What Factors are Most Important for Fat Loss?

Flow High Performance
16 May 202424:47

Summary

TLDRThe video script emphasizes that calorie intake is the most crucial factor for fat loss, advocating for a calorie deficit to lose weight while preserving muscle mass. It highlights the importance of resistance training to retain muscle during weight loss and suggests a high protein intake for muscle growth and preservation. The script also discusses the roles of physical activity, sleep, and the rate of weight loss, while downplaying the significance of macronutrient ratios and meal timing on fat loss. Practical recommendations are provided for achieving fat loss effectively.

Takeaways

  • 🔢 **Calorie Intake**: The most critical factor for fat loss is maintaining a calorie deficit over time, which is the primary driver of weight loss and fat reduction.
  • 💪 **Resistance Training**: Engaging in resistance training during weight loss helps to preserve muscle mass, which is essential for maintaining a higher proportion of fat loss.
  • 📉 **Protein Intake**: Consuming a higher daily protein intake is beneficial for muscle growth and retention during weight loss, with diminishing returns above 1.5g per kilogram of body weight.
  • 🚶 **Physical Activity**: Increasing daily physical activity levels helps to boost energy expenditure and can aid in appetite regulation, though it's less effective than diet changes for weight loss.
  • 🛌 **Sleep**: While sleep's importance is debated, chronic sleep restriction may negatively impact muscle retention and increase calorie intake, which can hinder fat loss efforts.
  • 📈 **Rate of Weight Loss**: Losing weight at a slower rate (no more than around 1% of body weight per week) can help preserve more muscle mass and increase the proportion of fat lost.
  • 🥗 **Macronutrient Balance**: The ratio of carbohydrates to fats in the diet does not significantly impact body composition changes when adequate protein intake and a calorie deficit are maintained.
  • 🥣 **Meal Frequency and Timing**: The number of meals per day and their timing have little effect on fat loss when calories and macronutrients are controlled.
  • 🧘 **Appetite Regulation**: Physical activity can help regulate appetite, which is beneficial for adherence to a calorie deficit.
  • 🏋️‍♂️ **Training Intensity**: High-intensity resistance training can help maximize muscle retention and should be performed with the same intensity as if building muscle mass.

Q & A

  • What is the most important factor for achieving fat loss while preserving muscle mass?

    -The most important factor for fat loss is calorie intake. Consuming fewer calories than you expend over time, while maintaining a high protein diet and engaging in resistance training, can help preserve muscle mass during weight loss.

  • How does resistance training influence the proportion of muscle versus fat lost during weight loss?

    -Resistance training provides an anabolic stimulus for muscles, which can help retain or even build muscle mass during the weight loss process. This results in a greater proportion of fat loss compared to muscle mass loss.

  • What is the role of total daily physical activity levels in fat loss?

    -Total daily physical activity levels play a role in increasing energy expenditure, which can influence the energy balance equation to help promote a calorie deficit. While exercise is effective for weight loss, it is not as effective as diet changes for inducing a calorie deficit.

  • How does protein intake affect muscle retention and fat loss during a calorie deficit?

    -Consuming a high daily protein intake is beneficial for muscle growth and preservation during weight loss. It helps retain a greater amount of fat-free mass and therefore increases the proportion of fat mass lost.

  • What is the recommended daily step count for moderate physical activity to assist with fat loss?

    -A moderate step count to assist with fat loss is between 5,000 to 10,000 steps per day. Increasing this above 10,000 steps can provide additional benefits, but going beyond 15,000 steps might not be worth the additional time and effort for most people.

  • How does sleep affect fat loss and muscle retention?

    -Chronically restricted sleep might have a small detrimental effect on the proportion of muscle versus fat loss during a calorie deficit. Additionally, restricted sleep can lead to higher calorie intake and decreased likelihood or effort of exercise, which are crucial for fat loss.

  • What is the recommended rate of weight loss for preserving muscle mass while losing fat?

    -To preserve as much muscle as possible, it is recommended to lose weight at a rate of no more than around 1% of body weight per week.

  • How does the macronutrient ratio of carbohydrates and fats affect fat loss when in a calorie deficit?

    -If you are in a calorie deficit and consuming sufficient protein, the exact ratio of carbohydrates to fats does not significantly impact fat loss. However, a higher carbohydrate intake might be beneficial for those performing high-volume resistance training or lots of exercise to support performance.

  • What is the impact of meal frequency, timing, and distribution on fat loss when calories and macronutrients are equated?

    -The number of meals consumed per day and when these meals are consumed has very little, if any, effect on fat loss when calories and macronutrients are equated. Individuals can adjust their meal frequency and timing based on personal preference.

  • What are some best practices for muscle growth training to maximize muscle retention during weight loss?

    -Best practices include training the muscles with at least 10 direct sets per week, taking each set close to failure with about three reps in reserve, lifting in the 5 to 20 rep range, and selecting exercises that ensure fatigue of the target muscle group is the limiter of each set.

  • How does energy compensation affect the role of exercise in weight loss?

    -Energy compensation refers to the involuntary reductions in energy expenditure via other components as we do more exercise. This means we don't expend as much additional energy as predicted, which suggests that while exercise helps burn more energy, it might not contribute as much to weight loss as one might think.

  • What are the practical recommendations for achieving fat loss while preserving muscle mass?

