How to Distribute Your Protein to Maximize Muscle Growth

FoundMyFitness Clips
30 Jul 202422:30

Summary

TLDRIn this podcast, the discussion delves into the intricacies of protein distribution for muscle synthesis, particularly focusing on the impact of protein intake timing and quantity. The conversation reveals that while a balanced protein intake throughout the day is ideal, consuming a larger amount in the evening can still be beneficial, especially for those engaging in physical activity. The host and guest explore the anabolic window post-exercise, emphasizing the body's heightened sensitivity to protein intake for up to 48 hours, which can enhance muscle reconditioning. The summary underscores the importance of regular exercise and adequate protein consumption for muscle mass gains, suggesting that the distribution of protein across meals matters less than the total daily intake and the consistency of training.

Takeaways

  • πŸ“Š Most people tend to consume the majority of their daily protein during their evening meal, which is about three times more than what they consume during breakfast or lunch.
  • πŸ‹οΈβ€β™‚οΈ A single meal containing 20 grams of high-quality protein can maximize muscle protein synthesis for up to 4 to 6 hours, emphasizing the importance of evenly distributing protein intake across main meals.
  • πŸŒ™ Consuming a protein-rich snack before sleep can be beneficial, especially for those who exercise in the evening, as it provides an anabolic stimulus and aids in muscle reconditioning.
  • πŸ“ˆ Studies show that distributing protein intake evenly throughout the day can optimize muscle building and conditioning, rather than skewing it heavily towards one meal.
  • πŸ” A study found that consuming 100 grams of protein led to a prolonged stimulation of muscle protein synthesis over 12 to 24 hours, suggesting that the quantity of protein can influence the duration of anabolic effects.
  • πŸƒβ€β™‚οΈ Physical activity, such as resistance training, can increase the body's sensitivity to protein intake, enhancing muscle protein synthesis for up to 24 to 48 hours post-exercise.
  • 🍽️ For those practicing time-restricted eating, ensuring adequate protein intake within the eating window is crucial to support muscle protein synthesis and overall muscle mass.
  • πŸ₯ Research indicates that protein consumed in the evening is digested and absorbed while sleeping, contributing to muscle protein synthesis overnight, which is particularly important for the elderly or those at risk of muscle loss.
  • πŸ€” While the distribution and timing of protein intake can influence muscle protein synthesis, the overall amount of protein consumed and regular engagement in physical activity are more critical for muscle mass gains.
  • 🚫 The script highlights that focusing solely on nutrition without considering the role of physical activity can lead to an incomplete understanding of how to optimize muscle reconditioning and overall health.

Q & A

  • How does the distribution of protein intake throughout the day affect muscle protein synthesis?

    -Protein distribution throughout the day is important for muscle protein synthesis. It's suggested that having 20-25 grams of protein in each main meal (breakfast, lunch, and dinner) provides an anabolic stimulus that optimizes muscle building and conditioning.

  • Is it better to evenly distribute protein intake or can it be skewed towards the evening?

    -While it's generally advised to evenly distribute protein intake, studies show that even a large evening meal can still stimulate muscle protein synthesis, suggesting that the body can effectively utilize protein even when consumed in larger quantities later in the day.

  • What is the significance of consuming a protein-rich snack before sleep for athletes?

    -A protein-rich snack before sleep can provide a continued anabolic stimulus overnight, which is particularly beneficial for athletes who exercise in the evening, helping to optimize muscle reconditioning and recovery.

  • How does the timing of protein intake in relation to exercise affect muscle protein synthesis?

    -Exercise increases the sensitivity of muscles to the anabolic effects of protein for up to 24 to 48 hours. Therefore, the timing of protein intake in relation to exercise is less critical than the consistency of both training and protein intake.

  • What is the role of physical activity in muscle protein synthesis and how does it interact with protein intake?

    -Physical activity, especially resistance training, enhances the body's efficiency in utilizing protein for muscle protein synthesis. It makes the body 'smarter' in handling protein, ensuring that more of the ingested protein is directed towards muscle building.

  • Can muscle mass be gained with a higher protein intake in fewer meals?

    -Yes, muscle mass can be gained even when protein is consumed in fewer, larger meals, as long as the total daily protein intake is sufficient. The body's response to protein intake is influenced by recent physical activity, which can increase the efficiency of protein utilization.

  • What is the impact of time-restricted eating on muscle protein synthesis and overall muscle mass?

    -Time-restricted eating, where meals are condensed into a shorter window, does not negatively impact muscle protein synthesis or overall muscle mass when total protein and calorie intake are maintained. It can be an effective strategy for some individuals to manage calorie intake and body weight.

  • How does the body respond to a single large meal of protein compared to multiple smaller meals?

