cynthia erivo and the "offensive" movie poster debate 🧙‍♀️

Summary

The video addresses the controversy surrounding Cynthia Erivo's comments about a fan-created poster for 'Wicked,' which led to backlash from enthusiastic supporters. The speaker criticizes Erivo for her perceived short-sightedness and the disproportionate reaction from social media, highlighting issues of misogyny and racism in Hollywood's treatment of women. They reflect on the artistry of the original poster, suggesting that criticism should be fair and context-aware. Ultimately, the video calls for understanding in the face of misunderstandings, while humorously engaging viewers to avoid discussions about 'Wicked' for the rest of the day.

Takeaways

• 😀 Cynthia Erivo's criticism of fan enthusiasm for a 'Wicked' poster led to significant backlash on social media.
• 😀 The speaker feels that Erivo unfairly labeled excited fans as racist, creating unnecessary negativity.
• 😀 The controversy highlights a misuse of power, drawing disproportionate attention to a misunderstanding.
• 😀 The speaker argues that there are more pressing issues in the world than the complaints raised by Erivo.
• 😀 Public reactions to women in Hollywood often involve misogyny and racism, which complicates discourse around criticism.
• 😀 The speaker encourages a nuanced understanding of Erivo's situation without dismissing the validity of calling her out.
• 😀 The artistic quality of the fan-created promotional poster was suggested to be better than the original, questioning Erivo's standards.
• 😀 There is a broader commentary on the culture of online hate and the dangers of taking criticism too far.
• 😀 Humor is used to address the absurdity of the situation, with the speaker suggesting a light-hearted 'homework' assignment for viewers.
• 😀 Overall, the speaker advocates for thoughtful engagement with the complexities of fandom and representation.

Q & A

What was the initial reaction of Cynthia Erivo regarding the promotional poster for 'Wicked'?

Cynthia Erivo reacted critically to a promotional poster, accusing fans who were excited about it of being racist and promoting offensive themes.

How did the speaker feel about Erivo's accusations towards fans?

The speaker found Erivo's accusations to be shortsighted and expressed disappointment in her labeling excited fans as racist.

What impact did the speaker believe the controversy would have on 'Wicked's publicity?

The speaker was concerned that the negative backlash from the controversy could harm 'Wicked's publicity, especially with the show's upcoming release in Mexico City.

What kind of negative feedback did Erivo report receiving?

Erivo reported receiving insulting messages, threats, and even individuals attempting to find her home address.

What did the speaker mean by describing Erivo's actions as callous?

The speaker suggested that Erivo's criticism was insensitive, especially considering the more severe issues many people face compared to her situation.

How does the speaker link the backlash against actresses like Erivo to broader social issues?

The speaker connects the disproportionate reactions against actresses to misogyny and racism, suggesting that these issues often underlie public backlash.

What is the speaker's opinion on the original creators of the poster?

The speaker believes that the original poster creators might feel offended by Erivo's reaction, as it implies that a Twitter user's version was superior.

How does the speaker feel about the edits made to Erivo's image in the poster?

The speaker critiques the fairness of holding the poster creators to a different standard for editing Erivo's image, arguing that all artistic interpretations should be considered equally.

What stance does Dave take regarding the posters for 'Wicked'?

Dave believes that both versions of the posters are offensive and plans to boycott the movie, indicating a more critical view of the adaptation.

What humorous suggestion does the speaker make to the audience at the end of the video?

The speaker jokingly challenges the audience to see if they can go an entire day without hearing about 'Wicked,' adding a light-hearted tone to the conclusion.