Strange answers to the psychopath test | Jon Ronson | TED

TED
15 Aug 201218:02

Summary

TLDRIn this humorous and thought-provoking talk, the speaker discovers they have 12 mental disorders after browsing the DSM manual. They meet with a Scientologist critic of psychiatry and visit Broadmoor Hospital to meet Tony, a man who faked insanity to avoid prison but ended up trapped in a psychiatric facility. The narrative explores the complexities of mental health diagnosis, the potential overreach of psychiatric labeling, and the gray areas of human behavior, culminating in a broader discussion about the nature of psychopathy and its surprising presence in society.

Takeaways

  • 📚 The DSM manual has expanded significantly from a slim pamphlet in the '50s to a comprehensive 886-page book listing 374 mental disorders.
  • 🤔 The speaker humorously discovers they have 12 mental disorders according to the DSM, including generalized anxiety disorder and nightmare disorder.
  • 😅 The concept of self-diagnosis is questioned, as the speaker ponders the implications of labeling normal human behavior as a mental disorder.
  • 🤝 An encounter with a Scientologist named Brian leads to a discussion about the validity of psychiatry and the introduction to Tony, a man at Broadmoor Hospital.
  • 🏥 Broadmoor Hospital, formerly an asylum for the criminally insane, is where Tony ended up after faking madness to avoid a prison sentence.
  • 🕴️ Tony's attempt to appear sane by dressing well and discussing normal topics backfires as the hospital staff misinterpret his behavior as signs of mental illness.
  • 🧐 The speaker becomes a certified psychopath spotter after attending a course by Robert Hare, the creator of the psychopath checklist.
  • 📊 One in a hundred people are considered psychopaths, with a higher percentage found among CEOs and business leaders, suggesting that certain psychopathic traits might be advantageous in capitalism.
  • 🔍 The speaker interviews 'Chainsaw Al' Dunlap, a business figure known for ruthless cost-cutting measures, and reflects on the tendency to focus on the extreme aspects of a person's character.
  • 🔄 The story concludes with Tony's release from Broadmoor after 14 years, highlighting the complexities and gray areas in diagnosing and treating mental disorders.

Q & A

  • What was the initial observation the speaker made about the DSM manual?

    -The speaker initially observed that the DSM manual, which lists mental disorders, has grown from a slim pamphlet in the '50s to a 886-page book listing 374 mental disorders.

  • How many mental disorders did the speaker discover they had upon self-assessment?

    -Upon self-assessment, the speaker discovered they had 12 mental disorders.

  • What is the significance of Broadmoor Hospital in the context of the story?

    -Broadmoor Hospital, formerly known as the Broadmoor Asylum for the Criminally Insane, is significant as it is where the speaker meets Tony, a man who faked madness to avoid a prison sentence but ended up in the hospital.

  • Why did Tony initially fake madness, and what was the outcome?

    -Tony initially faked madness to avoid a prison sentence for beating someone up. However, he faked it too well and ended up in Broadmoor Hospital for 12 years, longer than his original prison sentence would have been.

  • What was Tony's strategy to convince people of his sanity within Broadmoor?

    -Tony's strategy was to act and speak normally about everyday topics like football or current events, subscribing to New Scientist to have relevant conversations.

  • How did the staff at Broadmoor interpret Tony's behavior?

    -The staff at Broadmoor interpreted Tony's normal behavior, such as staying in his room and not wanting to socialize with other patients, as signs of madness, specifically aloofness and grandiosity.

  • What was the clinician's final assessment of Tony after his release from Broadmoor?

    -After 14 years, Tony was released from Broadmoor as they determined he should not be held indefinitely based on a checklist score that suggested a higher chance of recidivism.

  • What did the speaker learn about the prevalence of psychopathy in society after attending Robert Hare's psychopath-spotting course?

    -The speaker learned that one in a hundred regular people is a psychopath, with a higher prevalence among CEOs and business leaders, suggesting that certain psychopathic traits might be rewarded in ruthless capitalism.

  • How did the speaker's perception of Al Dunlap, the 'asset stripper,' align with the traits of a psychopath?

    -The speaker's perception of Al Dunlap aligned with psychopathic traits as he displayed grandiosity, manipulativeness, and a lack of empathy, which are characteristic of a psychopath.

  • What realization did the speaker come to regarding the nature of journalism and labeling people?

    -The speaker realized that journalism, like their own experience with labeling Al Dunlap as a psychopath, often focuses on the extreme or 'maddest edges' of a person's character, neglecting the normal aspects and leading to a one-dimensional portrayal.

Outlines

plate

Dieser Bereich ist nur für Premium-Benutzer verfügbar. Bitte führen Sie ein Upgrade durch, um auf diesen Abschnitt zuzugreifen.

Upgrade durchführen

Mindmap

plate

Dieser Bereich ist nur für Premium-Benutzer verfügbar. Bitte führen Sie ein Upgrade durch, um auf diesen Abschnitt zuzugreifen.

Upgrade durchführen

Keywords

plate

Dieser Bereich ist nur für Premium-Benutzer verfügbar. Bitte führen Sie ein Upgrade durch, um auf diesen Abschnitt zuzugreifen.

Upgrade durchführen

Highlights

plate

Dieser Bereich ist nur für Premium-Benutzer verfügbar. Bitte führen Sie ein Upgrade durch, um auf diesen Abschnitt zuzugreifen.

Upgrade durchführen

Transcripts

plate

Dieser Bereich ist nur für Premium-Benutzer verfügbar. Bitte führen Sie ein Upgrade durch, um auf diesen Abschnitt zuzugreifen.

Upgrade durchführen
Rate This

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

Ähnliche Tags
Mental HealthPsychiatry CritiqueDSM ManualBroadmoor HospitalFake MadnessPsychopathyCapitalismBusiness EthicsHuman BehaviorGray Areas
Benötigen Sie eine Zusammenfassung auf Englisch?