The Beer Hall Putsch (1923)

Summary

The Beer Hall Putsch on November 8th, 1923, was a pivotal moment in German history, reflecting the nation's political and economic turmoil. Adolf Hitler, capitalizing on widespread discontent, attempted a coup against the Weimar Republic. Despite initial failure, the subsequent trial turned Hitler into a national figure, ultimately shaping his strategy for power and foreshadowing his rise to Chancellor in 1933.

Takeaways

• ⚔️ The Beer Hall Putsch occurred on November 8, 1923, during a period of extreme political and economic instability in Germany.
• 📉 Hyperinflation in 1923 devastated Germany, with the German mark plummeting in value, causing widespread economic chaos.
• 🇫🇷 The Ruhr Valley, a critical industrial area, was occupied by the French due to Germany's failure to pay WWI reparations.
• 📜 The Treaty of Versailles deeply angered the German population, fueling political uprisings and extremist movements.
• 👁️ Adolf Hitler sought to overthrow the Weimar Republic, inspired by Mussolini's 1922 March on Rome.
• 🧠 Hitler's plan involved forcing Bavarian leaders to support him, but his early success at the Beer Hall quickly unraveled.
• 🎤 Despite initial opposition, Hitler’s speech at the Beer Hall won over the crowd with his nationalist rhetoric.
• 💣 The Putsch ultimately failed after a failed march through Munich, resulting in several deaths and Hitler's arrest.
• 🔒 Hitler's trial turned into a platform for him to promote his views, which increased his national prominence.
• 📚 Hitler only served nine months in prison, during which he wrote 'Mein Kampf' and shifted towards gaining power legally.

Q & A

What was the historical context of the Beer Hall Putsch in 1923 Germany?

The interwar period in Germany was marked by extreme political and economic instability. The Weimar Republic was seen as weak, having already seen several Chancellors and government cabinets. The Ruhr Valley was under French occupation due to unpaid World War I reparations, and there were political uprisings across the country. The Treaty of Versailles and hyperinflation had caused widespread discontent among the German population.

Why were the French occupying the Ruhr Valley during the time of the Beer Hall Putsch?

The French were occupying the Ruhr Valley to ensure payment of World War I reparations from Germany. This occupation was a significant source of tension and contributed to the unrest in the country.

What was the 'stab-in-the-back' myth mentioned in the script?

The 'stab-in-the-back' myth was a belief among many Germans that the German government's acceptance of the Treaty of Versailles terms, which were seen as harsh, was a betrayal that led to Germany's defeat in World War I, rather than the military situation.

How did hyperinflation affect the German economy and society during 1923?

Hyperinflation caused the German mark to plummet in value, leading to a loss of confidence in the currency. Money printed in larger amounts became worthless, and by December 1923, the mark had fallen to 4.2 billion to the dollar. This led to food shortages and people resorting to barter, using goods like coal or sausages as currency.

Who were the members of the Bavarian triumvirate that Hitler planned to coerce into joining his revolution?

The Bavarian triumvirate consisted of General Commissar State Commissioner Gustav von Kahr, General Otto von Lossow, the commander of the Reichswehr in Bavaria, and Colonel Hans Ritter von Seißer, the head of the Bavarian State Police.

What was the original date planned for the Beer Hall Putsch, and why was it changed?

The original date for the march was set for the 10th through the 11th of November. However, Hitler changed the plans to the 8th of November after discovering that Gustav von Kahr would be giving a speech at the Burgerbraukeller beer hall, providing an opportunity to capture all three members of the Bavarian triumvirate in one location.

How did Hitler attempt to gain the support of the Bavarian triumvirate during the Beer Hall Putsch?

Hitler burst into the beer hall where Gustav von Kahr was speaking, fired shots into the air, and proclaimed the national revolution had begun. He then coerced von Kahr, von Lossow, and von Seißer into a side room at gunpoint, where he explained his intentions and tried to gain their allegiance by a mixture of exaggerations and outright lies.

What was the turning point that led to the failure of the Beer Hall Putsch?

The turning point was when Hitler left the beer hall to attend to other matters, placing it under the command of General Ludendorff. In his absence, the three members of the Bavarian triumvirate renounced their support for Hitler's plan and left the beer hall.

How did the aftermath of the Beer Hall Putsch impact Adolf Hitler's future?

