Palestinian Dead Are Necessary (according to Hamas)
Summary
TLDRThe video script discusses the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, highlighting the silence of pro-Palestinian voices in the West and the Palestinians themselves when their leader refers to civilian deaths as a 'necessary sacrifice.' It delves into the historical context, comparing the attitudes towards life and death between Israelis and Palestinians, and criticizes the Western media for ignoring the reality on the ground. The script also addresses the role of Hamas, the construction of tunnels, and the portrayal of terrorists as heroes, emphasizing the need to listen to the other side to understand the conflict.
Takeaways
- 🗣️ The Israeli Prime Minister's hypothetical statement about Palestinian civilian deaths being a 'necessary sacrifice' is used to highlight a perceived double standard in global reactions to conflict.
- 🕊️ The script points out the silence from pro-Palestinian supporters in the West when Palestinian leaders make such statements, suggesting a lack of condemnation from those who are usually vocal about Israeli actions.
- 🗣️ It emphasizes the internal Palestinian agreement with the idea of civilian deaths as a 'necessary sacrifice', indicating a cultural acceptance of such losses in their struggle.
- 👂 The speaker claims to have a unique ability to listen to 'the other side', suggesting a deeper understanding of the Arab and Palestinian perspective that contradicts common Western beliefs.
- 🗓️ Historical quotes from Palestinian leaders are cited to show a long-standing stance of hostility towards Jews, dating back to before the establishment of Israel.
- 🏠 The script contrasts the treatment of civilians by both sides, with Israel investing in defense systems like the Iron Dome, while Hamas constructs tunnels and uses civilian areas for military purposes.
- 📊 It argues that the ratio of combatant to civilian casualties in the conflict is one of the lowest in recent urban conflicts, challenging the narrative of high civilian death rates.
- 🤥 The script accuses Hamas of inflating casualty numbers and the media of uncritically reporting these figures, which it suggests are used to gain sympathy and attention.
- 📜 Reference is made to the Hamas Constitution, highlighting the emphasis on Jihad and death over the establishment of a Palestinian state, indicating a different set of priorities.
- 👨👩👧👦 The script discusses the cultural differences between Israelis and Palestinians, including attitudes towards death, the treatment of terrorists, and the value placed on civilian life.
Q & A
What does the speaker claim would happen if the Israeli Prime Minister said that Palestinian civilian deaths were a necessary sacrifice?
-The speaker suggests that if the Israeli Prime Minister made such a statement, it would be widely condemned as evidence of a planned genocide against Palestinians and would be a topic of discussion for years.
Why does the speaker believe the pro-Palestinians in the West are currently silent?
-The speaker implies that pro-Palestinians in the West are silent because they cannot blame Israel for the situation and that they typically only speak up when they can place blame on Israel.
What does the speaker suggest about the Palestinians' own reaction to their leader's statement about civilian deaths?
-The speaker suggests that the Palestinians themselves are quiet about their leader's statement because they agree with it and see it as necessary.
What historical figure's views does the speaker mention to illustrate a point about the attitudes of Arab leaders in Palestine?
-The speaker mentions Hajj Amin al-Husseini, a leader of the Arabs in Palestine, who spent time in Nazi Germany and advocated for the killing of Jews.
How does the speaker describe the situation of Jews living in Arab territories after 1949?
-The speaker states that there were 160,000 Jews living in the Jewish state in 1949, but no Jews were left alive in the territories held by the Arabs.
What does the speaker claim about the behavior of Arabs towards each other within their own communities?
-The speaker claims that the Arabs are violent towards each other, citing thousands of deaths due to internal political turmoil and violence.
What does the speaker say about the Israeli development of defense systems like the Iron Dome?
-The speaker praises the Israeli development of defense systems like the Iron Dome, which are designed to protect civilians from rocket attacks.
How does the speaker contrast the Israeli approach to defense with that of Hamas?
-The speaker contrasts the Israeli approach by stating that Hamas has built tunnels and placed control rooms under hospitals and UN buildings, using the civilian population as human shields.
