BEST Password Manager tier list 2024 | The ULTIMATE showdown!
Summary
TLDRThis video script reviews various password managers, providing a tier list based on security, features, and user experience. LastPass is warned against due to past breaches and dishonesty. NordPass earns a top tier for its security and affordability. Dashlane and RoboForm follow with strong security but at higher costs. OnePassword is praised for its family plan, despite a past vulnerability. Keeper stands out for its self-destruct feature and design. BitWarden offers the best price but lacks advanced features. The script serves as a guide to help viewers choose the right password manager for their needs.
Takeaways
- π« LastPass is strongly advised against due to past security breaches and dishonesty regarding user data.
- π NordPass is highly recommended for its strong security, user-friendly interface, and budget-friendly pricing.
- π± Dashlane stands out for iOS compatibility and includes a VPN and dark web scanner, though it's more expensive.
- π RoboForm is praised for its security and reliability, with a history of no security breaches, but its UI could be updated.
- π¨βπ©βπ§ OnePassword is a top choice for family plans with unique features like travel mode and a security key.
- πΈ Sticky Passwords is criticized for its high price and outdated interface, offering little to justify the cost.
- π‘οΈ Keeper is noted for its strong encryption, self-destruct feature, and secure messaging app, though some features require extra payment.
- π° BitWarden is the most affordable option with solid security, but lacks some features like automatic backup.
- π NordPass and OnePassword are the top recommendations for individual and family plans, respectively.
- β οΈ The script serves as a cautionary guide, advising viewers to avoid LastPass and consider other options based on security, features, and value.
Q & A
Why is LastPass not recommended in the video?
-LastPass is not recommended due to security breaches, dishonesty regarding the breaches, and false claims about user data not being stolen.
What makes NordPass stand out as a secure password manager?
-NordPass stands out for its strong encryption, zero-knowledge architecture, multiple independent audits, and a range of 2FA options.
What is the significance of Dashlane's move away from desktop apps?
-Dashlane's move away from desktop apps signifies a shift towards mobile versions and browser extensions, which still provide a solid security package.
Why is RoboForm praised for its straightforward approach in password management?
-RoboForm is praised for its straightforward approach because it focuses on essential security features without unnecessary extras, and it has a long history without any security breaches.
What unique feature does 1Password offer for added protection?
-1Password offers a unique 34-symbol security key and robust two-factor authentication for added protection.
How does Sticky Password compare to other password managers in terms of pricing and features?
-Sticky Password is considered overpriced compared to alternatives like NordPass and RoboForm, which offer similar security at a lower cost. It also has an outdated interface and lacks live chat or phone support.
What is the standout feature of Keeper that enhances its security?
-Keeper's standout feature is its built-in two-factor authenticator, which removes the need for third-party tools, and its self-destruct feature that can automatically erase data in case of a breach attempt.
Why is Bitwarden considered a solid choice for managing passwords on a budget?
-Bitwarden is considered a solid choice for budget-conscious users because it offers the most affordable premium version among the reviewed options, while still maintaining industry-standard encryption and security features.
What is the main drawback of Bitwarden mentioned in the video?
-The main drawback of Bitwarden is the lack of an automatic backup feature and limited functionality in its desktop apps.
What is the primary reason for placing 1Password in the A tier despite a discovered vulnerability?
-1Password is placed in the A tier primarily due to its strong security measures, pricing, and features, even though a vulnerability was discovered in a non-updated Mac version.
Outlines
π Password Manager Tier List Introduction
The video script begins by addressing the challenge of selecting a suitable password manager from a vast array of options. The speaker introduces a tier list based on their team's extensive testing and research, incorporating both objective findings and personal opinions. The tier list is designed to guide viewers towards the best options and away from the less desirable ones. The script humorously notes that the order of discussion will be random, like 'the wheel of fate,' before diving into the first password manager: LastPass. LastPass is criticized for its history of security breaches and dishonest communication with users, particularly regarding the 2022 breach. The speaker warns viewers to avoid LastPass due to these issues, suggesting it might be better not to use a password manager at all than to use LastPass.