Although the Beer Hall Putsch failed, the subsequent trial gave Hitler a platform to showcase his views to the German public. He was sentenced to a relatively short prison term during which he wrote Mein Kampf. This period also taught him the importance of following legal means to gain power, which he later employed successfully.

What was the significance of General Erich Ludendorff's involvement in the Beer Hall Putsch?

Ludendorff was a prominent wartime leader and his involvement was intended to legitimize the Nazi position. Hitler planned to make him the commander of the Armed Forces after gaining power. His presence also lent credibility to the Nazi cause among nationalists.

Outlines

00:00

🇩🇪 The Beer Hall Putsch: Prelude to Hitler's Rise

The paragraph sets the stage for the Beer Hall Putsch, detailing the political and economic turmoil in Germany during the interwar period. The Weimar Republic's instability, with frequent changes in government and the French occupation of the Ruhr Valley, is highlighted. The Treaty of Versailles is identified as a source of national outrage, contributing to the 'stab-in-the-back' myth and fostering hostility towards the Republic. Hyperinflation is described, with the German mark's value plummeting and food shortages exacerbating the crisis. This environment is portrayed as fertile ground for extremist movements, including the Nazi Party. Adolf Hitler, inspired by Mussolini and Napoleon, plans a revolution against the Weimar government, aiming to coerce Bavaria's leading politicians into joining his cause and march on Berlin.

05:02

🔍 The Execution and Aftermath of the Beer Hall Putsch

This paragraph delves into the execution of Hitler's plan during the Beer Hall Putsch. It describes how Hitler and his followers interrupted a speech by Gustav von Kahr, aiming to gain his support for a national revolution. Hitler's oratory skills are highlighted as he manages to sway the initially skeptical crowd. The arrival of General Erich Ludendorff, a respected wartime leader, lends credibility to Hitler's cause, and von Kahr and his associates reluctantly agree to join. However, their support is short-lived as they later renounce it. Despite this setback, Hitler and Ludendorff proceed with a plan to march on Munich. The march ends in a violent confrontation with police, resulting in casualties and the arrest of key participants, including Hitler. The aftermath includes a trial where Hitler uses the platform to promote his ideas, which paradoxically boosts his public profile. His relatively short prison sentence and the opportunity to write 'Mein Kampf' during his incarceration are noted, as is the lesson he learns about seeking power through legal means rather than violent revolution.

10:04

📢 Propaganda and the Legacy of the Beer Hall Putsch

The final paragraph underscores the Beer Hall Putsch's significance as a propaganda tool for National Socialism. It suggests that the event and its aftermath, particularly the bloodshed, served to galvanize support for Hitler and the Nazi Party. The paragraph concludes with a call to action for viewers to subscribe and stay updated for more historical content, indicating the video's intent to educate and engage its audience on historical topics.

Keywords

💡Beer Hall Putsch

The Beer Hall Putsch, also known as the Munich Putsch, was a failed attempt by Adolf Hitler and the Nazi Party to seize power in Munich, Bavaria. It took place on November 8-9, 1923, and is a significant event in the history of the Nazi Party's rise to power. The term 'Putsch' refers to a sudden or forceful attempt to overthrow a government, and in this case, it involved Hitler's attempt to rally support by taking over a beer hall where a political meeting was occurring. The failure of the Putsch led to Hitler's arrest and trial, which paradoxically helped to raise his public profile and set the stage for his later political success.

💡Weimar Republic

The Weimar Republic refers to the period of the German government that existed from 1919 to 1933, named after the city of Weimar where the constitution was adopted. It was marked by political and economic instability, as well as a struggle with the effects of the Treaty of Versailles. The Weimar Republic is often seen as a weak government that was unable to effectively manage the hyperinflation and political extremism of the time, which contributed to its eventual collapse and the rise of the Nazi Party.

💡Treaty of Versailles

The Treaty of Versailles was the peace treaty that ended World War I between the Allied and Associated Powers and Germany. It was signed on June 28, 1919, and imposed heavy reparations and territorial losses on Germany. The treaty is often cited as a contributing factor to the economic and political instability of the Weimar Republic, as many Germans felt the terms were overly punitive and led to widespread resentment and a sense of national humiliation.