    -The body can effectively digest and utilize protein from a single large meal, with the protein synthesis response lasting longer due to the extended digestion and absorption process. However, distributing protein intake throughout the day can provide a more consistent anabolic stimulus.

  • What is the recommended protein intake for individuals who are physically active and want to maximize muscle gains?

    -For individuals engaged in regular physical activity, especially resistance training, a higher protein intake is recommended, typically around 20-25 grams of protein per meal, to ensure optimal muscle protein synthesis and support muscle gains.

  • How does the body handle protein intake in the context of overnight fasting?

    -Protein consumed in the evening can still be effectively digested and utilized by the body during overnight fasting. Consuming a protein-rich meal or snack before sleep can provide a continued anabolic stimulus, supporting muscle maintenance and growth.

Outlines

00:00

πŸ₯© Protein Distribution and Muscle Synthesis

The paragraph discusses the importance of protein distribution throughout the day for muscle protein synthesis. It highlights that most people tend to consume more protein during their evening meal compared to breakfast or lunch. The speaker suggests that consuming 20-25 grams of high-quality protein at each main meal can provide an anabolic stimulus, optimizing muscle building and conditioning. The conversation also touches on the idea that a single meal with 20 grams of protein can maximize muscle protein synthesis for 4 to 6 hours, supporting the notion of evenly distributing protein across meals. Additionally, the discussion points out that while more protein can extend the anabolic response, it's generally advised to have a balanced protein intake across meals for optimal muscle synthesis.

05:02

πŸ§ͺ Study on Protein Quantity and Digestion

This section delves into a study that examined the effects of consuming 100 grams of protein versus the standard 20-30 grams, which are known to maximize muscle protein synthesis. The study extended its observation period to 12 and 24 hours, finding a greater response with the higher protein intake. It also explored the digestion and absorption process by using a novel method of infusing cows with labeled amino acids, allowing researchers to track the digestion and absorption of protein in the body. The findings suggest that more protein takes longer to digest and can stimulate muscle protein synthesis over an extended period, challenging the conventional 4 to 6-hour window.

10:03

πŸ₯ Hospital Studies and Protein Timing

The discussion shifts to the application of protein intake research in hospital settings, particularly for elderly patients at risk of muscle loss. The speaker describes studies that involved giving protein to elderly participants during sleep to assess its digestion and absorption, and its impact on muscle protein synthesis. The results indicated that protein given in the evening is indeed digested and absorbed while sleeping, supporting the idea of an evening protein-rich meal or snack. The paragraph also addresses the question of whether the timing of a large protein intake before sleep affects muscle protein synthesis the following day, suggesting that the response to breakfast remains unaffected by the previous night's protein intake.

15:03

πŸ•’ Time-Restricted Eating and Protein Intake

This part of the conversation explores the impact of time-restricted eating on muscle protein synthesis and overall health. The speaker mentions studies that did not find significant differences in muscle protein synthesis between those who practiced time-restricted eating and those who did not. It also touches on the potential benefits of time-restricted eating for weight management and glucose homeostasis. The discussion emphasizes the importance of ensuring adequate protein intake during the eating window for those following time-restricted eating regimens, and suggests that physical activity, particularly resistance training, plays a crucial role in maintaining and building muscle mass, irrespective of the specific timing of protein intake.

20:04

πŸ’ͺ Physical Activity and Protein Sensitivity

The final paragraph focuses on how physical activity can influence the body's sensitivity to protein and muscle protein synthesis. It suggests that engaging in resistance training can make the body more efficient at utilizing protein for muscle building, even up to 24 to 48 hours post-exercise. The conversation points out that the timing of protein intake relative to exercise is less critical than the consistency of both training and nutrition. It concludes with a speculative discussion on whether distributing a higher total daily protein intake over fewer meals could affect muscle mass gains, suggesting that as long as adequate protein and training are maintained, the distribution may not significantly impact outcomes.

Mindmap

Keywords

πŸ’‘Protein Distribution

Protein distribution refers to the way individuals allocate their protein intake throughout the day across different meals. In the context of the video, it is discussed how the majority of people tend to consume more protein during their evening meal compared to breakfast or lunch, which is a pattern observed in nutritional surveys like NHANES in the United States. The video suggests that for optimal muscle protein synthesis, it is beneficial to evenly distribute protein intake across all main meals of the day, aiming for about 20-25 grams of high-quality protein per meal.

πŸ’‘Muscle Protein Synthesis

Muscle protein synthesis is the process by which the body creates new muscle proteins, which is crucial for muscle growth and repair. The video emphasizes the importance of protein intake in relation to muscle protein synthesis, noting that a single meal containing 20 grams of high-quality protein can maximize this process for up to 4 to 6 hours. The discussion also touches on how distributing protein intake evenly throughout the day can provide multiple anabolic stimuli, potentially optimizing muscle conditioning.