π‘οΈ A Closer Look at NordPass
The script then highlights NordPass as a user-friendly and budget-friendly password manager with a strong security record. Unlike LastPass, NordPass has never experienced a breach and is praised for its modern encryption methods and zero-knowledge architecture, which ensure that only the user has access to their private information. The speaker details NordPass's security features, including biometric authentication and a variety of two-factor authentication options. Additionally, NordPass offers a range of features such as password generation, sharing, and autofill, as well as a password health checker and a data breach scanner. The script notes a minor drawback: the requirement of a browser extension for autofill functionality. Despite this, NordPass is commended for its ease of use, even for beginners, and its cost-effectiveness, including a limited free plan. The speaker also provides a QR code and links for viewers to access deals on NordPass and other highly recommended password managers.
π± Dashlane: A Mobile-Centric Option
The script discusses Dashlane, a password manager that has transitioned away from desktop apps but maintains a robust security package through mobile apps and browser extensions. Dashlane is noted for its comprehensive feature set, including a VPN and a dark web scanner, making it an excellent choice for iOS users due to its feature parity with the Android app. Despite being more expensive, Dashlane's higher price is justified by its quality. The script emphasizes Dashlane's security features, such as industry-standard encryption and a zero-trust architecture, and its strong two-factor authentication. The speaker assigns Dashlane an 'A' tier rating, acknowledging its security, additional features, and suitability for iOS, but notes that its pricing and lack of desktop apps prevent it from achieving an 'S' tier.
Mindmap
Keywords
π‘Password Manager
π‘Security
π‘Encryption
π‘Two-Factor Authentication (2FA)
π‘Zero-Knowledge Architecture
π‘Biometric Authentication
π‘Autofill
π‘Data Breach
π‘Tier List
π‘User Interface (UI)
π‘Family Plan
Highlights
LastPass is warned against due to security breaches and dishonesty regarding user data.
NordPass is praised for its security, user-friendliness, and budget-friendliness.
NordPass has never been breached and uses modern encryption and zero-knowledge architecture.
Dashlane offers a solid security package with a VPN and dark web scanner, and is a great choice for iOS.
RoboForm is a veteran in password management with a strong focus on security and a straightforward approach.
1Password offers a unique 34-symbol security key and robust two-factor authentication.
Sticky Password is criticized for its high price and outdated interface despite focusing on security.
Keeper is highlighted for its built-in two-factor authenticator and self-destruct feature.
Bitwarden is noted for its affordability and strong encryption, despite lacking some features.
LastPass is placed in the D or F tier due to security concerns.
NordPass is recommended and placed in the S tier for its comprehensive security and features.
Dashlane is given an A tier ranking for its security and extra features, despite its higher price.
RoboForm earns a B tier for its reliability and affordability, though its UI could be updated.
1Password's family plan is given an S tier, but individual plan is an A tier due to a past vulnerability.
Keeper secures an A tier with its strong security features and intuitive design, but some features cost extra.
Bitwarden is a B tier choice for those prioritizing cost-effectiveness and basic password management.
The presenter provides QR codes and links in the description for the best deals on the recommended password managers.
The tier list is presented in a random order to keep the audience engaged.
Transcripts
choosing the right password manager from
the ocean of options can be daunting
that's why our team has tested most of
the options over the years and we've put
together this password manager tier list
based on our own experience all of it is
grounded in thorough research and a bit
of our personal opinions so the top
tiers are the password managers we fully
recommend while the bottom ones are
those we suggest you steer clear of
let's see where each one of them
lands all right this tier list won't go
from best to worst or vice versa to make
things more interesting it's going to be
completely random the wheel of fate
decided that first up we go with last
pass or maybe I should call it last
breach let me check when the last one
was yeah December
2023 still it's one of the most known
and used password managers out there but
to be honest the only reason I have it
on my tier list at all is to warn you to
avoid it however the worst thing was not
the breaches themselves but the fact
that last past lies all the time they
stayed silent after the breach in 2022
instead of disclosing it they allowed
further damage to their users privacy
and hopes of hiding that it happened at
all then they also claimed that no user
data was stolen which was also proven to
be a lie and after all that LastPass now
markets itself as the safest password
manager so we're not even going to go
into anything else like features ease of
use or pricing the biggest price in this
case would likely be your privacy anyway
so I'll put it into the D tier or you
know what maybe even the F since it
might be Sav for not using a password
manager at all all right next we've got
Nord pass it's userfriendly budget
friendly and continues to enhance its
already impressive features set but
let's start with what's most important
security Nord pass has everything you'd
