Pt.-3 Kolkata Horror To Badlapur | How ALL Politicians Encourage R@pists | Akash Banerjee & Rishi

Summary

The Kolkata doctor horror case has ignited nationwide outrage, prompting medical professionals to demand government accountability. Despite the Supreme Court of India's intervention, public anger towards Mamata Banerjee and the TMC remains high. The script criticizes political parties for their inadequate measures on women's safety, highlighting the presence of criminals in parliament and the lack of progress in addressing sexual violence. It calls for a shift from political propaganda to concrete solutions, questioning politicians' commitment to women's security and urging for a nationwide change.

Takeaways

• 📢 The Kolkata doctor horror case has sparked nationwide outrage, with medical professionals demanding government accountability and the Supreme Court of India taking notice.
• 🏛 The Chief Justice of India is set to handle the Kolkata case, highlighting its significance and the public's demand for justice.
• 🚨 Despite the case being handed over to the CBI, public anger towards Mamata Banerjee and her party, the TMC, remains high, with many suspecting a deeper conspiracy.
• 🔥 Arch-rivals Mohun Bagan and East Bengal football fans have united in demanding justice, showing the case's impact beyond the medical community.
• 💢 People's anger is palpable, from social media to the streets, and there is a widespread belief that the situation in RG Kar Hospital was politically motivated.
• 👥 The script criticizes the political protection that may have allowed the situation to escalate, suggesting that it was not an isolated incident.
• 🌐 The issue of women's safety is framed as a national problem, not just a Kolkata issue, with frequent incidents of violence against women reported across the country.
• 🏛️ The script points out the irony that despite having a woman chief minister, West Bengal has not seen an improvement in women's safety under Mamata Banerjee's leadership.
• 🤔 The script questions the effectiveness of political promises and campaigns regarding women's safety, given the continued high rates of crimes against women.
• 📊 It highlights the dismal conviction rates for rape cases and the lack of progress in women's safety over the past decade, despite political attention.
• 🔄 The script calls for a shift from political propaganda to concrete solutions, urging the public to demand accountability and action from politicians on women's safety.

Q & A

What is the Kolkata doctor horror case?

The Kolkata doctor horror case refers to a severe incident involving doctors and medical staff that has sparked nationwide outrage and has been taken notice of by the Supreme Court of India.

Why has the Supreme Court of India decided to take cognizance of the Kolkata doctor case?

The severity and public outcry over the incident have prompted the Supreme Court of India to intervene, with the Chief Justice of India set to handle the matter.

What is the public sentiment towards Mamata Banerjee in relation to the Kolkata doctor case?

Public sentiment is highly critical of Mamata Banerjee, with many believing she has not fulfilled her responsibilities properly and should resign.

How has the case impacted the perception of political parties and their stance on women's safety?

The case has exposed the perceived inadequacies of political parties in ensuring women's safety, with many questioning the sincerity of their stances on the issue.

What is the significance of the 46% figure mentioned in the script in relation to India's parliament?

The 46% figure signifies that a significant portion of MPs in the 2024 parliament have criminal cases, including those related to crimes against women, highlighting a concerning trend in political representation.

What is the 'Deshbhakt Part 3 episode' and what does it focus on?

The 'Deshbhakt Part 3 episode' is a segment that aims to focus on the politics of rape and how it intersects with the broader issue of women's safety in India.

Why is the script critical of the political response to incidents of rape and violence against women?

The script criticizes the political response for often being inadequate, exploitative of public emotions, and lacking in effective measures to prevent such incidents.

What is the role of the CBI in the Kolkata doctor case?

The CBI (Central Bureau of Investigation) has been handed over the case to conduct an investigation, indicating the gravity of the incident and the need for a thorough and unbiased inquiry.

What is the script's view on the effectiveness of political parties in addressing women's safety?

The script suggests that political parties have been largely ineffective in addressing women's safety, often prioritizing political gains over the implementation of robust measures to protect women.

What is the 'SCAW unit' mentioned in the script and what is its proposed function?

The SCAW unit, or Serious Crimes Against Women Unit, is proposed as a dedicated task force to handle serious crimes against women, aiming to rapidly solve and convict major crimes and set a national example.

How does the script evaluate the progress made in women's safety over the past decade?

The script evaluates the progress as insufficient, noting that despite political campaigns and promises, the number of reported rape cases has increased, and conviction rates remain low.

