Cambridge IGCSE History 0470 Russia and USSR Depth Study Overview

Summary

El colapso del zarismo en 1917, la consolidación del poder bolchevique y las políticas de Stalin forman el núcleo de este análisis histórico. La dificultad de gobernar un territorio vasto y diverso, la influencia de la Revolución de 1905 y la Primera Guerra Mundial en la caída del zar, así como el papel crucial de figuras como Lenin y Trotsky en la toma de poder, son explorados. Además, se examina la efectividad del gobierno provisional, la victoria en la guerra civil, el impacto de las políticas económicas de Stalin y cómo estas transformaciones afectaron a la población soviética.

Takeaways

• 🏰 La administración del territorio vasto y diverso de Rusia era un desafío para el zar, con dificultades de comunicaciones y una sociedad multiétnica.
• 👥 La política de rusificación del zar generó resistencia en las distintas etnias del Imperio, dificultando aún más su gobierno.
• 💥 La revolución de 1905 fue un punto de inflexión, donde la modernización y las condiciones laborales desastrosas provocaron un gran descontento.
• 🇯🇵 La guerra con Japón resultó en una humillación para Rusia y debilitó la posición del zar.
• 🌐 La Primera Guerra Mundial dejó a Rusia extremadamente debilitada y fue un factor clave en la caída del zar.
• 🔄 La revolución de marzo de 1917 fue exitosa porque todas las capas de la sociedad rusa se unieron contra el zar.
• 🕍 La incompetencia del gobierno provisional y su continua participación en la guerra contribuyeron a su derrocamiento.
• 🚂 Trotsky fue fundamental en la toma de poder por los bolcheviques y en la victoria en la guerra civil.
• 🛑 La NEP fue un intento de estabilizar la economía de Rusia tras la guerra, pero fue finalmente reemplazada por planes más centralizados.
• 🏭 Stalin se convirtió en líder a pesar de las advertencias de Lenin, utilizando la política y la manipulación para consolidar su poder.
• 🗑 Las purgas de Stalin fueron una forma de eliminar enemigos y consolidar su control totalitario sobre la Unión Soviética.
• 🌟 A pesar de las consecuencias humanitarias y económicas, las políticas económicas de Stalin transformaron a la Unión Soviética en una superpotencia.

Q & A

¿Por qué colapsó el zarismo en 1917?

El colapso del zarismo en 1917 se debió a varios factores, incluyendo la dificultad de gobernar un territorio tan extenso y diverso como Rusia, la falta de industrialización y comunicaciones, y la resistencia a la política de rusificación impuesta por el zar.

¿Cómo sobrevivió el zarismo el golpe de estado en 1905?

El zarismo sobrevivió al golpe de estado de 1905 debido a que, a pesar de la presión de los revolucionarios y las demandas de mejoras sociales, el zar Nicholas II implementó algunas reformas y cambió la constitución, lo que le dio un respiro temporal.

¿Cómo se debilitó el zarismo por la Primera Guerra Mundial?

La Primera Guerra Mundial debilitó enormemente al zarismo debido a la pérdida de vidas y recursos, y al descontento popular por la gestión de la guerra por parte del zar.

¿Qué factores contribuyeron al éxito de la Revolución de marzo de 1917?

La Revolución de marzo de 1917 fue exitosa debido a la unión de diferentes sectores de la sociedad rusa, incluyendo trabajadores, campesinos y soldados, quienes se cansaron del zarismo y buscaron un cambio.

¿Cómo logró Lenin volver a Rusia y qué impacto tuvo?

Lenin regresó a Rusia en un tren secreto financiado por los alemanes, y su regreso marcó el inicio de la lucha para derrocar al gobierno provisional y establecer el comunismo.

¿Quiénes fueron las figuras clave en la toma de poder por los bolcheviques en noviembre de 1917?

Las figuras clave en la toma de poder por los bolcheviques fueron Lenin y Trotsky. Mientras Lenin lideraba la revolución ideológica, Trotsky fue el cerebro detrás de la toma militar de la capital.

¿Cómo logró la Unión Soviética ganar la Guerra Civil Rusa?