    -The practical recommendations include maintaining a calorie deficit, engaging in resistance training, staying physically active with a moderate step count, consuming a high daily protein intake, ensuring adequate sleep, losing weight at a controlled rate (not more than 1% of body weight per week), and adjusting carbohydrate and fat intake based on personal preference and exercise levels.

Outlines

00:00

🔥 Calorie Intake: The Key to Fat Loss

The most critical factor for achieving fat loss is managing calorie intake. Consuming fewer calories than expended, particularly over the course of a week, creates a calorie deficit that leads to weight loss. While losing weight, the primary goal is to shed body fat while retaining muscle mass. Research indicates that without specific strategies to retain muscle, about 25% of the weight lost during a calorie deficit comes from lean mass. High protein diets can help retain more lean mass, but resistance training is paramount for muscle retention during weight loss.

05:00

🏋️‍♂️ Resistance Training: Maximizing Muscle Retention

Resistance training is the second priority for fat loss as it significantly influences the ratio of muscle to fat lost. It provides an anabolic stimulus that helps retain or even build muscle during weight loss. Training with high volume, intensity, and variety is crucial for muscle growth and retention. A meta-analysis showed that combining resistance training with calorie restriction can maintain lean mass, leading to a higher proportion of fat loss. The training approach should mirror that of muscle building, with at least 10 direct sets per muscle group per week, lifting to near failure, and focusing on the target muscle group.

10:01

🚶‍♂️ Physical Activity: Its Role in Energy Expenditure

While physical activity can increase energy expenditure and contribute to a calorie deficit, it is less effective for weight loss than diet changes. Studies show that exercise can lead to energy compensation, where the body unconsciously reduces energy expenditure in other areas. However, physical activity is still important as it helps regulate appetite and contributes to overall energy expenditure. A moderate step count of 5,000 to 10,000 steps per day is recommended, with potential benefits from increasing this count.

15:03

🥚 Protein Intake: Supporting Muscle Mass and Fat Loss

Daily protein intake is vital for both muscle growth and preservation during weight loss. Studies show that higher protein intakes help retain more muscle mass, leading to a greater proportion of fat mass lost. However, there are diminishing returns beyond 1.5 grams of protein per kilogram of body weight per day. Protein intake should be balanced with resistance training for optimal results. High protein diets should be sustainable and enjoyable, and individuals may need to adjust their protein intake based on factors like sex, body fat percentage, and personal preference.

20:05

💤 Sleep: Its Indirect Impact on Fat Loss

Sleep may not directly impact muscle growth and fat loss as significantly as other factors, but it plays an important indirect role. Restricted sleep can lead to increased calorie intake and decreased likelihood of exercising, negatively affecting fat loss. Studies show that while short-term sleep restriction doesn't greatly impact fat loss, chronic sleep deprivation can result in more lean mass loss and less body fat loss. Sleep also affects exercise performance and perceived effort, making adequate sleep essential for maintaining a calorie deficit and exercise routine.

📉 Rate of Weight Loss: Balancing Speed and Muscle Preservation

The rate at which weight is lost can influence body composition changes. A slower rate of weight loss, around 1% of body weight per week, is better for preserving muscle mass and therefore more effective for fat loss. Rapid weight loss can lead to greater muscle loss. While the rate of weight loss is less critical than calorie intake and resistance training, it's still an important consideration for those aiming to retain muscle mass during fat loss.

🍚 Macronutrient Balance: Carbohydrates and Fat Intake

The exact ratio of carbohydrates to fat in the diet does not significantly impact body composition changes when sufficient protein is consumed and a calorie deficit is maintained. However, higher carbohydrate intake may benefit those performing high-volume resistance training or extensive exercise by supporting performance and indirectly aiding in muscle mass preservation. A minimum of 0.5 grams of fat and 1.5 grams of carbohydrates per kilogram of body weight per day are recommended to support essential functions and exercise performance.

🕒 Meal Timing: Personal Preference Over Science

The frequency, timing, and distribution of meals throughout the day have minimal impact on fat loss when calories and macronutrients are controlled. Individuals can choose a meal frequency and timing protocol based on personal preference without significantly affecting fat loss outcomes. Whether one prefers fewer, larger meals or more frequent, smaller meals, adherence to a calorie deficit and adequate protein intake remains the priority.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Fat Loss

Fat loss refers to the process of reducing body fat while trying to preserve as much muscle mass as possible. It is the primary goal of the video, which focuses on strategies to achieve it through diet and exercise. The script emphasizes that fat loss is not just about losing weight but doing so in a way that minimizes muscle mass loss, as seen in various studies mentioned in the transcript.

💡Calorie Intake

Calorie intake is the total number of calories consumed throughout the day or week. It is identified as the most important factor for fat loss in the video. The concept is central to the idea of creating a calorie deficit, where fewer calories are consumed than expended, leading to weight and fat loss over time. The script explains that adhering to a calorie deficit is crucial for successful fat loss.

💡Calorie Deficit

A calorie deficit occurs when the number of calories consumed is less than the number of calories expended. This concept is essential for weight loss and is a key strategy discussed in the script for achieving fat loss. The video explains that maintaining a calorie deficit over time will result in weight loss, with the goal being to lose body fat rather than just weight.

