments over time, reducing the risk of making poorly timed purchases or sales.

💡Efficient Market Hypothesis

The Efficient Market Hypothesis (EMH) is the theory that asset prices fully reflect all available information, making it impossible to consistently achieve higher returns through market timing or stock picking. The video mentions EMH to underscore the difficulty of identifying undervalued or overvalued assets, reinforcing the idea that DCA is a practical strategy in such an environment.

💡Investing Windfalls

Investing windfalls refers to the strategy of gradually investing a large sum of money received unexpectedly, such as an inheritance or lottery winnings, rather than investing it all at once. The video suggests that investing windfalls gradually can help minimize the emotional impact of market volatility and reduce the risk of investing at an inopportune time.

💡Lump Sum Investing

Lump sum investing involves investing the entire amount of available funds at one time, as opposed to spreading the investment over a period. The video compares lump sum investing with DCA, stating that while lump sum investing can potentially yield higher returns in rising markets, it also carries higher risk if the market drops shortly after the investment is made.

💡Investment Strategy

An investment strategy is a set plan designed to help an investor achieve their financial goals. The video focuses on different investment strategies, primarily DCA, and discusses their pros and cons. It emphasizes that while DCA is not a magic solution, it is a disciplined approach that can help manage risk and reduce the emotional stress of investing.

💡Risk Management

Risk management in investing involves identifying, assessing, and prioritizing risks followed by coordinated efforts to minimize, monitor, and control the probability or impact of unfortunate events. The video explains how DCA can be an effective risk management tool by spreading out investments over time, thereby reducing the impact of market volatility and poor timing.

Highlights

Introduction to the channel and its purpose: building a portfolio that pays your bills.

Content disclaimer: information and educational purposes only, not investment advice.

Challenges of timing the market and the risks involved in trying to catch the best deals.

Explanation of dollar cost averaging (DCA) and how it helps navigate unpredictable markets.

Financial experts' consensus on the difficulty and risks of market timing.

The role of emotional reactions and the Efficient Market Hypothesis in making market timing difficult.

The benefits of a long-term investment approach and the drawbacks of frequent buying and selling.

Definition of dollar cost averaging and how it stabilizes the average cost of shares over time.

Pros of DCA: avoiding emotional decisions and minimizing the impact of bad timing.

Cons of DCA: potential for lower returns due to market values generally increasing over time.

Emphasis on the need to choose sound investments and conduct thorough research, even with DCA.

DCA as a risk management strategy and its effectiveness in reducing the impact of market volatility.

The psychological and practical benefits of investing windfalls gradually using DCA.

Conclusion on the emotional versus practical benefits of DCA, with a personal perspective on its use.

Invitation to download a free PDF guide to the 10 dividend investing commandments by subscribing via email.

