20 Mei 2025

Summary

In this episode of 'Ngobrol, Bareng Kita-Kita,' hosts Maya and Elsinta delve into a heated debate about the pros and cons of smoking versus vaping, a topic widely discussed among the youth. The conversation features guests from both sides—team 'Rokok' and team 'Vape'—who present their arguments about health, regulation, and environmental impact. While both sides agree that neither option is ideal, they emphasize the importance of understanding the risks involved. Ultimately, the episode encourages listeners to make informed decisions, highlighting that neither smoking nor vaping is a healthy solution.

Takeaways

• 😀 The podcast discusses the debate between smoking cigarettes and vaping, focusing on the health, environmental, and social implications of both.
• 😀 The hosts emphasize that the episode is not promoting smoking or vaping, but instead providing information for listeners to make informed decisions.
• 😀 Both smoking and vaping have negative health consequences, but vaping's long-term effects are still not fully understood.
• 😀 Smoking has a long history and cultural significance in many places, including Indonesia, where it is considered part of the local culture.
• 😀 Vaping, on the other hand, is a modern trend often popularized through social media platforms like TikTok, and is primarily seen as a 'cool' activity among younger generations.
• 😀 Both smoking and vaping contribute to environmental pollution, with cigarette butts being one of the largest types of litter, while vaping devices and their batteries add to waste.
• 😀 There is a belief that vaping could be a less harmful alternative to smoking, but the risks are not yet fully researched and may involve hidden dangers.
• 😀 While smoking is regulated, vaping products often lack consistent regulations, leading to issues like illegal and potentially harmful vape juices.
• 😀 The hosts highlight the importance of education around both smoking and vaping, as some young people may start vaping due to its perceived trendiness rather than understanding the risks involved.
• 😀 The key message is that neither smoking nor vaping should be considered as healthy alternatives, and the best option is to avoid both to protect health and the environment.

Q & A

What is the main topic discussed in this podcast episode?

The main topic discussed is the comparison between smoking cigarettes and vaping, focusing on their health, environmental, and social impacts.

Do the hosts promote smoking or vaping?

No, the hosts make it clear that they are not promoting smoking or vaping. They are only providing insights into both to help listeners make informed decisions.

What is Aisyah's argument in favor of smoking cigarettes over vaping?

Aisyah argues that smoking has a long history, is well-researched, and its risks are transparent. She believes that smokers are aware of the risks and take them willingly, while vaping lacks clear long-term research.

How does Shalom justify smoking despite its health risks?

Shalom points out that while smoking is dangerous, it is heavily regulated, and its risks are well-known. He suggests that vaping, with its unclear liquid compositions and potential safety issues, may not be safer.

What does Rani argue about vaping as an alternative to smoking?

Rani argues that vaping is marketed as a less harmful alternative to smoking, as it allows for better control over nicotine levels and avoids the combustion process that produces harmful chemicals like carbon monoxide.

What concern does Kaina raise about vaping devices?

Kaina acknowledges that while vaping can help people quit smoking, many cheap, unregulated vape devices are causing harm. She emphasizes the need for proper regulation to ensure safety.

What is the environmental impact of both smoking and vaping, according to the hosts?

Both smoking and vaping contribute to environmental harm. Smoking creates significant waste, especially cigarette butts, while vaping devices and their batteries are increasingly being discarded improperly, leading to environmental pollution.

How does vaping culture differ from smoking culture in terms of social influence?

Vaping is often associated with trends and is popular among younger people, especially on social media platforms like TikTok, where it's seen as a social activity. In contrast, smoking has a more established cultural history and is often associated with older generations.

What is the primary takeaway the hosts want listeners to understand?

The hosts emphasize that neither smoking nor vaping is a healthy choice. They advise listeners to avoid both, recognizing the risks of each while also pointing out that information and awareness are key to making healthier decisions.

What role do regulations play in the safety of smoking and vaping?

Regulations play a significant role in managing the risks of both smoking and vaping. Smoking is heavily regulated, but vaping lacks comprehensive regulations, especially regarding the quality and safety of vape devices and liquids.