SEMI 2 Mama Ngina Girls High School vs Strathmore School

Summary

In the semi-finals of the national debate season, teams from Mangina High School and Strathmore School debated whether parents should be held responsible for their school-going children's discipline problems. The proposers argued that parents, as primary caregivers, significantly influence their children's behavior and should be accountable. The opposers contended that societal influences and communal responsibility also play crucial roles in shaping children's conduct, advocating for a broader communal parenting approach. The debate highlighted the complexity of discipline issues and the multifaceted nature of parenting responsibilities.

Takeaways

• 🎙️ The debate revolves around whether parents should be held responsible for their school-going children's discipline problems.
• 🏫 The proposition team from Mangina High School argues that parents play a crucial role in shaping their children's behavior and should be accountable for their actions.
• 🙅‍♀️ The opposition team from Strathmore School contends that blaming parents alone is an oversimplification and that other factors, such as societal influences and peer pressure, also contribute to a child's behavior.
• 👨‍👩‍👧‍👦 The debate highlights the importance of communal parenting, suggesting that the entire community should be involved in a child's upbringing rather than placing the burden solely on parents.
• 🌐 The script references global issues like pornography and its impact on parenting, indicating that modern societal problems affect how parents raise their children.
• 📉 Statistics are cited to support arguments, such as high divorce rates in Kenya and the prevalence of pornography, which are used to argue that parents are struggling with their own issues and may fail to provide proper guidance.
• 👶 The definition of a 'child' is discussed, emphasizing that children are not just those under 18 but are continuously influenced by their parents throughout their lives.
• 🤔 The debate questions the effectiveness of holding parents legally responsible for their children's actions, suggesting that a moral approach to parenting might be more effective.
• 🏆 The final verdict awards Strathmore School with 80% of the vote, making them the winners of this debate round.
• 📢 The debate concludes with a call for continued conversation on the topic, encouraging audience engagement on social media platforms with the hashtag #GDCforsdgs.

Q & A

What is the main topic of the debate?

The main topic of the debate is whether parents should be held responsible for their school-going children's discipline problems.

Who are the participants in the debate?

The participants in the debate are students from Mangina High School and Strathmore School, with the ladies from Mangina High School being in the proposition and the gentlemen from Strathmore School in the opposition.

What is the definition of 'parent' used in the debate?

In the debate, 'parent' is defined as a person who is the anchor of a community, a caregiver, and someone who takes care of children, according to the UN RS.

What are the discipline problems mentioned in the debate?

The discipline problems mentioned include disrespect, defiance, arrogance, bullying, and aggression.

What is the proposition team's stance on parents being accountable for their children's behavior?

The proposition team argues that parents should be held accountable for their school-going children's discipline problems, as it would encourage positive behavior at home and reflect on the child's behavior at school.

What alternative viewpoints does the opposition team present?

The opposition team suggests that it's not solely the parents' responsibility and proposes a return to communal parenting, where the whole community is involved in the upbringing of the child.

What is the opposition team's argument regarding the role of the community in child upbringing?

The opposition team argues for communal parenting, where the entire community shares the responsibility of raising a child, leading to a more diverse and dynamic upbringing.

What is the proposition team's response to the argument about the community's role in child discipline?

The proposition team argues that by holding parents accountable, the community will also take up their roles as 'parents' and contribute positively to the child's upbringing.

What is the opposition team's stance on the broad definition of 'parent' used by the proposition team?

The opposition team criticizes the broad definition of 'parent' used by the proposition team, arguing that it is an abuse of language and that not everyone can be held responsible for a child's discipline problems.

What is the final outcome of the debate?

The opposition team from Strathmore School wins the debate with 80%, while the proposition team from Mangina High School receives 71%.

Outlines

00:00

🗣️ Opening of the National Debates Semi-Finals

The video script begins with the introduction of a national debate semi-final event, where the host, Asperia Kapanga and Chris Boru, set the stage for a debate on whether parents should be held responsible for their school-going children's discipline problems. The debate is framed within the context of societal roles and expectations, with the proposition team from Mangina High School and the opposition from Strathmore School. The first speaker from the proposition, Da Chen, emphasizes the impact of parental accountability on children's behavior, suggesting that parents' actions at home reflect on their children's conduct at school. The speaker also touches on the broader societal influences, including the internet, and argues for the importance of parents in shaping their children's moral compass.