What does the speaker claim about the frequency of Jewish self-killing for political reasons over the last 100 years?
-The speaker claims that there have been very few instances of Jews killing other Jews for political reasons over the last 100 years, and he can name all the times it has happened.
What does the speaker suggest about the reasons for civilian casualties in the conflict?
-The speaker suggests that many civilian casualties are caused by Hamas shooting from positions close to civilians and that Hamas uses the civilian population as human shields.
How does the speaker describe the role of the media in reporting on civilian casualties?
-The speaker accuses the media of accepting Hamas's inflated numbers of civilian casualties without verification, which he suggests is done for sensationalist headlines.
Outlines
🗣️ Palestinian Silence on Civilian Deaths
The paragraph discusses the Israeli Prime Minister's statement that Palestinian civilian deaths are a necessary sacrifice for the attention it brings to Israel's alleged genocidal intentions. It highlights the silence of pro-Palestinian voices in the West and the Palestinians themselves, suggesting an agreement with the leader's stance. The speaker emphasizes the historical context, including quotes from Arab leaders advocating for the annihilation of Jews and the lack of Jews in Arab territories post-1949. The narrative contrasts the internal violence within Arab communities with the unity and diversity within Israel, suggesting a cultural acceptance of violence and sacrifice among Palestinians.
🔪 The Brutality and Self-Sacrifice in Palestinian Society
This section delves into the brutality of the Palestinians, as evidenced by the October 7th attack, and compares it with the Syrian conflict. It discusses the Hamas Constitution, which glorifies Jihad and death, and contrasts this with Jewish values that celebrate life. The speaker points out the discrepancy between the number of times Jihad and Islam are mentioned in the Hamas Constitution versus the non-mention of a Palestinian State, suggesting a broader religious agenda over a nationalist one. The paragraph also addresses the Western media's portrayal of the conflict, accusing it of ignoring the realities presented by Hamas and Palestinian TV, which promote death and violence.
🛡️ The Irony of Defense and Offense in Israeli-Palestinian Conflict
The paragraph contrasts Israel's development of defense systems like the Iron Dome with Hamas's construction of tunnels for military purposes, positioning civilians as human shields. It discusses the cultural differences between Israelis and Palestinians, where Israeli soldiers face legal consequences for harming terrorists, while Palestinians celebrate acts of terror. The speaker argues that the Palestinian Authority's financial support for terrorists and the portrayal of civilian casualties are part of a strategy to gain sympathy from the West by playing the victim card.
🕋️ The Misunderstanding of Palestinian Civilian Casualties
This section addresses the issue of civilian casualties, challenging the narrative that Israel is solely responsible for the deaths. It discusses how Hamas's tactics and the media's portrayal of these events contribute to a misunderstanding of the conflict. The speaker argues that many civilian deaths are a result of Hamas's strategy, not Israeli aggression. The paragraph also touches on the importance of listening to the other side and not patronizing them, emphasizing that Palestinian actions are a reflection of their culture and beliefs, not a result of external influences.
Mindmap
Keywords
💡Palestinian
💡Genocide
💡Hamas
💡Jihad
💡Iron Dome
💡Human Shields
💡Terror Tunnels
💡Civilian Casualties
💡Propaganda
💡Khalifat
💡PLO
Highlights
The Israeli Prime Minister's statement on Palestinian civilian deaths being a 'necessary sacrifice' would be globally condemned if true.
The silence of pro-Palestinian voices in the West suggests a reluctance to criticize Palestinian leadership.
The leader of Palestinians in Gaza's statement 'All Quiet on the Western Front' is intriguing and not a slip of the tongue.
Palestinians' agreement with their leader's stance on civilian deaths indicates a cultural acceptance of sacrifice.
The speaker's 'special powers' of listening to the other side contradict Western beliefs about peace and cooperation.
Historical quotes from Arab leaders in Palestine reveal a long-standing desire for the annihilation of Jews.
The absence of Jews in Arab-held territories post-1949 contrasts with 160,000 Arabs living in the Jewish state.