πŸ’‘Anabolic Stimulus

An anabolic stimulus is a trigger that promotes the building of muscle tissue. In the video, it is mentioned that each main meal containing sufficient protein acts as an anabolic stimulus, contributing to muscle protein synthesis. The concept is used to explain why evenly distributing protein across meals is beneficial, as it provides a consistent stimulus for muscle building throughout the day.

πŸ’‘NHANES

NHANES stands for the National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey, which is a program of studies designed to assess the health and nutritional status of adults and children in the United States. The video references NHANES data to highlight typical protein consumption patterns, indicating that most people consume a disproportionate amount of their daily protein during their evening meal.

πŸ’‘Endurance Athlete

An endurance athlete is someone who participates in sports that require prolonged physical efforts, often involving aerobic activities like running or cycling. The script mentions that optimizing muscle conditioning through protein intake can be particularly beneficial for endurance athletes, as it can help them maintain the muscle mass necessary for their type of exercise.

πŸ’‘Bodybuilder

A bodybuilder is an individual who engages in resistance training to develop their muscles for aesthetic and competitive purposes. The video contrasts the nutritional needs of bodybuilders with those of endurance athletes, suggesting that bodybuilders might require a different distribution of protein to support the growth of larger muscles.

πŸ’‘Time-Restricted Eating

Time-restricted eating, also known as intermittent fasting, is an eating pattern where food is consumed only during a specific time window each day, with a corresponding fasting period. The video discusses how this approach might affect protein distribution and muscle protein synthesis, suggesting that even with a shorter eating window, ensuring adequate protein intake can still support muscle maintenance and growth.

πŸ’‘Protein Rich Snack

A protein-rich snack is a small meal or between-meal food item that contains a significant amount of protein. The video suggests that consuming a protein-rich snack, especially in the evening or post-exercise, can provide an additional anabolic stimulus and support muscle protein synthesis overnight.

πŸ’‘Glucose Homeostasis

Glucose homeostasis refers to the body's ability to maintain a stable blood glucose level. The video mentions that time-restricted eating can improve glucose homeostasis, which is beneficial for overall health and can be particularly important for individuals managing conditions like diabetes.

πŸ’‘Resistance Training

Resistance training involves exercises that work against an external force or weight to build muscle strength, power, and endurance. The video emphasizes the importance of resistance training in conjunction with protein intake for muscle growth and maintenance, suggesting that physical activity enhances the body's ability to utilize protein for muscle reconditioning.

Highlights

Protein distribution throughout the day is crucial for muscle protein synthesis.

Most people tend to consume more protein during their evening meal.

A single meal with 20 grams of high-quality protein can maximize muscle protein synthesis for 4 to 6 hours.

Even distribution of protein across meals is recommended for optimal muscle conditioning.

Athletes may benefit from additional protein intake, especially post-exercise.

Protein intake before sleep can aid in muscle protein synthesis overnight.

Recent studies show that larger protein meals can lead to a prolonged anabolic response.

Digestion and absorption of protein were measured using innovative methods involving stable isotope labeling.

The timing of protein intake in relation to sleep and physical activity is significant for muscle reconditioning.

Even with time-restricted eating, adequate protein intake can support muscle mass maintenance.

Physical activity enhances the body's sensitivity to protein intake for muscle protein synthesis.

Resistance training at least three times a week is essential for muscle mass gain.

The body's efficiency in utilizing protein increases with physical activity.

The anabolic window post-exercise lasts up to 24 to 48 hours, making protein intake throughout the day effective.

The total daily protein intake is more critical than the distribution across meals for muscle mass gains.

Physical activity should not be overlooked as it plays a significant role in muscle protein synthesis.

Nutrition and training consistency are key factors in optimizing muscle reconditioning.