Outlines

00:00

😡 Public Outrage and Political Accountability in Kolkata Doctor Case

The Kolkata doctor horror case has ignited nationwide protests, prompting medical professionals to demand government action. The Supreme Court of India has taken notice, with the Chief Justice set to preside. Unrest is palpable as people's anger towards West Bengal's Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee and her party, the TMC, intensifies. Allegations of a deeper conspiracy and political protection in the case are rife. The script discusses the broader issue of women's safety in India, implicating political leaders across parties in perpetuating a culture of rape. It highlights the high percentage of MPs with criminal cases, including those against women, and criticizes the political response to such incidents, suggesting that political parties are either complicit in exploitation or have rape-friendly policies. The script calls for a serious examination of the political landscape influencing women's safety in India.

05:07

🔍 Political Responses to Women's Safety: A Critical Analysis

This paragraph delves into the political reactions to the Kolkata horror case and the broader issue of women's safety in India. It questions the sincerity of political parties, including the BJP, Congress, and Samajwadi Party, in addressing the problem, citing instances where party members have been implicated in crimes against women or have shown leniency towards accused individuals. The script points out the failure of high-profile campaigns like Beti Bachao, Beti Padhao, which spent a significant amount on media advertisements with little impact on conviction rates. It also discusses the proposal for a Serious Crimes Against Women (SCAW) unit, which has seen limited implementation, and reflects on the lack of improvement in women's safety over the past decade. The paragraph ends with a call for politicians to be held accountable and for the public to demand effective solutions rather than being swayed by political propaganda.

10:10

🤔 Demanding Concrete Solutions Over Political Propaganda

The final paragraph emphasizes the need for the public to demand tangible solutions to the issue of women's safety rather than being manipulated by political propaganda. It suggests that the public should scrutinize politicians' track records and actions regarding women's protection and push for a change in the political climate that currently fosters rape-friendly policies. The paragraph calls for zero tolerance towards crimes against women and urges for a collective effort to prioritize women's safety above political interests. It concludes with a reflection on the necessity of a nationwide shift in attitudes and policies to ensure the safety and empowerment of women.

Keywords

💡Kolkata doctor horror case

This refers to a high-profile incident in Kolkata that has sparked outrage and protests, leading to widespread discussions on women's safety and the role of the government. The case has become a symbol of the larger issue of violence against women in India, as it has prompted medical professionals and the Supreme Court to take notice and act.

💡Supreme Court of India

The Supreme Court of India is the highest judicial body in the country, responsible for upholding the constitution and ensuring justice. In the context of the video, it signifies the gravity of the Kolkata case, as the court's decision to take cognizance implies that the matter is of national importance and requires intervention at the highest level of the judiciary.

💡Mamata Banerjee

Mamata Banerjee is the Chief Minister of West Bengal and a prominent political figure in India. The video script holds her responsible for the security lapses in the Kolkata case, suggesting that her government's policies or lack thereof have contributed to the incident and the broader issue of women's safety in the state.

💡CBI

The Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) is India's premier investigating agency, often tasked with handling complex and high-profile cases. The script mentions the case being handed over to the CBI, indicating a need for a thorough and unbiased investigation into the incident, reflecting the severity and public interest in the matter.

💡Rape culture

Rape culture refers to an environment in which sexual violence is normalized or excused due to societal attitudes and practices. The video discusses the prevalence of such attitudes in politics and society, suggesting that they contribute to the ongoing issue of violence against women and the lack of accountability for perpetrators.

💡Political propaganda

Political propaganda is the use of biased or misleading information to influence public opinion in favor of a political party or agenda. The script criticizes the exploitation of women's safety issues for political gain, rather than addressing them substantively, which undermines the quest for genuine solutions.

💡Women's safety

Women's safety is a central theme of the video, highlighting the need for societal and governmental measures to protect women from violence and harassment. The script argues that despite political rhetoric, there has been little progress in ensuring the safety and security of women in India.

💡Criminalization of politics

The term refers to the involvement of individuals with criminal backgrounds in politics. The video points out that a significant number of MPs have criminal cases, including those related to crimes against women, indicating a systemic issue where politicians themselves may be part of the problem rather than the solution.

💡Beti Bachao, Beti Padhao

Beti Bachao, Beti Padhao is a campaign by the Indian government aimed at addressing the preference for male children and promoting the education and safety of girls. The video criticizes the campaign for its heavy spending on media advertisements rather than substantive measures, suggesting a lack of commitment to the cause.

💡SCAW unit

The Serious Crimes Against Women (SCAW) unit is proposed as a dedicated task force to handle crimes against women more effectively. The script discusses the idea as a potential solution to the lack of progress in addressing and solving such crimes, emphasizing the need for specialized resources and attention.

💡Political parties

The script criticizes political parties across the spectrum for their lack of action or even complicity in perpetuating violence against women. It suggests that the issue has become a tool for political point-scoring rather than a genuine concern for women's safety and well-being.

Highlights

The Kolkata doctor horror case has drawn national attention with medical professionals and the Supreme Court of India taking notice.

