Diskusi: Pro Kontra PSSI Pecat Shin Tae-yong, Keputusan Tepat? | Liputan 6

Summary

The Indonesian Football Association (PSSI) has officially dismissed Shin Tae-yong as the national football team coach, amid mixed reactions from fans and analysts. Some supporters praised his contributions, including leading the team to the semifinals of the AFF Championship and showing improvement in the team's performance, while others criticized his strategies and results. Shin Tae-yong accepted the decision with gratitude and hoped for Indonesia's success in future competitions. The timing of the dismissal, close to important World Cup qualifiers, has sparked debate, with concerns over the potential risks involved.

Takeaways

• 😀 Shinta Yong has officially been dismissed by PSSI as the head coach of the Indonesian national football team.
• 😀 The decision to remove Shinta Yong has sparked a debate among football fans in Indonesia, with some supporting the move and others opposing it.
• 😀 PSSI stated that Shinta Yong's dismissal was part of a broader evaluation process and to ensure better leadership for the national team moving forward.
• 😀 Shinta Yong accepted his dismissal gracefully, thanking PSSI for the trust placed in him over the last five years.
• 😀 Despite his departure, Shinta Yong expressed hope that the national team would qualify for the 2026 World Cup.
• 😀 Some fans and analysts believe that Shinta Yong had already made significant progress with the team, helping them reach the third round of World Cup qualifiers.
• 😀 Critics argue that the timing of Shinta Yong's dismissal was questionable, especially so close to the next World Cup qualifiers.
• 😀 PSSI's decision was not rushed; the organization carefully considered the risks of replacing Shinta Yong at this stage of the qualifiers.
• 😀 Erik Thohir, Chairman of PSSI, confirmed that Shinta Yong's dismissal was not related to the team's failure at the AFF Cup, but rather due to previous issues leading up to the China match.
• 😀 The announcement of Shinta Yong's replacement was set to be made on January 12, 2025, with the new coach expected to prepare the team for the remaining World Cup qualifiers.

Q & A

Why was Shin Tae-yong dismissed as the head coach of the Indonesian national football team?

Shin Tae-yong was dismissed by PSSI due to concerns over the leadership and strategic direction of the team. PSSI wanted a coach who could better implement strategies, improve communication, and lead the team towards qualifying for the 2026 FIFA World Cup.

How did Shin Tae-yong respond to his dismissal?

Shin Tae-yong accepted the decision graciously, thanking PSSI for the trust given to him over the past five years. He expressed hope that the Indonesian national team would qualify for the World Cup.

What were some of the key achievements of Shin Tae-yong as the head coach of Indonesia?

Shin Tae-yong helped the Indonesian team reach the third round of World Cup qualifiers and led the U-23 team to the semifinals of the AFF Championship. These accomplishments were considered significant progress for Indonesian football.

How did the public react to Shin Tae-yong’s dismissal?

Many football fans and commentators disagreed with the decision, arguing that Shin Tae-yong had achieved important milestones for Indonesia's football progress and should have been given more time to work with the team.

What were the main reasons cited by PSSI for replacing Shin Tae-yong?

PSSI cited the need for a leader who could better communicate with the players and implement agreed-upon strategies. There were concerns that Shin Tae-yong's methods were not yielding the desired results, particularly in the World Cup qualification campaign.

Did the failure to progress past the AFF Championship semifinals influence the decision to fire Shin Tae-yong?

While the failure in the AFF Championship was discussed in the media, PSSI clarified that the decision was based on broader factors and dynamics within the team. The performance in the AFF Championship was not the sole reason for the dismissal.

What did PSSI say about the timing of the dismissal?

PSSI acknowledged that the timing of the dismissal was challenging due to the upcoming World Cup qualifiers. However, they felt it was better to make the change now, with two and a half months to prepare, rather than waiting and potentially regretting it later.

Who will replace Shin Tae-yong as the head coach of the Indonesian national team?

PSSI announced that the new head coach would be appointed by January 12, 2025. The specific individual who will replace Shin Tae-yong was not named in the transcript.

How did PSSI evaluate the risks of replacing Shin Tae-yong so close to the World Cup qualifiers?

PSSI evaluated the risks carefully, considering that several countries had also changed their coaches during World Cup qualification. They decided that the potential benefits of a new coach outweighed the risks, even with limited preparation time.

What is the general sentiment about the PSSI's decision to replace Shin Tae-yong?

The decision has sparked mixed reactions. Some believe that Shin Tae-yong deserved more time, given his achievements with the team. Others support the decision, believing that a fresh approach might be necessary for the team’s success in the World Cup qualifiers.