TOKOH HINDU BALI BANGUN PONDOK PESANTREN | YAKIN❓BALI BAROMETER HINDU❗INI PAK GIRI PRASTA

Summary

The video discusses a controversial statement by a Hindu leader, Giri Praste, about the presence of Islamic pesantren (boarding schools) in Bali. His statement, made in the context of political campaigns, sparked debates within the Hindu community, particularly in Badung. Concerns are raised about Bali's identity as a Hindu stronghold, especially with growing non-Hindu populations. The speaker, Aji Dewa, reflects on the need for Hindu unity to maintain Bali's cultural and religious significance. The conversation touches on politics, religious tolerance, and the future of Hindu education in Bali.

Takeaways

• 📜 The speaker discusses the existence of Islamic boarding schools (pondok pesantren) in Bali, which many locals, including prominent figures like Giri Praste, were not fully aware of.
• 🤔 Giri Praste, a leader in Badung, Bali, has stated that he only recently learned about pesantren in Bali, which some consider surprising given his leadership position.
• 🕌 There has been a historical Muslim presence in Bali, especially in places like Denpasar and Kepaon, with mosques existing for centuries.
• 🤝 The discussion raises concerns among the Hindu community in Bali, with some fearing the increasing Muslim presence might threaten Bali’s status as a Hindu barometer for the world.
• 💬 Giri Praste's statement about protecting pesantren has caused mixed reactions within the local Hindu community, with some seeing it as a political move ahead of elections.
• 💡 The speaker notes that there is often a trauma associated with the fall of the Hindu kingdom of Majapahit in Java, which influences current perceptions of religious coexistence in Bali.
• 🏫 There is concern that while Islamic schools (pesantren) are being supported, Hindu educational institutions, like Pasraman schools, lack adequate resources and attention.
• 🧠 The speaker suggests that Bali needs to prioritize Hindu education to maintain its identity and prevent the erosion of its cultural and religious heritage.
• 📈 The speaker believes that Bali has always been known for its tolerance, but warns that the increasing establishment of pesantren could lead to a significant cultural shift if not balanced by support for Hindu institutions.
• 🗣️ Lastly, the speaker encourages unity within the Hindu community in Bali, emphasizing that internal divisions and conflicts are more detrimental to the preservation of Bali’s Hindu identity than external influences.

Q & A

What is the main concern raised about the development of pesantren in Bali?

The main concern is that the development of pesantren (Islamic boarding schools) could affect Bali’s status as a Hindu barometer and may cause discomfort among the Hindu community, especially given Bali's cultural and religious significance.

Why did the speaker find it surprising that Giri Praste was unaware of pesantren in Bali?

The speaker found it surprising because Islam has been present in Bali since the 14th century, with established Muslim communities and mosques, particularly in areas like Kepaon in Denpasar. As a leader, Giri Praste should have been aware of this.

How does the speaker interpret Giri Praste's statement about supporting pesantren in Bali?

The speaker suggests that Giri Praste's statement might be politically motivated, particularly with upcoming elections. While it aims to garner support, it may have negative effects on the Hindu community in Bali.

What historical event is linked to the concern about Hinduism in Bali, according to the speaker?

The speaker links the concern to the fall of the Majapahit Empire in Java, which was influenced by political conflicts and the rise of Islamic rule. This historical trauma fuels fears that Hinduism in Bali might similarly decline.

What is the speaker's view on tolerance in Bali regarding different religions?

The speaker acknowledges that Balinese Hindus generally practice a high level of tolerance towards other religions, often not reacting to religious differences unless they feel directly threatened.

What potential impact could the establishment of pesantren have on Bali’s demographics?

The speaker suggests that the establishment of pesantren might attract more Muslims to Bali, both from within the island and from outside, potentially altering the demographic balance.

What critique does the speaker offer about the state of Hindu education in Bali?

The speaker criticizes the current state of Hindu education in Bali, noting that Hindu schools and Pasraman (Hindu religious schools) are underfunded and underdeveloped compared to initiatives like pesantren.

Why does the speaker believe that political motivations are behind Giri Praste's statement?

The speaker believes that Giri Praste's statement is politically motivated because it was made in the context of the upcoming regional elections, possibly aimed at gaining support from the Muslim community.

What does the speaker suggest as a solution to the issues raised in the discussion?

The speaker suggests that the Balinese Hindu community should remain united and focus on strengthening their own religious education and infrastructure to maintain Bali’s status as a Hindu cultural center.

How does the speaker propose dealing with external pressures on Bali’s Hindu identity?

The speaker proposes that if the Hindu community in Bali stays united and avoids internal conflicts, no external force will be able to diminish Bali’s Hindu identity or its role as a cultural and religious barometer.