💡Resistance Training

Resistance training involves exercises that work against an external force to build muscle and strength. In the context of the video, it is the second priority for fat loss because it provides an anabolic stimulus for muscles, helping to retain muscle mass during weight loss. The script cites research showing that combining resistance training with calorie restriction can help maintain lean mass and increase fat loss.

💡Lean Mass

Lean mass refers to the body mass excluding fat, primarily consisting of muscle, bone, and water. The video discusses the importance of preserving lean mass while losing fat. It mentions that without specific efforts, about one-fourth of the mass lost during a calorie deficit is lean mass, but strategies like resistance training can help retain more lean mass.

💡Physical Activity

Physical activity encompasses any bodily movement produced by skeletal muscles that results in energy expenditure. The video discusses its role in increasing energy expenditure and thus promoting a calorie deficit. However, it also notes that while exercise is beneficial, it is less effective for weight loss than diet changes and can lead to energy compensation.

💡Protein Intake

Protein intake is the consumption of protein-rich foods, which are vital for muscle growth and maintenance. The video highlights the importance of a high daily protein intake for preserving muscle mass during weight loss. It references studies showing that higher protein intakes can help retain more fat-free mass and lose a greater proportion of fat mass.

💡Energy Compensation

Energy compensation refers to the body's involuntary adjustments to reduce energy expenditure in response to increased physical activity. The video explains that as people exercise more, they may burn fewer additional calories than expected due to this compensatory mechanism, which can affect the overall effectiveness of exercise for weight loss.

💡Appetite Regulation

Appetite regulation involves the body's mechanisms to control hunger and fullness. The video discusses how physical activity can influence appetite regulation, suggesting that moderate activity levels can help regulate energy intake and expenditure, which may indirectly support fat loss by aiding adherence to a calorie deficit.

💡Sleep

Sleep is discussed in the video as a factor that can indirectly affect fat loss through its impact on exercise and diet behaviors. While not directly linked to muscle growth and fat loss, chronic sleep restriction can lead to increased calorie intake and decreased exercise effort, which are不利 to fat loss. The video suggests that maintaining adequate sleep is important for overall health and adherence to fat loss strategies.

💡Macronutrient Profile

The macronutrient profile refers to the proportion of carbohydrates, fats, and proteins in a diet. The video mentions that while protein intake is crucial for muscle retention during weight loss, the exact ratio of carbohydrates to fats in a calorie deficit does not significantly impact body composition changes, suggesting that personal preference can dictate macronutrient distribution.

💡Meal Frequency and Timing

Meal frequency and timing pertain to how often and when meals are consumed throughout the day. The video concludes that, in a calorie deficit with sufficient protein, the number of meals and their timing have little effect on fat loss. This suggests that individuals can choose meal patterns based on personal preference without significantly affecting fat loss outcomes.

Highlights

Calorie intake is the most important factor for fat loss, influencing energy balance and weight loss over time.

A calorie deficit is essential for weight loss, aiming to consume fewer calories than expended.

Weight loss should focus on losing body fat while preserving muscle mass.

High protein diets can help retain more lean mass during weight loss.

Resistance training is crucial for preserving muscle mass and increasing fat loss proportion.

Exercise plays a role in regulating energy intake and expenditure, aiding in appetite regulation.

Total daily steps can influence energy expenditure and appetite, with 5,000-10,000 steps recommended for moderate activity.

High daily protein intake is beneficial for muscle growth and preservation during weight loss.

Optimal protein intake for muscle retention during weight loss is around 1.5g per kilogram of body weight.

Chronically restricted sleep may lead to greater lean mass loss and reduced fat loss.

Losing weight at a rate of no more than 1% of body weight per week helps preserve muscle mass.

Carbohydrate and fat intake ratios have minimal impact on body composition changes when sufficient protein is consumed.

Meal frequency, timing, and distribution have little effect on fat loss when calories and macros are equated.

Practical recommendations for fat loss include focusing on calorie intake, resistance training, physical activity, protein intake, sleep, weight loss rate, and macronutrient balance.

Individuals can adjust their diet preferences and exercise levels to best support their fat loss goals.

Fat loss strategies should be personalized based on factors like biological sex, body fat, and personal preferences.

