Polling vs WebSockets vs Socket.IO (Simple Explanation) - Chat App Part11
Summary
TLDRThis video provides an insightful overview of various communication protocols essential for building a chat application. It begins with explaining the limitations of the HTTP request/response model for real-time chat applications, introducing concepts like short polling and long polling as workarounds for these limitations. The discussion then shifts to WebSockets, highlighting its bi-directional, real-time communication capabilities, distinct from traditional HTTP. Furthermore, it touches on Socket.IO, a JavaScript library that facilitates real-time web applications by intelligently handling WebSocket connections or falling back to HTTP polling when necessary. The video concludes with an introduction to Flask-SocketIO, promising to delve deeper into its workings in the next episode.
Takeaways
- 💻 Most of the internet operates over the HTTP request/response model, where a client's request initiates server response.
- 🔁 In the traditional HTTP model, servers can't push data to clients without an initial request, posing challenges for real-time applications like chat.
- 🔄 Short polling is a workaround where the client periodically checks with the server for new data at predefined intervals.
- 🕓 Long polling improves upon short polling by having the server hold requests until new data is available, reducing unnecessary data checks.
- 🌐 WebSockets establish a bi-directional, permanent connection between client and server, allowing real-time data exchange without the need for polling.
- ✉️ With WebSockets, servers can proactively push new data to clients, making it ideal for real-time applications such as chat.
- 🔌 Socket.IO is a JavaScript library that facilitates real-time web applications by enabling bi-directional communication between clients and servers.
- 🔄 Socket.IO can dynamically switch between WebSocket protocol and HTTP polling methods, optimizing connectivity based on what's available.
- 🔧 Flask-SocketIO integrates Socket.IO with Flask applications, simplifying the development of real-time web applications.
- 📚 The importance of understanding underlying protocols like HTTP, WebSockets, and libraries like Socket.IO for building effective real-time web applications.
Q & A
What is the primary communication model used by the internet?
-The primary communication model used by the internet is the HTTP request/response model.
Why is the HTTP model not suitable for chat applications?
-The HTTP model is not suitable for chat applications because the server cannot push new messages to the client without the client first making a request.
What is short polling in the context of web applications?
-Short polling is a technique where the client periodically sends requests to the server at predefined intervals to check for new data.
How does long polling improve upon short polling for real-time applications?
-Long polling improves upon short polling by having the server hold onto a client's request until new data is available, instead of the client repeatedly checking at set intervals. This can provide a more efficient real-time experience.
What are WebSockets, and how do they differ from the traditional HTTP request/response model?
-WebSockets establish a permanent, bi-directional connection between the client and server, allowing both to send and receive messages simultaneously, unlike the traditional HTTP model which is unidirectional and requires the client to initiate communication.
Why are WebSockets ideal for a chat application?
-WebSockets are ideal for a chat application because they allow the server to proactively push new messages to all connected clients in real-time, without waiting for a request from the clients.
What is Socket.IO, and how does it differ from WebSockets?
-Socket.IO is a JavaScript library that enables real-time web applications by providing bi-directional communication between clients and servers. It differs from WebSockets, which is a protocol, by automatically handling the upgrade or downgrade of connections to use WebSockets when available or fallback to HTTP polling methods otherwise.
How does Flask-SocketIO integrate with Flask applications?
-Flask-SocketIO is an extension that integrates Socket.IO with Flask applications, enabling easy setup of bi-directional communication between the client and server within a Flask web application framework.
Why might a developer choose to use Flask-SocketIO in their project?
-A developer might choose Flask-SocketIO for its ability to seamlessly integrate Socket.IO with Flask, facilitating real-time communication in web applications without worrying about the underlying protocol (WebSocket or HTTP polling).
What guarantees the use of WebSockets in modern browsers?
-Almost every modern web browser supports WebSockets, so if you have updated your browser in the last seven or eight years and are not using Opera Mini or Internet Explorer 9, it's very likely your browser supports WebSockets.
Outlines
🌐 Understanding Protocols for Real-Time Communication
This paragraph provides an overview of the protocols involved in real-time communication, particularly in the context of a chat application. It discusses the traditional HTTP request/response model, where the client initiates a request, and the server responds, which is not suitable for real-time communication. It then introduces short polling, where the client periodically checks for new data, and long polling, where the server holds the request until new data is available. Finally, it explains WebSockets, a protocol that allows bi-directional communication between client and server, enabling real-time information exchange.
🔌 Socket.IO and Flask-SocketIO
This paragraph introduces Socket.IO, a JavaScript library that enables real-time web applications by facilitating bi-directional communication between clients and servers. It explains that Socket.IO can upgrade a connection to the WebSocket protocol if possible, or downgrade it to HTTP polling methods transparently. The paragraph also mentions Flask-SocketIO, an extension that integrates Socket.IO with Flask applications. It concludes by stating that the next video will delve into the details of Flask-SocketIO and how it works.
Mindmap
Keywords
💡HTTP Request/Response Model
💡Short Polling
💡Long Polling
💡WebSockets
💡Socket.IO
💡Flask-SocketIO
💡Real-time Communication
💡Bidirectional Communication
💡Client
💡Server
Highlights
Most of the internet works over HTTP request/response model, where the client sends a request to the server, and the server sends back a response.