Internal violence among Arabs in Palestine has led to thousands of deaths, often overlooked by the media.
Hamas's constitution prioritizes Jihad and death over the establishment of a Palestinian state.
The Iron Dome versus Hamas's tunnels illustrate the differing approaches to civilian protection.
Hamas uses civilian structures as human shields, a strategy that leads to civilian casualties.
The Palestinian Authority financially rewards terrorists, incentivizing violence.
The ratio of combatant to civilian casualties in the current conflict is one: one, unusually low for an urban conflict.
Hamas inflates casualty numbers, and the media often uncritically reports these figures.
The Israeli Army's precision in targeting is contrasted with Hamas's strategy of operating near civilians.
Understanding the conflict requires listening to both sides and not patronizing the other side's culture and beliefs.
The speaker will respond to a video by 'go history' with a critique and deeper analysis.
The speaker is shifting focus from travel videos to conflict analysis due to the importance of understanding the current situation.
Transcripts
Palestinian civilian death are a
necessary sacrifice if an Israeli Prime
Minister said that the whole world would
be talking about it it would be proof
that Israel has planned a genocide
against the Palestinians it would come
up in every discussion for years but
when is in war the leader of the
Palestinians in Gaza says it All Quiet
on the Western Front and the Arab Muslim
front now sino's statement is very
interesting for a number of reasons and
as you will see it was not a slip of the
tongue let's unpack it and see how it
resonate with Hamas and the Palestinians
the first thing to notice is how silent
the pro Palestinians in the west are now
I'm not surprised prop Palestinians
won't say anything if they can't lay the
blame at Israel's door but I've
mentioned that so many times before
let's dig into the real interesting
aspects here first not only are the pro
Palestinians quiet but the Palestinians
themselves are also quiet can you
imagine your leader saying that civilian
death in your country are a necessary
sacrifice and it just passes without
protest and the crazy reason that his
words didn't meet with opposition is
that the Palestinians agree with it they
agree with it and they use use it let me
explain to be able to understand this
you are going to need to make a big
effort because it will contradict
everything that you as a westner believe
in I do understand it because I don't
want to brag but I have special powers I
can listen to the other side I can
listen to other people it is not always
easy because we all have our own voice
in our head which is great and then
there are the voices of others which are
often disappointing the voice in my head
says let's aim for peace compromise
cooperation but I hear different ideas
when I listen to the other side to the
Arabs of Palestine I will tell you what
I hear in 1947 so before the settlements
and before the nakba kawaki one of the
leaders of the Arabs in Palestine said
the only option is the annihilation of
every Jew in Palestine and in every Arab
State sounds sounds a bit Nazi this
makes sense as he spent a lot of time in
Nazi Germany in the 40s he was not alone
there the best known leader of the Arabs
in Palestine haaj Amin huseni also spent
the early 40s in Nazi Germany and said
kill the Jews wherever you find them
this pleases God history and religion
this saves your honor I can give you
more examples Hassan Elana the founder
of the Muslim Brotherhood said that they
would drive all the Jews to the Sea he
is the spiritual father of Hamas and
talked about his love of death and Jihad
the Secretary General of the Arab League
at the time Abdul Rahman aam said that
this would be a war of extermination and
momentous Massacre see if you can find
one Arab leader talking about achieving
peace with the Jews but it is not only a
few quotes actions speak louder than
words how many Arabs were there in the
Jewish state in
1949
160,000 and how many Jews were there in
the territories held by the Arabs zero
NADA gourish not a single Jew was left
alive but let's put the Jews aside for a
second let's see what the Arabs do to
each other look at how people behave to
one another in their homes and you will
understand how they will behave outside
once they are comfortable enough the
Jews in Israel are divided into many
groups there is a saying two Jews three
opinions only on very rare occasions
have these different opinions escalated
into violence in fact I can name all the
times when Jews killed other Jews for
political reasons over the last 100
years thean tobiansky maybe AR loov
Alena Emil greenswag andak Rabin does
anybody know how many of the Arabs of
