Should you Move to the US to Learn English?
Summary
TLDR视频中讨论了是否需要移居美国来学习英语以达到流利水平。演讲者明确表示,移居英语国家并不是达到高水平英语的必要条件。他通过自己在墨西哥的生活经验,以及遇见的英语母语者在墨西哥生活多年却未能掌握西班牙语的例子,来说明即使生活在外国,如果不主动学习和实践,语言能力也不会自动提高。同时,演讲者建议通过在线课程、播客、视频等资源,即使在本国也能实现语言的沉浸式学习。最后,他提到了生活在语言使用国的一个优势:能够学习到特定情境下的语言用法和表达,但这并不是学习语言的决定性因素。
Takeaways
- 🏠 你不需要搬到美国来学习英语,即使在外国生活,也不一定能自动提高语言水平。
- 🌐 即使身处非英语国家,通过互联网资源和书籍,也可以实现语言的沉浸式学习。
- 📚 即使生活在英语国家,如果没有主动学习和使用英语,语言能力也不会自然提高。
- 🗣️ 通过在线对话课程,可以有效地练习英语口语,即使不在美国也能进行大量实践。
- 🤔 人们往往高估了自己在外国环境中语言吸收的能力,实际上语言学习需要有意识的努力。
- 📈 通过自动化字幕功能,可以提高理解英语视频的能力,同时练习听力和阅读。
- 👥 即使在英语环境中,如果没有与说英语的人交流,语言能力也不会有显著提升。
- 📝 通过在线资源,可以接触到大量的英语材料,从而提高阅读和写作能力。
- 🎧 利用播客和视频作为背景声音,可以增加对英语的被动接触,提高语言感知能力。
- 🌟 虽然生活在英语国家可以接触到特定的词汇和表达方式,但这并不是学习英语的决定性因素。
- 📌 即使不在美国,通过有意识的学习和练习,也可以达到高水平的英语能力。
Q & A
为什么搬到美国并不一定能帮助你学会流利的英语?
-搬到美国并不能自动让你变得英语流利,因为语言学习需要主动的努力和实践,而不是仅仅通过生活在一个说英语的国家就能实现的。
为什么有些人即使在外国生活多年也无法流利地说当地语言?
-如果一个人没有主动学习当地语言的动力,不与说该语言的人交流,或者不将学习纳入日常生活,即使在外国生活多年也可能无法流利地说当地语言。
视频中提到的在墨西哥生活的英语国家人士的例子说明了什么?
-这些例子说明了即使在外国生活,如果没有积极学习和使用当地语言,人们可能仍然无法掌握该语言,即使他们已经在那里生活了很多年。
为什么说我们不是语言学习的“海绵”?
-“海绵”意味着我们能够自动吸收周围的一切信息,但语言学习并非如此。我们需要有意识地练习和使用语言,而不是被动地等待语言能力自然形成。
视频中提到的“自动化字幕”功能是什么?
-自动化字幕功能是指在视频播放时,系统自动生成的字幕,帮助观众更好地理解视频内容,特别是对于语言学习者来说,这是一个有用的工具。
如何通过互联网资源来提高英语水平,即使不在美国?
-可以通过听英语播客、观看YouTube视频、阅读英文书籍和文章等方式来提高英语水平。这些资源可以帮助你沉浸在英语环境中,从而提高语言能力。
为什么说在线对话课程是提高口语能力的有效方式?
-在线对话课程允许学习者与母语者进行实时交流,这不仅提供了实践口语的机会,而且还可以根据个人的时间表灵活安排课程。
视频中提到的italki.com是什么?
-italki.com是一个在线语言学习平台,提供与母语者进行一对一语言课程的机会,是提高语言实践能力的好方法。
为什么说在外国生活可能不会像预期的那样大量使用当地语言?
-在外国生活时,人们可能会发现自己在日常生活和工作中并不需要大量使用当地语言,特别是如果他们的工作和社交圈不需要使用该语言的话。
视频中提到的生活在说英语国家的一个“真正的好处”是什么?
-这个好处是指通过身处特定的物理环境和情境中,学习到特定词汇、短语和表达方式,这些是在非母语环境中很难学到的。
为什么墨西哥的停车助手的例子能够说明生活在语言国家的优势?
