Why Some Countries Are Poor and Others Rich

Summary

This script explores the factors influencing a nation's wealth, highlighting three key determinants: institutions, culture, and geography. It underscores the importance of good institutions in reducing corruption and enabling growth, the impact of cultural beliefs on economic development, and the challenges posed by tropical climates and landlocked locations. The summary also touches on the paradoxical effects of natural resources and suggests a distribution of influence among the factors, urging a nuanced understanding of the complex issues faced by poor countries.

Takeaways

• 🌍 There are 196 countries in the world, with 25 being very rich, defined by an average wealth per person of over $100,000 a year.
• 💰 The 20 poorest countries have a per capita wealth under $1,000 a year, equating to less than $3 a day.
• 📈 Growth rates vary significantly, with some countries like Zimbabwe projected to become rich in 722 years at their current rate.
• 🤔 The script seeks to understand why some countries prosper while others stagnate, focusing on the factors that contribute to this disparity.
• 🏛️ Institutions are crucial, with rich countries generally having good ones and poor countries having very bad ones, directly correlating with corruption levels.
• 💼 Corruption prevents the collection of sufficient taxes, hindering the development of essential services like education, health, and transport.
• 🧐 Clan-based thinking in poor countries leads to nepotism, limiting access to the intelligence and talent of the entire population.
• 📊 Culture plays a role, with a correlation between wealth and the importance of religion to a population; less religious countries tend to be wealthier.
• 🌡️ Geography affects wealth, with poor countries often located in tropical regions where agriculture and disease present significant challenges.
• 🚢 Connectivity is key, with landlocked countries facing disadvantages in trade and transportation.
• 🌳 Natural resources can be a curse for countries with poor institutions, leading to the 'resource trap' and exacerbating corruption and conflict.

Q & A

How many countries are there in the world according to the transcript?

According to the transcript, there are a hundred and ninety-six countries in the world.

What is the average wealth per person defined as 'very rich' in the transcript?

In the transcript, 'very rich' is defined as having an average wealth per person of over $100,000 a year.

What is the per capita wealth of the 20 poorest countries mentioned in the script?

The per capita wealth of the 20 poorest countries is under $1,000 a year or under 3 dollars a day.

How long will it take for Zimbabwe to become a rich country if it continues at its current growth rate, as stated in the transcript?

If Zimbabwe continues at its current growth rate, it will qualify as a rich country in two thousand seven hundred and twenty-two years.

What are the three factors that determine whether a country will be rich or poor according to the transcript?

The three factors determining a country's wealth are institutions, culture, and geography.

Why are institutions considered beyond important for a country's wealth according to the transcript?

Institutions are considered beyond important because they are directly correlated with poverty and corruption; rich countries have good institutions, while poor ones have very bad ones.

What is the correlation between corruption and the ability to collect taxes in poor countries as mentioned in the transcript?

The transcript mentions that when countries are corrupt, they can't collect enough taxes to get the good institutions they would need to escape the poverty trap.

How does the transcript describe the impact of clan-based thinking on a country's ability to access the intelligence and talent of the whole population?

The transcript describes clan-based thinking as a barrier to accessing the intelligence and talent of the whole population because it prioritizes hiring people from one's own group over the best candidate.

What is the general relationship between religiosity and wealth as stated in the transcript?

The transcript states that there is a general relationship where the less people believe (in religion), the richer they stand a chance of being.

Why does the transcript suggest that belief in religion might be detrimental to wealth creation?

The transcript suggests that belief in religion might be detrimental to wealth creation because religiosity is often connected with the idea that the here-and-now can't be improved, leading people to focus on the spiritual rather than material improvement.

What is the role of geography in determining the wealth of nations according to the transcript?

According to the transcript, geography plays a significant role in determining the wealth of nations as poor countries are often located in tropical regions with challenges in agriculture, disease, transport, and natural resources.

How does the transcript explain the paradoxical impact of natural resources on poor countries?

The transcript explains that natural resources can be a paradoxical trouble for poor countries because they can intensify the wealth of countries with good institutions but make countries with bad institutions even poorer, leading to a 'resource trap'.

What is the suggested distribution of factors determining the wealth of nations in the transcript?

