Bahasa Indonesia Kelas 10: Struktur Debat

Summary

This script outlines the structure of a formal debate, emphasizing the importance of a structured approach. It begins with an introduction where each team presents themselves. Following this, teams present their arguments supported by real data or facts. The core of the debate involves rebuttals, where each team challenges the other's points, also backed by evidence. The debate concludes with each team summarizing their stance, often presented by a moderator, encapsulating the essence of their arguments.

Takeaways

• 🗣️ The debate should have a structured format with four main parts.
• 👤 The first part is the introduction where each representative from both the pro and con sides introduces themselves or their team.
• 💡 The second part involves the presentation of arguments where each team presents their viewpoints on a predetermined issue or motion.
• 📊 Arguments presented should be supported by real data or facts.
• 🤔 The third part is the core of the debate where the con team challenges the pro team, and vice versa, with challenges ideally backed by data, values, or facts.
• 👏 Politeness and respect should be maintained even when challenging the opposing team.
• 🔍 The final part of the debate structure is the conclusion, usually presented by the moderator, but before that, each team summarizes their stance.
• 📝 The moderator typically reads the overall conclusion of the debate after each team has presented their individual conclusions.
• 👥 The debate format is designed to ensure that both sides have equal opportunities to express and defend their positions.
• ❓ The script ends with a question to the audience, asking which team they would like to join, indicating an interactive aspect of the debate.

Q & A

What are the four parts of a structured debate as described in the script?

The four parts of a structured debate are: 1) Introduction, where each representative from the pro and con sides introduces themselves or their group; 2) Argument Presentation, where each team presents their viewpoints on the predetermined issue or motion; 3) Debate, which is the core of the debate where the con team challenges the pro team and vice versa, with challenges ideally supported by data, values, or facts; 4) Conclusion, usually presented by the moderator but sometimes by the teams summarizing their viewpoints.

How should the arguments in a debate be supported?

The arguments in a debate should be supported by real data or facts to make them more convincing.

What is the core part of a debate according to the script?

The core part of a debate is the actual debate section, where the teams challenge each other's arguments.

How should challenges during the debate be conducted?

Challenges during the debate should be conducted politely and with respect, even though they are meant to refute the opposing team's arguments.

Who typically presents the conclusion of a debate?

The conclusion of a debate is typically presented by the moderator, but sometimes each team presents their own conclusion before the moderator summarizes.

What is the purpose of the introduction part in a debate?

The purpose of the introduction part in a debate is for each representative from the pro and con sides to introduce themselves or their group.

What should be the nature of language used during the debate challenges?

The language used during the debate challenges should be polite and respectful, despite the adversarial nature of the exchanges.

How should the teams refute each other's arguments in the debate section?

The teams should refute each other's arguments by presenting counterarguments supported by data, values, or facts.

What is the role of the moderator in concluding a debate?

The moderator's role in concluding a debate is to summarize the arguments and discussions that have taken place, often after hearing the teams' own conclusions.

Why is it important for teams to present their conclusions in a debate?

It is important for teams to present their conclusions to clearly summarize their stance and the key points they have made during the debate.

What does the script suggest about the tone and demeanor during a debate?

The script suggests that even during challenging exchanges, debaters should maintain a polite and respectful tone and demeanor.