KELTY REDWING 44 vs OSPREY PORTER 46

Summary

This video compares the Osprey Porter 46 and the Kelty Red Wing 44 backpacks, highlighting their features and drawbacks for travelers. The presenter prefers the Kelty for its comfort, better loading system, and more compact design, while the Osprey is noted for its ample compartments and laptop sleeve. Both bags offer unique advantages, but the Kelty's ability to contour to the back and overall functionality make it the superior choice for efficient travel. The video encourages viewers to consider carry-on backpacks over traditional roller bags for convenience.

Takeaways

• 😀 The Osprey Porter 46 and Kelty Red Wing 44 are compared as alternatives to traditional checked bags and roller carry-ons.
• 🎒 The Osprey Porter 46 offers a well-padded interior and multiple compartments for organization, including a dedicated laptop sleeve.
• ⚖️ The Kelty Red Wing 44 is noted for its comfort and contoured fit, making it ideal for longer wear.
• 📦 Both backpacks have the capacity to carry more than a standard roller bag, making them efficient travel options.
• 🧳 The Osprey features stowaway straps that reduce bulk when not in use, while the Kelty remains compact when empty.
• 💧 The Kelty includes side pockets for water bottles and quick-access items, unlike the Osprey which lacks this feature.
• 🛫 The Osprey has high-quality zippers and a well-made construction, ensuring durability during travel.
• 🔒 The Osprey's compartments have lockable zippers for added security, while the Kelty requires DIY solutions for similar functionality.
• 👖 Packing demonstrations highlight the efficient use of space in both bags, showing their ability to hold clothing and essentials.
• 📅 The Kelty is recommended for its overall comfort and adaptability, having been tested for three and a half months without issues.

Q & A

What is the main purpose of comparing the Osprey Porter 46 and Kelty Red Wing 44 backpacks?

The comparison aims to highlight the advantages of using carry-on backpacks over traditional checked bags and roller carry-ons, showcasing the practicality and storage capabilities of these backpacks.

What are some notable features of the Osprey Porter 46 backpack?

The Osprey Porter 46 features stowaway straps, a well-padded laptop sleeve for easy access, multiple compartments for organization, and durable construction with high-quality zippers.

What are the drawbacks of the Osprey Porter 46 as mentioned in the transcript?

The drawbacks include its bulkiness, a soft back that doesn't conform well to the wearer's back, and limited side pockets compared to the Kelty Red Wing 44.

How does the Kelty Red Wing 44 differ in terms of comfort compared to the Osprey Porter 46?

The Kelty Red Wing 44 is designed to contour to the wearer's back, providing better comfort with well-padded waist straps, while the Osprey Porter 46 tends to be bulkier and less comfortable during extended wear.

What is a unique packing feature of the Kelty Red Wing 44?

The Kelty Red Wing 44 has a top-loading capability, which allows for easier packing and access to items stored at the top of the bag.

What advantages does the Kelty Red Wing 44 offer in terms of organization?

While it has fewer internal compartments than the Osprey, the Kelty Red Wing 44 offers multiple side pockets for water bottles and quick-access items, enhancing its overall organization.

What travel experiences does the speaker mention regarding the Kelty Red Wing 44?

The speaker notes using the Kelty Red Wing 44 for three and a half months of travel without any issues, highlighting its durability and comfort during various trips.

How does the speaker suggest using the Osprey Porter 30 in conjunction with the Kelty Red Wing 44?

The speaker plans to use the Osprey Porter 30 as a personal item alongside the Kelty Red Wing 44, allowing for efficient organization of camera gear, clothing, and other essentials.

What overall recommendation does the speaker make regarding carry-on backpacks?

The speaker strongly recommends using a carry-on backpack like the Kelty Red Wing 44, emphasizing the benefits of reducing reliance on checked luggage and roller bags for a more convenient travel experience.

What is the significance of the speaker mentioning the packing process for both backpacks?

The packing process illustrates the functional differences and storage capabilities of each backpack, helping potential buyers understand how each bag can accommodate various travel needs.