SPECIAL PERFORMANCE: Arif Brata Matiin Mimpi Komika | SHOW #4 SUCI 11

Summary

The speaker expresses disappointment with the comedy show 'Suci 11,' highlighting issues such as poor sound quality and lack of audience interaction. They also discuss their own journey in stand-up comedy, from auditioning to becoming a judge. The speaker reflects on the challenges of selecting stand-up comedians, emphasizing the importance of strong stage presence and originality. Their experience with comedian Kak Gem, known for always having witty lines, serves as an example of the expectations in the industry. Ultimately, the speaker offers insights into the realities of pursuing comedy in Indonesia.

Takeaways

• 😀 The speaker expresses disappointment with Kompas and SUCI 11 due to poor audio quality, specifically the mic placement affecting audience feedback.
• 😀 The speaker criticizes the lack of engagement and impact in the stand-up comedy performances, which feel more like everyday conversation than a true comedy show.
• 😀 The speaker shows admiration for a comedian, Kak Gem, known for his spontaneous and memorable catchphrases, which have become his signature.
• 😀 Kak Gem's ability to deliver meaningful lines, like 'Oke, boleh, mencintai tapi jangan sama orang lain,' highlights his unique style and connection with the audience.
• 😀 The speaker emphasizes Kak Gem's ability to perform automatically, responding to key phrases without needing additional cues.
• 😀 The speaker shares their personal experience of starting out as a stand-up comedy contestant and later becoming a judge for SUCI 11 auditions.
• 😀 The speaker mentions how difficult it was for them to judge the auditions due to their empathy for the contestants, especially knowing the hard work involved in preparing.
• 😀 The speaker recounts seeking advice from Raditya Dika, who gave them a straightforward approach to judging: judge within the first 30 seconds and prioritize unique personalities.
• 😀 The speaker describes some of the audition contestants, highlighting one who had a slow delivery and another with overly predictable jokes.
• 😀 The speaker discusses how some performers didn't meet the required standards, such as an unoriginal joke style or a too-slow storytelling pace, which led to their elimination from the auditions.

Q & A

What is the speaker's main complaint about the show 'Suci 11'?

The speaker expresses disappointment with the show's audio quality, particularly the mic placement, which makes it hard for the audience to hear the comedians clearly. This impacts the viewer's experience, especially on platforms like FYP (For You Page).

Who is Kak Gem, and what is the speaker's opinion of them?

Kak Gem is a comedian known for always having a witty or meaningful response to interactions. The speaker respects Kak Gem for being able to engage with people using clever phrases or 'words of wisdom' in various situations, such as at the airport.

What does the speaker mean by saying Kak Gem is on 'autopilot'?

The speaker suggests that Kak Gem is so accustomed to giving witty responses that when he hears a keyword or cue, he instinctively knows what to say, as if operating on 'autopilot.' This shows Kak Gem's fluency and quick thinking in comedic interactions.

What experience did the speaker have with being a judge on 'Suci 11' auditions?

The speaker describes their experience as both enlightening and challenging. They recall being nervous but seeking advice from a fellow comedian, Bang Radit, on how to judge effectively. The speaker mentions that they understood the struggles of the contestants, which made the task emotionally difficult.

How does the speaker describe the role of a judge in an audition?

The speaker shares advice from Bang Radit, who told them that judges should give the contestants a brief 30-second window to impress them. If the performance is not engaging, the judge should not waste time and should move on to the next. The focus should be on finding performers with strong personalities and engaging material.

What does the speaker mean when they say 'cari yang ada personanya'?

The phrase 'cari yang ada personanya' means the judge should look for performers who have a strong and unique personality. The speaker suggests that these individuals will stand out and connect better with the audience, which is important for success in comedy.

What was the reaction to one of the audition contestants who told a slow, lengthy story?

The speaker found the contestant's storytelling style to be too slow and drawn out, comparing it to the pacing of a YouTube video. The contestant's storytelling was not engaging enough for the judges, leading to their dismissal from the audition.

What does the speaker think about the quality of the 'Suci 11' contestants?

The speaker believes some contestants have potential but struggle with their delivery or material. They provide an example of a contestant who was good but too slow in delivering their jokes, making it difficult for them to connect with the audience.

What advice did Bang Radit give to the speaker about judging auditions?

Bang Radit advised the speaker to be quick in evaluating auditions. He recommended giving a contestant only 30 seconds to showcase their skills, and if they didn't impress, the judge should move on to avoid wasting time for everyone involved.

What emotions did the speaker experience while judging the auditions?

The speaker describes feeling conflicted and empathetic towards the contestants. Although they were tasked with evaluating the performances, they could relate to the contestants' struggles and aspirations, making the experience emotionally challenging.