Brexit 3: Globalists vs Nationalists, with Stephen Fry. Facts, Illusions and Hidden Threats.

Pindex

26 Feb 201908:24

Summary

TLDRThis video script delves into the complexities of nationalism and globalism, highlighting the surge in nationalist voting in Europe and the US. It examines the potential for nationalism to harbor racism and elitism, and challenges the notion that globalists are merely corporate sellouts. The script discusses the economic disparities between the rich and the poor, the impact of automation on jobs, and the importance of global collaboration for national security and addressing climate change. It also showcases the contributions of immigrants to innovation and job creation, emphasizing the need for both patriotic and global thinking to overcome societal challenges.

Takeaways

🏛️ There is a surge in nationalist voting in Europe, with a significant portion of English identifiers showing racist tendencies.
🗳️ In the UK, a majority of those who identify as English rather than British voted for Brexit, and a concerning percentage exhibited blatant racism.
🤔 President Trump has been accused of appealing to racist sentiments and avoiding clear condemnation of white supremacists like David Duke.
🌍 The term 'globalist' is often used pejoratively, yet studies show that global citizens display higher levels of national pride.
🏢 The top one percent's wealth growth has outpaced that of the bottom fifty percent, leading to a perception of elitism among globalists.
🤝 Nationalism and globalism labels can be misleading and are sometimes used to divide groups rather than unite them.
🤖 Automation poses a significant threat to jobs, with nearly half of US jobs at risk, overshadowing the impact of outsourcing.
🚀 Elon Musk's ventures, such as Tesla and SpaceX, demonstrate the positive outcomes of immigrants taking risks and contributing to job creation.
🌳 Climate change is a global threat causing poverty and death, yet there is resistance to international collaboration to address it.
🧬 Intelligence studies suggest that mixed-race children with diverse gene pools have enhanced cognitive abilities, challenging racial stereotypes.
🇬🇧 The Brexit deal is criticized as being the worst of both worlds, and there is a call for a public vote to save Britain's identity.

Q & A

What is the surge in nationalist voting in Europe related to?
-The surge in nationalist voting in Europe is related to the rise of political movements that appeal to those who feel left behind by globalization and to those with nationalist sentiments, as seen in the Brexit vote and the rise of certain political figures.
What percentage of English identifiers voted for Brexit according to the script?
-According to the script, 70% of those who strongly identify as English rather than British voted for Britain to leave the EU.
What percentage of English identifiers showed blatant racism in the study mentioned?
-The study mentioned in the script found that 28% of those who identify as English rather than British showed blatant racism.
What views has President Trump been accused of echoing?
-President Trump has been accused of echoing views that some races are born less intelligent or less hard-working than others, and he has been criticized for not disavowing white supremacists.
What was Trump's response when asked about David Duke?
-Trump responded by saying he didn't know anything about David Duke or white supremacy, and he claimed to be the least racist person.
What does the script suggest about the term 'globalist'?
-The script suggests that the term 'globalist' is often used as an unhelpful label to pit one group against another, and it may not accurately reflect the views of those who identify as global citizens.
How does the script describe the relationship between nationalism and racism?
-The script describes a dark side of nationalism that can appeal to racists and those who feel marginalized by globalization, but it also points out that not all nationalists are racists.
What is the script's stance on the role of global collaboration in addressing threats?
-The script emphasizes the importance of global collaboration in addressing threats such as automation, autonomous weapons, and climate change, suggesting that nationalistic isolationism may not be effective.
What impact does automation have on jobs according to the script?
-According to the script, automation already accounts for most U.S. manufacturing job losses, and it is a greater threat to jobs than competition from other countries.
What is the script's view on the role of immigrants in job creation?
-The script highlights the role of immigrants in job creation, noting that half of America's billion-dollar startups were funded by immigrants and that immigrants are more likely to take risks and contribute to economic growth.
What does the script suggest about the benefits of a diverse gene pool?
-The script suggests that a diverse gene pool, as seen in mixed-race children, can lead to enhanced cognitive abilities, increased height, lung capacity, and higher educational attainment.
What is the script's position on Brexit and its implications for Britain's identity?
-The script implies that Brexit is a complex issue with resistance from both sides and suggests that the true fight to save Britain's identity lies in the public's response to the Brexit deal and the need for a public vote.

Outlines

00:00

🏛️ Nationalism vs. Globalism: The Debate and Its Impacts

This paragraph delves into the complex relationship between nationalism and globalism, exploring the rise of nationalist sentiments in Europe and the UK's Brexit decision. It highlights studies showing a correlation between English identity and racism, and examines President Trump's controversial views on nationalism and his reluctance to condemn white supremacists. The paragraph also discusses the economic disparities between the wealthy and the poor, and the misconceptions about globalists. It emphasizes the need for global collaboration to address pressing issues such as automation, autonomous weapons, and climate change, suggesting that nationalism can sometimes mask darker, more selfish motives.