expect from a reliable top password
manager unlike last pass it's never been
breached and has earned an exceptional
reputation over the years this can
largely be a tribute to one of the most
modern encryptions on the market
additionally nordpass employs a zero
knowledge architecture ensuring that
only you can access your private
information allegedly not even nordpass
staff can view it to validate this claim
nordpass underwent multiple independent
audits on top of that nordpass bolsters
its security with biometric
authentication and a wide range of 2fa
options as I mentioned earlier Nord pass
offers a ton of features that of course
includes all the essentials like
password generating and sharing Ing and
a well functioning autofill there is one
downside to it though for autofill to
work it does require a browser extension
be installed but it also comes with
plenty of additional functionality like
the password Health Checker which tells
you if your passwords are weak or the
data breach scanner that notifies you if
any databases that hold your information
online have been breached despite having
plenty of things jammed into one app it
still manages to be easy to use even for
beginners the layout just makes sense
when it comes to cost nordpass is one of
the most budget friendly options on this
tier list and even has a limited free
plan in case you go for the premium I
made sure to find you the best deals you
can snag them by scanning this QR code
or by checking out the links in the
description where I've got deals for all
the other higher tier picks too anyhow
considering its security is topnotch
it's filled with features yet easy to
use and won't break your bank it's the S
tier for Nord pass next up Dashlane this
provider is a bit of an interesting case
it moved away from desktop apps but
still offers a solid Security package
through its mobile versions and browser
extensions it includes valuable extras
like a VPN and a dark web scanner dash
lane is an especially great choice for
IOS as it has pretty much the same
functionality and feature set as the
Android app which to be honest is rare
however dashing is one of the more
expensive options that said the higher
price does come with quality dashan
stands out in security featuring
industry standard encryption and a zero
trust architecture to keep your private
data safe even without desktop apps
dashing retains key security features
including strong two-factor
authentication All Things Considered I
got to go with the a tier despite its
safety strong extra features and being
one of the best password managers for
iOS the pricing and lack of desktop apps
makes it miss out on the S tier now it's
time for password managing veteran Robo
form despite its somewhat dated UI Robo
form remains one of the best password
manager options out there and this is
mainly due to their straightforward
approach it doesn't come with extras
like a VPN but security-wise it has
everything you need Robo for uses
industry standard encryption offers
strong two-factor authentication and
handles the encryption locally it also
underwent an independent audit by the
reputable experts at se fault security
RoboForm also has a long and reliable
history in password management having
been around since 1999 without a single
security breach which is 20 25 years in
counting by the way anyhow RoboForm gets
a check mark for security from me
looking at features RoboForm does
include some extras one of those is the
security Center which checks if any of
your passwords are weak or outdated
other notable features are secure folder
sharing a strong password generator
autofill and dark web monitoring so
nothing out of the ordinary but it still
covers all the essentials well RoboForm
has excellent mobile apps and is among
the best password manager for Android
and iOS picks however the desktop
version could be more userfriendly so if
you want a modern look on your desktop I
recommend using the web browser client
another strong point for robo form is
pricing it's one of the most affordable
password managers featured in this best
password manager tier list if you need
coverage for more than just yourself
consider their family plan which
supports up to five users under a single
subscription while there is a free
version available it lacks many of the
essential features like secure shared
folders or emergency access so overall
it's a secure provider that has all the
essential features and comes at a low
price with some interface updates it
would be an A but for now it's the B
tier the next provider is my top pick
for securing multiple devices or
protecting your entire family so let's
start with security beyond the industry
standard encryption one password offers
a unique 34 symbol security key and
robust two-factor authentication for
added protection besides that it has
multiple independent audits to its name
unfortunately I can't say that one
password has never been breached though
there was a vulnerability found in a
non-updated Mac version which allowed
attackers to access users vaults uh-oh
luckily the vulnerability was discovered
and disclosed by the investment platform
Robinhood security team and was taken
care of soon after by one password
moving on from that I do like the extra
features like Watchtower which monitors
for password leaks or compromises all
without any extra cost while one
password may not have an abund of
additional features with the individual
plan their family plan is another story
it has the best fault customization in
the entire password Market sharing
information among family members is both
easy and secure it also includes unique
features like travel mode allowing you
