Bedanya Pendidikan di Singapura dan di Indonesia

Summary

In this video, Andrew Sofan compares the education systems in Indonesia and Singapore, focusing on key differences such as curriculum, tuition fees, teaching approaches, and overall education quality. He highlights Singapore’s consistent, globally recognized Cambridge-based curriculum and student-centered focus, contrasted with Indonesia’s fluctuating curriculum and a more traditional, batch-focused learning model. Singapore’s high costs are discussed, along with opportunities for scholarships. Andrew emphasizes the value of studying in Singapore, despite the financial challenges, while acknowledging the need for ongoing improvements in Indonesia’s education system.

Takeaways

• 😀 Education in Singapore is taught in English, while Indonesian schools primarily use Bahasa Indonesia, with some international schools offering English-medium instruction.
• 😀 Singapore's schools have superior facilities compared to Indonesia, though some international schools in Indonesia have caught up in this regard.
• 😀 In Singapore, education focuses on project-based learning and critical thinking, while Indonesian schools are more focused on classroom-based teaching.
• 😀 Singapore’s education system emphasizes critical thinking and the development of multiple perspectives, while Indonesia's education system often lacks this focus.
• 😀 Singapore’s education system is globally recognized, with institutions like NTU ranking high in Asia and globally, while Indonesia struggles with lower rankings.
• 😀 Singapore’s curriculum has remained stable for over 20 years, whereas Indonesia frequently changes its curriculum with new ministers.
• 😀 Teachers in Singapore emphasize understanding and problem-solving, while in Indonesia, teachers still rely on rote learning and content memorization.
• 😀 Singapore takes a student-focused approach, offering personalized learning experiences, while Indonesia follows a batch focus where only the top-performing students receive special attention.
• 😀 Studying in Singapore is expensive, with high tuition fees for international students, but the quality of education justifies the cost.
• 😀 Scholarships, such as the ASEAN scholarship, offer opportunities for students who cannot afford the high costs of education in Singapore, allowing them to study for free.

Q & A

What is the main focus of the video?

The main focus of the video is the comparison between the education systems in Indonesia and Singapore, highlighting the differences in curriculum, facilities, and teaching methods.

What are some key differences between the education systems in Indonesia and Singapore?

Key differences include the language of instruction (English in Singapore, Bahasa Indonesia in Indonesia), the focus on project-based learning in Singapore, critical thinking training, and the globally recognized standards of education in Singapore compared to Indonesia's lower international rankings.

How do the educational facilities in Indonesia compare to those in Singapore?

While Singapore is known for its high-quality facilities, Indonesia also has some international schools with similar quality facilities. However, overall, the facilities in Singapore tend to be superior.

What is emphasized more in the educational system in Singapore compared to Indonesia?

Singapore emphasizes critical thinking, social studies, and writing skills more than Indonesia, which traditionally focused more on classroom-based learning. Singapore also prioritizes student-centric learning and adaptation to different perspectives.

How does the education system in Singapore promote critical thinking?

In Singapore, students are taught to analyze various perspectives on issues and encouraged to think critically. An example mentioned is a social studies lesson on the Tamil Tigers, where students were asked to evaluate the situation from multiple viewpoints.

How does Indonesia’s ranking in education compare to Singapore's?

Indonesia's education system ranks much lower than Singapore's, with Indonesia's ranking being 54th in 2021 compared to Singapore's position as a top performer in global education rankings.

What are the implications of frequent changes in Indonesia’s education curriculum?

The frequent changes in Indonesia’s education curriculum can lead to instability and inconsistency in the education system, making it difficult for students and educators to adapt. In contrast, Singapore has maintained a consistent education system for decades.

What are some challenges faced by Indonesia in improving its education system?

Indonesia faces challenges in improving its education system, including insufficient teacher training and a focus on rote learning rather than contextual or adaptive learning. The curriculum often remains the same even with changing governments.

How are students in Singapore supported individually in their education?

In Singapore, students are supported on an individual level, where even if they are not the top performers in their class, they still receive attention and guidance from teachers, psychologists, or other support staff.

What is the financial cost of schooling in Singapore?

The cost of schooling in Singapore varies depending on the type of school and the student’s residency status. For example, international schools can cost up to SGD 60,000 for six years of primary education, while government schools are less expensive but still require significant financial investment.