05:02

👨‍👩‍👧‍👦 The Role of Parents and Society in Child Upbringing

In this paragraph, the debate shifts to discuss the broader implications of parenting and societal influences on children. The speaker from the opposition argues for a communal approach to parenting, suggesting that the entire community should share the responsibility of raising children. The speaker cites statistics on marriage and pornography use in Kenya to highlight the challenges faced by modern parents and proposes that a collective effort is necessary to address these issues. The argument is made that parents are not the sole influencers of a child's behavior, and that societal factors, including peer influence and community, play a significant role in shaping a child's character.

10:04

👨‍👩‍👧 The Impact of Parental Behavior on Children

The speaker from the proposition continues to argue that parents should be held responsible for their children's discipline problems, using examples of parental behavior and its direct impact on children. The argument is made that children mimic their parents' actions, and thus, poor parenting can lead to negative outcomes. The speaker also references a study that links poor parenting to serial killers, suggesting that the roots of serious societal issues can be traced back to inadequate parenting. The proposition team emphasizes the need for parents to 'pull up their socks' and take their responsibilities seriously.

15:05

🤔 Questioning the Sole Responsibility of Parents

In this section, the opposition challenges the notion that parents should bear the sole responsibility for their children's actions. The speaker points out that various factors, including peer pressure and societal issues, contribute to a child's behavior. The argument is made that blaming parents exclusively is unrealistic and that a more holistic approach, considering the community's role, is necessary. The speaker also addresses the complexity of family dynamics and the challenges faced by single parents, suggesting that the responsibility should be shared among various members of society.

20:06

🏆 Final Arguments and Judgement

The final part of the script includes the closing arguments from both teams and the announcement of the winners. The proposition team reiterates the importance of parental responsibility in shaping children's behavior, while the opposition team maintains that the community at large should be involved in child upbringing. The judges' decision is revealed, with Strathmore School being awarded 80% of the votes, making them the winners of the debate. The hosts conclude the event and thank the audience for their engagement, highlighting the ongoing conversation on social media platforms.

Keywords

💡Debate

A debate is a formal discussion on a particular topic in which opposing arguments are put forward. In the context of the video, the debate revolves around the responsibility of parents for their school-going children's discipline problems. The debate format allows for an exploration of different perspectives on the issue, with teams presenting arguments for and against the motion.

💡Discipline Problems

Discipline problems refer to behaviors that violate rules or norms, such as disrespect, defiance, arrogance, bullying, and aggression. The video's debate centers on whether parents should be held accountable for these issues in their school-going children, suggesting that parental guidance and upbringing play a crucial role in a child's behavior.

💡Accountability

Accountability implies the responsibility to report, explain, and be answerable for one's actions. In the video, the proposition argues that parents should be held accountable for their children's behavior in school, implying that they should be responsible for instigating and maintaining good conduct.

💡Inner Voice

The 'inner voice' is a concept that refers to the internal dialogue or moral compass that guides a person's actions. The script mentions that what parents say to their children becomes their inner voice, suggesting that parental influence is formative in shaping a child's moral and behavioral standards.

💡Parenting

Parenting encompasses the practices and processes of raising and guiding children. The video's debate discusses the role of parents in shaping their children's behavior, with the opposition arguing for a broader communal approach to parenting that includes the community's role in a child's upbringing.

💡Community

Community refers to a group of people living in the same place or having a particular characteristic in common. In the context of the debate, the opposition argues for a communal parenting model where the entire community shares the responsibility of raising and disciplining children, rather than placing the burden solely on parents.

💡Mental Health Disorders

Mental health disorders are conditions that affect a person's thinking, feeling, mood, and behavior. The script mentions that mental health disorders can contribute to disciplinary problems in school-going children, suggesting that these issues are complex and may not be solely attributable to parental influence.

