Muncul Wacana Penerapan Kembali Ujian Nasional, Bagaimana Tanggapan Para Siswa? | Beritasatu

Summary

The video discusses the ongoing debate in Indonesia regarding the reintroduction of the National Exam (UN). Abdul Muti, the Minister of Primary and Secondary Education, states that the government is still reviewing the proposal. While some support the return of the UN, others oppose it. Several students share their diverse opinions, with some feeling ready for the exam if reinstated, while others prefer the current system without it, citing less pressure and more focus on learning. The discussion reflects the tension between maintaining academic standards and reducing student stress.

Takeaways

• 😀 Abdul Muti, the Minister of Education and Culture, stated that the government is still reviewing the possibility of reintroducing the National Examination (UN).
• 😀 The decision regarding the reintroduction of the UN is not final yet, and there are varying opinions about its necessity.
• 😀 Some people believe that the National Examination should be reintroduced as a graduation requirement to ensure students are well-prepared.
• 😀 Others argue that the National Examination is not necessary and that its absence has led to a more relaxed and beneficial learning environment.
• 😀 A student named Saiful mentioned that although he had not heard of the decision to reintroduce the UN, he believes it is important to have exams to measure students' knowledge.
• 😀 Another student, Nazura, supports the reintroduction of the UN, arguing that it provides clearer goals and forces students to study more seriously.
• 😀 Some students feel more motivated and focused when there is a national exam because it offers a clear target for their preparation.
• 😀 A few students expressed concerns that the frequent exams, especially the UN, could lead to burnout and hinder the overall educational experience.
• 😀 There is a growing sense of disagreement among students regarding the pressure and stress of taking the National Examination.
• 😀 The Indonesian Ministry of Education continues to assess the potential impact of reintroducing the UN and will engage with both students and educators before making a decision.

Q & A

What is the main topic discussed in the script?

The script primarily discusses the debate over the potential reintroduction of the national examination (Ujian Nasional or UN) in Indonesia. It highlights various opinions and reactions from both officials and students.

Who is Abdul Muti and what is his role in the discussion?

Abdul Muti is the Minister of Education for Primary and Secondary Education (Mendik Dasmen). He mentions that the government is still considering the reintroduction of the national exam, though no final decision has been made yet.

What are the differing views about the reintroduction of the UN?

Some people support the reintroduction of the UN, believing it is necessary, while others oppose it, arguing that it is no longer needed as a graduation requirement.

What did Abdul Muti state about the government's stance on the UN?

Abdul Muti stated that the government is still studying the idea of reintroducing the national exam and that the decision is not final yet.

How do the students in the script feel about the potential reintroduction of the UN?

The students have varied opinions. Some are in favor of the UN returning, believing that it helps them focus on studying, while others are opposed, preferring no exams like the current system.

What does one student named Saiful think about the possibility of the UN returning?

Saiful is aware of rumors about the UN being reintroduced and expresses a readiness to face it, stating that exams are necessary to obtain a grade, although he personally prefers no UN.

What is the opinion of the student Nazura on the matter?

Nazura supports the return of the UN, as she feels that it would encourage students to study more seriously and provide clearer assessment standards, particularly for moving on to high school or junior high school.

What is the general sentiment about the UN's impact on education?

There is a sense that the UN, if reintroduced, would push students to study harder and provide a clear benchmark for academic readiness, but some students also feel it creates unnecessary pressure and disrupts the current, less exam-focused education system.

Why do some students oppose the return of the UN?

Some students oppose the reintroduction of the UN because they feel it adds extra pressure and prefer the current system, which is perceived as more relaxed without mandatory national exams.

How do the students in the transcript view the current education system?

The students seem to have mixed feelings. Some appreciate the more relaxed approach with no national exams, while others feel that exams like the UN provide clearer academic goals and motivate them to study more effectively.