-这个例子说明了只有通过身处特定的文化和物理环境中,人们才能学习和理解特定情境下的语言使用,这是通过在线课程或在非母语环境中难以获得的经验。
Outlines
😀 移居美国学习英语的必要性探讨
视频脚本首先提出了一个常见问题:是否应该移居美国来学习英语。视频中指出,移居英语国家并不是达到流利程度或像母语者一样说话的必要条件。虽然生活在英语环境中有一个巨大的优势,但大多数人并未意识到这一点。视频承诺将在后半部分讨论这一优势,但首先解释了为什么没有必要移居美国来学习英语。此外,视频还提到了自动字幕功能,并邀请观众参加发音研讨会以改善他们的发音。
😐 居住在外国并不自动带来语言流利度
视频通过分享在墨西哥生活的经验,说明了即使在外国生活多年,也不一定能够流利地说该国语言。举例说明了几位来自英语国家的人在墨西哥生活多年,但他们的西班牙语水平参差不齐,甚至有的人几乎不会说西班牙语。原因在于他们没有积极学习,没有与说西班牙语的人交流,也没有将学习西班牙语作为目标。这表明,即使在外国,如果没有学习的动力和实际行动,语言能力也不会自动提高。
🤔 人们高估了语言吸收能力
视频指出,人们往往错误地认为自己可以在另一个国家自动吸收语言,就像海绵一样。然而,实际上,许多人在国外的生活并没有太大变化,他们可能仍然使用电脑远程工作,与母国的团队交流,或者与不会说当地语言的朋友交往。因此,他们接触和使用当地语言的机会并不多,这与他们在自己的国家没有太大区别。视频强调,语言学习不是自动的过程,需要有意识的努力和实践。
📚 在本国也能进行语言沉浸学习
视频提出了即使在本国也能通过沉浸式学习来掌握语言的观点。通过互联网和书籍,可以轻松地让自己沉浸在英语环境中。例如,可以通过播客、YouTube视频、书籍和文章等方式,让英语在日常生活中不断播放,即使不是主动学习,也能提供大量的语言暴露机会。视频还分享了个人学习法语的经验,强调了通过技术手段进行语言沉浸的可行性。
🗣️ 在线对话课程提高口语能力
视频建议通过在线对话课程来提高口语能力,这是当前语言学习者的一个巨大优势。通过网站如italki.com,可以预约与母语者的课程,进行定期的口语练习。视频分享了个人学习法语时的实践,强调了在线课程的灵活性和有效性,并鼓励观众也采取这种方式来提高英语口语。同时,视频指出,即使在美国生活,也不一定能像预期的那样大量使用英语进行交流。
🌐 居住在语言国家的特殊语言学习优势
视频讨论了居住在语言国家的一个特殊优势:能够学习到特定情境下才会出现的词汇、短语和表达。这些是在物理环境中与当地人互动时才会出现的,例如在墨西哥停车时与指挥停车的人交流。这种情境下的语言使用是在线课程或与非本地人交流时难以遇到的。视频通过分享个人在墨西哥的经历和与墨西哥裔美国朋友的故事,说明了这种优势的重要性。
👋 结语:鼓励在任何地方学习英语
视频最后强调,观众不需要移居美国就可以学习英语,并鼓励他们利用现有的资源和方法,如在线课程和沉浸式学习,来提高英语能力。同时,视频再次提到了提供的帮助改善发音的服务,并感谢观众观看视频,预告了下一期视频的内容。
Mindmap
Keywords
💡语言学习
💡沉浸式学习
💡母语者
💡发音
💡自动字幕
💡情境语言
💡在线课程
💡语言吸收
💡语言环境
💡语言动机
💡语言实践
Highlights
不需要搬到美国也能学好英语。
居住在外国并不自动使人精通该语言。
在墨西哥生活六年的英语教师不会说西班牙语的例子。
即使在美国生活多年,也不一定能说流利的英语。
人们高估了自己在外国环境中语言吸收的能力。
即使在外国,如果不主动学习,也不会自动提高语言能力。
可以通过互联网和书籍在本国进行语言沉浸式学习。
即使在外国,日常生活中实际使用目标语言的时间可能并不多。
在线对话课程是提高语言能力的有效方法。
居住在外国的一个优势是能学到特定情境下的语言用法。
即使不居住在英语国家,也可以通过多种方式学习并接近母语者水平。
作者通过个人经验强调,语言学习需要有意识的努力和实践。
即使在外国,如果没有与当地人交流,语言能力也不会自然提高。
介绍了italki.com等网站,推荐使用在线资源与母语者进行对话练习。
在外国生活可以接触到特定环境下的词汇和表达方式。
即使不居住在目标语言国家,也可以通过多种在线资源进行有效学习。
作者提供了关于如何提高发音和听起来更像母语者的额外资源。
强调了即使在外国,日常生活中实际使用目标语言的时间可能被高估。
Transcripts
should you move to the US to learn
English is that the secret to becoming
fluent is that what you need in order to
uh reach that high level and to speak
more like a native speaker well this is
a question that I receive a lot uh many
students have asked me about this and
just people in general ask about this
should uh someone move to uh a country
that speaks the language that they're
trying to learn right in your case
you're all learning English so should
you move to the US or to some other
English-speaking country well I'm G to
give you the short answer first and then
we're going to talk in more detail about
this okay so you don't need to move to
the US so don't worry I'm going to talk
about why that is why you don't need to
move here uh to reach a high level in
English however there is one really big
advantage of living in a country that
speaks that language in this case living
in the us where we speak the language
that you're learning there is one really
big advantage that most people never
even think of they never think about
this and I'm going to talk about that
towards the end so first I'm going to
talk about why you don't need to come
here okay however uh I will talk about
that one really big Advantage at the end
that's at least worth considering and
keeping in mind okay so also before we
move on I know that some of you ask for
the subtitles on these types of videos
that I've recently started doing I'm not
going to put the subtitles on there I'm
sorry but you can click on the little
button down below the settings button
and you can turn on the automated
subtitles they're pretty good it's going
to be correct most of the time so go
ahead and do that if you need to uh
click on that settings button and uh
turn on those subtitles um and then just
try to understand me without look
looking at the subtitles because I'm
speaking slowly and clearly but if you
need to see a certain word or a phrase
that I used and you didn't understand
then you can just look down below oh and
one other thing I don't mention this a
lot but if you want to practice your
pronunciation if you want my help to
train your pronunciation to speak more
like a native speaker to sound more like
a native speaker then uh you can join my
seminar uh and join the tier that says
uh listening time super member or any
tier above that and you'll get my
pronunciation seminars so those will
really help you uh start to uh see the
patterns and notice the patterns um that
you're not pronouncing correctly and I
help you pronounce these things more
like a native speaker okay so the link
to that is down below all right let's
talk about why you don't need to live in
the US if you want to learn English well
the first thing to consider is that
living in a foreign country doesn't
automatically make you fluent in that
language uh and it doesn't even
guarantee that you're going to improve
in that language I know that for some of