Transcripts

play00:00

maybe we can talk we can get into that a

play00:01

little bit more in a minute I wanted to

play00:02

kind of continue on the nutrition part

play00:04

with with protein distributions you've

play00:07

done a lot of research in this area as

play00:09

well and I had done some some reading

play00:12

preparing for this podcast on like some

play00:14

of the nutritional surveys that are done

play00:16

in the United States they're called and

play00:17

Hanes in terms of like how are people

play00:21

typically Distributing their protein

play00:23

amongst their males and I think probably

play00:25

it's very similar to what's found in

play00:27

Europe where people are eating the

play00:30

majority of their protein is skewed

play00:32

towards their evening meal their last

play00:34

meal of the day and um in in in most

play00:37

cases at least with respect to this

play00:38

anhan data it's about three times the

play00:41

amount of protein in their in their

play00:43

evening meal versus their morning meal

play00:45

or even their afternoon meal does it

play00:47

matter with respect to you know how the

play00:50

muscle responds to amino acids

play00:53

throughout the day like is it better to

play00:56

evenly have your protein evenly

play00:59

distributed or can you skew it in the

play01:02

evening and still have the same I don't

play01:04

want to just say increases in muscle

play01:06

protein synthesis because as you

play01:07

mentioned that doesn't always translate

play01:09

to gains and muscle mass people are more

play01:10

interested in gains and muscle mass so

play01:13

let's let's leave it with that end point

play01:16

so we try to make it more simple but it

play01:20

is actually much more complex but if you

play01:23

consider that a single meal containing

play01:25

20 grams of a high quality protein

play01:27

maximizes muscle protein synthesis for

play01:30

up to 4 to 6 hours then it makes the

play01:33

most sense that every main meal

play01:35

throughout the day is an anabolic

play01:37

stimulus so that you would have 20 to 25

play01:41

grams of protein in your breakfast 20 to

play01:43

25 grams of protein in your lunch and 20

play01:46

to 25 25 grams of protein in your in

play01:48

your dinner and then theoretically you

play01:51

have three anabolic stimuli throughout

play01:53

to day helping you to optimize muscle

play01:57

building not see muscle building muscle

play01:59

reconditioning

play02:00

I actually make that mistake all the

play02:01

time by saying that it's not about

play02:03

muscle build building it's optimizing

play02:05

muscle conditioning and that could be

play02:06

for the endurance atlete that would be

play02:09

better muscle to do endurance type

play02:11

exercise and for the bodybuilder that

play02:13

might be a bigger muscle that's the

play02:16

that's what now everybody's being

play02:17

advised for athletes that consume more

play02:20

than those 75 grams of protein that you

play02:23

can also add another meal moment and

play02:26

that's for example the pre-sleep uh

play02:28

evening snack for example if you

play02:31

exercise in the evening you take a

play02:33

protein Rich snack after that exercise

play02:35

session in the evening and when you have

play02:37

dinner for example at 4 5 or 6 and you

play02:40

have a training session between 700 and

play02:42

9 you have a protein Rich snake snack at

play02:44

9: before you go to bed at say 11 and so

play02:48

that's what a lot of athletes do just

play02:49

have a nice distribution to throughout

play02:51

the day the long-term studies longterm

play02:55

semi longterm on um nitrogen balance or

play02:59

on muscle protein synthesis are not that

play03:02

clear there's some studies saying you

play03:04

have better retention of your of your

play03:06

protein and of your nitrogen when you

play03:08

actually have a nice distribution but

play03:11

we've also have a recent study that we

play03:12

show that if you have a huge meal you

play03:14

have a greater anabolic response when

play03:16

you assess it over a more prolong period

play03:18

of time now a lot of people are now

play03:20

asking us like should I have one meal uh

play03:24

no it's a study to show that the 6h hour

play03:28

or the 4-Hour response to a single meal

play03:30

can be longer if you give more protein

play03:32

because all the protein still needs to

play03:34

be digested and absorbed but that

play03:36

doesn't change what I think now from all

play03:38

the evidence that we have it's being

play03:40

advised to have a nice even distribution

play03:43

of your protein in your main meals so

play03:45

let's talk a little bit about that that

play03:47

study since you brought it up because um

play03:50

it was surprising to to many people

play03:52

maybe you can talk a little bit about

play03:54

the difference in terms of the quantity

play03:56

it was like 100 gram of protein versus

play03:59

what has previously been shown maybe 30

play04:01

I think grams of protein was was

play04:03

something that's been shown in terms of

play04:05

maximizing now this was muscle protein

play04:07

synthesis yep that you were looking at y

play04:09

so the older studies there are there's

play04:12

two basically two dose response studies

play04:14

that show in healthy young people um at

play04:17

rest or after exercise 20 gram maximizes

play04:20

muscle protein synthesis for somewhere

play04:23

between uh 4 to 6 hours after the meal

play04:27

so in that time period four to 6 hour

play04:29

post Ral period we call

play04:31