The transcript suggests that 50% of a nation's wealth comes from its institutions, 20% from its culture, and 10% each from latitude, connectivity with the rest of the world, and geological resources.

Outlines

00:00

🌍 Wealth Disparity and Growth Factors

This paragraph discusses the stark contrast between the world's richest and poorest countries, highlighting the slow growth of the latter. It emphasizes the importance of institutions, noting that corruption is a direct indicator of poverty. The correlation between wealth and religious beliefs is also explored, suggesting that less religious societies tend to be wealthier. Additionally, the paragraph touches on the challenges posed by tropical geography, including agricultural difficulties and the impact of diseases, which contribute to the wealth gap.

05:00

🌱 Geographical and Cultural Impacts on Economic Development

The second paragraph delves deeper into the geographical and cultural factors affecting a nation's wealth. It explains how the climate, particularly in tropical regions, affects agricultural productivity and the prevalence of diseases that hinder development. The paragraph also addresses the disadvantages faced by landlocked countries in terms of trade and connectivity. Furthermore, it examines the paradoxical impact of natural resources, which can either intensify wealth or poverty depending on the quality of a nation's institutions. The summary concludes with an estimation of the relative importance of institutions, culture, geography, and other factors in determining a nation's wealth.

Keywords

💡Countries

Countries are geopolitical entities with defined borders and governments. In the context of the video, the number of countries in the world is mentioned, highlighting the disparity in wealth among them. The script discusses the economic conditions of these countries, particularly focusing on the 20 poorest and 25 richest nations, emphasizing the economic growth paths they are on.

💡Wealth

Wealth, in this video, refers to the economic value of all assets, including money, property, and other possessions. It is used to differentiate between rich and poor countries, with rich countries having an average wealth per person of over $100,000 a year, and poor countries having a per capita wealth under $1,000 a year. The video explores factors that contribute to the wealth or poverty of nations.

💡Institutions

Institutions are the established laws, social norms, and organizations that govern a country. The video emphasizes the importance of good institutions in rich countries and the lack thereof in poor ones. It suggests that corruption and the inability to collect taxes are direct results of poor institutions, which hinder economic growth and development.

💡Corruption

Corruption is the dishonest or fraudulent conduct by those in power, typically involving bribery or embezzlement. The script directly correlates corruption with poverty, stating that the most corrupt countries are also the poorest. Corruption prevents the collection of taxes necessary for funding public services and contributes to the poverty trap.

💡Clan Based Thinking

Clan based thinking refers to the practice of favoring one's own family or group members in decisions, often at the expense of merit. The video uses this term to illustrate how poor countries often prioritize personal connections over merit, which limits access to the full range of talents and intelligence within the population, thereby hindering economic progress.

💡Culture

Culture, in the context of the video, refers to the shared values, beliefs, and practices of a society. It is suggested that cultural factors, such as the importance placed on religion, can influence a country's economic prosperity. The video posits that societies where religion is less important tend to be wealthier, as they are more focused on improving the material world.

💡Religiosity

Religiosity is the degree of being religious or the commitment to religious practices. The script highlights a correlation between lower religiosity and higher wealth, suggesting that a focus on the spiritual can detract from efforts to improve the material conditions of life. However, it also notes an exception in the United States, where high religiosity coexists with wealth.

💡Geography

Geography is the study of Earth's natural and human environments. The video discusses how geographic factors, such as climate and location, can impact a country's wealth. Tropical regions, for example, face challenges in agriculture and disease that can hinder economic growth, while temperate climates and better connectivity can facilitate prosperity.

💡Tropical Diseases

Tropical diseases are illnesses that are prevalent in tropical regions. The script mentions that many low-income countries are affected by multiple tropical diseases, which can be a significant burden on their economies and public health systems. This is one of the geographic challenges that contribute to poverty in these regions.

💡Natural Resources

Natural resources are materials and elements found in nature that have economic value, such as oil, minerals, and metals. The video discusses the paradox of resource-rich countries often being poor, suggesting that natural resources can exacerbate corruption and conflict, leading to a 'resource trap' that hinders economic development.

💡Policymaker

A policymaker is an individual or group responsible for making decisions that influence public policy. The video implies that understanding the factors that determine a country's wealth can have practical implications for policymakers, who can use this knowledge to design policies aimed at promoting economic growth and reducing poverty.

