JUS INDO #117 : BAGAIMANA CARANYA AGAR KITA GA DIKERJAIN LAGI AMA WASIT TIMTENG

Summary

In this passionate discourse, the speaker critiques the corrupt practices within FIFA and the AFC, highlighting the unfair voting system that disadvantages stronger football nations in Asia. They express frustration over the influence of Middle Eastern countries and the lack of representation for nations like Japan and South Korea. The speaker advocates for strategic lobbying to improve Indonesia's standing in the AFC and emphasizes the importance of personal relationships in Asian culture. They call for collective action from fans and stakeholders to prevent further injustices in officiating and governance, ultimately aiming for a stronger presence in Asian football.

Takeaways

• ⚽ FIFA has a flawed system that enables corruption, particularly benefiting Middle Eastern countries in AFC.
• 💰 Smaller countries with less football infrastructure can sway votes in international football, despite having less influence.
• 🔍 FIFA and AFC are influenced by financial incentives, leading to corruption that goes unchecked.
• 📰 The American banking system played a crucial role in uncovering FIFA's corrupt practices due to their auditing rights.
• 🇮🇩 Indonesia's football representation has diminished over the years, highlighting the need for stronger lobbying within AFC.
• 🤝 Building personal relationships is crucial in Asian culture for successful lobbying within AFC.
• 🏟️ Strong networks, such as that of the PSSI chairman, can help improve Indonesia's standing in Asian football.
• 🌍 FIFA opening an office in Indonesia is seen as a positive step towards better relations, although local lobbying remains vital.
• ⚖️ Continuous efforts are needed to address unfair treatment from referees, especially those from the Middle East.
• 🗣️ Social media can amplify the voices of netizens and hold governing bodies accountable, but real change requires significant power.

Q & A

What main issue does the speaker highlight about FIFA and AFC?

The speaker points out that FIFA and AFC have corrupt practices, particularly noting that smaller nations are influenced by financial incentives, resulting in an unfair voting system where their votes carry the same weight as those of larger, more competitive countries.

Why does the speaker believe that the voting system in AFC is flawed?

The voting system is flawed because all member countries, regardless of their football development and contributions, have equal voting rights. This allows countries with less footballing significance to disproportionately influence decisions.

What historical context does the speaker provide about FIFA's operations?

The speaker explains that FIFA was established as an organization free from government interference, with each national football association acting as a member, which complicates accountability and transparency.

How does the speaker suggest addressing the issues with FIFA and AFC?

The speaker suggests that stronger lobbying efforts should be directed towards the AFC to ensure that they are taken seriously and to improve their standing within the organization, emphasizing the importance of personal relationships and networking.

What role does money play in the influence exerted by certain countries in AFC?

Money plays a crucial role as wealthier nations can buy votes and influence decisions within the AFC, allowing them to maintain control and secure leadership positions over the interests of other nations.

What example does the speaker provide to illustrate the systemic corruption?

The speaker mentions that FIFA's corruption was uncovered through American banking systems, highlighting the irony that the enforcement came from the U.S. rather than European agencies, despite FIFA's headquarters being in Europe.

What cultural aspect does the speaker emphasize in improving relations within AFC?

The speaker emphasizes the importance of 'silaturahmi' (personal relationships) in Asian culture, suggesting that building connections and fostering good relations is crucial for effective lobbying and influence.

Who does the speaker believe should take action to improve the situation within AFC?

The speaker believes that the current chairman of PSSI, who has significant networking capabilities, should actively work to strengthen relations with key figures in the AFC and encourage government involvement in sports diplomacy.

What specific examples does the speaker give about lobbying efforts?

The speaker mentions the need for more engagement with key AFC leaders and suggests that the Indonesian government should reach out to Qatar and other influential nations to enhance diplomatic ties, particularly in football.

How does the speaker view the role of social media in this context?

The speaker acknowledges the power of social media as a platform for expressing dissent and raising awareness about issues in football governance, suggesting that collective voices can create pressure on authorities.