Palestine have been killed due to Inner
political turmoil and violence thousands
and thousands from the 1930s to the PLO
members that Hamas threw from the
rooftops of Gaza in 2007 somehow nobody
cares but when you realize just how
violent the Arabs are to one another you
understand the situation much better
many Israelis were left in Shock by the
brutality of the Palestinians in October
7th attack I wasn't 10 years ago I said
that if the syrians could murder
thousands of other syrians in the most
brutal ways then what would they do to
us if they got the chance the leader of
Hamas in Gaza in has killed many
Palestinians with his own hands for the
smallest things and the Palestinians
accept that but don't take my word for
it I'm just a Zionist let's see what
Hamas says about itself in the Hamas
Constitution it says Jihad is the path
and death for the sake of Allah is the
loftiest of its wish
they say that they love death this
culture see death and killing as the
best thing you can do they say as much
quite
clearly we the Jews say that we will win
because we love life and they say that
they will win because they love death
they are saying it listen to the other
side here is a very basic fact that you
probably didn't know and no news
organization has ever told you Jihad is
mentioned 11 times in the Hamas
Constitution and Islam is mentioned 130
times and how many times are the words
Palestinian State
mentioned zero don't you think that this
is crazy go and read the Hamas
Constitution yourself all these people
who are talking about a Palestinian
State what are you talking about Hamas
wants a Muslim khalifat not a
Palestinian State listen to them not to
the voice in your head listen to the
other side the Hamas Constitution is
what they live by listen to these
mothers on Palestinian
TV for
[Music]
can you imagine a mother in France or
Wisconsin or Australia or Israel saying
that she wants her sons to die below I
will leave a link to a video with dozens
of clips from Palestinian TV I find it
insane that the Western media totally
ignores the things I'm talking about and
it is all out there the Hamas
Constitution Palestinian TV those are
not secret documents and look at what
they teach their
[Music]
children and this is the mainstream of
Palestinian Society now you might have a
better idea why it is that when the
Palestinian leader says that Palestinian
death are a necessary sacrifice the
civilians don't protest because they
agree with it here is another fact that
shows you how different Israelis and
Palestinians are Israel developed the
Iron Dome and other defense systems to
protect civilians from Rockets these are
probably the best systems in the world
at protecting civilians Hamas built more
than 300 kilomet of tunnels they have
built their control rooms under
hospitals and un buildings so they are
using the civilian population as human
Shields they could fit a very large part
of the population of Gaza into the
tunnels but civilians don't enter and no
one says a word here is another example
that shows you how different the
Israelis and Palestinian societies are
in Israel a soldier went to jail for
shooting a wounded terrorist
the Palestinians on the other side see
terrorists who blew up a bus or a cafe
full of Israeli civilians as Heroes and
not only that the Palestinian Authority
pays 7% of its budget to terrorists the
more Jews you kill the more money you
get terrorists earn more money than the
average worker in the Palestinian
Authority how many people know this very
few so the Palestinians love Jihad and
teach their children to hate and fight
as hard as it for our Western Minds to
grasp many of them believe that civilian
casualties are necessary and are
necessary because that is the only
strong card that they hold and this is
how the Palestinians get sympathy from
the west by playing the victim card and
I get this all the time this is not the
first video I've made about the conflict
and I bring facts to the table now
because my facts are solid prop
Palestinians can't prove me wrong and so
one of the most common comments I get
from prop Palestinians is that the facts
that I'm laying out don't justify
killing children I don't find this
comment particularly smart just because
you can prove me wrong that doesn't mean
that I support the killing of children
so let's look at the number of Civilian
casualties in the current conflict and
see why most people get it wrong the
rure of combatant to civilian casualties
is about one: one which is the lowest
rure there has been in any urban
conflict over the last few decades but
if you watch the news you get a
different impression so why is that well
there are a few reasons the first one is
that Hamas lies about the numbers even
the UN has changed its estimation from
34,000 to