People's anger towards Mamata Banerjee and the TMC party has not subsided despite the case being handed over to the CBI.

There is a belief among the public that there is a deeper conspiracy in the Kolkata doctor case.

Arch rivals Mohun Bagan and East Bengal fans united in demanding justice for the Kolkata doctor case.

Nirbhaya's mother has called for Mamata Banerjee's resignation due to her perceived failure in fulfilling responsibilities.

The situation at RG Kar Hospital and Principal Sandip Ghosh's actions suggest political involvement in the case.

46% of MPs in the 2024 parliament have criminal cases, with 170 having serious crimes against women.

Political parties are criticized for being 'rapist friendly' and not promoting women's safety.

The Kolkata Horror case has led to a surge in public demand for justice and a reevaluation of women's safety in India.

Congress and other political parties have also faced criticism for their handling of women's safety issues.

The proposed Serious Crimes Against Women (SCAW) unit aims to handle crimes against women more effectively.

The Home Ministry's 2015 proposal for an investigative unit for crimes against women has seen limited adoption by states.

The conviction rate for rape cases in India is under 30%, indicating a need for improvement in the justice system.

Political campaigns for women's safety have often been criticized for being superficial or turning into a comedy show.

The Beti Bachao, Beti Padhao scheme has been criticized for spending a large portion of its budget on media ads rather than substantive measures.

The transcript questions whether the outrage over the Kolkata Horror will lead to real change in women's safety or just a temporary political shift.

The need for zero tolerance towards crimes against women and a serious approach to women's safety by politicians and parties is emphasized.

Transcripts

You can guess how big an issue Kolkata doctor horror case has become by the fact that

doctors, nursing staff, medical interns from all over the country have put the government on notice

Supreme Court of India has decided to take cognizance of this case and make it heard.

Chief justice of India will handle the matter

Arch rivals in Football Mohun Bagan and East Bengal fans forgot rivalry and demanded justice in unison

Even after handing over the case to CBI, people's anger towards Mamata Banerjee hasn't subsided.

Most people believe that there is a deeper conspiracy in the Kolkata doctor case.

We had told you about this in detail in the last episode.

Mamata Banerjee has been held responsible for Kolkata horror

Nirbhaya's mother has even said that Mamata Banerjee has not fulfilled her responsibilities properly and she should resign.

From drawing room to the streets, from social media to the headlines, people's anger is rising.

Demand for justice... People's anger towards Mamata Banerjee and TMC is justified.

The way the situation was created in RG Kar Hospital, the Dadagiri that Principal Sandip Ghosh was doing

the way the matter was initially tried to suppress, it was not possible without politics and political protection.

And in today's Deshbhakt Part 3 episode, we would like to focus on this very politics of rape.

And not just Kolkata, sample the headlines in the last 2 days.

Every day, every state, every hour, such incidents are happening.

Women are being openly attacked. Our outrage will end, but the demons will not stop

We are also innocent. For 2 days, we will be angered, but we will not move towards solutions.

We will demand alcohol ban. Trend of all men rape.

We will be trapped in political propaganda.

But we will forget that the biggest reason for the insecurity of women in our country is our leaders

Either they will be busy in exploitation.

Or their party, their policies will be very rapist friendly.

If politicians would have really promoted women safety, we would not have been stuck in this mess.

The fact is that 46% of MPs in 2024's parliament have criminal cases.

170 such parliamentarians have cases of rape, murder, attempt to murder, kidnapping and crimes against women.

All parties are involved... so you can understand what it is

We are the ones who choose them. And then we hope that the condition of the women in the country will improve.

How? A woman chief minister will keep women safer.

This misconception has also been removed by Mamata Banerjee in the last decade.

Park Street rape case was a fabricated incident.

Hanskhali rape was an affair

Those raising voice against Kamduni rape are CPIM protesters

Those questioning Mamata Banerjee are Maoists

And the incident of Sandeshkhali was a conspiracy to bring down her government.

Whatever happens, it is someone else's fault. It cannot be TMC's fault, it cannot be Mamata Banerjee's fault.

The entire world is wrong. Because of this attitude, Mamata Banerjee has to face massive anger

Congress has criticized Kolkata Horror, Rahul Gandhi demanded justice for the doctor

But the Congress's own track record is not good in the case of women's safety.

Chaudhary Lal Singh, who rallied in support of Kathua rape accused,

who was also removed by BJP, Congress accepted him after 6 years.

Congress has many MLA's who are accused of rape and sexual exploitation.

If MLA doesn't do anything, his son is making father and party proud

Sometimes, action is needed when the matter becomes heated.

Like Karan Morwal, who was expelled from Madhya Pradesh Congress Committee when he was charged with serious rape.