you that sounds a little bit strange
like you would imagine that if someone
lives in the US and supposedly they're
learning English that they would
definitely uh improve a lot while being
here that can definitely happen of
course and I think in most cases it
probably does happen to an
extent however it's not automatic let me
me talk a little bit about my experience
living in Mexico I lived in Mexico for
six years okay during that time I met
multiple people who were from the US or
some other English-speaking country and
who moved to
Mexico uh for whatever reason and they
had very different levels of Spanish
okay and these people have been living
in Mexico for years right let me first
talk about um an instructor that I had
she was the instructor of the tefel
program that uh I had to pass in order
to get my teaching certificate to teach
English as a foreign language so at that
time uh that instructor that I had she
had lived in Mexico for I think it was 6
years the amount of time that I spent
there she had already lived in Mexico
for 6 years and she could not say one
sentence in
Spanish I know that sounds crazy but it
was true she couldn't speak a word of
Spanish and how can that happen well she
didn't make the effort to actually learn
Spanish she didn't spend a lot lot of
time with people who were speaking
Spanish to her she spent a lot of time
with English speakers and she didn't um
she didn't put in the necessary effort
to actually learn and it wasn't even her
goal I don't think so I think it's
pretty obvious if you go to another
country and you don't have the
motivation to learn you don't uh take
the necessary steps to learn
and you just don't even pay attention
to uh the the language that's spoken
around you you're not going to learn
we're not sponges we don't just absorb
everything and then suddenly it's inside
us um that's an idea that people have
about language learning that is
definitely not true okay if you're not
intentionally doing
the the thing making the effort uh doing
what you need to do we are not sponges
like that uh especially as adults okay
so that's one example of a person and
then I remember a friend I had who uh he
was going to live in Mexico for like two
years he knew he was going to go back to
the US um but he didn't really have the
goal of learning a lot of Spanish and by
the end of those couple years he
couldn't speak any Spanish he didn't
have uh the the ability to say sentences
or have a conversation with someone
after two years of living there and I
remember one other friend who was
married she was married to a Mexican
okay and she had lived in Mexico for
years and she at least had some Spanish
but she could not have uh a long
conversation in Spanish she probably
couldn't even have a short conversation
in Spanish she could probably uh more or
less communicate in a very basic way and
that was the extent of her abilities and
I thought you're married to a Mexican
you live in Mexico
uh how is it that you're not learning
this language and I remember talking to
her and uh I think that she was
answering a question I think we were in
a group and someone had asked her like
about maybe taking Spanish classes to
improve her Spanish and she said
something like I just want to learn
naturally I'm just going to absorb it as
I go go I'm just going
to uh acquire Spanish you know just in a
natural way living my life here and I
thought you've already lived here for
multiple years you're married to a
Mexican and you still barely speak any
Spanish
like this obviously isn't working so why
am I talking about all of this why am I
giving these examples well it's to show
you
that whether or not you live in the
country that speaks that language
doesn't really matter if that's the only
Factor if it's just I'm GNA do the same
thing here uh let's pretend I live in uh
Mexico and I say okay I'll do the same
thing here but I'm GNA live in the US
and then absorb all the English it
doesn't work like that so
so what's the problem well people
overestimate how much language that
they're absorbing people tend to think
of themselves as sponges and I can just
go and live in another country I'll
absorb the language I'll be fluent but
the problem is that when you're living
in another country many people aren't
really doing things differently from how
they would do them in their own country
so if uh people from the US move to
Mexico but they have their same life
that they live in the US they work um
from their using their computer they
work remotely they have their team in
the US that they're interacting with uh
they um I don't know have friends that
they're still interacting with in the US
or maybe they have friends in Mexico but
those friends have to speak English to
you because you don't speak Spanish or