💡Peer Pressure

Peer pressure is the influence that people of similar age or status have on an individual to act in ways they might not otherwise. The video's debate touches on the role of peer pressure in shaping a child's behavior, with the opposition arguing that it is one of many factors that can influence a child's conduct, beyond parental control.

💡Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs)

The Sustainable Development Goals are a collection of 17 global goals set by the United Nations. The video's debate links the motion to SDG number four, which focuses on quality education. The debaters argue that discipline problems can affect a child's education, and thus the achievement of this goal, and that addressing these issues is a collective responsibility.

💡Responsibility

Responsibility refers to the state or fact of having a duty to deal with something or to account for one's actions. The debate's central question is whether parents should bear the responsibility for their children's disciplinary issues in school, with arguments presented on both sides regarding the extent and limits of this responsibility.

Highlights

The debate topic is whether parents should be held responsible for their school-going children's discipline problems.

Da Chen from Mangina High School defines 'parent' and 'child' in the context of the debate.

The proposition argues that parents' accountability can lead to positive behavior changes at home.

The opposition team from Strathmore School suggests that communal parenting and societal factors also influence children's behavior.

The debate highlights the impact of parental behavior on children's learning and social development.

The opposition points out the flaws in solely blaming parents for children's disciplinary issues.

The proposition emphasizes the role of parents as the first educators and moral guides for their children.

The opposition discusses the importance of communal responsibility in child upbringing.

The debate touches on the influence of societal issues like pornography on family dynamics and parenting.

The proposition argues for a return to communal parenting as a solution to the flaws in individual parenting.

The opposition team challenges the broad definition of 'parent' used by the proposition.

The debate considers the role of mental health in school-going children's disciplinary problems.

The proposition concludes by reiterating the importance of parental responsibility in shaping children's behavior.

The opposition concludes by advocating for a broader societal role in child upbringing beyond just parents.

The judges' decision awards Strathmore School with 80%, making them the winners of the debate.

The debate concludes with a call for continued conversation on social media platforms with the hashtag #GDCforSDGs.