Transcripts

hello and welcome back to the dividend

experiment the channel that helps you

build a portfolio that pays your bills

the content that'll be discussed is

intended for information and educational

purposes only and should not be

considered investment advice or

investment recommendation investing can

be tough especially for those who try to

time the market for the best deals and

sometimes miss out dollar cost or in

most of our case pound cost averaging is

a smart strategy that helps navigate

unpredictable markets by automating

purchases it also encourages investors

to stick to a routine of investing

regularly timing the market is risky the

general consensus in financial circles

is that trying to time the market is

risky and often ends up being a losing

strategy perhaps you can time the

perfect time to buy into a stock but

that's still leaves needing to sell at

the right time too over the course of

time doing this consistently proves to

be very difficult Financial experts

caution against this for several reasons

that are easy to understand first

predicting short-term movements in the

market is tough because because it's

influenced by many things like economic

indicators and Global events the

efficient market hypothesis adds another

layer suggesting that asset prices

already include all available

information making it hard to

consistently spot undervalued or

overvalued assets emotional reactions

play a big role in short-term Market

changes and trying to time the market

involves making decisions based on

predicting how others will act which can

obviously be unpredictable on top of

that frequent Panic buying and selling

assets can lead to extra costs and taxes

eating into your overall returns taking

a long-term approach has historically

been more successful as it helps you

ride out the ups and the Downs trying to

time the market consistently is tough

for even experienced professionals and

doing so might cause you to miss out on

opportunities for potential gains if

you're waiting for the perfect moment to

jump here in or out so this leads to the

Natural solution dollar cost averaging

so what is dollar cost averaging dollar

cost averaging is like putting your

money on a roller coast to ride but in a

smart and steady way instead of trying

to time when when to invest based on the

ups and downs of the market maret with

dollar cost averaging you decide to

invest a fixed amount of money regularly

say every month no matter what's

happening with the price of stocks or

other Investments this strategy helps

you stay calm when markets get

crazy and here's why when prices are

high your fixed amount buys fewer shares

and when prices are low it buys more

shares this way over time the average

cost of all your shares becomes more

stable dollar cost averaging takes the

stress out of trying to predict the

perfect moment to invest it's like

setting up a little savings plan for

yourself

plus while you're buying a bit at a time

you're less likely to make rash

decisions based on emotions which can be

a real challenge in the world of

investing anyone can doll cost average

into their Investments whether you have

a lot or a little money to invest it's a

straightforward and accessible way to

get into the investing game but keep in

mind while dollar cost averaging is a

sensible strategy for long-term

investors it's not a magic technique

that will guarantee you make a profit

always consider what's happening in the

market any fees you might pay and how

taxes might play a role when you decide

to give dollar cost averaging a try the

pros and cons of dollar cost averaging

although this method can assist in Risk

Management the likelihood of achieving

exceptionally High returns is lower

evaluating the pros and cons of dollar

cost averaging can Aid investors in

deciding whether it aligns with their

investment strategy the pros are that it

avoids emotional decisions so using

dollar cost averaging means you invest

the same amount regularly regardless of

how the price goes up and down this way

you don't let your feelings guide your

investment choices even if the price

suddenly drops you stick to your plan

and you see as a chance to get more

shares at a lower cost it minimizes the

impact of bad timing putting all your

money into a single asset once comes

with the risk of investing just before

the market takes a downturn for example

if you'd invested right before the 2007

Market downturn you would have faced

more significant losses compared to

investing only a portion of your money

earlier on the flip side this approach

also means you might not catch the

opportunity to invest a substantial

amount just before the market starts

rising in a bull market however since

accurately timing the market is

difficult dollar cost averaging emerges

as a practical strategy reducing the

impact of Market volatility the cons are

that the market values generally

increase over time one drawback of

dollar cost averaging is that since

markets tend to rise generally speaking

investing a large sum earlier often

performs better than spreading a small

amounts over an extended period for

instance consider what happens after

investing $5,000 all at once in a stock

that annually increases by about 10% at

the start of a 10-year period this would

be financially more advantageous than

investing the same out gradually over

time such as $500 per year dollar cost

averaging is not a replacement for

finding sound Investments dollar cost

averaging doesn't eliminate all

investment risks even if you choose the

passive approach of dollar cost

averaging you still need to pinpoint

good Investments and conduct thorough

research if the asset you choose turns

out to be a poor investment you'll

consistently invest in a losing Venture

essentially just dollar cost averaging

down by following a passive strategy you

won't react to Market ups and downs

whether they're positive or negative as

the investment landscape evolves you may

come across new information about an

investment that prompts you to

reconsider your approach reducing risk

with dollar cost averaging dollar cost

averaging can also be used if you're a

type of investor who doesn't like risky

Investments it spreads out the prices

which you buy your Investments making

things less risky since none of us can

see into the future using dollar cost

averaging is a safer bet because it

doesn't depend on guessing what the

stock market will do it's a bit like

