Piers Corbyn on alternative climate change | Energy Live News

Energy Live News

9 Sept 201601:12

Summary

TLDRThe video script challenges the mainstream narrative on climate change, labeling it a 'conspiracy theory.' It argues that carbon dioxide (CO2) is not the primary driver of global temperatures, contrary to popular belief. Instead, it suggests that world temperatures dictate CO2 levels. The script criticizes renewable energy as inefficient and costly, with wind power being three times more expensive than coal. It also accuses American and United Nations organizations of manipulating data to support the climate change theory, which the speaker deems fraudulent.

Takeaways

🌍 The script suggests that climate change theory is a conspiracy and labels it as 'stupid'.
🔄 It argues that the narrative of carbon dioxide (CO2) controlling world temperatures is false.
❌ The script claims that actual data shows world temperatures control CO2 concentration, not the other way around.
📊 It asserts that satellite data supports the claim that CO2 does not affect climate, in contrast to what it deems as 'fraudulent' data from the American and United Nations operations.
📉 The script accuses these operations of manipulating data to create a false impression of warming.
💨 It criticizes renewable energy, specifically wind farms, as being inefficient and costly compared to coal.
💰 The cost of power production from wind farms is stated to be at least three times that of coal.
🚫 The script implies that CO2 is not a pollutant and is not harmful.
🌬️ It questions the necessity of cleaning the output from power stations, suggesting that CO2 is not a concern.
🌿 The script implies a skepticism towards the mainstream view on climate change and renewable energy.
🤔 It encourages viewers to question the validity of the data and the narratives presented by major institutions.

Q & A

What is the main claim of the script regarding climate change?
-The script claims that the current climate change narrative is false and that climate change is a conspiracy theory.
According to the script, what is the relationship between carbon dioxide (CO2) and world temperatures?
-The script argues that world temperatures control CO2 concentrations rather than CO2 controlling world temperatures.
What evidence does the script present to support its claims about climate change?
-The script mentions satellite data as evidence showing that the climate is cooling, contrary to data produced by American and United Nations operations, which it alleges is fraudulent.
How does the script view the data produced by American and United Nations operations?
-The script views the data produced by American and United Nations operations as fraudulent, claiming they select data to make the past look colder and the present warmer.
What is the script's stance on renewable energy?
-The script claims that renewable energy is extremely inefficient and a waste of money.
How does the script compare the cost of producing power from wind farms to coal?
-The script states that the cost of producing power from wind farms is at least three times that of coal.
What does the script suggest about the necessity of cleaning the output from power stations?
-The script acknowledges the need to clean the output from power stations but argues that CO2 itself is not a pollutant.
Does the script believe CO2 has any effect on the climate?
-No, the script claims that CO2 does not have any effect on the climate whatsoever.
What does the script claim about the current state of the climate according to satellite data?
-The script claims that the climate is cooling based on satellite data.
What underlying message does the script convey about climate change data and narratives?
-The script conveys a message of skepticism towards mainstream climate change data and narratives, suggesting they are manipulated and false.

Outlines

00:00

🌍 Climate Change Theory Critique

This paragraph argues that the current climate change narrative is false, suggesting that carbon dioxide levels are not the primary driver of global temperatures. It claims that temperatures control CO2 concentrations instead. The text alleges that satellite data shows a cooling climate, contrary to what it describes as manipulated data from American and United Nations sources. Additionally, it criticizes renewable energy as inefficient and costly compared to coal, stating that CO2 is not a pollutant.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Climate Change Theory

Climate Change Theory refers to the scientific understanding that the Earth's climate is changing due to human activities, particularly the burning of fossil fuels which release greenhouse gases into the atmosphere. In the script, the theory is controversially labeled as a 'conspiracy theory,' suggesting that it is a false narrative constructed to deceive the public, which is a common misconception among climate change skeptics.

💡Carbon Dioxide (CO2)

Carbon Dioxide, or CO2, is a greenhouse gas that is released through various natural processes such as respiration and more significantly from human activities such as deforestation and burning fossil fuels. The script claims that CO2 does not affect world temperatures, which contradicts the scientific consensus that CO2 is a primary driver of global warming.

💡World Temperatures

World temperatures refer to the average surface temperature of the Earth. The script suggests that world temperatures control the concentration of CO2, which is a misrepresentation of the scientific understanding that CO2 levels influence global temperatures, not the other way around.

💡Satellite Data

Satellite data in the context of climate science refers to measurements taken by satellites to monitor various aspects of the Earth's climate system, including temperature, ice coverage, and atmospheric composition. The script implies that satellite data supports the claim that climate change is not influenced by CO2, which is a controversial stance as the majority of satellite data aligns with the consensus on human-induced climate change.

💡Fraudulent Data

The term 'fraudulent data' in the script is used to discredit climate data produced by institutions like the American and United Nations operations. It suggests a conspiracy to manipulate data to support the narrative of climate change, which is a baseless claim as these institutions are widely recognized for their rigorous scientific methodologies.

💡Renewable Energy

Renewable energy encompasses energy sources that are replenished naturally and sustainably, such as wind, solar, and hydroelectric power. The script criticizes renewable energy as inefficient and expensive, contrasting with the mainstream view that sees renewable energy as a key solution to reducing greenhouse gas emissions.

💡Wind Farms

Wind farms are large arrays of wind turbines used to convert wind energy into electricity. The script argues that the cost of producing power from wind farms is significantly higher than from coal, which is a point of debate as the costs of renewable energy technologies have been decreasing and can be competitive in various contexts.

💡Pollutant

A pollutant is any substance that contaminates a natural resource, such as air or water, making it harmful or undesirable. The script incorrectly states that CO2 is not a pollutant, despite the fact that excessive CO2 in the atmosphere contributes to climate change and ocean acidification, which are recognized environmental pollutants.

💡Efficiency

Efficiency in the context of energy production refers to how effectively and economically energy can be generated and utilized. The script claims that renewable energy, particularly from wind farms, is inefficient, which is a subjective assessment that does not take into account the full life-cycle costs and environmental impacts of different energy sources.

💡Cost of Producing Power

The cost of producing power is a critical factor in evaluating energy sources. The script suggests that the cost of power from wind farms is at least three times that of coal, which may be a simplified view that does not consider externalities such as health costs associated with air pollution from coal.

💡Clean the Output

Cleaning the output refers to the processes involved in reducing pollutants from the emissions of power stations. The script implies that this is necessary for coal but not for CO2, which overlooks the fact that CO2 emissions also require mitigation strategies to address climate change.

Highlights

Climate change theory is considered a conspiracy theory by some.

The narrative claims that carbon dioxide is the main force controlling world temperatures.

Actual data suggests that world temperatures control carbon dioxide concentration.

CO2 is argued to have no significant effect on climate.

Satellite data is cited as evidence against the climate change narrative.

Fraudulent data production by American and United Nations operations is alleged.

Data selection is accused of making the past appear colder and the present warmer.

Renewable energy is deemed extremely inefficient and a waste of money.

Wind farms are claimed to be at least three times more expensive than coal power.

The need to clean output from power stations is mentioned as an issue.

CO2 is not considered a pollutant by the speaker.

The speaker implies that the actual climate is calling, as shown by satellite data.

There is a critique of the current climate change narrative as being false.

The speaker emphasizes the importance of data integrity in climate discussions.

The transcript suggests a distrust in mainstream climate change data sources.

The economic implications of renewable energy are highlighted.

The transcript raises questions about the reliability of climate change data.