Transcripts

ladies and gentlemen we are back at the

semi-finals of national debates in this

season the best of the best continue to

battle it out for who will be the

greatest debater of this season I am

your host Asperia kapanga and I am Chris

boru the bone of contention between our

intellectual teams today is parents

should be held responsible for their

schoolgoing children's discipline

problems in the proposition are the

ladies from mangina High School in the

opposition we have the gentlemen from

Strathmore

School propos number one you have 3

minutes to make a submissions what

parents say to children become their

inner voice my name is Da Chen from

mangina girls Mombasa

County who is a parent a parent

according to the UN RS is a person who

is the anchor of a community he's a

caregiver and who takes care of the

children being held responsible is to

consider somebody accountable schoolo in

this case is attending school and who's

a child a child is a person under the

age of 18 years discipline problems this

is when students act out in a variety of

ways impacting those around them and

they ability to learn in this case we

have discipline issues such as

disrespect Defiance arrogance bullying

and

aggression this motion parents should be

held responsible for their school

growing children School growing

children's discipline problems simply

means that parents in a certain way are

accountable for their schoolgoing

childrens and not and not only

responsible you should see that not that

only parents we have some other issues

such as the children themselves can be

blamed we have the internet can also be

blamed but parents in a in a certain

aspect must be

blamed so if a parent is to be held

accountable what do you think will

happen let me tell you if a parent knows

that he or she will be held accountable

for what he or her child is doing in

school like bullying that that parent

will act in a way that is positive in

back at home I'll talk about uh

sensitivity and critical thinking what

you do back at home will reflect on how

your child will behave our parents our

mothers spec specifically are the first

people we see the moment you start

speaking and seeing those who breastfeed

you they may not be your mothers they

may not be your fathers they may even be

your teachers in terms of your ability

to think and learn I'll talk about this

parents the first person you see I said

is your parent is your mom and when you

see your mom insulting your dad you do

not expect me to come from the womb

where there's no knowledge and learning

to come to this world and not insult

people like my mom does do you

understand so parents should be held

responsible for their moral upbringing

of their

children parents learn a children learn

a great deal about their social

behaviors from their parents I'll talk

about the teachers and the parents when

you go to school and your teachers tell

you uh insulting people is a crime you

tend to leave with that insulting people

is a crime when you go back home your

mom although your mom does not tell you

insulting people is a crime you learned

it from school right so that means that

parents who in this case are are

teachers and also your parents have made

you learn on a broader aspect the impact

of discipline in you so they should be

held responsible because if they're not

then no one will teach us discipline a

child is a child and does doesn't know

what every adult knows so certain leeway

need to be given and a child is of an

age sorry a child is a child and doesn't

know what adults know so when it reaches

reaches an age as 18 years and the child

is able to know what he or she should do

then you canot hold the parents

responsible but until then hold them

responsible Pastor kza you have 3

minutes to make your submissions what a

wonderful quote what parents say to

children become the inner voice I'd like

to ask you then so what do bad parents

leave with their

children getting married is a choice but

I believe parenting is a calling because

many

parents go out of their way way to give

for their

children however many parents today are

selfish which is against sdg number four

on reduced

inequality according to

standardmedia.co.ke approximately 9

million Kenyan men watch pornography on

a weekly basis according to Nairobi wire

in Kenya nearly as many women as men

indulge in

pornography

74.4% of people surveyed sorry stated

they considered marriage a joke I mean

what and the divorce rate in Kenya has

almost doubled in the past 3 years a

whooping three out of every five

children are born in families where

their parents never got married or the

man ran away so what does this mean for

Kenya the situation is

dire however divorce rates in Kenya are

half fat in the rest of subsaharan

Africa according to

www.nation.co.ke and the pornography

statistics Amiga

1.83%

globally now we all know the negative

effects pornography has on the brain and

human interaction especially between

parents and their children so what does

this say about how parents globally will

raise their children

today now I'm not just blaming parents

because today's children are way more

entitled than they used to be according

to the World Bank children served in the

UK Canada and Brazil felt like their

parents were obliged to take them to the

University of their choice if within

their means despite the cost now while

that's not a bad thing most parents of

today raised through hardship fail to

understand why their children behave the

way they do their discipline will

therefore be flawed as a failure to

understand is guar guaranteed to cause a

rift between the parents and their

children so what do we propose a return

to communal parenting that has not been

wiped out completely in Kenya and most

of Africa where where the whole

Community is responsible for taking part

in the upbringing of the child the more

people that are involved in the

upbringing of children the better life

Dynamic and diversity of World Views the

child is brought up with a study in

Chile done in 2017 according to the UCLA

brain mapping Center found that children

raised by an extended family were more

responsible and mentally stable compared

to their dual parent

counterparts so therefore I'd like to go