Transcripts

play00:01

fat loss is achieved by losing weight

play00:03

while preserving as much muscle mass as

play00:05

possible there are many factors that go

play00:07

into achieving this but not all are

play00:09

equally important so which factors are

play00:11

most important and which don't have much

play00:13

of an impact at all the first and by far

play00:16

the most important factor for fat loss

play00:18

is calorie intake this refers to the

play00:21

total number of calories consumed

play00:23

throughout the entire day and more

play00:25

importantly throughout the entire week

play00:27

our energy intake is the biggest

play00:29

modifiable factor that can influence

play00:31

energy balance or the net balance When

play00:33

comparing energy intake versus energy

play00:35

expenditure essentially we want to eat

play00:38

in a calorie deficit on average over

play00:40

time meaning to eat fewer calories than

play00:42

you expend successfully adhering to a

play00:45

calorie deficit will result in weight

play00:47

loss Over time however weight loss

play00:50

itself isn't necessarily the goal here

play00:52

the goal here is to lose body fat if we

play00:54

were to Simply lose body weight we would

play00:56

certainly see substantial fat loss but

play00:58

we will also likely lose a decent amount

play01:01

of muscle mass in the process this was

play01:03

seen in this research review which

play01:05

looked at body composition changes with

play01:07

weight loss this graph shows how much

play01:09

fat Mass versus lean mass was lost in

play01:11

various different studies with different

play01:13

diet strategies and in all cases around

play01:16

25% of the weight that was lost came

play01:19

from lean mass while the rest came from

play01:20

fat Mass apart from the high protein

play01:23

diet which is something we will discuss

play01:25

later so as a general rule we would

play01:27

expect around one4 of the mass lost

play01:29

during a calorie deficit to be lean mass

play01:32

and around 3/4 to be fat Mass if there

play01:34

is no specific effort to enhance muscle

play01:37

retention although there are other

play01:39

unmodifiable factors influencing how

play01:41

much fat-free Mass loss we will see with

play01:44

weight loss we generally see a greater

play01:46

proportion of lean mass lost in leaner

play01:49

individuals compared with those at a

play01:50

higher body fat and females tend to see

play01:53

less lean mass losses compared with

play01:55

males while these factors are

play01:57

unmodifiable there are strategies we can

play02:00

Implement to increase the amount of lean

play02:02

mass we retain during weight loss and

play02:04

therefore increase the amount of fat

play02:06

that is lost and this leads us onto our

play02:09

next priority for fat loss which is

play02:11

resistance training this has the biggest

play02:13

influence on the proportion of muscle

play02:15

versus fat we lose during weight loss

play02:18

resistance training provides an anabolic

play02:20

stimulus for our muscles this gives our

play02:22

physiology a reason for muscle mass to

play02:24

be retained or even built during the

play02:27

weight loss process and this will almost

play02:29

certainly improve the amount of lean

play02:31

mass we retain during weight loss and

play02:33

therefore increase the proportion of fat

play02:35

loss this was seen in this meta analysis

play02:38

which assessed the influence of

play02:39

resistance training during weight loss

play02:41

on body composition changes it was found

play02:43

that calorie restriction alone is

play02:45

effective for weight loss but also

play02:47

results in a little bit of lean mass

play02:49

loss as we would expect however when

play02:51

resistance training is implemented

play02:53

alongside calorie restriction lean mass

play02:55

can be entirely maintained in some cases

play02:58

this therefore results in a greater

play03:00

amount of fat loss as a proportion of

play03:02

the total weight lost so how should you

play03:05

train to maximize muscle retention well

play03:08

essentially you would want to train in

play03:09

the same way as if you were intending to

play03:12

build muscle mass here is a general

play03:14

overview of best practices for muscle

play03:16

growth training train the muscles you

play03:18

want to grow with at least 10 direct

play03:20

sets per week take each set close to

play03:23

failure at least around three reps in

play03:25

reserve lift anywhere within the

play03:27

approximate 5 to 20 rep range and adjust

play03:30

loads accordingly select exercises and

play03:33

lift with a technique that ensures

play03:35

fatigue of the target muscle group is

play03:37

the limiter of each set the third

play03:40

priority on our list is our total daily

play03:42

physical activity levels for the

play03:44

purposes of fat loss physical activity

play03:46

has the role of increasing energy

play03:48

expenditure this can influence the

play03:51

energy balance equation to help promote

play03:53

a calorie deficit while this is true

play03:55

exercise doesn't seem to be quite as

play03:58

effective as we might think for weight

play04:00

loss for example this study explored the

play04:02

effects of a diet or exercise

play04:04

intervention on weight loss

play04:07

439 overweight or obese women were

play04:10

assigned to an exercise and or diet

play04:12

protocol for one year one group was

play04:15

assigned to perform 45 minutes of

play04:17

aerobic exercise five times per week

play04:20

another group received individualized

play04:22

nutrition counseling from a dietitian

play04:24

and the third group were assigned both

play04:26

the exercise and diet interventions

play04:29

after after 1 year all groups

play04:31

successfully lost weight the exercise

play04:33

group lost around 2% of their initial

play04:36

body weight the diet group lost around

play04:38

9% body weight and the combined exercise

play04:41

and diet group lost the most weight

play04:43

around 11% so while exercise appears to

play04:46

be effective for weight loss it doesn't

play04:48

seem to be as effective as diet changes

play04:51

one reason for this is likely due to the

play04:53

concept of energy compensation this