💡Hyperinflation

Hyperinflation refers to a period of extremely high and typically out-of-control inflation. In the context of the video, hyperinflation in Germany during the Weimar Republic led to a dramatic devaluation of the currency, the German mark. This economic crisis severely impacted the German population, causing widespread financial hardship and contributing to social unrest. The situation was so dire that by December 1923, the German mark had plummeted to 4.2 billion to the US dollar, and a loaf of bread could cost as much as 200 billion marks.

💡Bavarian triumvirate

The Bavarian triumvirate refers to the three key political figures in Bavaria that Hitler attempted to coerce into supporting his coup during the Beer Hall Putsch. These men were Gustav von Kahr, the State Commissioner of Bavaria, Otto von Lossow, the Commander of the Reichswehr in Bavaria, and Hans Ritter von Seisser, the Head of the Bavarian State Police. Their support was crucial for Hitler's plan to gain legitimacy and control in Bavaria, but ultimately they did not support Hitler's coup, contributing to its failure.

💡Adolf Hitler

Adolf Hitler was an Austrian-born German politician who was the leader of the Nazi Party and became the dictator of Germany from 1933 to 1945. In the context of the video, Hitler is depicted as a key figure in the Beer Hall Putsch, a failed attempt to overthrow the Weimar Republic government. His actions during this event and subsequent trial helped to raise his public profile, which eventually led to his rise to power and the establishment of the Third Reich.

💡Ruhr Valley

The Ruhr Valley was an area of Germany that was of significant industrial importance, particularly for its coal mines and steel production. In the aftermath of World War I, the French and Belgian forces occupied the Ruhr Valley in 1923 to ensure that Germany would meet its reparations obligations under the Treaty of Versailles. The occupation led to economic disruption and further contributed to the hyperinflation and political instability experienced during the Weimar Republic era.

💡Economic instability

Economic instability refers to a period of extreme financial and economic uncertainty and upheaval. In the interwar period in Germany, this was characterized by hyperinflation, unemployment, and a general lack of confidence in the German currency. The economic instability played a significant role in the political climate of the time, leading to widespread dissatisfaction with the Weimar Republic and the rise of extremist political movements, including the Nazi Party.

💡Nationalism

Nationalism is a political ideology that emphasizes the importance of a shared national identity and often advocates for a strong, unified national government. In the context of the video, nationalism was a significant force in German politics during the interwar period, with many Germans feeling a strong sense of national pride and a desire for a return to a more powerful and respected Germany. This sentiment was exploited by politicians like Adolf Hitler, who used nationalist rhetoric to gain support for his agenda and the Nazi Party.

💡Interwar period

The interwar period refers to the years between the end of World War I in 1918 and the beginning of World War II in 1939. This was a time of significant political, economic, and social change, as countries recovered from the devastation of the war and grappled with the effects of the peace treaties. In Germany, the interwar period was marked by the rise and fall of the Weimar Republic, economic crises such as hyperinflation, and the eventual ascent of Adolf Hitler and the Nazi Party.

Highlights

The Beer Hall Putsch took place on November 8th, 1923, during a period of extreme political and economic instability in Germany.

The Weimar Republic was seen as weak, with multiple Chancellors and government cabinets in a short period.

The Ruhr Valley, Germany's industrial center, was under French occupation due to unpaid World War I reparations.

The Treaty of Versailles and hyperinflation led to widespread outrage and a loss of confidence in the German government.

Adolf Hitler and other nationalist politicians saw an opportunity to start an open revolution against the Weimar Republic.

Hitler planned to coerce the Bavarian triumvirate into joining his revolution, inspired by Mussolini's march on Rome.

The original date for the march was moved up to November 8th to coincide with a speech by Gustav von Kahr.

Hitler and his men burst into the beer hall where Kahr was speaking, intending to gain their support by force.

Hitler used a combination of exaggerations and lies to convince the crowd and the Bavarian triumvirate of his cause.

Despite initial resistance, Hitler's oratory skills swayed the crowd and the triumvirate to support his revolution.

The involvement of General Erich Ludendorff, a prominent wartime leader, was meant to legitimize the Nazi's position.

Hitler's decision to leave the beer hall led to the triumvirate renouncing their support for the revolution.

The march into Munich the following day resulted in a firefight, with several Nazis and state policemen killed.