back to the quote that we were given at

the beginning what parents say to their

children becomes their inner voice this

is true and therefore parents shouldn't

be the only ones raising their children

because parents of today sadly have

their flaws based on the Society of

today we cannot give parents the

responsibility of the future generation

we are all responsible thank

you second proposal you have 3 minutes

for cross- examination well well well

you couldn't have said it better

according to our team we we Define

parents as a caregiver judge Mina you

are a parent judge Nancy you are a

parent Madame siin you're a parent for

in our team we stand and say that

parents are not the people who give

birth to you parents are are the

caregivers everyone in the community are

parents so Chris you can also be a

parent I hope you got that right parents

are everyone in the community so I like

to give you this example it's it's

something in our society right

now I give you an example of a parent

who comes home

drunk get that picture in your mind a

parent who's drunk and you know when

you're drunk you don't have control of

your mind you just speak things that you

don't know sometimes we tend to do these

thing in front of our children yeah and

then the child will grow up in the sense

that H so Mom and Dad they drink they

take alcohol so it's good Let me also

take a sip you'll find children when you

ask them why are you taking alcohol or

doing drugs and they'll tell

you so you see parents should be held

responsible for their schoolgoing

children discipline problems I like to

tell you that in a study presented by

the Journal of police and criminal

psychology it states that oneir of the

serial killers in the world if you look

at their history till the root you'll

get to see that they had poor parenting

and you know the effects of serial

killers they just kill it's like they

kill for pleasure but if you go down if

you narrow down your points you'll see

that the parents are to be blamed for

serial killers so we are saying that

poor parenting is something in the world

right now and the parents you need to

pull up your sock you really need have

you need to pull up your socks because

you're really failing us parents should

be held responsible yeah and as the the

SW people

say so us as children we have this habit

of mimicking people I'll mimic what you

do because I see like ah he's older than

me so we tend to

mimic yeah so as parents it's our

responsibility parents have said

teachers our Guidance the people who

gave birth to us is the responsibility

to act and give us everything we deserve

as children and yeah maybe and probably

will change our

ways seconda you have 3 minutes for

cross examination hello everyone it's

clear from the statements made there is

a lot of Chaos in this world because I'd

like to ask um if someone is taking

alcohol at home does this person not

have a house help where are their

siblings where is everyone else where

are the neighbors I would like i' like

to ask which kind of house this is

you're living in where you're completely

alone you know I'm really sickened by

the statements being made here because

this sdg this motion is very closely

linked to SG number four which is on

quality education when people have

disciplinary issues it's going to affect

their education and where do these

issues come from is it really just the

parents let's use a personal example I'm

in the choir and next week we have music

festivals some schools are going to be

sleeping away from home for a long time

now let's say there's a girl who decides

that she's going to have some fun and

she ends are pregnant do you expect the

principal to pick up his phone and say

hello Mama Sarah your daughter is

pregnant and I Blame You is it really

just her fault can we really just I

think it's quite clear how ridiculous

this is where are who are Sarah's

friends is Sarah a person with no

friends does she have no siblings where

is the community is Sarah living on her

own Island because I think it's

ridiculous to think for a second just

because you have bad parents you're

allowed to act badly let's say I had bad

parents does that give me an excuse to

come and burn this building down I have

friends who will advise me properly I

have teammates rather not teammates but

opponents who will see what I am doing

and who will stop me I don't really

understand why people are blaming it

completely on parents now let's look at

some of the reasons why children act out

some children have homes which are

horrific homes or they are abused and I

think that the nuclear family unit

really enhances this abuse because we

don't really have a chance to seek an

outside perspective let's look at the

communal family structure that African

society had let's say something bad is

happening to me my dad might not be

around but I have a sibling don't I I

have a cousin I have an entire group of

people who I was circumcised with am I

really going to lack I mean people I

need you to realize that there are so

many other problems it's not just

parents are you really going to tell the

single mother of eight you have to take

care of every single thing your child

takes care of no that woman is

struggling to feed eight mouths do you

really think she's going to talk to each

one of them and ask them what did you do

wrong today okay please tell me what did

you do wrong so I can advise you because

I think it's just nonsense you shouldn't

really blame only parents we have an

entire Society this entire room can spot

someone drinking alcohol in the corner

and go up to them and say perhaps you

should stop perhaps you'll develop a

problem now I'd like to show that um

standardmedia.co.ke ran a survey and

found that 64.4% of men deemed

themselves unprepared for fatherhood and

among the 15 to 19yearold demographic at

least one in five girls have an

unplanned pregnancy now what does this

tell us let's be honest most parents

don't know what they're doing they are

young and they are inexperienced and

sometimes we can't judge their

circumstances and therefore it's up to

the community to step up and really tell

us that perhaps you should be doing this

with your child if I happen to do

something Reckless I don't want a single

person to call my parents and say that

