Minangkabau Diakui Milik Negara Jiran Bahasa Indo Disebut turunan Melayu! Momen Klaim dari Malaysia

Summary

This video highlights ongoing disputes between Indonesia and Malaysia over cultural ownership, from traditional attire and food to music and language. The script details claims made by Malaysia over Indonesian cultural heritage, such as Minangkabau adat, rendang, batik, and the song 'Rasa Sayange,' among others. The video also touches on controversies involving sports figures, like Jordi Ahmad, and incidents of cultural appropriation in Malaysia, causing widespread outrage among Indonesian netizens. The script explores the tensions between the two nations regarding the misattribution of cultural identities and historical claims.

Takeaways

• 😀 Malaysia has repeatedly claimed cultural and territorial aspects traditionally associated with Indonesia, sparking frustration among Indonesians.
• 😀 Batik, a traditional Indonesian fabric art, was falsely claimed by a Malaysian local during an influencer's visit, leading to confusion and backlash from Indonesians.
• 😀 Rendang, a famous Indonesian dish from Sumatra, has been incorrectly attributed to Malaysia, causing outrage among Indonesians.
• 😀 Indonesian footballer Jordi Ahmad was mistakenly listed as a Malaysian national player, contributing to the ongoing territorial and cultural disputes.
• 😀 Malaysia claimed the traditional Minangkabau attire from Sumatra as their own during the Miss Komo 2024 event, which angered many Indonesians.
• 😀 The song 'Rasa Sayang,' originally from Indonesia's Maluku, was misrepresented as Malaysian, despite clear historical ties to Indonesia.
• 😀 Malaysia's claim to the Sipadan and Ligitan islands, located near Indonesia’s Kalimantan, was decided by the International Court of Justice but remains a sensitive issue for Indonesia.
• 😀 PSS Sleman football fans' unique chanting style was misattributed to Malaysia, further escalating tensions between the two nations.
• 😀 A Malaysian professor stated that Bahasa Indonesia is derived from the Malay language, which was met with strong criticism from Indonesians, who see it as a misrepresentation of their language’s history.
• 😀 Malaysia's attempts to claim cultural heritage, such as the Reok Ponorogo dance, have intensified national pride in Indonesia, as these cultural assets are part of Indonesia's identity.

Q & A

Why is there tension between Indonesia and Malaysia?

The tension between Indonesia and Malaysia arises from disputes over cultural heritage and territorial claims. Malaysia has often been accused of claiming Indonesian cultural elements as its own, such as batik, rendang, and traditional attire, which has sparked controversy among Indonesians.

What is the controversy surrounding batik and its origin?

Batik is a traditional fabric design technique that was claimed by Malaysia to be part of their heritage. However, batik originated in Indonesia, as clarified by an American influencer, Iso Speed, who confirmed its Indonesian origin after being misinformed by a Malaysian netizen.

How did Iso Speed react to the claim that batik is Malaysian?

Iso Speed, upon hearing the claim, was confused and questioned it further. After researching on Google, he found out that batik is from Indonesia, which led to his discomfort in Malaysia, where he chose to stay for only a brief period.

What happened regarding the claim about rendang's origin?

Rendang, a popular dish from Indonesia, especially Sumatra, was claimed by some in Malaysia to be a Malaysian dish. This sparked outrage in Indonesia, especially after an influencer posted a video where many Malaysians confidently stated that rendang was from their country.

How did Malaysian netizens react to Lucinta Luna's appearance?

Lucinta Luna, an Indonesian celebrity, was mistakenly identified by Malaysian netizens as being from Malaysia after meeting influencer Iso Speed. This misidentification triggered a wave of comments, with some Malaysians humorously or provocatively claiming that Lucinta Luna was theirs.

What is the issue with the Minangkabau traditional dress?

At the Miss Komo 2024 event, a finalist from Malaysia wore the traditional Minangkabau dress, claiming it as part of Malaysia's heritage. This claim was disputed by Indonesians, as the attire is a clear part of the Minangkabau culture from West Sumatra, Indonesia.

What happened with the claim about the Reog Ponorogo dance?

Reog Ponorogo, a traditional dance from East Java, Indonesia, was at one point presented by Malaysia with their logo, and there were even talks of Malaysia registering it with UNESCO. This caused anger among Indonesians, as they viewed it as an attempt to appropriate Indonesian cultural heritage.

How did the issue of language differences between Malaysia and Indonesia come up?

A Malaysian professor, Awang Sariyan, controversially claimed that the Indonesian language is a variant of the Malay language and is thus part of Malaysia’s linguistic heritage. This claim was criticized by Indonesians, as Bahasa Indonesia has distinct historical roots and is based on various local languages of Indonesia, not just Malay.

What was the controversy over the song 'Rasa Sayange'?

The song 'Rasa Sayange,' originating from Maluku, Indonesia, became a point of contention when it was used to promote tourism in Malaysia in 2007. The dispute resurfaced when it was played at the SEA Games 2017, with some Malaysians claiming it as their own, while Indonesians assert it is part of their cultural heritage.

Why were Indonesian football fans upset about PSS Sleman?

Indonesian football fans were upset when Malaysian netizens mistakenly claimed the fan chants from PSS Sleman, an Indonesian football club, as being from Kelantan, Malaysia. This misattribution caused backlash among Indonesian supporters who were proud of their unique football culture.