that some of that protein might not have

play04:34

been digested and absorbed if you give

play04:36

more than those 20 G so the 40 gam that

play04:40

they showed in those studies didn't show

play04:41

a greater response but they only

play04:43

measured for four or 6 hours were

play04:45

depending now we wanted to do a study to

play04:48

show that if you give 100 grams which is

play04:51

absolutely not something that I'm

play04:52

suggesting that people should be

play04:54

consuming that it takes longer to digest

play04:57

everything and that you have a longer s

play04:59

ulation of muscle protein synthesis over

play05:01

a more prolong period of time so we also

play05:04

measured not over 6 hours but over 12

play05:06

and even 24 hours and then we see that

play05:09

you get a greater response now the

play05:11

interesting part of this study is is we

play05:13

also assessed digestion and absorption

play05:17

now that is difficult because how do you

play05:19

do this now instead of infusing tracers

play05:23

only and measuring the incorporation in

play05:25

muscle that's how you measure muscle

play05:26

protein synthesis we actually did an

play05:29

experiment before that we Infuse the cow

play05:32

with labeled amino acids so you have

play05:35

amino acids with a chemical flag stable

play05:38

isotope labeled we Infuse it in the cow

play05:41

the cow actually incorporates it in the

play05:43

milk so we have milk protein and we

play05:46

extract the milk we extract the milk

play05:47

protein so we have milk protein where

play05:49

those labeled amino acids are

play05:51

Incorporated and then we provide that

play05:53

protein so we can see the digestion we

play05:56

see those labeled amino acids coming out

play05:58

of the protein being released to the

play06:00

circulation then we take a blood sample

play06:02

we can actually see those amino acids so

play06:04

we see how much of the protein that you

play06:06

ingest is released in the circulation

play06:09

and then we can even see how much is Con

play06:10

converted to muscle and then you see

play06:13

that it takes much longer to get all

play06:15

those amino acids in the circulation and

play06:18

also to get a longer stimulation of

play06:19

muscle protein synthesis so simply

play06:22

regard also the fact that time is a is a

play06:25

factor in all of this but of course we

play06:28

most of us eat one meal and then four to

play06:31

6 hours later the second meal and that's

play06:33

why all the previous studies always

play06:35

looked at 4 to 6 hour post prenal

play06:37

periods unless it's your last meal of

play06:40

the evening good point so the question

play06:42

then is if you if it's your last meal in

play06:44

the evening and you know let's say

play06:47

you've already distributed your protein

play06:49

intake fairly decently in your first two

play06:52

meals some people we'll talk about a

play06:54

minute time restricted eating and

play06:55

caloric restriction but um and and let's

play06:58

say you you want to go a little higher

play06:59

for your maybe not all the way to 100

play07:01

gram but you know 60 whatever then would

play07:06

you have would you if you speculate on

play07:08

this and this kind of this there's two

play07:10

parts to this question would you think

play07:12

that the the increase in muscle protein

play07:14

synthesis would be higher if you had

play07:16

ingested 60 gram of protein in that last

play07:19

male versus

play07:21

25 throughout the evening like we're

play07:23

talking like 12 20 hours and also what

play07:27

if you then wake up in the morning and

play07:29

then you have a again your first meal is

play07:31

that going to change the muscle protein

play07:34

synthesis or are you better off having

play07:36

that meal higher are you going to get

play07:38

just are you really maximizing it I I

play07:41

love those questions because the the the

play07:42

three questions that you now asked is

play07:44

probably seven years of my life so um

play07:49

what we so one of the things how I

play07:51

should start answering this is that we

play07:54

see a lot of people in the hospital

play07:57

losing muscle

play08:00

and so they're admitted to hospital

play08:02

losing a lot of muscle and we know that

play08:03

the the loss of muscle or muscle mass is

play08:05

an important predictor of clinical

play08:08

complications readmission Health Etc so

play08:12

we wanted to do something for patients

play08:14

to reduce muscle muscle loss so we

play08:17

thought like if we give these just in

play08:18

less with athletes if we give these

play08:21

elderly people another meal in the

play08:23

evening can we minimize muscle loss or

play08:26

stimulate muscle protein synthesis now

play08:28

when you're in the hospital probably

play08:29

hear the same thing you get your last

play08:30

meal about 5 or 6:00 in the evening and

play08:33

then the next meal is breakfast the next

play08:34

day at 9:00 so you spend more than 15 16

play08:38

17 hours in an overnight fasted state

play08:41

which is maybe nice for for people

play08:42

trying to lose weight or anything like

play08:44

that but for people at risk of muscle

play08:46

muscle loss it's not a good thing so we

play08:50

started thinking about if you give

play08:52

protein in the evening is it digested

play08:54

while you sleep does this all work while

play08:57

while you sleep now that's difficult

play08:59

because you can't take muscle biopsies

play09:01

when somebody sleeps and not wake the

play09:02

person up and you also can't ingest