it is just your fault perhaps I was

influenced by my peers we really need to

go back to this method where we have

many influences on a child because a

child is like a clay pot and from a

person who has struggled with Pottery I

can tell you that every single every

single imprint really matters to that

child

the proposals have been asked if parents

are actually to blame then where does

that leave the street children and

orphans who are criminals but do not

have parents to take care of them or

guide them in life the opposers on the

other hand have been asked if it is a

responsibility of the whole Community to

bring up children in our society what do

they have to say about the negative

influences that are there in these same

communities proposer you have 3 minutes

to respond now basing on our explanation

of a parent a parent is a caregiver or a

teacher it can be biological biolog

biologically this parent can be entitled

to the child their teachers their

relatives all these are parents now to

answer your qu question Faith from kahia

girls this children these criminals are

we are blaming the parents yes because

the community are part are should play

their part should play should play their

part as parents so the

community when we blame parents the

community will take up their roles the

relatives in the communities the

teachers the neighbors if everyone

understands that we are all parents and

we have a responsibility to play then we

wouldn't have Street children wouldn't

have I mean we we wouldn't have

criminals now let's look at parenting

there are two ways the legal aspect and

the moral aspect in responsibility now

in the legal aspect we see that in

countries like UK USA Florida in

Michigan different states there are

legal I mean there are laws that bind

the parents to responsibility these are

the trany laws but in some aspects they

have not

worked now if we if we emphasize on

these parents to play their

responsibility they wouldn't have this

Le we wouldn't have the legal aspect we

didn't we do not need laws to bind them

now we'll move to the moral aspect of it

traditional African society where

everyone was a parent to a child you see

a parent doing a m i mean you see a

child doing a mistake and EV I mean

anyone was allowed to to rectify the

child from a sister to a brother we're

not defining a parent from Wikipedia or

um the dictionary meaning we are putting

parentship according to the UN a

caregiver and a teacher I am a parent to

my sister and I'm proud of that if I'm

held accountable then the next day I see

my sister watching pornography as as

they say then I will be entitled to make

sure that I set it straight for my

sister that pornography rhy is not the

way we are the future parents now if we

hold each one and everyone of us

accountable through proposing standing

firm with me on this motion then we are

sure that parental skills will be

instilled in the ne in the Next

Generation we be sure that those bad

parents that we have wouldn't be there

you can't tell me that just because we

have a drunker father that's mean the

societ at large has failed no there are

the there are good people in the society

as are we saying the implementation is

easy no we we might not achieve 100% but

the 90% is enough my name is freebi cazo

from mangina girls strongly oppostion

strongly proposing the motion at stake

thank

youa you have 3 minutes to respond

ladies and gentlemen it is honestly so

frust ating to hear our The Proposal

saying that everyone in society is a

parent God forbid that I go home today

to my parents and tell them mom and dad

I am a parent now I can't imagine what

sort of H hell will be raised at home

when I issue such a

statement I also need to redefine what

they've said a child to be a child isn't

just someone between the age of Zer and

18 I don't cease to be my part child the

day I turn 18 a child is merely The

Offspring of a human

being so when I am 25 when I'm 30 when

I'm 40 I'll still be my parents child

now I was asked about negative

Personalities in society and how that

relates to commun communal parenting

well not everyone in society is bad in

fact it's a few bad apples in the entire

sack that is society we can't let a few

bad people will deter from communal

parenting just because they may have a

bad

influence I've there's a phrase that

I've always heard called that says kill

them with goodness well if we drown them

out with the good influences they won't

have time for the

bad now you may ask what else can we

blame

for disciplinary problems among child

schoolgoing children well you

researchers at the University of

Minnesota at minap police they conducted

a survey among 3,000 teachers in the

state of Minnesota in the US what they

found was that 70% of teachers blame

mental health disorders on the dis

forther disciplinary problems now we

live in a country where according to the

University of Nairobi 34 34% of people

have a mental illness that means that on

this stage at least two people according

to these statistics suffer from one

mental disorder another we also live and

that's not meant as an insult it's a

very serious case people struggle with

things like depression on a daily basis

and we live in a society where the

mention of mental illness draws laughter

from a crowd how are such people

supposed to say that they have a problem

and get help for it no they can't so

instead they'll go to school and act out

and no one will know why and we did be

fair to blame the parents for mental

illness that the society has stigmatized

so much that they don't feel a teas

with talking about it that would be

immoral and it would be horribly wrong

you also can't blame parents for

negative peer pressure it has been sung

to me by my parents that I should keep

good company if I decide to defy them

and join a bond of Rascals in school

will you blame my parents for not

guiding me in the right way you really

can't a study at D University was done

and found that 65% of students blamed

their friends for introducing them to

alcohol are the parents to blame for

that shall we blame the parents for

everything no that's making them escape

goat for a societal issue that isn't as

simple as the proposers want us to

believe my name is Victory Waki thank

[Applause]