La Unión Soviética ganó la Guerra Civil Rusa gracias a la organización y estrategia militar de Trotsky, quien fue el padre del Ejército Rojo que derrotó a las fuerzas anti-bolcheviques.

¿Qué fue el Nuevo Política Económica y cuál fue su impacto?

El Nuevo Política Económica fue una política de laissez-faire que permitió cierta libertad económica para estabilizar la economía de Rusia después de la guerra civil, pero fue considerada un retroceso por Lenin y posteriormente abandonada.

¿Cómo se consolidó el poder de Stalin en la Unión Soviética?

Stalin se consolidó como líder de la Unión Soviética utilizando tácticas de política interna y manipulación, incluso en contra de la voluntad de Lenin, y eliminando a sus oponentes para asegurar su posición.

¿Cuál fue el objetivo de los planes quinquenales de Stalin?

El objetivo de los planes quinquenales de Stalin era la industrialización rápida de la Unión Soviética para fortalecerla y protegerla de futuras invasiones, especialmente de parte de Alemania.

¿Cómo afectó la colectivización de las tierras a la población soviética?

La colectivización de las tierras bajo Stalin resultó en el genocidio de millones de ucranianos y la represión de los campesinos, pero también permitió a Stalin controlar los medios de producción y aumentar la producción agrícola.

Outlines

00:00

🏰 Colapso del zarismo en Rusia (1905-1941)

El primer párrafo explora las razones del colapso del régimen zarista en 1917. Se enfatiza en la dificultad de gobernar una Rusia vasta y diversa con infraestructuras de comunicaciones limitadas y una sociedad multiétnica. La política de 'russificación' generó resistencia en las minorías étnicas. Además, la sobrevivencia del zarismo a la revolución de 1905 y cómo la Primera Guerra Mundial debilitó enormemente al zarismo, llevándolo a su fin, son temas clave. Se menciona la influencia de personajes como Sergei Witte, Rasputin y la participación de Trotski en la revolución.

05:03

🔥 La consolidación del poder bolchevique

El segundo párrafo se centra en cómo los bolcheviques, liderados por Lenin y Trotski, ganaron poder y consolidaron su统治 en Rusia tras la revolución de marzo de 1917. Se discute la ineficacia del gobierno provisional y cómo su continua participación en la guerra resultó en su declive. La revolución de octubre de 1917 y la posterior victoria en la guerra civil, con la creación del Ejército Rojo por Trotski, son aspectos clave. También se menciona el impacto del 'Nuevo Política Económica' (NEP) y cómo fue un paso atrás hacia el capitalismo para estabilizar la situación económica del país.

10:04

🛠 Políticas económicas y represalias de Stalin

El tercer párrafo aborda la ascensión de Stalin y cómo utilizó la burocracia y la purgas para consolidar su poder, a pesar de las advertencias de Lenin en su testamento. Se describen las políticas de Stalin para controlar la Unión Soviética a través del terror y la violencia, incluyendo el uso de campos de concentración y la represión general. Además, se discuten las políticas económicas de Stalin, como los planes quinquenales y la colectivización agrícola, y su impacto en la población, especialmente durante el Holodomor en Ucrania.

15:04

🌐 Impacto en la población soviética y superpotencia

El cuarto y último párrafo reflexiona sobre el impacto de las políticas de Stalin en la población soviética y cómo estas transformaron a la Unión Soviética en una superpotencia. Se cuestiona si los sacrificios en términos de vidas y sufrimiento fueron justificados por los logros económicos y militares. Se explora la posibilidad de que la Unión Soviética pudiera haberse fortalecido sin tales medidas extremas y se considera el papel de factores externos, como el invierno, en la resistencia al avance alemán en la Segunda Guerra Mundial. Finalmente, se invita a reflexionar sobre el bienestar y la percepción de la población soviética ante estos cambios.

Keywords

💡zarus regime

El término 'zarus regime' se refiere al gobierno del zar en Rusia antes de la revolución de 1917. Este régimen enfrentó dificultades significativas para gobernar un territorio tan extenso y diverso como el Imperio Ruso. En el guion, se menciona que el zarus regime tenía problemas para administrar Rusia, enfrentándose a retos como la falta de infraestructura y la diversidad étnica, lo que llevó a la implementación de políticas de 'russificación'.