But still, he is seen meeting with ex-CM Digvijay Singh

Women's safety and Samajwadi Party have the same relationship as Bigg Boss contestants and decent language has

Recently, Samajwadi Party leader Nawab Singh was arrested on the charge of attempt to rape of a minor.

Nawab Singh was a close associate of Dimple Yadav.

Now, SP is distancing from him

But Uttar Pradesh CM Yogi Adityanath also said that the only purpose of SP leaders is to prove every rapist and criminal innocent.

Adityanath reminded people in a speech that Narendra Modi is the PM who is doing work for women empowerment

Beti bachao, beti padhao, act for women - 33% reservation in Lok Sabha

BJP knows that women's safety is an emotive issue.

Delhi CM Sheila Dixit's political career ended after Nirbhaya incident

People's anger on Dixit broke so much that Congress's head was swept away in Delhi

Will it be the same in Bengal? There is no doubt that Mamata Banerjee did not pay much attention to women's security.

Now, strong measures are being taken after so much outrage.

It is also true that TMC has a lot of anti-social elements.

Okay, Sandeshkhali was used for politics. But leaders like Sheikh Shahjahan are also in the party.

In Kolkata horror, Principal Sandip Ghosh was tried so much to save... if not, then backlash would be less

But can BJP take high moral ground on women security?

It's been three months since Prajwal Revanna's incident. Has he been hanged or is the case fast-tracked?

Did JDS, Modi or BJP leadership not know that a bhakshak was in between them when they were sharing the stage?

And what difference would it have made if they had known?

Brij Bhushan Singh who considered sport of wrestling his own property

Even after such a big protest, Singh did not face any major setback.

Kathua or Hathras, party leader are seen with accused

And sometimes, party leaders themselves do the entire job.

Kuldeep Singh Sengar, first involved in gang rape, then plans to clean up the victim's entire family.

BJP's behaviour has been worse in Bilkis Bano case, when convicted rapists were released.

But Supreme Court sent them back to jail.

On the other hand, Ram Rahim, convicted rapist, these days, less time in jail and more outside

I don't know about Make in India, but the government is making good arrangements for Rape in India.

Today, in 2024, we feel that after Kolkata Horror, after such a big outrage, things will change.

But after 2011, when people were angry, they still thought that things will change.

But has women's security increased or decreased in the last 10-15 years?

We have talked about SCAW unit many times on Deshbhakt.

Serious Crimes Against Women Unit. A task force that will handle serious crimes against women in a dedicated manner.

will solve the biggest and the most heinous crimes in own way, rapidly and will take it to the level of conviction.

will set an example for the country , will give a message that the government is now serious about this matter.

This unit will have technical, legal, financial resources.

By the way, this idea is not new.

In 2015, the Home Ministry gave a proposal to set up investigative unit for crimes against women to states

Because law and order is a state subject.

150 such districts where crimes against women are the highest, a unit will be set up to deal with rape, dowry, human trafficking.

It's been almost 10 years since the proposal. How many states have accepted this investigative unit for crimes against women?

If taken seriously, horrific crime would not be reported every other day

In 2014, women's security was a big issue in defeat of Congress.

But did any improvement happen in the last 10 years?

In 2012, 25,000 rape cases were reported in the country.

After 10 years, that figure is around 30,000.

The case was reported on it. Even if you fight the case in the court, the conviction rate is not up to 30% as per NCRB data

murder, kidnapping, rioting have better chances of conviction.

If any party, be it Congress, BJP, Left or Right, had run a campaign for women's safety,

the situation would not have been so bad.

Only when there are so many rape-friendly laws and parties, the situation is so bad.

And when the campaign was running, it was made into a comedy show

According to a report by the Parliament Committee, BJP government's flagship scheme, Beti Bachao, Beti Padhao, cost Rs. 446 crore.

80% of that was spent on media ads.

After Nirbhaya, Congress and Sheila Dixit had to pay a heavy price.

Maybe after Kolkata Horror, TMC and Mamata Banerjee had to pay the same price.

But the question still remains, will the doctors and women be treated better?

Or will the situation calm down after the politics, and vote share transfer?

CBI investigation will continue, the rapists will become MPs again.

If you look at the history, the propaganda of political parties, the election strategy, it will be the case

So, when you show your anger in this matter, remember that you have to ask for solutions.

You have to ask politicians what to do to stop this cases

What have politicians done to protect women in the country?

How can we take the issue of women's safety ahead of political propaganda?

Because people's emotions are being exploited and political propaganda is being run on it.

The question is, how can a change be brought not only in Bengal but in the whole country?

And until politicians, parties are rapists friendly, and do not show zero tolerance, this safety is not possible.