whatever and you just live your normal
routine you're actually not getting a
lot of Spanish in that case right
because you're not spending your day
interacting in Spanish with people
around you very few people do that when
they move to another country I've lived
in another country I've met many people
that have moved and uh lived in other
countries and very few people do this
okay that's just not how people normally
act when they move abroad they don't
just move abroad and then now they just
surround themselves all day with people
who are speaking Spanish to them or
sorry whatever language that they're
learning and then they're speaking to
them that's not a very big percentage of
your day okay so people overestimate how
much they're absorbing and they
overestimate how much of that language
they're even hearing right when I lived
in Mexico I was able to live uh a large
part of my life there without even
really talking to people in Spanish okay
because you know if you work from home
you spend many hours at home uh you're
not spending your day with that language
does that make sense so and the same
goes for people who live in the US so
Mexicans who come and live here for
example right there are millions of
people in the US that don't speak
English even though they've lived here
for years or even decades there are many
people that have lived here for 20 years
30 years 40 years and don't speak
English That's Just Not Gon to happen by
putting yourself in a country that
speaks English there's nothing automatic
about it so now let's talk about
learning from where you are right now
whatever country you're living in
whatever City you're in right now what
can you do
uh to learn without coming to the US and
how can you learn even better okay
because sometimes you learn even better
if you don't come and uh one way to do
this is immersing yourself with the
language and you might think well but
I'm still in my country how do I immerse
myself well it's easy because if you
have access to the internet and if you
have books you can immerse yourself very
easily in English Okay for example I'm
learning French
and learning French is not my ultimate
goal in life it's not my number one
priority you know throughout my day it's
below a lot of other priorities however
uh I'm still able to uh do hours of
French practice every day not actively
the whole time but passively okay
because we have our phones we have our
computers we have podcasts YouTube
videos books articles things like that
right so uh you can immerse yourself
without going to another country you can
constantly have a podcast playing in the
background for example example right
while you're doing other things you uh
hear this podcast in the background and
sometimes you're paying attention and
sometimes you're not but it doesn't
matter the immersion is there right
because if you go to another country and
you're just expecting the English to
just come and arrive here um you're
probably overestimating how much English
you're hearing because like I said
you're probably working or you're doing
some type of study some course so you're
spending many hours just isolated or
with your computer and then afterwards
you're not going out and then just you
know interacting with English speakers
for the next six hours that's probably
not going to happen right so wherever
you are you can just use podcasts and
videos and books and things like that
and you can get tons of immersion tons
of exposure to English wherever you are
right I've probably listened to hundreds
many hundreds of hours of French over I
don't know how long but I've probably
listened to many hundreds of hours of
French in uh
my recent uh year last couple of years
or I don't know maybe the last year
let's say I've listened to hundreds of
hours of French without needing to
listen to people in France without
needing to live in that country does
that make sense the it's logical if you
just think about it like that you don't
need to be there physically to hear all
of that French for example right you can
be at your house in your own country
right so the immersion is easy you can
just have uh English playing in the
background all day if you want when
you're taking a shower when you're
getting ready for bed you're just
hearing English just all day that's
pretty easy to replicate if you have
WiFi right so there's your immersion and
then you might say well how about
speaking because that's just listening
or reading or whatever well with
speaking I already said when you go to
another country and you live in another
country you're not going to be speaking
that language as much as you think trust
me I've had so many students throughout
the years that live in the United States
they live here and they would still take
