Le Conseil d'État, la plus haute juridiction administrative en France (Les clés de la République)
Summary
TLDRIn 1905, a bull escaping in a southern French village led to a dramatic chase by the police, ultimately resulting in the animal's death and a stray bullet injuring a local resident, Tomaso Greco. Greco's complaint against the state marked a pivotal moment, as the Council of State ruled on the limits of state responsibility and the right to contest state decisions. The Council of State, created by Napoleon in 1799, not only delivers justice but also advises on legislative matters. As the most prestigious body in France, it balances the public power through its dual role as adviser and judge.
Takeaways
- 😀 A bull escaped from a cattle market in a village in southern France in 1905, causing panic in the streets.
- 😀 The police chased the bull, which was elusive and dangerous, leading to a shootout where the bull was ultimately killed.
- 😀 A stray bullet from the police gunfire injured a local resident, Tomasso Greco, who filed a complaint against the state.
- 😀 The Council of State ruled to exonerate the police for their actions, establishing the principle of questioning state actions.
- 😀 This case helped form rules regarding the state's responsibility and its limits in relation to individual rights.
- 😀 Citizens can contest state decisions in an administrative court and can appeal to the Council of State if dissatisfied.
- 😀 The Council of State, beyond being a judicial body, also serves as an advisor to the government on legislative matters.
- 😀 Ministers must consult the Council of State before introducing bills to ensure their usefulness, clarity, and legality.
- 😀 The Council of State was founded by Napoleon Bonaparte in 1799 and has evolved into a critical institution for both advising and judging state actions.
- 😀 The President of the Council of State is officially the Prime Minister, but the Vice-President, a senior civil servant, actually presides over the Council.
Q & A
What event is described in the beginning of the transcript?
-The transcript begins by describing an event in a village in southern France in 1905, where a mad bull escapes from a cattle market, causing panic in the streets. The police try to capture it but end up shooting the animal, leading to a stray bullet injuring a local resident named Tomaso Greco.
What happens after Tomaso Greco is injured by the stray bullet?
-After Tomaso Greco is injured by the stray bullet, he files a complaint against the state. The Council of State issues a ruling that exonerates the police, but for the first time, it raises the principle of questioning the state’s actions.
What key legal principle does the case establish?
-The case establishes the principle that an individual can contest the state's decisions. It marks the first instance where the state’s responsibility is questioned and sets the groundwork for future legal rules about the limits of the state's actions.
What is the role of the Council of State in French law?
-The Council of State in France has two main roles: it serves as an advisory body for the government, ensuring bills are useful, well-written, and legally sound, and it also functions as a court where individuals can challenge state decisions.
How does the Council of State influence legislative decisions?
-Before a bill is presented to Parliament, it is submitted to the Council of State, which assesses whether the bill is well-written, clear, and respects legality. The Council's review helps ensure that laws are effective and legally sound before they are voted on by Parliament.
Who appoints the members of the Council of State?
-Members of the Council of State are appointed by the government or through the National School of Administration (ENA).
Who presides over the Council of State?
-The President of the Council of State is officially the Prime Minister, but the Vice-President, a highly respected civil servant appointed by the head of state, is the one who truly presides over the institution.
What historical role did the Council of State have?
-The Council of State was originally the King's Council and was created by Napoleon Bonaparte in 1799. It has since evolved into its current form as both an advisory body and a court.
What is the significance of the Council of State within the French state apparatus?
-The Council of State is considered the most prestigious institution within the state apparatus, serving a dual role as both an advisor to the government and as a judge. It helps balance the actions of public power.
How does the administrative court process work in relation to the Council of State?
-If an individual is dissatisfied with a decision made by an administrative court, they can appeal to the Council of State, which will make the final ruling on the matter.
Outlines

此内容仅限付费用户访问。 请升级后访问。
立即升级Mindmap

此内容仅限付费用户访问。 请升级后访问。
立即升级Keywords

此内容仅限付费用户访问。 请升级后访问。
立即升级Highlights

此内容仅限付费用户访问。 请升级后访问。
立即升级Transcripts

此内容仅限付费用户访问。 请升级后访问。
立即升级浏览更多相关视频

Siji Warga Moring –Moring Nduk Kantor Deso | POJOK KAMPUNG JTV

Bentrok Antar Suku di Wamena Tewaskan 1 Orang

Kepergok Beraksi, Maling Motor Tewas Dihakimi di Bekasi | Kabar Siang tvOne

Wily Jackal - Hitopadesha Tales in English - Animation/Cartoon Stories For Kids

Watch Neighbor Unplug Bounce House That Deflated on 12 Kids at Birthday Party

Viral Pencuri Pisang Diarak Warga, Pemilik Kebun Buka Suara
5.0 / 5 (0 votes)