play09:04

protein while you're sleeping so what we

play09:06

did is and that's when we started doing

play09:08

studies with the older people the great

play09:11

volunteers much better than most of the

play09:13

athletes that they call us and then they

play09:15

actually say like look I was in your lab

play09:17

last year can I come back do you have a

play09:19

new study running and then then I would

play09:21

say something like oh yeah you can come

play09:23

over what we'll do we put a nasogastric

play09:25

tube down your nose in your gut we take

play09:27

a muscle biopsy then we put you to bed

play09:30

in the hospital then at 2:00 at night

play09:32

while you're sleeping we'll tiptoe into

play09:35

into your next to your bed put 40 Gams

play09:37

of pro protein in your gut and then wake

play09:40

you up in the morning at 7:00 with a

play09:42

muscle biopsy and then they respond like

play09:44

where can I sign sign up and when can I

play09:46

come over so these are cool studies but

play09:49

they showed that if you give um 40 grams

play09:52

of protein in the evening that protein

play09:54

is digested and absorbed while you sleep

play09:57

because we use that intrinsically

play09:58

labeled protein so we could follow it

play10:00

and it's actually converted to muscle

play10:03

now that study was weird because when we

play10:05

published that that was a nice proof of

play10:07

principle study I got a lot of coaches

play10:09

and and people calling me and asking me

play10:12

where they could buy those naso gastic

play10:14

tubes and I said like like no this is a

play10:17

proof of principle study just have a

play10:19

protein Rich snack in the evening so

play10:21

just to make that clear we actually

play10:23

follow that up with an ad lead study

play10:25

where we showed that having a protein

play10:27

Rich snack in the evening is digested in

play10:29

absorbed and stimulates muscle protein

play10:30

synthesis overnight and so that amount

play10:34

of protein will help you reconditioning

play10:36

more

play10:37

efficiently that's the first answer to

play10:39

your or the question to your first first

play10:42

question now the second was is it of

play10:45

benefit on top of knowing that you'll

play10:47

have breakfast and lunch the next day so

play10:51

we also did that study we provided

play10:53

protein in the evening or we didn't

play10:55

provide protein in the evening and

play10:57

looked at the response to breakfast now

play11:00

response to breakfast in both conditions

play11:02

was exactly the same to my surprise

play11:04

because I expected if you give a lot of

play11:06

protein the evening before then the

play11:08

response to breakfast would be minimized

play11:10

but it wasn't it was exactly the same so

play11:15

it does give me some insight that at

play11:18

least in the first 24 hours you have a

play11:20

greater benefit when you provide

play11:22

sufficient protein to maximize the

play11:24

reconditioning what about people so Tim

play11:27

restricted eating you mentioned a lot of

play11:29

people are do practice time restricted

play11:32

eating and they're eating in an 8 Hour

play11:34

window and they're fasting for 16 hours

play11:36

and you've done some research in this

play11:37

area as well so can you eating that that

play11:41

large evening you know that large

play11:43

protein Bolis with your last meal you

play11:45

know what if it's earlier and it's not

play11:47

like right before sleep because you have

play11:50

your your feeding window your eating

play11:51

window and then you have your fasting

play11:52

window do you think based on your your

play11:55

study with a 100 grams of protein really

play11:57

extreme case that that protein will be

play12:01

digested longer and incorporated into

play12:04

muscle for muscle protein synthesis So

play12:07

based on the theory that you need an

play12:08

anabolic stimulus every every main meal

play12:11

in order to get the optimal 24-hour

play12:13

response then you would actually have to

play12:16

conclude that intermittent fasting of

play12:18

Tim restricted feeding is not a good

play12:21

thing but uh we've done a study a more

play12:23

longer term study EMA did that with

play12:25

labeled water and she did that when um

play12:28

in in

play12:29

where I had a visiting professorship

play12:32

position there and we didn't see a

play12:34

difference in muscle protein synthesis

play12:37

with the time restricted eating versus

play12:39

the the non-time restricted eating so

play12:42

it's possible the explanation is that if

play12:45

you have a period to where there's less

play12:47

uh or there's no food intake but you had

play12:50

a greater meal as the last one that that

play12:52

actually also had a greater response

play12:54

over a more long period of time just

play12:56

like the 100 G study so it's possibly

play12:58

that that evens it out the other big

play13:01

question is of course why would you do

play13:03

Tim restrictive eating or um um

play13:07

intermittent fasting um the other thing

play13:10

on on that study was we didn't see

play13:12

differences or that project I should say

play13:15

is we didn't see a difference in fat

play13:18

loss so and I have a lot of people

play13:21

calling me and saying like but the time

play13:23

restricted eating uh intermittent

play13:25

fasting really works for me now I I did

play13:28

it myself as well works really well why

play13:31

because in the morning I go to work I

play13:34

don't think about food because I'm too

play13:36