play04:56

essentially means that as we do more

play04:58

exercise we see in inv voluntary

play05:00

reductions in energy expenditure via

play05:02

other components and as a result we

play05:05

don't expend as much additional energy

play05:07

as we might have predicted this idea was

play05:10

established in this research review

play05:12

which aimed to explore the influence of

play05:14

physical activity on total daily energy

play05:16

expenditure overall the researchers

play05:19

found that the evidence tends to support

play05:21

what is known as a constrained model of

play05:23

energy expenditure this essentially

play05:25

means that as we burn more energy via

play05:28

physical activity other components are

play05:30

downregulated so the net total daily

play05:33

energy burned follows more of a

play05:35

diminishing returns response as opposed

play05:37

to being directly additive however we

play05:40

don't quite know what exact components

play05:42

of energy expenditure are downregulated

play05:44

and to what extent how this changes at

play05:47

different body fat levels how this

play05:49

changes as we gain maintain or lose body

play05:51

weight and whether this is more of an

play05:53

acute response or a chronic adaptation

play05:56

in either case exercise does help to

play05:58

burn more energy but it probably isn't

play06:00

going to contribute quite as much as we

play06:03

may think so it shouldn't be the number

play06:05

one priority when trying to induce a

play06:07

calorie deficit for weight

play06:09

loss however there is another way in

play06:12

which physical activity can influence

play06:14

the energy balance equation and that is

play06:16

via appetite regulation This research

play06:19

review aimed to explore the mechanisms

play06:21

regulating how much food we eat they

play06:23

propose that exercise plays a role in

play06:25

regulating our energy intake if you

play06:28

exercise very little then there seems to

play06:30

be a disregulation of energy intake

play06:32

versus expenditure meaning your appetite

play06:35

tends to be greater relative to how much

play06:37

energy you burn but as you become at

play06:40

least moderately active your energy

play06:42

intake becomes regulated to a greater

play06:44

extent meaning your appetite tends to

play06:46

increase proportionately with the amount

play06:48

of energy you burn so overall physical

play06:52

activity is still important for fat loss

play06:54

just not as important as diet using

play06:57

total daily steps as a guide we probably

play06:59

want to achieve at least a moderate step

play07:02

count to assist with expending a little

play07:03

more energy and helping to regulate our

play07:06

appetite somewhere between 5 to 10,000

play07:09

per day for additional benefits it is

play07:11

probably going to be helpful to increase

play07:14

this above 10,000 per day if it is

play07:16

viable then going Beyond 15,000 per day

play07:20

might have some small additional

play07:21

benefits but it probably isn't worth the

play07:23

additional time and effort required

play07:25

unless you habitually have a very high

play07:28

activity level our next priority for fat

play07:31

loss is another nutrition variable and

play07:33

that is our total daily protein intake

play07:36

it is well established that consuming a

play07:38

high daily protein intake is beneficial

play07:40

for muscle growth via resistance

play07:42

training and also to preserve muscle

play07:44

mass during weight loss this was seen in

play07:46

this study which compared the effects of

play07:48

different protein intakes during a

play07:50

calorie deficit on body composition

play07:52

changes 39 military personnel from the

play07:56

US Army performing their regular

play07:58

physical activity schedule were assigned

play08:00

to a 40% calorie restricted diet for 3

play08:03

weeks one group were assigned to consume

play08:06

the recommended dietary protein intake

play08:08

of 0.8 G per kogam of body weight per

play08:11

day the other group consumed double this

play08:14

amount 1.6 G per kg per day and the

play08:17

third group consumed triple the RDA at

play08:19

2.4 G per kg per day after 3 weeks all

play08:23

groups lost a significant amount of body

play08:25

weight however the low protein group

play08:28

lost a greater portion of fat-free Mass

play08:31

meaning they lost a lower proportion of

play08:33

fat Mass while the moderate and high

play08:35

protein groups retained a greater amount

play08:37

of fat-free mass and therefore lost a

play08:39

greater proportion of fat Mass however

play08:42

we should be aware that a high protein

play08:44

intake isn't a replacement for

play08:46

resistance training resistance training

play08:48

is going to have a greater effect on

play08:50

muscle retention than just consuming a

play08:52

high protein diet and ideally you would

play08:55

want to perform resistance training and

play08:57

consume a high protein intake for the

play08:59

best fat loss results this was seen in

play09:02

this study which compared the effects of

play09:04

protein intake and or resistance

play09:06

training on body composition changes

play09:08

during weight loss 100 overweight or

play09:11

obese adults followed a diet designed to

play09:13

be 600 calories below their estimated

play09:16

energy needs for 10 weeks one consuming

play09:19

a lower protein intake of 0.8 G per kog

play09:22

per day one consuming a higher protein

play09:25

intake of 1.3 G per kog per day the

play09:28

Third consuming a lower protein intake

play09:31

but also performing resistance training

play09:33

three times per week and the last group

play09:35

consuming a higher protein intake plus

play09:37

performing resistance training three

play09:39

times per week after 10 weeks all groups

play09:42

lost significant body weight the low and

play09:45

high protein intake groups approximately

play09:47

maintained all their fat-free Mass the

play09:49

group exercising saw a slight increase

play09:51

in fat-free mass and therefore a greater

play09:54

proportion of fat loss and the high

play09:56

protein plus exercise group saw an even

play09:58

greater increase in fat-free mass and

play10:01