having a safety net that protects you

from the ups and downs of the market

making your investment Journey a bit

smoother and less uncertain investing

windfalls when you suddenly come into a

big chunk of money like an unexpected

windfall it's an emotionally easier move

to invest it gradually rather than all

at once this helps minimize the

volatility that comes with the ups and

downs of the market instead of putting

everything in at a single moment you

spread out your Investments over time

this way you're not trying to guess the

perfect time to invest and it provides a

more stable and less risky path to grow

your money it's tough to see your money

fall only days after you put the money

into the stock market it's a lot easier

to manage mentally if you only invested

a little bit of the total sum initially

and still have more to add as time goes

on on top of the mental benefits with

dollar cost averaging you can set up a

plan for regular contributions and then

pretty much forget about it once it's

all set your Investments grow without

needing constant attention this approach

frees up your time and lets you

concentrate on other parts of your life

while your money keeps working for you

in the background it's like putting your

finances on autopilot making things more

convenient and allowing you to pursue

other interests without worrying about

the day-to-day of your

Investments is dollar cost averaging a

wise strategy yes it can be beneficial

but most of the benefits in my opinion

and more on the emotional side rather

than the Practical Finance side so why

don't I do it in my opinion if you're

investing in individual stocks dollar

cost averaging doesn't make sense and

then if you're investing in index funds

or ETFs then lumpsum investing is

technically a better strategy

historically and let me explain what I

mean so for individual stocks when you

buy an individual stock you're making a

statement about its price versus its

value by buying the stock you're saying

that you think the current price is

necessarily below its current value just

like when you buy anything you believe

you're getting something of more value

than you believe your money is worth of

course this is true cuz otherwise you

would keep the money or buy something

else instead so what's the purpose of

deliberately holding back money that you

think is less valuable than the stock

you're looking at you might believe that

there's a risk that the price will go

down lower than it currently is and want

to hold off just in case a better way to

think about this is make a plan to

decide how much you want to own of it

and then try to accumulate to that level

rather than thinking whether now is the

optimum time to buy or whether to hold

off it could go up in the opposite

direction and then you're averaging up

instead personally I think it's better

to think in terms of buying what you

want to own if you have money and you

think the price is good then buy don't

regret it afterwards as you now own

something that you wanted there are

going to be a million could have should

have and would have in life so as long

as you're following your plan or

strategy the short-term drop in prices

doesn't need to bother you that you

timed it wrong as such and what about

for ETFs or index funds now ETFs are

harder to Value as there's many

components and some will be up some will

be down so I think buying in increments

over time makes sense however I don't

Advocate leaving cash that you would

want to invest lying around just for the

sake of dollar cost averaging just lump

sum the amount you want to invest

shortly after you get paid from a blog

post written by Nick muli he writes this

question comes up a lot when we're

chatting with clients I understand the

fear they may have around investing this

money and there's a lot at stake

hundreds of thousands maybe millions of

dollars what if the market crashes right

after you invest wouldn't it be better

to average in over time to smooth out

any unlucky timing on your part

statistically the answer is no in a

paper from 2016 Vanguard found that 68%

of the time it's better to invest your

money right away rather than buying in

over 12 months the main reason that

lumpsum outperforms dollar cost

averaging is because most markets

generally rise over time because of this

positive long-term Trend dollar cost

averaging typically buys at higher

average prices than lumpsum additionally

in those rare instances where dollar

cost averaging does outperform lumpsum

I.E in Falling markets it's difficult to

stick with dollar cost averaging so the

times where dollar cost averaging has

the largest Advantage are also the times

when it can be the hardest for investors

to stick to their plan that means

statistically dollar cost averaging I

holding money aside to invest later is a

losing proposition so while it may have

some emotional benefit to doing it this

way and you feel better about doing it

that way it usually is going to end up

worse off for your finances well that's

just my thoughts on it anyway you're of

course welcome to disagree and invest

whichever way suits you this isn't

financial advice after all in conclusion

attempting to time the market is a

challenging task even for seasoned

professionals and it often proves to be

an unreliable strategy the

unpredictability of Market movements and

the multitude of factors influencing

them makes it difficult to consistently

make accurate predictions while there

are no guarantees in investing dollar

cost averaging aligns with the principle

of discipline long-term investing making

it compelling choice for those seeking a

reliable strategy to navigate the

complexities of the financial markets

though at at a higher level it may not

be as great as it may first seem if you

lik this video and if you made it this

far I'm guessing you probably did then I

have some good news for you I'm giving

away my PDF Guide to the 10 dividend

investing Commandments or the criteria

that I use to pick dividend paying

stocks and I'm giving it away to you for

free all you need to do is submit your

email in the link below and you'll get

delivered to your inbox straight away

again that's for free but that's not the

only benefit of joining the email you

also get updates on the almost daily

dividend portfolio interesting stock

ideas or news and special deals and free

stuff that I can share with you thanks

for watching and I hope to see you on

the next video see

you