busy and everybody's just walking into

play13:37

my office by around 4:00 I get like a

play13:40

little bit Bish so I start eating

play13:42

something and then I get home around 6

play13:45

and around 7 I open up the computer to

play13:47

see what crap emails I got and then I

play13:50

start having my main meal and snacking

play13:52

if I decide to not eat after

play13:55

6 I will eat much less than I actually

play13:59

ire so I'll lose weight so basically

play14:01

because More than 70% of my energy

play14:04

intake is after 7:00 at night time

play14:06

restricted eating would be great for me

play14:08

but if I would eat all the food that I

play14:10

would eat after seven throughout the day

play14:13

I would lose or I would not lose that

play14:15

fat mass and I would not lose weight so

play14:18

it's a good way for people to cope with

play14:21

a lower energy intake right I think

play14:24

there's now been many many studies that

play14:26

have done that have found that people

play14:28

naturally

play14:29

doing time restricted eating you know in

play14:31

they're free living conditions on on

play14:33

average reduce their calorie intake by

play14:35

about 200 calories per day and and

play14:39

that's just you know natural because

play14:40

people don't snack or they don't eat

play14:42

that dessert or they skip you know

play14:44

because they are trying to to restrict

play14:46

their their meals into a shorter time

play14:47

period but and I think you've even shown

play14:49

this and other studies many Studies have

play14:50

shown while if you do keep calories the

play14:53

same you will not lose fat-free mass and

play14:55

weight right um then glucose the glucose

play15:00

homeostasis is still improved by not

play15:03

eating in a huge you know like by

play15:05

restricting your time eating window

play15:07

shorter to let's say eight hours you

play15:08

know in some cases 10 but mostly eight

play15:11

even shorter than that six hours so

play15:14

there are there are people also that are

play15:15

very interested in their glucose

play15:17

homeostasis that you know want to eat

play15:20

within a a shorter time window as well

play15:22

but the question then goes is well if

play15:24

they're skipping meals or skipping

play15:25

snacks then they're potentially skipping

play15:27

protein intake right if someone is doing

play15:30

the Tim restricted eating schedule where

play15:32

they're eating within an 8- hour window

play15:35

then they really do need to make sure

play15:37

they're they're not losing their their

play15:40

their protein correct yes and so if they

play15:43

maintain the normal protein intake then

play15:45

they should be fine uh because it's

play15:48

possible that more protein per meal has

play15:51

a greater effect like the 100 grams but

play15:53

the other part is also I mean let's not

play15:55

I mean it's it's funny but we always end

play15:58

up talking about nutrition and then we

play16:00

don't talk about the physical activity

play16:03

um because I mean the same thing when

play16:05

people ask me like what should I eat to

play16:07

to to lose weight and I always say less

play16:10

uh because there is no magic bullet but

play16:12

the physical activity we know from all

play16:14

hypercaloric diets that if you actually

play16:17

are are on a hypercaloric diet that two

play16:20

sessions of resistance exercise

play16:22

throughout the week prevents the lean

play16:24

mass loss

play16:26

so maybe instead of focusing on the

play16:29

protein focus on physical activity in

play16:32

order to maintain your fat-free mass by

play16:33

doing two resistance exercise sessions a

play16:35

week much more important than than the

play16:37

protein so let me rephrase my question

play16:40

for someone who's doing time restricted

play16:42

eating in an 8 Hour window fasting for

play16:44

16 hours and they're engaged in

play16:45

resistance training at least three times

play16:48

a week minimum and they're taking in

play16:50

their protein they're not they're not

play16:51

missing their protein and can they and

play16:53

they they're in the resistance right and

play16:55

yes can they gain muscle mass can they

play16:56

gain it yes yes sir okay that's an

play17:00

absolute yes I mean there's even studies

play17:02

that um so again

play17:06

um8 g of protein you can actually gain

play17:10

muscle on8 gram of protein maybe you can

play17:14

gain more muscle on 1.2 but you can

play17:17

still gain muscle on A8 gram protein per

play17:19

kilogram body mass per day the body is

play17:22

much smarter than we think if you

play17:24

actually do exercise and we ingest the

play17:26

same protein that we can track

play17:27

throughout the body we see that the same

play17:29

amount of proteins of course digested

play17:31

and absorbed but more goes to the lag

play17:33

that it exercise so there's also an

play17:35

efficiency effect physical activity

play17:38

makes you more of what you just ate so

play17:41

more of the protein is actually

play17:42

converted when you perform physical

play17:44

activity so the body gets smarter how it

play17:47

handles protein I have a question so if

play17:50

we we were talking about protein

play17:52

distribution and perhaps you know being

play17:54

beneficial to more evenly

play17:56

distribute protein but how does physical

play18:00

activity because you said physical

play18:01

activity sensitizes I mean your your you

play18:04

said it sensitizes muscle to amuno acids

play18:08

um how does that does that change

play18:10