therefore an even greater proportion of

play10:03

fat

play10:03

loss so how much protein should we aim

play10:06

to consume well essentially higher

play10:09

protein intakes tend to be better for

play10:11

muscle growth or retention but there

play10:12

seems to be diminishing returns once

play10:15

protein intake exceeds around 1.5 G per

play10:18

kilog per day there likely isn't much

play10:21

additional benefit going higher than

play10:22

this furthermore this relationship

play10:25

probably looks different based on

play10:27

biological sex and body fat females at a

play10:30

higher body fat likely require a lower

play10:32

relative protein intake and males at a

play10:35

lower body fat likely see more benefit

play10:37

from a slightly higher relative protein

play10:39

intake check out the video in the

play10:41

description for more detail on how to

play10:43

individualize protein intake based on

play10:46

these factors while a high protein diet

play10:48

is generally helpful for fat loss from a

play10:51

physiological perspective a very high

play10:53

protein diet can potentially be harmful

play10:56

from a behavioral standpoint in some

play10:58

cases try to consume a very high protein

play11:01

intake can make it more difficult to

play11:03

adhere to a calorie deficit which is our

play11:05

number one priority this might be due to

play11:08

a few reasons such as trying to Target a

play11:11

very high protein intake might result in

play11:13

you eating more calories than you

play11:15

otherwise would just to hit a Target if

play11:18

you were to consume a very high protein

play11:20

intake and adhere to your calorie Target

play11:22

this means you will need to consume

play11:24

fewer fats and carbohydrates which may

play11:26

make your diet less flexible and

play11:28

sustainable you may also just not enjoy

play11:31

eating very high protein low fat and low

play11:33

carb foods all the time making it less

play11:36

likely for you to stick to the diet and

play11:38

lastly high protein foods are generally

play11:41

the most expensive in our diet which

play11:43

could make it less sustainable in some

play11:45

cases the next Factor on our hierarchy

play11:48

of importance for fat loss is sleep some

play11:51

may argue that sleep should be higher on

play11:53

the list of importance and that might be

play11:55

true however there is simply not much

play11:57

evidence which directly looks at the

play11:59

effects of sleep on muscle growth and

play12:01

fat loss in a controlled setting so it

play12:03

is hard to justify sleep being of

play12:06

Greater importance until we have more

play12:08

clear data to support it so what

play12:10

evidence do we have well there are two

play12:13

studies I am aware of which explore this

play12:15

topic the first looked at the effects of

play12:17

restricted sleep during a calorie

play12:19

deficit on body composition changes 36

play12:23

overweight or obese adults consumed a

play12:25

calorie intake of 95% of their predicted

play12:28

metabolic rate for 8 weeks one group

play12:31

slept normally during the diet which

play12:33

ended up being around 6 and 1/2 hours

play12:35

per night the other group were

play12:37

instructed to reduce their total time in

play12:39

bed by 90 minutes from their habitual

play12:41

sleep habits for 5 days of the week and

play12:44

then sleep as normal on the other two

play12:46

days this group ended up sleeping for an

play12:48

average of 5 1/2 hours per night on the

play12:51

restricted sleep days and around 7 and

play12:53

1/2 hours on the non-restricted days

play12:56

after 8 weeks both groups lost a similar

play12:58

amount of total body weight and in both

play13:00

cases the proportion of fat mass and

play13:02

lean mass that was lost was also similar

play13:05

and the other study we have explored a

play13:07

similar Concept in this study 10

play13:10

overweight adults consumed a calorie

play13:12

intake of 90% of their predicted

play13:14

metabolic rate on two separate 14-day

play13:17

periods on one occasion they were

play13:19

permitted 8 and 1/2 hours in bed and on

play13:22

the other occasion they were only

play13:24

allowed 5 1/2 hours of time in bed with

play13:26

the goal of restricting sleep it was

play13:28

found found that after both

play13:30

interventions total weight lost was

play13:32

similar however the participants lost a

play13:34

greater amount of fat-free Mass during

play13:36

the restricted sleep condition compared

play13:38

with the normal sleep condition this

play13:41

also meant that when sleeping longer

play13:43

subjects experienced greater fat loss

play13:45

compared with when sleep was restricted

play13:47

so overall if sleep is restricted a

play13:50

little on some days but you catch up on

play13:52

other days it doesn't seem to have much

play13:54

of an impact on Fat Loss however if

play13:57

sleep is chronically restricted then it

play13:59

might result in a greater amount of lean

play14:01

mass loss which would therefore result

play14:03

in less body fat loss sleep also plays

play14:06

an important indirect role in The Fat

play14:09

Loss process too and this is its effects

play14:11

on exercise and diet behaviors for

play14:14

example this study explored the effects

play14:16

of sleep restriction on food intake 12

play14:19

healthy adults underwent two separate

play14:21

14-day periods of controlled time in bed

play14:24

with unlimited access to food throughout

play14:26

the day on one occasion they were given

play14:29

9 hours of bedtime and on the other

play14:31

occasion they were only given 4 hours of

play14:33

time in bed with the goal to restrict

play14:35

sleep it was found that during the Sleep

play14:38

restriction phase subjects ate an

play14:40

average of about 250 calories more

play14:43

compared with when they were given more

play14:44

sleep and in terms of exercise this

play14:47

study compared the effects of sleep

play14:49

restriction on exercise performance and

play14:51

perceived fatigue 10 females with at

play14:54

least 6 months lifting experience

play14:56

performed four resistance training

play14:58

sessions over a 9-day period on two

play15:00

separate occasions on one occasion they

