Wizard of Oz Method in UX

Summary

The Wizard of Oz Method is a research technique where a human, or 'wizard,' controls system responses during user interface testing. It's useful for assessing interface utility before fully developing a technical solution. The method comes in closed and open variations, with the latter allowing real-time response creation by the wizard. A hybrid approach combines both, offering insights into system responses and user expectations. This cost-effective method provides valuable insights into user interactions with potential technologies.

Takeaways

• 🧙 The Wizard of Oz Method is a research technique where a human operator, or 'wizard', controls system responses during user interaction with an interface.
• 🎭 Named after the character in L. Frank Baum's 'The Wonderful Wizard of Oz', the method involves a facade of technology with a human behind the scenes.
• 🔍 It's used to assess the utility of an interface before investing in a full technical solution, providing insights into user interactions.
• 🔑 There are two main variations: the closed paradigm with pre-set responses, and the open paradigm where the wizard creates responses in real-time.
• 🤔 The open paradigm is particularly useful during the discovery phase to understand user mental models, expectations, and vocabulary.
• 🤝 A hybrid approach combines elements of both closed and open paradigms, using pre-set responses and creating new ones as needed.
• 🛠️ The method requires careful planning of tools, technology, and communication between the wizard and the user.
• 📈 It's an inexpensive way to experiment with and gain insights into technologies that might be costly to develop fully.
• 👨‍🏫 The wizard needs substantial knowledge of the product domain to effectively control the interface and respond to user actions.
• 📚 For closed or hybrid studies, a flowchart can be a helpful tool for the wizard to follow during the test.

Q & A

What is the Wizard of Oz Method?

The Wizard of Oz Method is a moderated research technique where a user interacts with an interface controlled by a human, who manages the system responses, simulating a fully functional system.

How does the name 'Wizard of Oz Method' originate?

The name is derived from L. Frank Baum's children's book 'The Wonderful Wizard of Oz,' where a giant head that appears to be a powerful wizard is actually an ordinary man manipulating levers behind a screen.

What is the purpose of conducting a Wizard of Oz test?

A Wizard of Oz test is useful for creators to assess the utility of an interface before investing in building a full technical solution, allowing them to gain insights into user interactions at a lower cost.

What are the two popular variations of the Wizard of Oz Method?

The two variations are the closed Wizard of Oz paradigm, where the wizard selects from a fixed set of system responses, and the open paradigm, where the wizard composes responses to user actions on the fly.

Why is substantial knowledge of the product domain necessary for the wizard in an open Wizard of Oz paradigm?

In the open paradigm, the wizard needs to have extensive knowledge of the product domain to effectively and accurately compose responses to user actions without pre-defined responses.

What is a hybrid Wizard of Oz paradigm and how does it work?

A hybrid paradigm combines elements of both closed and open Wizard of Oz methods. It uses a pre-existing set of system responses but allows the wizard to create new responses on the fly when no appropriate response exists.

How does the Wizard of Oz Method help in the discovery phase of a product?

During the discovery phase, the open or hybrid Wizard of Oz Method is used to understand user mental models, expectations, and vocabulary, which helps in shaping the product's development.

What preparations are needed for setting up a Wizard of Oz prototype study?

To set up a Wizard of Oz study, one must define the tools and technology for communication between the wizard and user, determine which technologies will be used, and create necessary hooks for the wizard to control the prototype.

What tools might be helpful for the wizard in a closed or hybrid Wizard of Oz study?

A flowchart can be a helpful tool for the wizard in closed or hybrid studies, as it provides a guide on how to respond to user actions based on the predefined system responses.

What are the benefits of using the Wizard of Oz Method?

The Wizard of Oz Method is an inexpensive way to gain valuable insights on technologies that might be costly to experiment with and build, making it a cost-effective approach for early-stage product testing.

Where can one find more resources on UX and register for UX courses as mentioned in the script?

Additional UX resources and courses can be found on the website nngroup.com, which offers a free library of articles and live, hands-on UX training courses.

Outlines

00:00

🧙‍♂️ The Wizard of Oz Method Explained

The Wizard of Oz Method is a moderated research technique where a user interacts with an interface that is controlled by a human, mimicking the system's responses. Named after L. Frank Baum's 'The Wonderful Wizard of Oz,' this method involves a facilitator who provides tasks to the participant while a 'wizard' remotely controls the interface. This method is useful for assessing the utility of an interface before investing in a full technical solution. It comes in two variations: the closed paradigm, where the wizard chooses from a set of predefined responses, and the open paradigm, where the wizard creates responses on the fly, requiring deep product domain knowledge. A hybrid approach combines elements of both. The method is cost-effective for gaining insights into technologies that are expensive to develop.

Keywords

💡Wizard of Oz Method

The Wizard of Oz Method is a research technique where a human, referred to as the 'wizard,' controls the responses of a system that a user interacts with, simulating a fully functional interface. This method is central to the video's theme, as it is used to assess the utility of an interface before investing in a full technical solution. The name is derived from L. Frank Baum's 'The Wonderful Wizard of Oz,' where a giant head appears to be a powerful wizard but is actually controlled by an ordinary man behind a curtain.

💡Moderation

In the context of the Wizard of Oz Method, moderation refers to the process of overseeing and controlling the interaction between the user and the system. The wizard, who is the moderator, decides how the system should respond to the user's actions, which is crucial for understanding user expectations and system usability. The video mentions that the wizard remotely controls the interface, highlighting the moderated nature of the method.

💡Prototype

A prototype in the video refers to an early model of the interface that is being tested. It is not a complete system but is designed to simulate the user experience. The Wizard of Oz Method is particularly useful for testing prototypes, as it allows for user interaction and feedback without the need for a fully developed technological solution.