💡revolución de 1905

La 'revolución de 1905' fue un intento fallido de cambio político en Rusia que presenció el surgimiento de varios movimientos revolucionarios y la respuesta del zar Nicholas II. En el guion, se destaca cómo la modernización llevada a cabo por Sergei Witte y la decisión del zar de involucrarse en la guerra con Japón contribuyeron a la tensión que llevó a la revolución.

💡primera guerra mundial

La 'primera guerra mundial' tuvo un impacto devastador en el zarus regime y en Rusia en general. El guion menciona que el zar Nicholas II, al ir al frente para animar a las tropas, dejó atrás a su esposa y a Rasputin, lo que llevó a un descuido del gobierno y a la eventual destitución y asesinato del zar por parte de los bolcheviques.

💡revolución de marzo de 1917

La 'revolución de marzo de 1917', también conocida como la revolución de febrero en el calendario juliano, fue un evento clave que llevó al colapso del zarus regime. El guion describe cómo diferentes sectores de la sociedad rusa, incluyendo trabajadores, campesinos y soldados, se unieron para oponerse al zar Nicholas II.

💡gobierno provisional

El 'gobierno provisional' fue el gobierno interino establecido después de la revolución de marzo de 1917 y antes de la revolución de octubre. Aunque intentó llevar a Rusia por una senda democrática, el guion señala que su incapacidad para sacar a Rusia de la guerra y su decisión de atacar resultaron en su fracaso.

💡bolcheviques

Los 'bolcheviques' fueron un partido político revolucionario que eventualmente se hizo con el poder en Rusia después de la revolución de octubre de 1917. El guion destaca la figura de Lenin y su papel crucial en la destrucción del gobierno provisional y la consolidación del poder bolchevique.

💡revolución de octubre

La 'revolución de octubre' fue el segundo evento revolucionario en 1917 que llevó a los bolcheviques al poder. El guion menciona que, a diferencia de la revolución de marzo, esta revolución no pasó directamente del zar al comunismo, sino que hubo un periodo de gobierno provisional entremedio.

💡trótsky

Leon 'Trótsky' fue un líder revolucionario clave en la revolución rusa y en la consolidación del poder soviético. El guion destaca su papel como estratega militar y su papel crucial en la toma del poder y la fundación del Ejército Rojo.

💡NEP

El 'NEP', o New Economic Policy, fue una política económica implementada por Lenin para estabilizar la economía de la Unión Soviética después de la guerra civil. El guion describe cómo el NEP, que permitía prácticas capitalistas limitadas, fue visto como un retiro temporal del comunismo hacia el capitalismo para recuperar la economía del país.

💡estalinismo

El 'estalinismo' se refiere al período de la historia soviética dominado por Joseph Stalin, quien se convirtió en el líder supremo después de Lenin. El guion describe cómo Stalin usó la política y la manipulación para consolidar su poder, a pesar de las advertencias de Lenin en su testamento.

💡planes quinquenales

Los 'planes quinquenales' fueron una serie de planes económicos desarrollados por Stalin con el objetivo de industrializar rápidamente a la Unión Soviética. El guion explica que Stalin creía que la industrialización rápida era esencial para proteger a Rusia de una invasión alemana, lo que eventualmente se demostraría como una premisa correcta.

Highlights

The difficulty of administering a vast and diverse territory like Russia before 1914.

The multiethnic society of the Russian Empire and the policy of russification.

The 1905 Revolution and its causes due to modernization and social unrest.

How Nicholas II's decision to start a war with Japan backfired and contributed to his downfall.

The impact of World War I on weakening the Russian Empire and leading to its collapse.

The success of the March 1917 Revolution due to widespread dissatisfaction with the Tsar.

The establishment of the Provisional Government between the February and October Revolutions.

The ineffective rule of the Provisional Government in 1917 and its failure to end the war.

The role of Lenin and Trotsky in the Bolsheviks' seizure of power in November 1917.

Trotsky's pivotal role in the military takeover and the establishment of the Soviet Union.

The reasons behind the Bolsheviks' victory in the Russian Civil War.

The introduction of the New Economic Policy (NEP) as a temporary retreat to capitalism.

Stalin's rise to power despite Lenin's warnings against him.