classes with me every week or twice a
week or three times a week and I would
say you're living in the US why do you
need to take classes with me you're
already in the US there are English
speakers
everywhere what's the deal and they
would say well I actually don't really
speak a lot of English in my everyday
life even though I live in the US and
I've heard that so many times I'm not
exaggerating I've heard that so so many
times and that's what happens when you
go to another country you go with the
idea that you're going to be speaking so
much of that language and usually it
doesn't happen like that you don't have
a routine and a lifestyle that just
makes you talk all day in that other
language usually there are some cases
where that happens but that's not
usually what happens and so you're not
speaking that much even if you're in
that country unless you like marry
someone from that country like me that's
different but most of you aren't going
to get married to an English speaker
okay so that's a a different case but
just uh in a normal situation you're not
going to be speaking as much English as
you think you will be so what can you do
from home well
you can take conversation classes online
this is great this is an amazing time
period for language Learners you can
just go uh open your computer uh
schedule classes with native speakers
and talk to them this is what I do okay
right now uh I'm learning French like I
said I started speaking regularly
probably about five five or six weeks
ago I think and uh during that time
period I've been talking uh two or three
times a week to a different French or uh
Belgian person in completely in French
and we have conversations and I do this
right here right where I'm sitting right
now and it's super easy it's really
flexible and I'm doing consistent French
speaking practice for the first time in
my life because I'm just making the
effort to take conversation classes so I
highly recommend that you do this for
English Okay use a website for example
like italki.com I always recommend this
website and take classes with native
speakers and do it uh twice a week if
you can and try to keep a consistent
rhythm with that and yeah maybe you're
not speaking quite as much as you would
be if you lived in the US for example
but in all honesty in most people's
cases they're really not going to be
talking a lot when they move here unless
they marry someone from here okay so
yeah you probably won't be able to talk
as much even with those
conversation classes but still it's not
going to be that big of a difference uh
again unless you have some different
case different situation okay but I'm
just talking from my experience um you
know people have this idea that they
move to another country like someone is
going to move to Mexico and they're
gonna just be talking Spanish all day to
the lady who's selling tortillas and the
cashier and the waiter and that might be
true but when you really total up the
the number or the amount of time that
you spend talking to these people the
mailman or whoever you see when you just
do your daily routine it's very little
speaking okay like here in the US not
counting my family I speak very little
to strangers here and I speak the
language here so it's easy for me I
speak very little like
maximum like four or five minutes a day
in my daily routine uh that's like the
maximum that I spend talking to Cashiers
and waiters and workers and the person
at the gas station and you know
neighbors like that just isn't a very
big part of my day okay
so in reality if you do three uh
conversation classes a week from where
you are you're probably talking almost
as much as you would with a normal
routine in the US like there's probably
not that big of a difference okay
because at least with conversation
classes you're forcing yourself to speak
like 30 minutes right now or an hour
tomorrow and that's a good amount of
speaking time so take conversation
classes uh make friends even with the
tutors that you're talking to and maybe
you can even end up you know talking uh
just for fun with them like there are a
lot of ways that you can connect with
native speakers and talk to them right
okay before uh we get to the end of the
video I wna talk about the one very big
advantage of living in the country that
speaks that language and that is that
you will
learn uh specific
vocabulary specific phrases and
expressions that arise they appear
because of situations that you are
physically in like your body is there
you're interacting in that situation not
like me talking to someone you know uh
having a conversation class and that
person is in another country right I'm
talking about like you are standing
there with the person you have some
physical environment around you two um a