whether I mean you would think that in

play18:12

the background of someone who's

play18:13

Physically Active does all these other

play18:15

little differences matter I think so I

play18:17

mean all it's all those little things

play18:19

that matter I mean to look at the

play18:20

cyclist it's the bike it's the helmet

play18:23

it's the it's the it's it's the

play18:24

nutrition it's the it's the training

play18:26

it's the mental coaching and all of this

play18:27

together make better lead so it's all

play18:29

these small things but um so what is

play18:32

interesting to see is that you have an

play18:34

anabolic response to feeding you have an

play18:36

anabolic response to exercise you have

play18:39

an anabolic response a greater anabolic

play18:40

response when you compare the two now

play18:43

the nice thing is that uh I think number

play18:46

question number one the most the

play18:47

question I was being asked the most is

play18:50

do I need to take the protein before or

play18:52

after the exercise session which is

play18:54

almost the same question you asking

play18:56

should I do the exercise before the meal

play18:58

or after the meal meal it's basically Al

play19:00

also the same thing it doesn't really

play19:02

matter that much because exercise makes

play19:04

the muscle more sensitive to the

play19:06

stimulation of muscle protein synthesis

play19:08

through food intake but it does so for

play19:10

up to 24 to even 48 hours so if you do

play19:13

an exercise session today your response

play19:16

to breakfast tomorrow morning will be

play19:18

greater but also lunch tomorrow

play19:21

afternoon and also dinner tomorrow night

play19:24

and so after that you have your second

play19:26

exercise session so it's not about what

play19:28

should go go first but it's a

play19:29

consistency of training and meals in

play19:32

between and the training will make your

play19:34

meals more efficient in how they

play19:36

optimize muscle reconditioning well the

play19:38

thing that's so interesting about this

play19:40

recent study that you published on on

play19:42

the higher dose of protein and that

play19:44

being incorporating into muscle is so if

play19:45

you have that 24-hour anabolic window as

play19:48

you're as you're saying and you're going

play19:50

to be more sensitive to amino acids

play19:51

throughout that 24 hours of course then

play19:54

every meal so if you have you know 10

play19:56

meals on the extreme end okay every 10

play19:59

you know 10 me 10 times of protein

play20:00

you're going to be sensitive to that

play20:02

protein because it's still within that

play20:03

24-hour window however if you don't have

play20:07

time because you're working as you you

play20:09

know said to eat three or four or five

play20:12

meals throughout the day it's also nice

play20:14

to know that you can go a little further

play20:16

than 30 gram in those let's say three

play20:20

meals and perhaps still get a similar

play20:24

amount of muscle protein synthesis in

play20:27

fact let me ask you to speculate let's

play20:29

say a person with did two people or the

play20:32

same person and you did a crossover

play20:33

study where they do both conditions

play20:36

they're they're doing their resistance

play20:37

training their anabolic windows 24 hours

play20:40

they're sensitive to the amino acids the

play20:42

first time they're eating you know let's

play20:45

say what 80 grams of of protein they're

play20:49

doing that within five meals or they're

play20:52

going to do it within three do you think

play20:55

they'll have the same amount of gains in

play20:57

muscle mass um um this is I mean this is

play21:01

cool study but I think if there's

play21:03

differences they will be too small to

play21:05

pick up that's one if you would have

play21:08

each of those meals would have 20 gram

play21:10

so it's depending on total protein

play21:12

intake if you do for example 5 * 20 or 2

play21:16

* 50 does that make sense I don't think

play21:19

you'll find any difference there if you

play21:21

would do uh I would be more less sure

play21:25

about my case if you would do 20 times 5

play21:29

G versus uh 3 *

play21:34

33.3 okay so that maybe maybe there's a

play21:38

difference that you don't reach that so

play21:40

so-called lucing

play21:42

threshold but to be honest if there's

play21:44

the day before there's physical

play21:46

activity a good training session with

play21:49

the lags

play21:50

involved I'm not so sure whether we

play21:53

would be able to pick up a difference

play21:55

there okay so it is it pure theory of

play21:58

course yeah speculation essentially it

play22:00

you know it sounds like certainly in the

play22:02

context of training in the background

play22:04

that you can skew your protein somewhat

play22:07

with yes your meals and and and still

play22:11

not be missing out on what you otherwise

play22:13

would gain in muscle mass rather not

play22:15

worry about that but don't miss that

play22:17

training session absolutely that's the

play22:19

essential thing that's the that's the

play22:21

Baseline right you have to more people

play22:23

talk about nutrition the less they're

play22:24

actually doing the training that's what

play22:26

you often see I know it's true it's

play22:29

absolutely true

Rate This
β˜…
β˜…
β˜…
β˜…
β˜…

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

Related Tags
Protein DistributionMuscle SynthesisNutrition AdviceAthletic PerformanceProtein IntakeMeal TimingExercise ImpactNutrition ResearchAnabolic ResponseHealth Optimization