Highlights

There are 196 countries in the world, with 25 being very rich, defined by an average wealth per person of over $100,000 a year.

The 20 poorest countries have a per capita wealth under $1,000 a year, equating to less than $3 a day.

Countries are on paths to growth, but the poor ones grow very slowly; Zimbabwe will take 722 years to become rich at its current rate.

Three main factors determine a country's wealth: institutions, culture, and geography.

Good institutions are crucial for a country's wealth; rich countries have them, and poor ones suffer from very bad ones.

Corruption is directly correlated with poverty, and the most corrupt countries are also the poorest.

Clan-based thinking in poor countries leads to hiring within one's own group rather than the best candidate.

Religion's importance to people inversely correlates with a country's wealth, with 19 of the richest having 70% or more of the population valuing religion less.

The United States is an exception, combining great religiosity with wealth due to its specific, materialistic form of Protestantism.

Geography plays a significant role in wealth, with poor countries often located in the tropics where life is tougher.

Tropical regions have agricultural disadvantages, including less nutritious plants and poor soil.

Tropical climates can hinder photosynthesis, affecting the ability to develop technology and increase agricultural productivity.

The presence of the tsetse fly in Africa has devastated domesticated animals, impacting technological and agricultural development.

Tropical diseases affect all low-income countries, with many facing at least five simultaneously.

An optimal temperature of 16 degrees Celsius is beneficial for civilization, but poor countries are often in warmer climates.

Poor countries are often landlocked or poorly connected, affecting trade and economic growth.

Natural resources can be a curse for poor countries, leading to the 'resource trap' and exacerbating corruption.

The Democratic Republic of the Congo, rich in minerals, suffers from armed conflict and corruption due to its natural resources.

A suggested distribution of factors influencing a nation's wealth is 50% institutions, 20% culture, 10% latitude, 10% connectivity, and the rest to other factors.

Policymakers should consider these factors for practical implications, while individuals should develop modesty and sympathy for struggling societies.