lot of vocabulary and phrases and
expressions arise from this type of
physical situation like here's a good
example in Mexico there are these people
that uh will stand in the streets where
there is street parking and they will
kind of like help you park your car and
watch your car for you to keep it safe
and then you give them a little money
it's not a formal job but people just
kind of do it to make money right if
you're from Mexico you know exactly what
I'm talking about so this is something
thing that uh someone who is not from
Mexico or doesn't live in Mexico has
zero idea about okay so the first time
you go and you're in Mexico driving and
you want to park your car and this
person starts saying things to you and
starts uh helping you park your car and
giving you instructions there are going
to be some phrases some words that this
person uses that you're probably never
going to hear in any other situation
right talking about that specific
movement of you know turning your wheel
to get into the space and going more and
then stopping like these are physical
instructions that someone will probably
never give you unless you live in the
country and you're parking your car
there by the curb you talking to your
English tutor
in a conversation class you're probably
never going to even think about this
type of vocabulary and this physical
situation um and even if you do the same
words won't come out of that
conversation as when you're physically
there doing that so I use this example
because sometimes I go to Mexico with
Mexican
Americans uh friends I have here who who
are native Spanish speakers they grew up
speaking Spanish but they've never lived
in Mexico so they only speak Spanish
like to their parents okay and I'll take
them down to Mexico and in situations
like this they like might not even
understand what this person is telling
them right because they've never been in
that situation before where someone is
helping them Park their car and telling
them to stop because another car is
coming like they never hear these types
of uh like phrases and slang that is
used by these people that are helping
you park your car like they've never
heard that before and even though these
friends of mine are native speakers they
have never lived in that physical
environment in Mexico so there are
certain phrases and expressions that
they just don't know and I have to teach
them even though I'm not an Spanish
speaker it's pretty crazy right I teach
a lot of uh phrases words Expressions to
my native Spanish-speaking friends who
have never lived in Mexico before and so
that kind of shows you that there is uh
a certain advantage of uh living in the
physical environment because certain
vocabulary will be learned from having
those physical situ situations of you
being there and interacting with the
environment around you does that make
sense so that's something that you will
probably never get if you don't live in
the country but in all honesty that's
not the most important thing that's uh
something you can learn in the future
when you travel to the US or whatever
you can learn that as you go um but it
is something that you probably won't be
exposed to until you have that physical
situation okay so I did want to mention
that cuz I think it's something really
interesting uh that most people never
think of but I think of it all the time
because every time I go to Mexico with
my Mexican American friends they're like
lost like they don't understand a lot
and I'm like having to describe and uh
help them understand certain expressions
and things like that they just never
learned because they've never physically
been in this environment okay all right
I hope this was interesting for you and
I hope it uh encourages you to uh know
that you can learn English from from
wherever you are okay you don't need to
come and live in the US all right and
remember like I mentioned before if you
want help improving your pronunciation
if you want to sound more like a native
speaker then remember to sign up for my
membership and become a listening time
super member family member or VIP and
you'll get my pronunciation training and
I know that it'll be really helpful for
you people really like it uh when they
try it out for the first time so the
link is down below if you want to sign
up for that and thank you so much for
watching this video and I'll talk to you
in the next one
Browse More Related Video
Building up your English Brain | part 2 | __Jackson Tech's
【全英中字】英语口语真的不是光靠努力就能提高的😓
How to think in English and stop translating in your head
Building up your English brain | part 1 | __Jackson Tech's.
I regret studying medicine in Russia! MBBS in english is a scam? exclusive interview PRT 1
一句ChatGPT Prompt提示语 让给ChatGPT变身英语口语老师 ChatGPT Prompts魔法咒语大集合
5.0 / 5 (0 votes)