Hitler was arrested and put on trial for treason, but the trial turned into a platform for him to promote his views.

Hitler's sentence was just five years, of which he served only nine months in a comfortable prison cell.

During his imprisonment, Hitler wrote Mein Kampf, consolidating his thoughts and strategies for the future.

The Beer Hall Putsch taught Hitler that winning power in Germany required legal means rather than violent revolution.

The failed Putsch was later seen as a turning point, leading to Hitler's rise to power in 1933.

Transcripts

the Beer Hall Putsch November 8th 1923

the interwar period in Germany was one

of extreme political and economic

instability and by 1923 the country was

in a state of turmoil the fiema Republic

Germany's first attempt at a true

democracy was seen as weak and had

already seen the election of several

different Chancellor's and nine

government cabinets the Ruhr Valley the

center of industrial production was

under occupation by the French who were

attempting to ensure payment of first

world war reparations and across the

whole of Germany political uprisings on

both the left and the right were taking

place the whole German nation was

outraged - the Treaty of Versailles that

was imposed on them as a dick taught a

dictated piece the German government's

acceptance of the terms of the Treaty of

Versailles reinforced the

stab-in-the-back myth and made many

Germans hostile to the new vemma

Republic hyperinflation was running

rampant the German people lost

confidence in their own currency and

money printed in bigger and bigger

amounts became worthless the German mark

which in January had been already a

dismal 17,000 - the dollar had by

December plummeted to 4.2 billion - the

dollar a loaf of bread cost as much as

200 billion marks despite a good harvest

that year farmers were refusing to sell

their produce because of the risk of

price drops adding food shortages to the

list of problems facing the German

people people resorted to barter using

products such as coal our sausages as

currency the inflationary crisis

catastrophic for most Germans had

economic social political and

psychological effects the virtual

collapse of the economy in 1923 helped

to foster the perfect breeding ground

for various extremist political

movements including the Nazi Party Adolf

Hitler as well as several other

nationalist politicians believed that

the time was right

to start an open revolution against the

Vimal regime taking inspiration from

Mussolini's march on Rome the previous

year and Napoleon's march from Elba

Paris in 1815 Hitler planned to force

the hand of several of Bavaria's leading

politicians coerced them to join with

him and then march on Berlin the men who

Hitler planned to coerce collectively

known as the Bavarian triumvirate were

general commissar state commissioner

Gustav von Kahr general otto von musel

commander of the Vikes fear german army

in bavaria and colonel hans Ritter von

sisa the head of the Bavarian State

Police all three men already had

nationalist sympathies and were not

afraid to ignore direct commands from

the central government planning for what

would become known as the Beer Hall

Putsch or the Munich butch did not get

off to a good start the date of the

march was originally set for the 10th

through the 11th of November but on the

7th Hitler discovered that car would be

giving a speech in Munich's burger

brauch Keller beer hall and that was saw

and size' would have also been

attendants unable to pass up the

opportunity of capturing all three men

in one location the plans were moved up

to the very next day the 8th of November

his basic plan went as follows Hitler

and his men including several

high-ranking Nazis such as Hermann

Goering were to surround the ruger

brighella

interrupt the proceedings and gain

assurances of allegiance from car Wausau

and size' when this was done a signal

would be sent to ernst röhm who was

waiting in a second beer hall with more

men upon receiving said signal from room

all of his men would then capture

several strategic buildings around

Munich for Hitler things did not run

smoothly the evening started well enough

for the Nazis around 8:30 p.m. Hitler

along with his accomplices and

bodyguards burst into the Beer Hall in a

myths of cars speech Hitler jumped on a

table fired a couple of shots into the

air and proclaimed to the crowd of

stunned onlookers the national

revolution has begun using a mixture of

exaggerations and outright lies hitler

explained that the building was

surrounded by six hundred men that there

was a machine gun in the lobby and the

local police and army barracks were

already occupied and that both state and

national government at our

fallen car LaSalle and size' were then

led into a side room at gunpoint

where Hitler explained to them his

intentions he also told them that he had

four bullets in his gun one for each of

them and the fourth for himself if they

failed to come to an agreement car

initially refused to join with Hitler

saying he could shoot him if he wanted

in the meantime the crowd in the beer

hall began to get rowdy Hitler was not a

particularly well-known or popular

