SENA vs. CARDO - Welche Geräte sind besser?! 🧐

Summary

In this video, the presenter compares two high-end motorcycle helmet communication systems: the Sena 50S and the Cardo Packtalk Edge. Both devices offer premium features, such as Bluetooth and mesh communication, but differ in size, weight, range, and battery life. Sena provides greater range and a traditional jog dial interface, while Cardo is smaller, lighter, and uses Bluetooth 5.2. The video explores various features, including ease of installation, audio quality with JBL and Harman Kardon speakers, and practical differences. Viewers are encouraged to choose based on their specific needs and preferences.

Takeaways

• 🛵 The video compares two high-end motorcycle helmet communication devices: the Sena 50S (with jog dial control) and the Cardo Packtalk Edge.
• 📏 In terms of dimensions, the Cardo Packtalk Edge is more compact and lighter (84mm x 46mm x 23mm, 46g) compared to the Sena 50S (102mm x 56mm x 27mm, 64g).
• 🎵 Both devices have enhanced audio systems: the Sena uses Harman Kardon speakers and microphone, while the Cardo features JBL speakers.
• 🔋 For battery life, the Cardo offers about 13 hours of communication, whereas the Sena provides 12 hours for Bluetooth and 11 hours for mesh communication.
• 📡 The Sena 50S offers a longer communication range of 2 km compared to the 1.6 km range of the Cardo Packtalk Edge.
• 📱 Both devices can be controlled via apps, support voice commands, music sharing, FM radio, and allow communication with multiple riders (up to 24 with Sena and up to 15 with Cardo).
• 🗣️ Sena supports Bluetooth 5.0, while Cardo operates on the newer Bluetooth 5.2, enhancing compatibility and performance.
• 🛠️ Mounting options differ: Sena offers a robust clamping system, while Cardo’s setup is more compact but not as secure as Sena’s clamping mechanism.
• ⚖️ In terms of price, Sena devices tend to be more affordable than Cardo’s, although both offer three years of warranty and are highly reliable.
• 🤝 Both devices can interconnect, but only via Bluetooth, allowing communication between Sena and Cardo users with up to four participants, though mesh functionality is not supported between the brands yet.

Q & A

What are the key differences between the Sena 50S and 50R models?

The main differences between the Sena 50S and 50R are their control methods and mounting systems. The 50S has a jog dial for easier control, while the 50R uses button controls. Additionally, the 50S is slightly bulkier and uses a clamp mounting system, whereas the 50R is more compact and adheres to the helmet with adhesive.

What is the advantage of Cardo's Packtalk Edge over Sena's 50S in terms of size and weight?

The Cardo Packtalk Edge is more compact and lighter than the Sena 50S. It measures 84mm in length, 46mm in height, and 23mm in thickness, weighing 46g. In comparison, the Sena 50S measures 102mm in length, 56mm in height, 27mm in thickness, and weighs 64g.

Which brand, Sena or Cardo, offers a longer theoretical communication range?

Sena offers a longer theoretical communication range of 2 km for the 50S model, whereas Cardo's Packtalk Edge has a range of 1.6 km. However, both ranges are subject to environmental factors like obstacles.

What Bluetooth versions do the Sena 50S and Cardo Packtalk Edge use?

The Sena 50S uses Bluetooth 5.0, while the Cardo Packtalk Edge operates on Bluetooth 5.2, providing a slightly newer and more efficient communication protocol.

How do the audio systems in Sena and Cardo differ?

Sena uses Harman Kardon for its speakers and microphones, while Cardo partners with JBL for its audio system. Both brands emphasize high-quality sound, but they use different manufacturers for their components.

How many people can you connect with in mesh mode using Sena and Cardo devices?

In mesh mode, the Sena 50S allows communication with up to 24 people in a closed mesh and unlimited participants in an open mesh. The Cardo Packtalk Edge supports up to 15 people in mesh mode.

What are the battery life estimates for the Sena 50S and Cardo Packtalk Edge?

The Sena 50S offers approximately 12 hours of battery life in Bluetooth mode and 11 hours in mesh mode. The Cardo Packtalk Edge provides 13 hours of battery life, regardless of the mode.

Do both the Sena 50S and Cardo Packtalk Edge offer similar additional features?

Yes, both devices offer similar additional features such as app control, voice commands, FM radio, the ability to share music with conversation partners, and the ability to stream music from a smartphone.

Which model has more flexibility in mounting options, the Sena 50S or Cardo Packtalk Edge?

Both the Sena 50S and Cardo Packtalk Edge come with both clamp and adhesive mounting options. However, the reviewer notes that the Sena's clamp solution is more elegantly designed compared to Cardo’s.

What is a major practical consideration when choosing between the Sena and Cardo devices?

A major practical consideration is compatibility with other riders' devices. Often, riders choose a device based on what their friends or riding group are using, as both brands are interoperable via Bluetooth but not mesh.