play15:03

were given eight or more hours in bed to

play15:05

sleep as normal on the other occasion

play15:08

they were restricted to only 5 hours in

play15:10

bed per night it was found that total

play15:12

volume load per session was similar

play15:15

during both phases indicating that

play15:17

lifting performance wasn't significantly

play15:19

inhibited however sleep restriction

play15:22

increased the subjects perceived

play15:23

exertion of each training session shown

play15:25

in the orange indicating that it took

play15:27

more effort to complete each workout and

play15:30

subjects also reported a greater

play15:32

training distress score which is a

play15:34

subjective rating of stress fatigue and

play15:36

depressive symptoms during the

play15:38

restricted sleep protocol so in terms of

play15:41

diet and exercise Behavior restricted

play15:43

sleep is likely to have negative effects

play15:46

it can decrease the likelihood of

play15:47

sticking to a calorie deficit and

play15:49

increase the perceived effort it takes

play15:51

to exercise which are the two most

play15:53

important factors for fat loss next on

play15:56

our hierarchy of importance for fat loss

play15:58

is the rate at which we lose weight

play16:01

while simply being in a calorie deficit

play16:03

over time is the most important factor

play16:05

for fat loss the magnitude of the

play16:07

deficit also seems to influence body

play16:09

composition changes too eating in a

play16:11

greater calorie deficit will result in a

play16:14

faster rate of weight loss while eating

play16:16

in a smaller calorie deficit will result

play16:18

in slower weight loss so how does our

play16:20

rate of weight loss influence fat loss

play16:23

this was explored in this study which

play16:25

compared the effects of a faster versus

play16:27

slower rate of weight loss in a Le

play16:29

athletes 24 Elite athletes from the

play16:31

Norwegian Olympic sports center

play16:33

performed their regular sport training

play16:35

during their offseason in addition to

play16:37

four resistance training sessions per

play16:39

week half the subjects were prescribed

play16:41

to lose weight at a slower rate while

play16:43

the others aimed to lose weight at a

play16:45

faster rate the slow weight loss group

play16:47

lost 4.2 kg in about 9 weeks while the

play16:51

fast weight loss group lost the same

play16:53

amount of body weight in around 5 weeks

play16:55

and protein intake was the same between

play16:57

groups at 1 .6 G per kog of body weight

play17:01

per day it was found that although both

play17:03

groups lost the same amount of total

play17:05

body weight the slow weight loss group

play17:07

resulted in a small gain in lean mass

play17:09

while the fast weight loss caused a very

play17:11

slight decrease in lean mass this meant

play17:14

that the slow weight loss group lost a

play17:16

little more fat Mass while the faster

play17:17

weight loss group lost a little less fat

play17:19

Mass although both groups lost mostly

play17:22

fat since they were both performing

play17:24

resistance training and had a high

play17:25

protein intake so although it isn't the

play17:28

most important consideration you would

play17:30

probably want to avoid rapid weight loss

play17:32

if the goal is to retain as much muscle

play17:34

as possible as a general rule losing

play17:37

weight at a rate of no more than around

play17:39

1% of body weight per week will likely

play17:41

increase the amount of muscle we can

play17:43

preserve and therefore increase the

play17:45

proportion of fat

play17:47

lost now we are moving on to the factors

play17:49

which don't seem to be very important

play17:51

for fat loss the first of which is your

play17:53

carbohydrate and fat intake in addition

play17:56

to protein these macronutrients will

play17:58

make up your total calorie intake if you

play18:00

were eating in a calorie deficit and you

play18:02

were getting a sufficient amount of

play18:04

protein per day the exact ratio of

play18:07

carbohydrate versus fat doesn't seem to

play18:09

have much of an influence on body

play18:11

composition changes for example the

play18:13

study compared the effects of weight

play18:15

loss with different macronutrient

play18:17

profiles on body composition changes 62

play18:20

subjects with non-alcoholic fatty liver

play18:22

disease were assigned to one of three

play18:25

different weight loss diets for 12 weeks

play18:27

these were either a low carb high fat

play18:29

diet a 52 diet or individualized

play18:32

nutrition counseling referred to as

play18:34

standard of care as we can see protein

play18:37

made up about 20% of total calories in

play18:40

each diet but the other macronutrients

play18:42

differed the low carb diet had a much

play18:45

lower proportion of carbohydrate and

play18:47

much higher fat while the other two

play18:49

diets consisted of about 40% of calories

play18:52

coming from both fat and carbohydrates

play18:55

after 12 weeks all groups lost weight

play18:57

with the 52 and low carb diets losing

play19:00

more weight the proportion of abdominal

play19:02

adapost tissue reduced similarly in all

play19:05

groups which was relative to the amount

play19:07

of weight that was lost and thigh muscle

play19:10

volume which was the only measure of

play19:11

muscle mass taken reduced by a similar

play19:14

proportion in all groups too there might

play19:17

be however a small advantage of

play19:19

consuming a higher carbohydrate diet for

play19:21

those performing lots of exercise this

play19:24

systematic review aimed to assess the

play19:26

influence of carbohydrate intake on

play19:28

resistance training performance overall

play19:30

it was found that carbohydrate intake

play19:33

doesn't seem to have a significant

play19:35

impact on lifting performance in most

play19:36

cases although performance during high

play19:39

volume lifting sessions May benefit a

play19:41

little from a higher carbohydrate diet

play19:44

so if you were performing a high volume

play19:46

of resistance training or lots of

play19:48

exercise in general you might want to

play19:50

opt for a slightly higher carb hydrate

play19:53