24,000 the number dropped drastically
but the damage has already been done in
thousands of Articles accusing Israel of
genocide the death toll published by
Hamas grows at the same rate every day
which doesn't make sense there are lots
of articles about it but you don't need
to dive too deep to know that they are
lying when Israel says that Four
soldiers and four civilians were killed
then it is true you get to see the names
and pictures of of them all but when the
health Ministry in Gaza which is run by
Hamas publishes its numbers they never
say how many of those who died were
Hamas Fighters they count them all as
civilians and pump up the numbers now
that is strange not a single Hamas
member was killed during the fighting
only after a few months did Kamas admit
that a few thousands of its members have
died but when the headlines come out it
was 100% civilians and the media just
love it headlines saying dozens of
civilians killed will get many more
clicks it is a win-win situation for
Hamas and the media Hamas get sympathy
and the media gets bombastic headlines
without having to do any hard work the
BBC only needs to add says Hamas at the
end of the headline and then they are
not technically lying they are just
quoting the lies of Hamas now you might
say that there are nonetheless thousands
of civilians dead in Gaza and that is
true if Hamas Fighters were civilian
closes although they have uniforms and
if they shoot from hospitals and schools
and if they don't protect their own
civilians and don't allow them to enter
their 300 kilometers of tunnels then
they are bound to be civilian casualties
I was in the tanks and let me tell you
how how we see it let's say we are
escorting the Infantry and my tank
identifies someone that is shooting at
the Infantry from let's say 300 M away
we inform the Infantry and we shoot at
the source of firing we don't go out to
the Hamas member and tell him hey can
you please get out of the kindergarten
no you shoot at us we are going to shoot
back we will do it as accurately as we
can but if your family members are next
to you they will probably join you in
hell and that is your own fault it is
actually your own responsibility the
Israeli Army occasionally makes mistakes
and sometimes we accidentally shoot at
our own soldiers this this happens in
every Army and in every war but most of
the Palestinian civilian death are
caused by Hamas shooting from positions
close to civilians and as their leader
said Palestinian death are necessary I
say that one of the most important
things we can do in order to understand
this conflict is to listen to the other
side another important factor is not to
patronize the other side if the Arabs of
Palestine have said since the 1940s that
they want to eliminate the Jews that is
before the establishment of the state of
Israel and before the so-called
occupation then they mean it if they
have killed thousands of other
Palestinians because of differences of
opinion then this is part of their
culture and not the fault of European
colonialism if Islam is mentioned 130
times in the Kamas Constitution and the
Palestinian state is mentioned zero
times
then they mean that they are not
interested in a state but in a Muslim
khalifate if they kill gays then it is
not because of Israel it is because of
their radical Muslim views if they
invest billions of dollars in rockets
and Terror tunnels and not in education
then it is because fighting and death
are what they consider to be most
important and if they say that
Palestinian death are necessary
then they mean it to us westerners it is
hard to understand because we value life
but they value Jihad in my next video I
will be responding to go history's video
about the Israeli Palestinian conflict
he got about 45% of it right it is
definitely going to be interesting so be
sure to subscribe and follow for more if
you already follow me you will probably
have noticed that I'm making fewer
travel videos and more videos about a
conflict I will continue making them
because I think that right now
understanding the conflict is more
important than videos about tips for for
Tel Aviv I won't be printing any more of
my tour guide booklets about Jerusalem
msada and Tel Aviv so if you want to get
a copy and support my work please do so
now the link will be below
I want to thank all my supporters you
keep me going see you next week yala by
Voir Plus de Vidéos Connexes
How Far Away Is a Ceasefire? An Update on Gaza and the Rafah Invasion | Ian Bremmer
From the River to the Sea, Palestine will be Free | Explained
Powerful Speech by Israel's Ambassador To UN
Desmontando las mentiras sobre la historia de Israel y Palestina
The origins of the Hamas-Israel war explained | ABC News
Asking Palestine Protestors What From the River to the Sea Means...
5.0 / 5 (0 votes)