Transcripts

there are a hundred and ninety six

countries in the world twenty-five of

them are very rich defined as having an

average wealth per person of over

$100,000 a year they are but far more

countries are quite poor and some which

we're considering here a very very poor

these are the 20 poorest countries in

the world where the per capita wealth is

under $1,000 a year or under 3 dollars a

day every country is now more or less on

a path to growth but the poor ones are

growing very very slowly

if Zimbabwe continues at its current

growth rate it will qualify as a rich

country in two thousand seven hundred

and twenty two years what we want to

know in this film is why some countries

prosper and others stagnate so that we

can understand what rich countries are

doing right and get a better grip on the

challenges and hurdles facing poor

countries there are basically three

factors that determine whether a country

will be rich or poor the first is

institutions institutions are beyond

important

broadly speaking rich countries have

good institutions and poor ones have

very very bad ones the correlation

between poverty and corruption is direct

the richest countries in the world are

quite simply invariably also the least

corrupt ones and the most corrupt

countries are also the poorest when

countries are corrupt they can't collect

enough taxes to get the good

institutions they would need to escape

the poverty trap half of the wealth of

the world's poorest 20 countries those

into offshore accounts lost revenues in

these countries totals between 10 and 20

billion dollars a year meanwhile without

an adequate tax base poor countries

can't invest in police education health

and transport now a more generous way to

look at corruption is that it's really a

case of clan based thinking so you're

hiring someone in the rich countries

you're meant to do so simply on their it

interviewing lots of candidates then

picking the best one irrespective of any

personal connection but in poor

countries under the sway of clan based

thinking that approach would itself be

seen as corrupt it's your duty to

disregard the so called best candidate

from an anonymous bunch in

to pick someone from your own team your

uncle your brother your second cousin

the guys from the same tribe as a result

poor countries don't allow themselves

access to the intelligence and talent of

the whole population there's a second

thing that keeps countries poor culture

what goes on in people's minds their

outlooks and beliefs a striking

statistic pops up here in relation to

religion

if there's one generalization you can

make about religion and wealth it's that

the less people believe the richer they

stand a chance of being 19 of the

richest countries in the world have 70%

or more of their populations saying that

religion is not at all important to them

the exception here is unsurprisingly the

United States which manages to combine

great religiosity with huge wealth more

on that in a second and conversely the

poorest nations in the world are also

extremely believing once here's how many

people think religion in the

supernatural is deeply important in the

following countries in the world's

poorest country simply everyone is a

believer why is belief quite so bad for

wealth creation because in general

religiosity is connected up with the

idea that the here-and-now can't be

improved so you should focus on the

spiritual and look forward to a next

world instead it makes quite a bit of

sense when you live here in the rich

world on the other hand people are

generally great believers in their

capacity to alter their destiny through

effort and talent incidentally to

explain the anomaly of the United States

religion seems not to slow down economic

growth here because it's a particular

sort of religion an overwhelmingly

Protestant and exceptionally

materialistic kind the American God

doesn't want you to think of building

the New Jerusalem in the next world he

wants it here and now in Kansas or

Houston there's another big factor that

determines the wealth and poverty of

Nations geography poor countries are

overwhelmingly located in the tropical

regions this isn't a coincidence life is

in many ways simply far far tougher

there

the problems begin with agriculture

tropical plants are generally a lot less

packed with carbohydrates poor countries

have worse soil - also in

surprisingly a tropical climate can be

disadvantageous to photosynthesis

historically a key determinant in the

likelihood of societies growing rich was

their possession of large domesticated

animals such as horses and oxen which

liberated a huge part of the workforce

from having to plow by hand but in

tropical Africa domesticated animals

have throughout time been devastated by

a further appalling scourge that sits a

fly this small fly exclusively present

in Africa because of its heat and

humidity knocks out animals on an

enormous scale making them sleepy or

inactive and has had a profound effect

on the ability of Africans to develop

technology increase agricultural

productivity and amass wealth

it isn't just plants and animals that

suffer in the tropics in the middle

latitudes humans are open to a

terrifying array of diseases including

hundred percent of low income countries

are affected by at least five tropical

diseases simultaneously the magical

temperature which has helped to make

rich countries rich is 16 degrees

centigrade however superficially

unpleasant that drop below 16 degrees as

autumn starts to bite is quite literally

a foundation stone of civilization

geography also encompasses transport and

poor countries are on the whole very

badly connected landlocked Bolivia and

semi landlocked Paraguay are the poorest

nations in South America Africa has only

one major navigable river the Nile and

hosts fifteen landlocked nations eleven

of which have average incomes for six

hundred dollars a year or less not

coincidentally the poorest country in

Asia Afghanistan is also landlocked then

there's the matter of natural resources

natural resources like oil or precious

metals can be real trouble and

paradoxically poor countries tend to

have them in spades these natural

resources are what economists call

intensifiers they will help to make a

country with good institutions richer

but one with bad institutions get even

poorer precipitating what's called the

resources trap so the Democratic

Republic of the Congo is one of the

world's most mineral rich countries

holding most of the world's coltan which

every mobile phone has a bit of inside

but natural resource wealth helps elite

to grab money without requiring the

cooperation of the whole society if the

only way to grow wealthy is to assemble

high-tech aero engines for example

you're going to need your whole society

to buy into the project but if you just

need to extract a few minerals you can

do so with a small labor force some guns

and an airstrip long enough to ferry

your loot out to market the wealth from

coltan keeps DRC armed rebels and guns

and corrupt every level of society so

how should one way ask the relative

importance of all these different

factors institutional cultural and

geographic in determining the wealth of

nations there's no hard and fast rules

but as a guide one can suggest that 50%

of the nation's wealth comes down to the

state of its institutions 20% is due to

its culture and 10% each can be

allocated to latitude connectivity with

the rest of the world and geological

disclosure if you're a policymaker this

discussion has wide practical

implications but at a more personal

level one might take away two things

from it firstly modesty you should have

a better idea of what you are your

individual success 2 which is not so

much your own hard work or fine mind as

the broader society you live in which

was produced over centuries and which

you natural benefit from unknowingly at

the same time sympathy an ability not to

see failing societies just as basket

cases but rather as countries facing

comprehensible and hugely difficult

problems our sympathy can be enhanced by

reflecting that the troubles of

desperate lands are to a considerable

extent to do with malaria a lack of

navigable river and horrific buzzing a

dead City fly rather than always some

more intimate human failing which we

would ourselves never manifest

you

you

you