Para Maling Ikan yang Kembali Masuk di Periode Kedua Jokowi | Buka Mata

Summary

The video script explores the complex dynamics of illegal fishing in General Santos City, Philippines, highlighting the impact of Indonesian maritime policies under former Minister Susi Pudjiastuti. While her measures temporarily curtailed theft from Indonesian waters, illegal fishing surged again after her departure, threatening the local fishing industry, which relies heavily on supplies from other nations. The analysis of satellite data reveals fluctuations in fishing vessel activity, emphasizing the need for stronger cooperation between Indonesia and the Philippines. Direct exports from Sangihe and Talaud to Gensan are proposed as a solution to improve local economies and combat illegal fishing.

Takeaways

• 😀 General Santos City (Gensan), known as the 'Tuna Capital of the Philippines,' relies heavily on the fishing industry, which has been impacted by illegal fishing activities in Indonesian waters.
• 😀 Susi Pudjiastuti, former Minister of Maritime Affairs and Fisheries in Indonesia, temporarily reduced illegal fishing in the region, but after her tenure, fish theft resumed.
• 😀 Satellite data, including Vessel Monitoring System (VMS) and VIIRS Boat Detection (VBD), were used to track illegal fishing activities in Indonesian waters, showing a dramatic decrease during Susi's policy implementation.
• 😀 The fishing industry in Gensan saw a sharp economic decline when Susi's policies reduced illegal fish supplies, with data showing fewer vessels docked at Gensan in 2016.
• 😀 The 'Dinosaur Area' in Indonesia's Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ) is a hotspot for illegal fishing activities, with Filipino vessels regularly operating in the area, confirmed by satellite imagery.
• 😀 When Filipino vessels steal fish in Indonesian waters, they often disable tracking systems like VMS and use transshipment methods to transport stolen fish to Gensan, avoiding detection.
• 😀 Economic data shows that while illegal fishing has hurt Gensan's tuna industry, local fishermen in Indonesia's Sangihe and Talaud regions have benefited from reduced illegal activity.
• 😀 The economic value of fish in Sangihe and Talaud would increase by nearly 45% if direct exports of tuna and mackerel to Gensan were allowed, rather than first passing through Indonesian domestic markets.
• 😀 Direct tuna exports from Sangihe and Talaud to Gensan could create a sustainable, legal supply of fish for the Philippines and help reduce illegal fishing activities.
• 😀 Despite the potential benefits, the Philippine government has been slow to respond to proposed Memoranda of Understanding (MoU) for new fisheries management cooperation, with suspicions that fish stocks may have returned to normal as illegal fishing resumed.

Q & A

What is the main issue discussed in the script regarding General Santos City?

The script highlights the illegal fishing activities affecting General Santos City, particularly the theft of fish from Indonesian waters, and how management policies have influenced these practices.

Who was Susi Pudjiastuti, and what impact did her appointment have on the fishing industry in Gensan?

Susi Pudjiastuti served as the Minister of Maritime Affairs and Fisheries in Indonesia. Her policies temporarily reduced illegal fishing, but after her departure, such activities resumed, significantly impacting the fish supply for Gensan.

How did the statistical data regarding fishing vessels in Gensan change from 2015 to 2017?

The number of fishing vessels longer than 50 meters docked in Gensan increased from 855 in 2015 to 1,289 in 2016, indicating that Susi's policies were effective in increasing the number of vessels in the port.

What methods were employed to detect illegal fishing activities?

The script mentions using the VIIRS Boat Detection satellite imagery, which detects light emissions from fishing vessels at night, and VMS data from the Ministry of Marine Affairs and Fisheries to monitor vessel activities.

What phenomenon occurred regarding fish stocks and illegal fishing activities after Susi Pudjiastuti's policies?

After her policies were implemented, there was a notable decrease in illegal fishing activities and an increase in fish stocks in Gensan. However, once she left office, illegal activities surged again, reflecting a decline in fish stocks.

What was referred to as the 'dinosaur area,' and why is it significant?

The 'dinosaur area' refers to a region in the Sulawesi Sea where illegal fishing activities are prevalent. It is significant because it highlights the areas vulnerable to foreign fishing incursions into Indonesia's exclusive economic zone.

What challenges do local fishermen in Sangihe and Talaud face due to illegal fishing?

Local fishermen face increased competition from illegal Filipino vessels, leading to reduced fish stocks and necessitating patrols that limit their operational days to only 90-100 days per year.

What potential solution is proposed to address illegal fishing and improve economic conditions for local fishermen?

The script suggests that establishing direct exports of seafood from Sangihe and Talaud to Gensan could minimize illegal fishing and improve economic conditions by providing better prices and access to markets.

What economic value is estimated for tuna and mackerel production in Sangihe and Talaud if direct exports occur?

The estimated annual production of tuna in Sangihe and Talaud is 3,709.3 tons, and for mackerel, it's 13,925.7 tons. If these fish are directly exported to Gensan, the economic value would increase by nearly 45 percent compared to sending them to Bitung.

How did the Covid-19 pandemic affect fishing activities in Gensan?

The pandemic led to a temporary increase in the number of fishing vessels docked in Gensan in 2020, but overall activities returned to normal levels in 2021-2022, coinciding with the resumption of illegal fishing activities.