to designate certain vaults as travel
safe any Vault marked as unsafe is
automatically locked when you leave the
country once you return just turn off
the travel mode to gain the access Again
One password's Design is clean and
simple across both desktop and mobile
app CSE with all the essential features
you'd expect including a password
generator with a pass key option and
password sharing most of these features
are user friendly and work well the
exception being their autofill feature
often requiring manual searches through
vaults that kind of defeats the purpose
of having an autofill function in the
first place pricing wise one password is
a decent Choice their standard plan is
reasonably priced but unlike most other
providers one password doesn't have a
money back guarantee let's focus on the
positives though with one password
there's no limit on the number of
devices you can use per account but the
strongest point is their family plan
which becomes more affordable than the
individual plan if you share the fee
with at least one other person given the
security measures pricing and features
of the one password family plan I would
go with the S tier but the discovered
vulnerability on Max knocks it down one
tier so it gets an a some strong choices
so far can sticky passwords stick with
them spoiler alert not really while it's
very focused on security and has
implemented secure protocols to minimize
vulnerabilities Alternatives like Nord
pass Robo form offer the same level of
protection at a much more affordable
price sticky password to interface is
not eye candy either it feels outdated
maybe even more so than Robo form while
navigation wasn't an issue since it has
a similar layout to other providers
given the high price I expected
something more polished what else would
I expect for such a high price live chat
or phone support but that's also not
available you can only contact them via
email or search their knowledge base for
answers if you're still interested in
this provider you can try the free
version First and who knows maybe you'll
like it as far as the features go
there's really nothing unique but it
does cover the basics like password
generating and sharing dark web
monitoring and autofill overall it's a
safe provider with all the basic
features but unreasonably priced and
with a dated interface for those reasons
I can't put it any higher than the C
tier okay moving past the badl looking
interfaces next up we've got keeper but
it has more to offer than just greatl
looking apps it's never experienced a
breach and has only strengthened its
reputation over the years and like most
top managers it employs strong
encryption one standout feature of
keeper is its built-in two Factor
authenticator removing the need for
thirdparty tools additionally keeper
offers a unique self-destruct feature
allowing you to configure local
passwords vaults messages or files to
automatically erase in the event of a
breach attempt all of that combined with
its proprietary authenticator makes
keeper a highly secure password manager
besides self-destruct keeper has other
extra features to offer too those
include keeper chat a secure messaging
app and breach watch Keeper's version of
dark web monitoring which comes at an
additional cost when it comes to
essential features keeper covers all the
basics it includes a strong password
generator a password sharing feature
reliable autofill and password security
audits I also appreciate keeper
intuitive design everything is easy to
find regardless of which app you use and
if someone asked what a modern looking
password manager interface should look
like I'd just show them keeper now
looking at pricing it's still on the
pricier side on this best password
manager tier list keeper offers a
Premium plan and a family plan which
makes it a good value if you need
coverage for at least two additional
users besides yourself that said the
main drawback is not the base price but
the fact that some features are locked
behind an additional pay wall with that
in mind I can't place it into the S tier
but a seems reasonable all right let's
talk about bit Warden one of the biggest
pros of this provider is its pricing bit
warden's premium version is the most
affordable in this entire lineup yes
even cheaper than Robo form that said
when considering a cheap password
manager security should be an even
greater concern but bit Warden uses the
same industry standard encryption as
other premium tools and its security is
further enhanced by a variety of
two-factor authentication options and a
zero knowledge architecture like every
other top option that I've recommended
in this video bit Warden has never been
breached or hacked but just like every
password manager bit Warden has its cons
too there's no automatic backup feature
and the desktop apps are somewhat
Limited in functionality overall bit
Warden is a solid choice for managing
passwords especially if you're looking
to save money besides coming at a really
low price it has a serviceable free
option as well that said if you need
more than just the basics there are
better choices for you so the B tier it
is but going for bit Warden is not the
only way to save money I've got
discounts for all other B tier or higher
picks down in the description so let's
take a quick look at our final tier list
to be honest there's just one provider I
recommend avoiding while all others at
the very least can be serviceable
choices so my top recommendations have
to be Nord for the individual plan and
one password if you need a family plan
that would be all in this one thanks for
watching and see you soon
Browse More Related Video
5.0 / 5 (0 votes)