05:00

🚀 Elon Musk: A Catalyst for Global Solutions and Immigrant Contributions

The second paragraph focuses on Elon Musk's journey from humble beginnings as an immigrant to becoming a leading figure in innovation and technology. It underscores the significant role immigrants play in job creation, with half of America's billion-dollar startups being funded by immigrants. The narrative highlights Musk's ventures, including Tesla and SpaceX, and how they exemplify the benefits of taking risks and embracing global challenges. The paragraph also touches on the cognitive advantages of mixed-race children and the importance of diverse gene pools for overcoming global issues. It concludes with a critique of Theresa May's Brexit deal and a call to arms for patriotism and global thinking to save Britain's identity and resist the 'bungled hour' of Brexit without a public vote.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Nationalist

A nationalist is someone who advocates for the interests of their nation, often prioritizing them above international concerns. In the video's context, the term is associated with a surge in nationalist voting in Europe and is linked to controversial figures like President Trump, who is accused of appealing to racist sentiments. The script mentions 'nationalist' in relation to Trump's rhetoric and the potential coded language towards white nationalism.

💡Globalist

A globalist is a person who supports the idea of global cooperation and integration, often in economic and political terms. The video contrasts globalists with nationalists, suggesting that globalists are sometimes seen as elitist or detached from national concerns. The script discusses how globalists are sometimes mislabeled as not caring about their own country, but a study mentioned shows they may actually have higher levels of national pride.

💡Racism

Racism is the belief in the inherent superiority of one race over another, which often results in discrimination and prejudice. The script highlights a study where a significant percentage of English identifiers showed blatant racism, agreeing with statements about racial superiority in intelligence and work ethic. It also critiques President Trump for not condemning white supremacists, suggesting a connection between his nationalist stance and racist ideologies.

💡Fascism

Fascism is a far-right, authoritarian political ideology characterized by dictatorial power and forcible suppression of opposition. While not explicitly defined in the script, the term is implied when discussing the rise of nationalist sentiments, hinting at a potential shift towards more authoritarian forms of governance that could be associated with fascist ideologies.

💡EU (European Union)

The European Union is a political and economic union of 27 European countries that are committed to working together for peace and prosperity. The script refers to the UK's decision to leave the EU, known as Brexit, which is a significant event reflecting the rise of nationalist sentiments and a desire for greater national sovereignty.

💡Brexit

Brexit refers to the United Kingdom's decision to leave the European Union. The video discusses the implications of Brexit, suggesting that it represents a bungled hour for Britain and a potential loss of identity. It also raises the question of whether the deal should be passed without a public vote, indicating a concern for democratic processes.

💡Automation

Automation is the use of technology to perform tasks with minimal human intervention. The script mentions a study that found a high percentage of US jobs are at risk of automation, challenging the narrative that jobs are being taken by immigrants. It suggests that robots and algorithms, rather than foreign workers, are the real threat to certain job sectors.

💡Global Warming

Global warming refers to the long-term increase in Earth's average surface temperature due to human activities, primarily the emission of greenhouse gases. The video points out that while scientists agree on the human cause of global warming, figures like President Trump are not convinced, and this skepticism can have significant implications for environmental policies and the fight against climate change.

💡Immigration

Immigration is the process of moving to a new country with the intention of residing there permanently. The script discusses the positive contributions of immigrants, such as Elon Musk, who founded companies like Tesla and SpaceX. It argues that immigrants are often risk-takers and job creators, challenging the notion that they are a burden on the economy.

💡Patriotism

Patriotism is the love for and devotion to one's country. The video contrasts patriotism with globalism, suggesting that true patriotism involves both national pride and a commitment to global cooperation. It references historical figures like Winston Churchill, who embodied a balance of patriotism and globalism during World War II.

💡Mixed Race

Mixed race refers to individuals who have ancestors from different racial backgrounds. The script cites a study that shows mixed-race children have enhanced cognitive abilities and other benefits due to diverse gene pools. This challenges racial stereotypes and highlights the value of diversity.

Highlights

Nationalists and globalists are often misunderstood, with nationalists sometimes perceived as racists and globalists as elitist corporate sellouts.

Europe is witnessing a significant increase in nationalist voting, reminiscent of trends seen after World War II.

A substantial percentage of those identifying strongly as English rather than British voted for Brexit, with a notable fraction showing racist tendencies.

President Trump has been accused of echoing nationalist sentiments and failing to disavow white supremacists.

Trump's definition of nationalism is questioned, with critics suggesting it may be a coded message to white nationalists.

A study reveals that individuals identifying as global citizens exhibit higher levels of national pride than those rejecting the label.

The terms 'nationalist' and 'globalist' are critiqued as unhelpful labels often used to divide groups.

Trump's business dealings and political stances are scrutinized, questioning the authenticity of his nationalist stance.

Automation is identified as a major threat to jobs, with a significant number of U.S. jobs at high risk over the next 10 to 20 years.

Trump's promise to bring back jobs is contrasted with the reality of automation's impact on manufacturing job losses.

Global collaboration is emphasized as crucial for addressing threats such as autonomous weapons and climate change.

The importance of global solutions for challenges like climate change and extreme poverty is highlighted.

Tesla's CEO, Elon Musk, is presented as an example of immigrants contributing significantly to job creation and innovation.

Studies show that mixed-race children with diverse gene pools exhibit enhanced cognitive abilities and other advantages.

The Brexit deal is criticized as being the worst of both worlds, with a rising resistance from both sides.

The narrative of patriotism and globalism is explored through historical references and their relevance to contemporary issues.

The call to action for viewers to engage with the content on Patreon for more informative videos and discussions.