Stalin's use of purges to eliminate enemies and consolidate power.

The methods Stalin used to control the Soviet Union, including terror and the secret police.

Stalin's economic policies, including the Five-Year Plans and their focus on heavy industry.

The collectivization policy aimed at breaking independent farmers and gaining control of agriculture.

The impact of Stalin's policies on the Soviet people, including the genocide of the Ukrainian people.

The transformation of the Soviet Union into a superpower under Stalin's rule.

The debate over whether Stalin's policies were worth the immense human and material cost.

The question of whether Stalin saved the Soviet Union or caused more harm than good.

The effects of Stalin's changes on the mentality, psychology, and well-being of the Soviet people.

Transcripts

e

you for depth study C Russia 1905 to

1941 the first section is why did the

zarus regime collapse in

1917 the focus points how well did the

zarus regime deal with the difficulties

of ruling Russia up to

1914 so this is going to be a section

where you're going to say oh Russia is

incredibly big it's difficult to

administer such a territory

it was not industrialized so there were

not railroads yet they were being built

under Sergey Vita there were

Communications problems between Asian

Russia and European Russia because there

wasn't any telegraphs or telephone lines

yet you know and they were being built

as well so it was quite a difficult

situation there it was a multiethnic

society Russians are actually the

minority in the Zar Empire they're about

49% are almost 50 but ethnic minorities

actually outnumber the ethnic Russians

when I say ethnic minorities I mean fins

Finland was part of the Russian Empire

at this time ukrainians um the Baltic

states USCS kazak Central Asian

countries like that Caucasian countries

like Georgia azerbijan Armenia uh

there's a lot of ethnic groups within

Russia itself uh

tatars um English all these types of

people chin so it is incredibly diverse

and this is why a policy of

russification is set up by the Zar and

there's a lot of resistance to that

basically making people get rid of their

languages and customs and religions and

stuff like that so there was a lot of

resistance and push back and it was

difficult to govern such a diverse

population with these autocratic means

the second bullet point says how did

thear survive the 1905

Revolution in 1905 Russia was exploding

because of the modernization campaign

that Sergey Vita was undertaking it

exacted a terrible price on the

peasantry the working conditions were

terrible uh social revolutionaries

marxists they all wanted to overthrow

the Zar there were nationalists of the

different ethnic groups that also didn't

want to be part of the Russian Empire so

Nicholas said to himself oh why don't I

start a war with Japan we'll take it in

3 days

well I'm sorry that's another Zar that

said that for a different country but he

definitely thought he would wipe the

floor with Japan and gain a lot of

popularity through this he was wrong

Japan was no pushover and they humiliate

Russia multiple times the third one how

far was thear weakened by the first

world war the answer is tremendously it

is his downfall he goes to the front to

see what's going on and provide some

morale to the Troops even though he has

no military modern military background

he's very good at parades and wearing

uniforms and stuff like that but when it

comes to going up against the German

officer Corp he's no match for that so

we will see him go to the front leave

his wife and Rasputin who is a very

colorful character in Russian history

they're in charge and they just cause

Havoc back home and eventually by tying

his fate to World War I Russia losing he

will be deposed and eventually killed by

the Bolsheviks why was the revolution of

March 1917

successful you'll see all of the aspects

of Russian Society unite to say this guy

is terrible the workers in St Petersburg

which is the capital at that time the

peasants in the countryside the soldiers

just start to leave they desert on mass

letting the Germans just kind of go

deeper and deeper into the country the

aristocracy sees that the country is

slipping away so they also start to

think of replacing the Zar they want to

keep the monarchy but they want to get

rid of Nicholas but the March Revolution

is a revolution of the democratic forces

in Russia led by Alexander kinsky so

Lenin will start to play a role a bit

later on but this first Revolution you

have to understand it doesn't go from

the Zar to the Communists the there is a

provisional government in between the

March Revolution and the October

Revolution I I like to use the the

Russian dates I'm sorry so if you're

going to go March you have to say

November but I always say the Fe

February Revolution and the October

Revolution because the calendar is

different between Western calendars and

Russian calendars Gregorian and Julian

so the second section how did the bolics

gained power and how did they

consolidate their rule first Focus Point

how effectively did the provisional

government rule Russia in

1917 the answer is not well

um first things first they did not take

