Adu Kekuatan Militer Iran Vs Israel Siapa Paling Kuat?

CNBC Indonesia

7 Oct 202408:41

Summary

TLDRThe video discusses escalating tensions between Israel and Iran, highlighting Iran's recent missile attack on Israeli military facilities in response to Israeli actions in Gaza and Lebanon. The video compares the military strengths of both countries, covering personnel, weaponry, and defense systems. While Iran has an advantage in artillery, helicopters, and submarines, Israel is superior in air defense, combat aircraft, and funding. Israel's possession of 90 nuclear warheads is also a significant factor. Despite the differences, the video emphasizes the hope for peace rather than war.

Takeaways

🚀 Iran launched 200 missiles at Israeli military facilities as a direct response to prior Israeli actions in Gaza, Lebanon, and the killing of IRGC, Hamas, and Hezbollah leaders.
🛡️ Iran ranks 14th in the 2024 Global Firepower Index, while Israel ranks 17th, with Iran having a slightly higher power index than Israel.
👥 Iran has a larger military force with 610,000 active personnel, compared to Israel's 169,500 active soldiers.
💣 In terms of ground military assets, Iran surpasses Israel with over 10,500 tanks and 6,798 artillery weapons, while Israel has 400 tanks and 530 artillery pieces.
✈️ Israel holds an edge in air power, with 345 combat aircraft and 43 attack helicopters, while Iran has 312 combat aircraft and fewer helicopters.
⚓ Iran dominates naval forces with 17 submarines and 68 patrol boats, whereas Israel has 5 submarines and 49 patrol boats.
🗺️ Due to geographical separation, direct ground warfare between Iran and Israel is unlikely, but air warfare is a more probable scenario.
🛡️ Israel is known for its advanced air defense systems, including the Arrow, David’s Sling, Patriot, and Iron Dome, which protect against various missile threats.
🎯 Iran has a missile that can reach up to 2,500 km, while Israel’s notable advantage is its nuclear capability, possessing 90 nuclear warheads.
💰 Israel's military budget is three times larger than Iran's, spending $27.5 billion in 2023 compared to Iran’s $10.3 billion.

Q & A

2024年10月以色列和伊朗之间的军事冲突是如何开始的？
-2024年10月，以色列和伊朗之间的军事冲突升级，以色列指责伊朗发射了近200枚导弹针对以色列的军事设施，这是伊朗伊斯兰革命卫队（IRGC）所宣布的，他们声称这是对以色列早先行动的回应，包括对加沙和黎巴嫩平民的袭击以及IRGC、哈马斯和真主党领导人的死亡。[^1^]
伊朗和以色列的军事力量对比如何？
-根据2024年全球火力指数，伊朗军事力量排名第14位，拥有0.2269的战力指数，而以色列排名第17位，拥有0.2596的战力指数。伊朗在陆军、火炮、海军舰艇和潜艇方面优于以色列，而以色列在空中防御系统、战斗机和核能力方面更强。[^1^]
以色列的防空系统包括哪些？
-以色列以其世界上最好的防空系统而闻名，拥有四种先进的防空系统：'Arrow'用于拦截远程导弹；'David's Sling'用于拦截中程导弹；'Patriot'专门用于击落飞机，包括无人机；以及'Iron Dome'用于击落短程火箭。[^1^]
伊朗的军事预算是多少？
-根据斯德哥尔摩国际和平研究所的数据，截至2024年4月，伊朗的军事预算为10.3亿美元，相当于158万亿印尼盾。[^1^]
以色列和伊朗是否有直接的陆地边界？
-以色列和伊朗之间没有直接的陆地边界，两国之间隔着其他国家，如约旦、伊拉克和叙利亚。[^1^]
伊朗对以色列的导弹攻击是否造成了人员伤亡？
-据以色列救援服务报告，在伊朗对以色列的导弹攻击中，有两人在特拉维夫被弹片轻伤，并且有建筑物受损，但尚未有死亡报告。[^1^]
以色列如何回应伊朗的导弹攻击？
-以色列总理本雅明·内塔尼亚胡表示，伊朗对以色列的导弹攻击是一个重大错误，伊朗将会为此付出代价。具体的回应措施尚未公开，但以色列可能会考虑攻击伊朗的核设施。[^3^]
伊朗的导弹攻击是否使用了新型导弹？
-是的，专家们表示，伊朗似乎使用了更新、更复杂的导弹，这可能是其攻击比今年4月的攻击更成功的原因之一。[^7^]
以色列是否已经对伊朗的导弹攻击做出了回应？
-截至2024年10月2日，以色列尚未公开其对伊朗导弹攻击的具体回应措施。[^6^]
伊朗声称其导弹攻击的目标是什么？
-伊朗声称其导弹攻击的目标是以色列的军事和安全设施，这些设施负责在加沙和黎巴嫩的种族灭绝行为。[^6^]