SHOCKING RESULTS!!! Canon R5 Mark II vs R3 vs R5 (Rolling Shutter + 10,000 ISO Comparison)

Jared Polin
22 Sept 202414:06

Summary

TLDRIn this detailed comparison, Jared from FroKnowsPhoto evaluates the rolling shutter and high ISO performance of three Canon cameras: the R5, R5 Mark II, and R3. He demonstrates how these cameras handle fast-moving subjects like a baseball, highlighting the improved rolling shutter performance of the R5 Mark II and R3 over the R5. He also explores high ISO results at 10,000 ISO, showing that all three cameras perform similarly in real-world scenarios. Ultimately, he advises that while the R5 Mark II offers a well-rounded package, the R3 remains a solid choice if found at a good price, especially for sports photography.

Takeaways

  • 😀 The Canon R5, R5 Mark II, and R3 were tested for rolling shutter and high ISO performance using the same lenses, settings, and electronic shutter across all cameras.
  • 😀 The R5 has a slower readout speed (around 15-12 milliseconds), causing noticeable rolling shutter artifacts when capturing fast-moving objects like a baseball.
  • 😀 The R5 Mark II has improved rolling shutter performance (6.2 milliseconds) compared to the R5, reducing distortion and warping in fast-moving subjects.
  • 😀 The Canon R3 offers the fastest readout speed (5.5 milliseconds), effectively minimizing rolling shutter and delivering near-perfect capture of fast-moving objects like baseballs.
  • 😀 While the R5 Mark II and R3 have similar rolling shutter behavior, the R5 still exhibits noticeable warping, especially in close-up or fast action shots.
  • 😀 Higher megapixel cameras, like the R5 (45MP), offer more detail when zoomed in but may be more prone to rolling shutter artifacts compared to lower-resolution cameras like the R3 (24MP).
  • 😀 For most practical use cases, such as sports or dynamic photography, the R5 Mark II and R3 provide very usable images despite minor differences in rolling shutter performance.
  • 😀 At high ISO (e.g., 10,000 ISO), the R5 Mark II and R3 show similar noise performance, with the R5 Mark II being slightly brighter but still producing acceptable images for professional use.
  • 😀 The R5 Mark II’s higher ISO performance and better rolling shutter make it a strong contender for sports and action photography, while the R3 remains an excellent choice for fast-moving subjects with lower resolution needs.
  • 😀 Global shutters, like those in some Sony cameras, deliver perfect rolling shutter performance, but Canon is still transitioning, with improvements expected in future models such as the R1.

Q & A

  • What is the main focus of the video?

    -The video primarily compares the rolling shutter performance and high ISO capabilities of the Canon R5, R5 Mark II, and R3 in a real-world setting using the same lenses and settings.

  • How do the rolling shutter speeds of the R5, R5 Mark II, and R3 differ?

    -The R5 has a slower readout speed of approximately 15-12 milliseconds, the R5 Mark II has a faster readout speed of 6.2 milliseconds, and the R3 is slightly faster at 5.5 milliseconds.

  • What is the impact of rolling shutter on the images of fast-moving subjects like a baseball?

    -The rolling shutter causes distortion, or 'warping,' in fast-moving subjects like a baseball, especially with the R5. The R5 Mark II and R3 perform better in reducing this warping due to faster readout speeds.

  • How do the R5 and R5 Mark II compare when it comes to capturing fast-moving objects?

    -The R5 exhibits significant warping of the ball due to its slower readout speed, while the R5 Mark II shows much less distortion and performs better in fast-moving scenarios.

  • What effect does filling the frame with a fast-moving object like a bat have on the rolling shutter performance?

    -When a fast-moving object like a bat fills more of the frame, the warping caused by rolling shutter becomes more noticeable because the object stays on the scan line longer, resulting in greater distortion.

  • Is there a significant difference between the R5 Mark II and R3 in terms of rolling shutter performance?

    -While both the R5 Mark II and R3 perform similarly in reducing rolling shutter, the R5 Mark II has a slightly slower readout speed, though the difference is minimal and not easily noticeable in most scenarios.

  • How does the R3 perform in high ISO settings compared to the R5 and R5 Mark II?

    -The R3, which has a lower resolution (24 megapixels), performs excellently at high ISOs, showing minimal noise even at 10,000 ISO. The R5 Mark II, with its 45 megapixels, also performs well but appears slightly brighter, leading to more noticeable noise in certain areas.

  • Why does the R5 Mark II appear slightly brighter than the R5 and R3 at the same ISO settings?

    -The R5 Mark II seems brighter, possibly due to differences in processing between the cameras or Lightroom's treatment of the images. This could be a factor of how the camera processes shadows and exposure.

  • What impact does using a mechanical shutter versus an electronic shutter have on high ISO performance?

    -Using the mechanical shutter can yield slightly cleaner results at high ISO (about one-stop better) compared to the electronic shutter. However, the electronic shutter offers advantages like 30 fps and pre-shooting capabilities, which are crucial for sports photography.

  • What are the key advantages of the R5 Mark II over the R3 for general use?

    -The R5 Mark II offers a well-rounded package with 45 megapixels, a faster readout speed for reduced rolling shutter, 30 fps continuous shooting, and impressive high ISO performance. It's a powerful choice for both stills and sports photography, especially with its new sensor and features.

Outlines

plate

Dieser Bereich ist nur für Premium-Benutzer verfügbar. Bitte führen Sie ein Upgrade durch, um auf diesen Abschnitt zuzugreifen.

Upgrade durchführen

Mindmap

plate

Dieser Bereich ist nur für Premium-Benutzer verfügbar. Bitte führen Sie ein Upgrade durch, um auf diesen Abschnitt zuzugreifen.

Upgrade durchführen

Keywords

plate

Dieser Bereich ist nur für Premium-Benutzer verfügbar. Bitte führen Sie ein Upgrade durch, um auf diesen Abschnitt zuzugreifen.

Upgrade durchführen

Highlights

plate

Dieser Bereich ist nur für Premium-Benutzer verfügbar. Bitte führen Sie ein Upgrade durch, um auf diesen Abschnitt zuzugreifen.

Upgrade durchführen

Transcripts

plate

Dieser Bereich ist nur für Premium-Benutzer verfügbar. Bitte führen Sie ein Upgrade durch, um auf diesen Abschnitt zuzugreifen.

Upgrade durchführen
Rate This

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

Ähnliche Tags
Canon R5R5 Mark IIR3Rolling ShutterHigh ISOSports PhotographyCamera ComparisonFast ActionLow LightISO TestPhotography Gear
Benötigen Sie eine Zusammenfassung auf Englisch?