[Music]

you proposition you have 1 minute to

give your final submission okay so all

of us here are under a school either

you're from kahia you're from mangina

girls you're even from stro school all

of us here are are under our various

parents who are our teachers so when we

decide to boycott anything here who will

be held responsible our parents who are

who our teachers so parents should be

held responsible for their schoolgoing

children and I repeat schoolgoing

children discipline problems you know I

am the kind of parent my mother was to

me I will be the kind of parent my

mother was to me and the par you should

understand that Parent Parenthood is

almost changing its roles nowadays

because people don't want to accept the

blame they don't want to blame

themselves as parents for the discipline

problems that are taking that are are

taking course in this nation at this

moment they tend to blame it on other

factors and one thing that most people

don't understand is this the moment you

start blaming someone else from for your

failures you start failing so we have

failed as parents because we have

decided to blame other factors apart

from parents which is one of the factors

that are to be held responsible for our

and I mean my discipline problems thank

[Applause]

[Music]

you oosers you have one minute for a

final submission there's still a lot of

confusion present but don't worry I'm

here I think that we should all look at

the atmology of the word parent because

it comes from the Latin word par and Par

means to bring forth and while the

motion does mention parents it doesn't

really mention parenting because

parenting can be done by basically

anyone if my mother were to pass away

and so were my father and I had uh let's

say a sibling who was like 3 years old

then I would definitely be their parent

however we can't simply call everyone a

parent because that's just abusing

language and the moment we start making

things up we start believing in

delusions such as parents being the only

ones responsible for our disciplinary um

faults now let's say I did something bad

the same example they've given are you

really telling me that I won't be held

responsible no one here will be held

responsible that seems a bit unfair

because I think that everyone has a role

to play in the morality of society

everyone has a very special part to play

sg11 sustainable cities and communities

how are we ever going to achieve this if

we're simply going to absolve ourselves

of guilt if we're going to let people

keep bad friends if we're going to let

everyone act however they want to no

matter how badly just cuz they don't

have the term parent my name is Mark

itaka and I pray for a better Society

[Music]

I think I'll give credit to wa is d stro

uh the three gentlemen you're smart guys

interestingly when you take the stage to

speak I have to stop what I'm doing and

listen to you and that is the mark of a

great debater um very smart the way you

are analyzing issues is very intelligent

you're the embodiment of the great

debater are the Great Debaters rather

and you remind me of season two Great

Debaters tro school still I I mean they

left an impact in my mind and today I

think I've Just Seen season 2 reborn in

season 9 so to speak and we have

excellent debators uh mangina school I

think you are good the problem is the

broad definition of the word parents I

think you took a very a dangerous

direction or a direction that did not

favor you that much if you look at

everyone in terms of a parent then the

question is what direction are you

giving to the motion how are you

intending to approach the topic and how

do you intend to reason to the end and

are we sure we want to hold parents to

account I don't

know Daisy you began pretty well and I

think the challenge for the other team

members is when your opponents came onto

stage and uh challenged some of the um

submissions that you have made and so

you you wanted to defend your position

but in the process got lost and you know

when you then gave a very broad

definition of parents which was not

where you began then you kind of lost us

um but I think overall you have put up a

good fight um for Strathmore um I think

one of the things that I admire about

your team is the teamwork and the way

that there's such a Lo logical

progression from the first debater to

the last

debater um one of the things that I

liked is that uh I think for Joseph you

spend quite a lot of time just setting

the stage for your team members and make

it very easy for them them now to come

on and build on the arguments that

you've

made for this

debate M girls the judges saw it fit to

award

you 71% let's give them a round of

applause stos

School the judges awarded

you 80% making you the winners of this

debate

congratulations to both semifinalists

and to sto congratulations for being the

greater Debaters in this particular

debate dear audience thank you so much

for staying tuned to watch the show that

gives you the best of high school

debates it does not end here cuz the

conversation still continues across our

social media platforms with the hasht

GDC for sdgs until the next episode I've

been your host Chris B and I am Esperia

kapanga see you at the finals

[Music]

[Music]

[Music]