💡Usability Test

A usability test is a method for evaluating a product or system by testing it with users. In the video, the Wizard of Oz Method is compared to a normal usability test, where the key difference is the presence of a wizard controlling the system responses. This comparison helps to illustrate the unique aspects of the Wizard of Oz Method in assessing user interaction.

💡Closed Wizard of Oz Paradigm

This refers to a variation of the Wizard of Oz Method where the wizard has a fixed set of system responses to choose from. These responses are predetermined, and the wizard selects the appropriate one based on the user's actions. The video explains that this paradigm is useful for testing a limited range of user interactions without the need for real-time response creation.

💡Open Wizard of Oz Paradigm

In the open paradigm, the wizard composes responses to user actions in real-time, without a predefined set of responses. This requires the wizard to have a deep understanding of the product domain to create relevant and timely responses. The video mentions that this variation is commonly used in the discovery phase to understand user mental models and expectations.

💡Hybrid Paradigm

A hybrid paradigm combines elements of both the closed and open Wizard of Oz methods. The wizard uses a pre-existing set of system responses but also has the ability to create new responses on the fly if none are suitable. This approach allows for testing of existing system responses while also exploring new possibilities, as discussed in the video.

💡Facilitator

A facilitator in the context of the Wizard of Oz Method is a person who guides the participant through the testing process. They provide prompts and tasks, similar to a normal usability test, but with the added complexity of a wizard controlling the system. The facilitator's role is crucial for ensuring that the user interaction is meaningful and directed towards the study's objectives.

💡Product Domain

The product domain refers to the specific area of knowledge or expertise related to the product being tested. In the video, it is mentioned that the wizard needs substantial knowledge of the product domain to effectively respond to user actions in an open or hybrid Wizard of Oz test. This knowledge is essential for creating realistic and relevant system responses.

💡Flowchart

A flowchart is a visual tool used to outline a process or system. In the context of the Wizard of Oz Method, especially in closed or hybrid studies, a flowchart can help the wizard navigate the predefined system responses and decide how to respond to user actions. The video suggests that a flowchart can be a helpful tool for the wizard to follow during the study.

Highlights

The Wizard of Oz Method is a moderated research method where a user interacts with an interface controlled by a human.

The method's name is inspired by L. Frank Baum's 'The Wonderful Wizard of Oz'.

In the story, characters discover a powerful wizard is actually an ordinary man controlling levers, similar to the research method.

A usability test is conducted with a participant and a facilitator, but with a remote 'wizard' controlling the interface.

The method is useful for assessing utility before investing in a full technical solution.

There are two variations: closed and open Wizard of Oz paradigms.

In the closed paradigm, the wizard selects from a fixed set of system responses.

The open paradigm allows the wizard to compose responses on the fly.

The wizard needs substantial knowledge of the product domain to respond effectively in the open paradigm.

A hybrid approach combines elements of both closed and open paradigms.

The hybrid method uses existing system responses and creates new ones when necessary.

This method can generate insights about system responses and explore alternatives.

To conduct a study, define the tools and technology for wizard-user communication.

A flowchart can be a helpful tool for the wizard in closed or hybrid studies.

The Wizard of Oz method is an inexpensive way to gain valuable insights on technologies.

The method allows for experimentation with technologies that might be costly to build.

Transcripts

- The Wizard of Oz Method is a moderated research method

in which a user interacts with an interface

manned by a human who controls the system responses.

The name cleverly comes

from Frank Baum's 20th Century American Children's book

the Wonderful Wizard of Oz.

In the book, the characters meet a giant head

that appears to be a powerful wizard, only to learn

that it's just an ordinary man pulling the levers

behind a screen, just like we see with this method.

So let's see an example in practice.

In setting up a Wizard of Oz prototype study,

we have a participant testing the interface,

a facilitator in the room with them

providing prompts and tasks like a normal usability test.

What differentiates this from a normal usability test

is that there's a wizard remotely controlling the interface.

When is a Wizard of Oz test useful to run?

The Wizard of Oz method can help creators

of interfaces assess utility before investing resources

into building a full technical solution.

There are two popular variations of Wizard of Oz.

The first is the closed Wizard of Oz paradigm

where there's a fixed set

of system responses from which the wizard can choose.

These responses can be various screens or text snippets.

Second, there is an open Wizard of Oz paradigm

where the wizard composes responses to user actions

in a timely manner on the fly.

And as you might guess,

the wizard needs to have substantial knowledge

of the product domain to compose those responses on the fly.

This variation is commonly used

in the discovery phase to understand user mental models,

expectations, and vocabulary.

You can also conduct a hybrid

of the closed and open paradigms.

In a hybrid,

there would be an existing body of system responses

which are used whenever possible, like in a closed test.

However, if there is not an appropriate response

in the response corpus, a new one would be created

on the fly and provided to the user during the session.

This approach can generate insights

about the existing already implemented system responses

and explore alternatives to current dead ends.

So how do you pull it off?

For this particular type of study,

you'll need to define tools and technology.

How will the wizard and user communicate?

Which technologies will be used?

What hooks need to be created

for the wizard to be able to control the prototype?

For closed or hybrid studies,

one tool that might be helpful

to the wizard is a flowchart to follow.

After you've established your setup, you're ready to go.

The Wizard of Oz method

is an inexpensive way to gain valuable insights

on technologies that might otherwise be very

costly to experiment with and build.

- Thanks for watching.

If you want to see more of our UX videos,

take a look at these over here and consider subscribing

to our channel.

On our website, nngroup.com,

you can access our free library of over 2,000 articles.

You can also register for one

of our UX courses that offer live, hands-on UX training.