The HTTP model is not suitable for a chat application because the server cannot proactively push data to the client without the client requesting it first.
Short polling is a technique where the client automatically checks with the server for new data at predefined intervals, simulating real-time updates.
Long polling is similar to short polling, but the client makes a request and the server holds on to it until new data is available, then sends the data and the client makes a new request.
WebSockets establish a permanent, bi-directional connection between the client and the server, allowing simultaneous sending and receiving of messages without the request-response model.
WebSockets are well-suited for chat applications, as the server can proactively dispatch messages to all connected clients without them having to poll for new data.
Most modern web browsers support WebSockets, except for some older versions like Opera Mini or Internet Explorer 9.
Socket.IO is a JavaScript library that enables real-time web applications, and it will automatically upgrade the connection to WebSockets if possible or fall back to HTTP polling.
Flask-SocketIO is an extension that integrates Socket.IO with Flask applications.
In the next video, the details of Flask-SocketIO and how it works will be discussed.
Transcripts
welcome back everyone to the code long
series on creating a chat application
before we start writing code for our
chat application in this video we'll
take a step back and talk about the
protocols whenever you read the
documentation you will see some of these
terms being used so it will help if you
have an overview of this as you may
already know most of the internet works
over HTTP request/response model in this
the client sends the request to the
server and based on this request the
server sends back a response so in a
simple example when we click on a link
and request the server to show us a page
the server would respond with the
contents of the page the important thing
to note here is that the client has to
initiate a request before the server
sends back a response the server is just
sitting there constantly listening for
any requests the server cannot
independently push data to the client
without the client having requested at
first while this model works fine if
you're requesting data which is already
in the server for example if you want to
view a web page and the page is already
there in the server then the server can
send us the page the moment we request
it but this model is not going to work
well for a chat application can you see
why that's right when the server
receives a new message that our friend
sends us it cannot proactively push this
message to us because in a typical HTTP
client server model the client has to
request the data before the server can
send it so the server has to patiently
sit on this new data till the time the
client asks the server to send this new
data so one way around it is to use what
is called as short poling in short
pooling the client will automatically
check with the server for new data at
predefined intervals the server still
cannot send a response without a request
from the client however since the client
automatically places the request
periodically the new data is also sent
to the client at regular intervals you
can think of this like a kid in the car
who after every couple of seconds will
ask are we there yet are we there yet
are we there yet
depending on how short is the time gap
between each automatic request that the
client sends short pooling can feel like
real time now an alternative method for
achieving the experience of real time is
long polling it's similar to shot
pooling except the client does not
blindly keep checking for new
information at a set interval instead in
this model the client makes a request
the server holds on to the request till
new data is available only when the new
data is available will the server send
the data to the client and the moment
the client receives the new data it
immediately pulls the server for new
data again the server once again holds
on to this request till any new data is
available and the moment new data is
available it sends it to the client
right away and the client again
automatically holds the server for new
data so even this seems like a viable
option for a chat application let's talk
about WebSockets
after the initial handshake both the
client and the server established a
permanent connection through which they
can simultaneously send and receive
messages to and from each other
so in WebSockets protocol the server
does not have to wait for a request from
the client to send any new data the
moment server receives any new data it
sends it automatically to the client so
this is bi-directional and is different
from the request response model we have
seen so far this connection is permanent
till either the client or the server
chooses to close it let's see how this
will work for our chat application now
hopefully in our chat application we are
not just sending messages to ourselves
we have a few other friends connected to
the server so the moment we type in a
message and hit enter the server can
proactively dispatch the message to all
the clients connected without those
clients having to pull the server for
new data and when one of our friends
sends a message to the group the server
can push the message to all the
connected clients proactively without
each client having to ask the server to
send new data this real-time information
exchange is what makes the chat applique
dick almost every single modern web
browser supports WebSockets if you have
updated your browser anytime in the last
seven or eight years or you're not using
Opera Mini or Internet Explorer 9
chances are your browser supports
WebSockets now let's talk about socket
IO socket IO is a JavaScript library to
enable real time web applications it
allows clients and servers to have
bi-directional communication so how is
this any different from web sockets you
ask well web sockets is a protocol like
HTTP it's a piece of technology while
socket IO is a JavaScript library and
what socket IO does is that it will
upgrade a connection between a client
and a server to WebSocket protocol if
it's possible otherwise it will
downgrade the connection transparently
to http pooling method socket IO will do
all of this in the background for us so
as a user we don't have to worry about
switching from one protocol to another
the user experience will seem like a
real-time communication in this project
we'll be using flask socket IO flask
socket IO is an extension that
integrates socket IO with our flask
application I will leave a link below to
the flask socket IO documentation page
ok now that you understand some of the
protocols involved in the next video
we'll get into the details of flask
socket IO and how it works if you found
this video useful please hit the like
button subscribe to the channel and
share it with your friends see you in
the next video
Посмотреть больше похожих видео
Socket.io v4 or websockets in 2023 - which should you use? - socket.io #1
How Web Sockets work | Deep Dive
What are WebSockets? How is it different from HTTP?
Top 8 Most Popular Network Protocols Explained
How The Web Works - The Big Picture
What is WebSocket? Why is it used & how is it different from HTTP?
5.0 / 5 (0 votes)