Russia out of the war or they did not

even just play a defensive War they

decided to go on the attack which was

completely idiotic looking back on it

and it led to their downfall so World

War I killed the zaris Empire and the

failure of the provisional government to

get out of the war or to at least

minimize Russia's role LED it to a

similar fate Lenin comes back from

Switzerland the Germans shoot him in in

a secret train and he's causing Havoc

from day one so it's his goal to destroy

the provisional government and he

ultimately

succeeds why were the bulvik able to

seize power in November 1917 I want to

mention a few names here of course we

have lennin but we also have trosky you

need to know who trosky is he is the

brains behind the military takeover of

the capital and the installing of the

petrograd Soviet and all of these other

types of things so troski is a

tremendously important figure you need

to put him up there with Lenin as

probably the number two guy who's the

most responsible for creating the Soviet

Union Stalin does a great job of

eliminating trosky from the history

books but for those that know real

Russian history you need to know tronky

bullet point three why did the

Bolsheviks win the civil war well

speaking of trosky not only did he set

up the petrograd Soviet and the MRC the

military revolutionary Council and all

these other things to uh kill the

provisional government trosky also goes

on to win the Russian Civil War for the

bulvik the Red Army he's the father of

the Red Army which destroys the white

Army and the anti-bolshevik forces the

last bullet point for section two how

far was the New Economic Policy a

success you need to know the term War

communism War communism was the economic

policy for the Bolsheviks to win the

civil war after that Russia's in

complete ruins uh there's famines

there's disease outbreaks there's rapid

devaluation of the currency it's just a

mess so they decide to bring in this New

Economic Policy which is basically

capitalism it's a limited version of

capitalism in order to get people to get

food back into the big cities so it was

a complete disaster and within a few

years the New Economic Policy manages to

stabilize the situation it is a retreat

Lenin sees it as a temporary Retreat to

capitalism but in this kind of

transitional period it's an interesting

idea to think what would have happened

if the New Economic Policy would have

stuck around we shall never know but

after the New Economic Policy is killed

by Stalin we see the 5-year plan model

which is used for decades and decades in

the Soviet

Union speaking of Stalin how did Stalin

gain and hold on to power section three

why did Stalin not trosky emerg as

Lenin's

successor Stalin was a master bureaucrat

he was in these days his office politics

would be just off the charts he emerged

as the leader of the Soviet Union even

after Lenin wrote down in his will and

testament do not let this guy become the

leader do not put him in charge trosky

had way more accomplishments father of

the Red Army he was up there equaling

Lenin almost in many ways but Stalin who

is a very minor figure manages to use

politics and his position as party

secretary to stack the deck in his favor

and eventually outmaneuver everyone so

playing politics that's how Stalin

became the Undisputed leader of the

Soviet Union and ruthlessness just

killing exiling eliminating his enemies

his ruthlessness can be indicated here

why did Stalin launch the purges to get

rid of his enemies to consolidate power

all these famous Stalin Quotes no man no

problem death of one man is a tragedy

death of a million men is a statistic he

had a very cold calculating way to just

murder everyone to hang on to power so

he does it a few times during his rule

but this first Purge is to get rid of

all the old guard the guys that actually

successfully carried out the Russian

Revolution and to put in his own version

of how things should be what methods did

Stalin use to control the Soviet Union

terror terror and murder um those are

the most used tools in his toolkit he

also was using foreign experts so

Americans and British and French and

Germans and all these people during the

Great Depression so looking into The

Five-Year Plan era of Stalin 1928 after

that and then the great crash of Wall

Street in 1929 we see a lot of American

companies even though America is very

opposed to Communism and doesn't stop

American companies from trying to make

money in the Soviet Union so he uses

foreign experts he uses spying to steal

Secrets he uses uh the bureaucracy of

the Soviet Union and secret police nkvd

GPR all these different types of apparat

chicks as they're known in Russia these

um secret policemen and people that are

loyal to Stalin anybody who even hinted

at being unloyal would be eliminated so

there's a lot of different methods you

can write a great essay for depth study

coursework with this particular question

so the methods are manyfold but at the

end of the day force and violence are

the main levers using concentration

camps goog systems and stuff like that

as well so this is something that you

can really sink your teeth into if you

want to write a long essay lastly in