and therefore lower fat diet to support

play19:55

exercise performance this might

play19:58

indirectly influence fat loss by helping

play20:00

to preserve greater muscle mass via

play20:02

resistance training as a general rule

play20:04

you probably want to consume a minimum

play20:06

of around 0.5 G per kilogram of fat per

play20:10

day for essential bodily functions and

play20:12

you probably want to get at least around

play20:14

1.5 G per kog of carbohydrates per day

play20:18

to support exercise performance Beyond

play20:21

these minimum levels you can adjust the

play20:23

exact ratios of carbs and fats to suit

play20:26

your diet preferences and exercise

play20:28

levels

play20:29

and the last Factor on our list that is

play20:31

probably least important is the

play20:33

frequency timing and distribution of

play20:35

when we eat our meals throughout the day

play20:38

if you were eating in a calorie deficit

play20:40

with sufficient protein the number of

play20:42

meals you consume per day and when these

play20:44

meals are consumed has very little if

play20:46

any effect on fat loss in the majority

play20:48

of cases for example the study compared

play20:51

the effects of different meal

play20:53

frequencies during weight loss on body

play20:55

composition changes 43 overweight or

play20:58

Beast females were prescribed a diet

play21:00

containing 90% of their estimated

play21:03

calorie needs for 3 months the diets

play21:05

consisted of 55 to 60% carbohydrates 12

play21:09

to 15% protein and 25 to 30% fat half

play21:14

the subjects consumed this across three

play21:16

larger meals per day while the others

play21:18

consumed this across six smaller meals

play21:20

per day after 3 months both groups lost

play21:23

a similar amount of total body weight

play21:25

with similar proportions of fat mass and

play21:27

fat-free Mass lost so individuals can

play21:30

Implement a meal frequency and timing

play21:32

protocol based on their personal

play21:34

preferences you could eat fewer larger

play21:37

meals per day or more frequent smaller

play21:39

meals as long as you able to adhere to a

play21:41

calorie deficit and consume a decent

play21:43

amount of protein with all this

play21:46

information let's establish some

play21:47

practical recommendations the most

play21:50

important factor to achieve fat loss is

play21:52

calory intake you want to eat in a

play21:54

calorie deficit to lose weight over time

play21:57

during the weight loss period resistance

play21:59

training is going to be the most

play22:01

effective way to preserve muscle mass so

play22:03

that a greater proportion of the lost

play22:05

weight comes from fat resistance

play22:07

training to retain muscle mass should

play22:09

essentially look the same as if you were

play22:11

intending to build muscle mass next we

play22:14

have General physical activity which is

play22:16

best Quantified as the total number of

play22:18

steps performed per day higher activity

play22:21

levels can help to burn a little more

play22:23

energy but shouldn't be relied upon as

play22:25

the primary method of inducing a calorie

play22:27

deficit being Physically Active also

play22:30

helps to regulate hunger and satiety

play22:32

levels which may help adherence to a

play22:34

calorie deficit next on the list is

play22:37

protein intake consuming more protein

play22:39

per day in conjunction with resistance

play22:41

training can increase the amount of

play22:43

muscle we preserve during weight loss

play22:45

more protein generally seems to be

play22:47

better but there is less additional

play22:49

benefit as protein intake becomes higher

play22:52

and higher if possible it would be

play22:54

beneficial to try and consume 1.5 g of

play22:57

protein per kilogram body weight per day

play22:59

or more if it is practically viable the

play23:02

next Factor on our list is sleep

play23:04

chronically restricted sleep might have

play23:06

a small detrimental effect on the

play23:08

proportion of muscle versus fat loss

play23:10

during a calorie deficit however the

play23:13

bigger concern is that restricted sleep

play23:15

seems to result in a higher calorie

play23:17

intake and decreases the likelihood or

play23:19

effort of exercise next on the list is

play23:22

our rate of weight loss losing weight at

play23:25

a faster rate tends to result in a

play23:27

little more muscle being lost in the

play23:29

process while losing weight at a slower

play23:31

rate tends to be a little better for

play23:33

muscle preservation as a general rule

play23:35

you want to try and lose weight at a

play23:37

rate of no more than around 1% of body

play23:39

weight per week next on the list is

play23:42

carbohydrate and fat intake if you are

play23:44

adhering to a calorie deficit and

play23:46

consuming sufficient protein the exact

play23:49

amount of carbohydrates and fat you

play23:51

consume doesn't seem to have much of an

play23:53

impact on Fat Loss a minimum of 0.5 G

play23:56

per kilog per day of fat is recommended

play23:59

to support essential functions and a

play24:01

minimum of around 1.5 G per kog per day

play24:05

of carbohydrates are recommended to

play24:07

support exercise performance once these

play24:09

minimums are met you can decide to

play24:11

consume a slightly higher carb or higher

play24:13

fat diet based on personal preference

play24:16

and lastly we have meal frequency timing

play24:19

and distribution with calories and

play24:21

macros equated the exact number of meals

play24:23

you consume per day and the timing of

play24:25

these meals doesn't seem to have much if

play24:28

any influence on Fat Loss therefore how

play24:30

many meals you eat per day and when you

play24:32

eat these meals can be adjusted based on

play24:35

personal

play24:36

preference thanks for watching and

play24:39

hopefully you got something out of this

play24:40

video check out Floy performance.com for

play24:43

online coaching training templates

play24:45

ebooks and more

Rate This

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

Related Tags
Fat LossMuscle PreservationCalorie DeficitResistance TrainingNutritionProtein IntakePhysical ActivityWeight ManagementExercise PerformanceSleep Impact