figure at the time and they did not take

him or his band of Nazis seriously with

the four men at an impasse Hitler

returned to the main room fired a shot

into the air to silence the crowd and

took to the podium what followed was

described by one eyewitness as an

oratorical masterpiece Hitler in the

course of just a few sentences was able

to completely change the mood of the

crowd from one of derision to one of

ardent support he did so by appealing to

their sense of nationalism and

encouraging within them the spirit of

revolution in the meantime max erewan

von shebna rikta a leading Nazi and one

of the key strategists behind the

evenings events had left the Beer Hall

to collect general Erich Ludendorff

Ludendorff was one of Germany's

pre-eminent wartime leaders from the

period of the first world war after the

war he became involved in ultra

nationalist völkisch politics the Nazis

hoped that his involvement would help to

legitimize their position and Hitler

planned on making him the commander of

the Armed Forces after gaining power

after Ludendorff's arrival Carr LaSalle

and size' gave their grudging but public

consent to the scheme it was at this

point that Hitler made a critical

mistake deciding to leave the Beer Hall

to see to matters elsewhere in the city

and placing it in the command of

Ludendorff when Hitler returned a short

time later he found that all three

members of the triumvirate had taken the

opportunity to abandon the cause and

leave the Beer Hall all three then

renounced their declarations of support

without the help of the triumvirate

Hitler knew his plant national

revolution was destined to fail but

nevertheless he had Ludendorff put

together a plan to march into the center

of Munich and take over the city the

following day at noon the two men along

with the rest of the Nazi

revolutionaries set off with around

2,000 men they made it through the first

police blockade unscathed but not the

second a shot rang out and there was a

quick but intense firefight lasting

roughly half a minute shebna rikta who

at the time was linking palms with

hitler was shot in the lungs and died

instantly dislocating hitler's shoulder

as he fell to the ground after this the

revolution fell into immediate disarray

Hitler crawled away at the first

opportunities when Goering was shot in

the leg

Newton Dorf attempted to embolden the

men by continuing to march towards the

army but they didn't follow he was

peacefully arrested as soon as he

crossed the line by the time the guns

felt quiet 14 Nazis and four state

policemen had lost their lives in the

immediate aftermath of the push several

of the surviving Nazis including the

wounded Goering escaped over the border

into Austria Hitler instead sought

refuge in the house of a friend just

outside Munich it didn't take long for

the police to track him down and he was

arrested two days later this should have

been the downfall of Adolf Hitler and

the Nazi Party but the resulting trial

proved to be a blessing in disguise

Hitler and his co-defendants were

clearly guilty of treason and should

have faced lengthy jail terms in

addition to his crimes Hitler was not a

German citizen meaning that he was

eligible for deportation

instead sympathetic judges gave him the

opportunity to showcase his views to the

German public at the end of one of

Hitler's speeches one of the judges was

heard to remark what a tremendous chap

this Hitler the Chief Judge George

Neihardt was a nationalist sympathizer

who allowed the court proceedings to be

part open and part closed and even more

surprisingly let the defense decide what

would become public knowledge this had

the effect of allowing Hitler

after his public image and by the end of

the trial he was in national celebrity

Hitler impressed the German public by

his eloquence and the fervor of his

nationalism the trial happened in

February 1924 just before the elections

and helped the Nazis to become the third

largest group in Bavaria at the

culmination of the trial

Hitler was sentenced to the minimum

possible sentence that was just five

years in the fortress prison of

Landsberg of which he would serve only

nine months while sounding draconian in

reality the cells of the fortress prison

were comfortable and well furnished and

inmates were allowed to receive daily

visitors Hitler used his period of

confinement to further consolidate his

thoughts and to write mine Kampf he

would later describe this period of

confinement as free education at the

state's expense he emerged from

Landsberg a reinvigorated man with a

newfound sense of purpose perhaps the

most enduring legacy of the Beer Hall

Putsch was that it taught Hitler that

the way to win power in Germany was by

following legal means rather than

violent revolution one of his cronies

Alfred Rosenberg claimed that November 9

1923 gave birth to January 30th 1933 the

day that Hitler was made Chancellor of

Germany Hitler himself commented in 1933

that the events of the ninth of November

1923 with its blood sacrifice proved the

most effective propaganda for National

Socialism

subscribe and click the notification

bell for more history videos

you