this section how complete was Stalin's

control over the Soviet Union by

1941 it's pretty complete uh I would

have a I would have a difficult time

arguing against it is a pure

totalitarian state religion is

eliminated all other parties are

eliminated the Communist Party of the

Soviet Union itself has been purged

repeatedly uh the Red Army is completely

under his thumb all of the industry

there's no businessmen he controls

everything so you can make a balanced

argument for it sure but he had way more

individual power than the other

dictators of the time even Hitler and

musolini and these types of people were

checked by other forces unlike Stalin

and the last one what was the impact of

Stalin's economic

policies first one was why did Stalin

introduce the five-year

plans Stalin believed without rapid

industrialization Germany would come

invade Russia and take it over so he was

quite right with the intentions of

Germany so he thought any slowdown of

industrialization was treason and that

would leave the country vulnerable and

the revolution vulnerable to the Germans

so looking at the fiveyear plans you

should know the first one is just all

Heavy industry the second one is all

Heavy industry in in different aspects

Communications and stuff like that but

it's all bullets and tanks and steel and

guns and uh railroads and all that kind

of stuff so no consumer goods no real

care about the welfare of the Soviet

citizen just all weaponry and heavy

industry next one why did Stalin

introduce

collectivization it was to break the

independent farmer and again it's about

control everything about Stalin is about

control no one else can have power but

him collectivization was also

ideologically more sound than having

individual for-profit Farms so

collectivization was a big Target for

Stalin to gain control of all the means

of production and the crop for wheat and

other harvests we will see the genocide

of the Ukrainian people the homore the

death by

hunger in collectivization so millions

of people were killed either by bullets

or by starvation and and uh the impact

of this is becoming more and more known

the hore when I was growing up this

wasn't mentioned in my high school

history class European history but now

we see especially with current events

the hore is being recognized as a

genocide by more and more countries

every year how successful were Stalin's

economic

changes this is one thing you can say

about Stalin he did create a superpower

by the time of his death

the Soviet Union is a superpower one of

only two with the USA so you can't argue

with the strengthening of the country

that Stalin did what you can argue is

the insane price that was paid in lives

in wasted material just

absolute chaos for many many years in

large parts of the country so it's up to

you to make a well argumented well

evident and well explained essay to say

was it all worth it was was the cost in

lives and material and misery all worth

it do you think Stalin actually saved

the Soviet Union that's another huge

question could all of this suffering

been avoided and still have the Soviet

Union be part of the winning team on

World War II um it's an interesting wh

if you shouldn't get too deep into wha

ifs of course uh in IGCSE history but

you can give evidence saying that Stalin

ignored the warnings that Hitler was

going to invade he shot all of his most

competent officers in the Red Army and

he really caused havoc in the armed

forces allowing the Germans to swoop in

and just have success after success in

operation Barbarosa in the early months

but another thing that you can't give

Stalin credit for was General winter the

were at the gates of Moscow and they

just ran out of good weather to continue

their offensive so yeah you can say

Stalin created a superpower no question

a country of metal the Man of Steel as

he named himself but there are other

factors to say Stalin caused more harm

than good last question is quite

interesting in the section and in the

overall course how were the Soviet

people affected by these changes so was

Stalin just a red Zar was he just a

communist ideology version of Nicholas

II an autocrat that just wanted things

done the way that he wanted them and

there was no real gains for the Soviet

people there was only more hardship toil

in factories toil in the field

repression but on the other hand you can

say the Soviet people did gain a lot of

power internationally and were able to

safeguard their country from any further

attacks by gaining a powerful military

and Industrial base and also eventually

gaining nuclear weapons so again I think

maybe this is my favorite question of

the whole course the whole depth study

just the effects on the mentality the

psychology the overall

well-being of the Soviet people the

Soviet people again compris of dozens

and dozens of different people not just

Russians but Ukraine Ians of Bellar

Russians movans of the Baltic states

Central asians caucasians people in the

Far East of Russia it is so many

different kinds of people how were all

of these people affected by these change

how were women affected how were

children affected it is a fascinating

question to ask

[Music]

[Applause]

[Music]

he

[Music]